Next Article in Journal
Modeling and Analyzing of CMOS Cross-Coupled Differential-Drive Rectifier for Ultra-Low-Power Ambient RF Energy Harvesting
Previous Article in Journal
Enhancing Performance of Composite-Based Triboelectric Nanogenerators Through Laser Surface Patterning and Graphite Coating for Sustainable Energy Solutions
 
 
Font Type:
Arial Georgia Verdana
Font Size:
Aa Aa Aa
Line Spacing:
Column Width:
Background:
Article

Greenhouse Gas Emission Estimation Using Extended Input–Output Tables for Thailand’s Biomass Pellet Industry

by
Prangvalai Buasan
1,2,
Boonrod Sajjakulnukit
1,2,
Thongchart Bowonthumrongchai
3 and
Shabbir H. Gheewala
1,2,*
1
The Joint Graduate School of Energy and Environment (JGSEE), King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi, Bangkok 10140, Thailand
2
Centre of Energy Technology and Environment, Ministry of Higher Education, Science, Research and Innovation, Bangkok 10140, Thailand
3
Faculty of Economics, Srinakharinwirot University, Bangkok 10110, Thailand
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Energies 2024, 17(21), 5355; https://doi.org/10.3390/en17215355
Submission received: 30 August 2024 / Revised: 11 October 2024 / Accepted: 14 October 2024 / Published: 28 October 2024
(This article belongs to the Section A4: Bio-Energy)

Abstract

:
Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from Thailand’s biomass pellet production were comprehensively assessed, with a specific focus on wood and corn pellets. Employing the extended input and output tables, the anticipated economic and environmental effects of the rising demand for biomass pellets within the Asia–Pacific Economic Cooperation region, which is projected to see an increase exceeding 33% by the year 2050, were investigated. The estimations of CO2, CH4, and N2O emissions, which were conducted utilizing an open Leontief model based on the 2015 National Input–Output Tables, covered each stage of the production process. The results show that emissions from the production of corn pellets are expected to rise steadily, from 52.91 MtCO2e in 2022 to 75.77 MtCO2e by 2030, whereas emissions from wood pellet production are set to increase more substantially, from 210.30 to 301.18 MtCO2e within the same timeframe. Data derived from surveys and interviews with corn farmers and wood pellet manufacturers informed the lifecycle data for the biomass pellet supply chain from cradle to gate. The findings suggest that Thailand’s power sector could benefit significantly from the biomass potential in the northern part of Thailand, which boasts an estimated energy content of corncob at 39 ktoe (0.0016 TJ). Market demand scenarios were explored in two forms: one where it was assumed that all biomass pellets are to be exported to Japan and South Korea, expecting a combined demand of approximately 560,262 tons by 2030, and another positing that 10% of production will be reserved for the domestic market, with a forecasted annual increase of 10% from 2020 to 2050. This paper highlights the need to prioritize low-emission renewable energy sources, expand technologies with lower lifecycle emissions, optimize the biomass supply chain to enhance efficiency, and introduce sustainable energy practices. The detailed GHG emissions analysis provides critical insights for policy formulation, underscoring the importance of sustainable transitions in the context of increasing biomass demand.

1. Introduction

In the late 20th and early 21st centuries, the demand for renewable energy (RE) has consistently increased worldwide, following an upward trajectory with an average annual growth rate of 4% [1]. The Asia–Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) region observed a notable 6% increase in RE demand in 2022 over the previous year, with predictions suggesting a continued 4% rise in 2023 [2]. In this context, the power generation sector, particularly within APEC nations utilizing solid fuels like coal and biomass pellets, leads in RE demand. The demand for renewable energy (RE), as reported by the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC), is expected to rise by over 33% among APEC members by 2050 compared to 2000 [3,4]. This significant growth in RE demand is propelled by the global push towards mitigating climate change, as outlined in the Paris Agreement’s objectives, such as achieving net zero emissions by 2050 and implementing carbon border taxes [5]. These initiatives have urged countries listed under both Annex I and Non-Annex I of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) to implement robust GHG reduction strategies to meet their GHG reduction targets. The shift towards RE, particularly the adoption of biomass pellets for electricity generation by major importers like Japan and South Korea within APEC, underscores the critical role of GHG emissions in shaping energy policies [6,7]. Thailand was ranked in the top 5 APEC countries that significantly exported biomass pellets to Japan and South Korea [8]. According to the analysis of the Kasikorn Bank Research Center, in 2022, Thailand had an export volume of approximately 20,000 tons, accounting for about 2.0% of the market share. The cost per ton of product was around THB 4462.73. The Kasikorn Bank Research Center also forecasted total revenue from exporting this type of commodity in 2025, predicting that Japan will import approximately 209,000 tons of biomass pellets from Thailand due to the growth of biomass pellet power plants in Japan [9,10].
An analysis of the biomass pellet market in South Korea, published by the Department of International Trade Promotion in Seoul, reveals that the Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) increased the country’s demand for biomass pellets as a substitute for solid fossil fuels in both conventional and biomass power plants. The country has continuously imported biomass pellets from Thailand since 2012. In 2022, South Korea imported approximately 409,233 tons of biomass pellets from Thailand at a cost per ton of around THB 3731.86 [11,12]. The analysis from the Kasikorn Bank also provides a forecast of the biomass pellets demanded by South Korea in 2025, predicting that the country may import around 232,000 tons of biomass pellets from Thailand.
As a significant exporter, it contributed to this dynamic by generating substantial revenue through biomass pellet exports, underscoring the economic impact of transitioning to RE. The anticipated increase in RE demand in Japan and South Korea’s power sectors not only highlights a shift in energy consumption patterns but also points towards a strategic move to lower GHG emissions by reducing the reliance on fossil fuels. Moreover, the expected decline in biomass consumption in South Korea’s power sector due to an expansion in solar PV capacity reveals a nuanced approach to achieving a sustainable energy mix, further aligning with GHG emission reduction goals. Thailand’s energy strategy revisions, aiming for increased biomass fuel usage, reflect a broader commitment to both economic growth and environmental sustainability [13,14].
Most existing research has not adequately incorporated the biomass pellet industry into detailed economic models like input–output tables (IOTs). For example, Pruitichaiwiboon et al. [15] applied IOTs to construct energy IOTs to evaluate energy structural decomposition affected by the choice of energy from either side of energy demand and supply in South Korea. This study primarily examined energy consumption and GHG emissions from the demand side. The analysis considered 96.25% of major energy sources, including coal, crude petroleum, natural gas, and nuclear energy, while only 3.8% was considered from renewable resources such as wind and solar. Le Quyen Luu et al. [16] applied a hybrid multi-regional input–output approach for quantifying and assessing the life cycle GHG and other air emissions in Italy and its electricity sector. This study focused only on the power sector, and more than 90% of the considered electricity generation was from oil, natural gas, and solar energy.
This omission leaves a gap in understanding how shifts in the biomass pellet market specifically affect the broader economy and environmental outcomes. This study extends the existing input and output tables to incorporate the biomass pellet industry, offering a unique lens through which the economic and environmental implications of RE demand shifts can be analyzed. By integrating the open Leontief model, this research not only explores the economic impacts within the biomass pellet sector but also highlights the pivotal role of GHG emissions in driving policy decisions and market trends. The extended analysis of GHG emissions in response to shifts in RE demand provides invaluable insights for policymakers and industry stakeholders, emphasizing the importance of sustainable energy transitions in mitigating climate change impacts.

2. Methods

As mentioned in the previous section, the primary objective of this research was to examine the GHG emissions of Thailand’s biomass pellet industry in response to fluctuations in market demand, focusing on both wood pellets and corn pellets. The study estimated three types of GHG emissions—CO2, CH4, and N2O—associated with the consumption of input materials at each stage of the production process. The 2015 National Input–Output Tables, published by the Office of the National Economic and Social Development Council (NESDC), were applied to enhance the input–output framework of Thailand’s biomass sector [17]. An overview of the research methodology is shown in Figure 1. Data on inputs and outputs across the supply chain were collected through surveys and interviews. The details of input and output data will be presented in Section 3.
For the production of corn pellets, Nan province was chosen as a demonstration province for developing the corn pellet supply chain diagram due to three major biomass pellet exporters being located in the province, enabling the study to cover the entire production process. The concept of developing a biomass supply chain diagram was considered to create a comprehensive process [18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25]. A template for data collection was distributed among groups of corn farmers to gather details regarding corn planting and sorting techniques. Moreover, four interview sessions were held to interact with both commercial and non-commercial corn pellet producers, with the objective of understanding their operational processes. For the production of wood pellets, this research incorporated findings from a survey conducted by Saosee et al. [26] aimed at obtaining insights into the wood pellet supply chain in Thailand. All collected input data served as the foundation for creating a diagram illustrating the biomass pellet supply chain. The operational boundary of corn pellet production focused on in this research covered four processes: corn growing, sorting, transportation of the product, and pellet production. Inputs and outputs of export products to other areas and import products from other areas were not considered in this research. The data collected during the data collection process were used as raw data for analyzing the input and output quantities of each process. Operational data from each process was organized into three main categories: raw material usage, energy consumption, and water supply. Financial data was categorized into four distinct groups: energy expenses, raw material costs, labor expenses, and transportation expenditures. An illustration of the entire process and inventory list of corn pellet production is shown in Figure 2.
This research considered wood pellets from both fast-growing and Para rubber trees. Wood logs harvested from fast-growing trees are directly sent to pellet manufacturing facilities as raw material. Conversely, wood logs from Para rubber tree plantations are transported to the Para rubber wood industry for plywood production. Only wood waste generated by the process (e.g., wood chips and sawdust) is sent to the pellet manufacturer. This research did not consider the input and output items of the Para rubber wood industry, as they were outside the operational boundary. The flow process for the production of wood pellets is depicted in Figure 3.
The data obtained from the preceding tasks were sorted into two categories: input and output. Inputs encompass raw materials, energy, and labor, whereas outputs consist of biomass products, generated energy, and its by-products. Employing a material balance approach, alternatively known as a mass balance approach, facilitated the calculation of input quantities per production unit. The raw data collected from the research conducted by Saosee et al. [26] were incorporated to develop a supply chain diagram for wood pellets. The research team developed a survey form and distributed it among eight targeted wood pellet manufacturers to gather operational data. The calculation of GHG emissions from fuel and electricity consumption utilized the IPCC Tier 2 approach [27]. Country-specific emission factors were sourced from the emission factors published by the Thailand Greenhouse Gas Management Organization [28]. The emission factors, measured in kgCO2e per unit of input, were applied to the activity data to derive the total GHG emissions in tCO2e for each stage of the production process. Developing biomass input–output tables for Thailand’s biomass pellet sector entailed gathering data on the various inputs and outputs associated with biomass production and utilization in the country. This undertaking typically involved a blend of data collection, analysis, and structuring. Data organization was achieved using a matrix format. Guidance for this process was drawn from the Eurostat Manual of Supply, Use, and Input–Output Tables issued by the Statistical Office of the European Communities [29]. Monetary data obtained from the data collection stages were categorized based on input–output identification codes published by the Office of the National Economic and Social Development Council of Thailand. Sources of data for biomass pellet IOTs are shown in Table 1.
The IO model’s framework comprised four sections: (1) industries selling their products to other industries, (2) the primary input factors of the selling sector (e.g., labor cost, capital cost, and import cost), (3) the intermediate user sectors/industries purchasing products from the selling sector, and (4) sectors representing final demand. The structure of the IO model is shown in Table 2.
In general, let X1, X2, …, Xn represent the total output of industries that produce products and supply them to the biomass pellet industry. zij is the value in monetary units of the delivery from industry I to industry j in a certain period for a certain economic system. Zj is the total value of all inputs needed by the industry j. For the primary input factors, lj represents labor costs of industry j. kj is the capital cost of industry j. Oj is payments to the government by industry j, and mj is import costs of industry j. For the section of final demand, hi stands for the value of consumption by households of goods from industry i. gi is purchased by the government of goods from industry i. ii is purchased as an investment from industry I, and ei is the export by industry i. In the IO model, the matrix equation depicts the net output of goods and services needed to satisfy industrial demand. Central to this method are the inter-sectoral direct requirements. Subsequently, matrix computation is employed to delineate a commodity system. Following the framework developed by Leontief and detailed by Miller and Blair [30,31,32], element zij of commodity sector A indicates the input value necessary in commodity sector I to produce sector J. To streamline the process, the matrix can be expressed as Equation (1), where A represents the input and output matrix of an economic system, F denotes the external demand vector, and X signifies the production level vector.
A = z 11 z 13 z 31 z 33 ,   X = x 1 x 2 x 3 ,   F = f 1 f 2 f 3 ,
The matrixes in Equation (1) are related according to Equation (2):
X = AX + F
The total output value of a commodity sector is the sum of final demand F and intermediate demand AX, which can be written by Equation (3):
X − AX = F
(I − A)X = F
where I is n × n identity matrix represented by
I = 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1
The Leontief model serves as a comprehensive economic framework for analyzing entire countries or regions. Within this model, n industries generate n distinct products, ensuring that input equals output, implying that consumption matches production. In the case of the open Leontief model, some production is consumed internally by industries, while the remainder is consumed by external industries. This model yields production levels based on given external demand. Denoting the industries, the exchange of products is delineated through input and output data. The sectoral output in exogenous demand X is obtained by multiplying Equation (3) with [IA]−1:
X = [IA]−1F
Four datasets necessary for calculation according to the aforementioned formula were compiled. The first dataset, the intermediate transaction (matrix A), was derived from the preceding activity. Secondly, a 45 × 45 matrix (matrix I) was generated. Thirdly, the Leontief inverse matrix, also known as (I − A)−1, was computed. Lastly, a demand matrix (matrix F) was constructed. The demand matrix was formulated to account for two scenarios: in the first scenario, there was an escalation in biomass pellet demand in the South Korean and Japanese markets, while the second scenario was shaped by national forecasts of biomass pellet demand. The quantity of biomass pellet demand in Japan and South Korea projected by the Kasikorn Research Center and the Office of Foreign Trade Promotion in Seoul was used as demand in the international market. Scenario 1 presupposed that all biomass pellets manufactured in Thailand will be exported to Japan and South Korea, as projected by the Kasikorn Research Center and the Office of Foreign Trade Promotion in Seoul. Conversely, the second scenario posited that 10% of total production will be allocated to the domestic market, with the remaining 90% destined for international markets. This scenario was derived from an assessment of wood pellet demand informed by importer policies and the Thai government’s indication that biomass pellet demand in Thailand will increase by 10% annually from 2020 to 2030.

3. Results and Discussions

3.1. Create a Biomass Pellet Supply Chain Diagram

As mentioned in the methodology section, Nan province was selected as the demonstration province for the development of the corn pellet supply chain diagram due to three commercial biomass pellet manufacturers that export to the international market being located in the province. This made it convenient to gather data and ensure the research covers the entire process. A data collection survey form was developed and disseminated among the Na Noi Agriculture Cooperative members in Nan province of Thailand to obtain insights into their corn farming practices. Of these, fifty-five corn farmers returned the completed surveys and agreed to partake in a follow-up interview session. This session was split into two separate occasions. Detailed interviews were conducted with fifty-five corn farmers and two officials from the Office of Agricultural Economics in Nan province to delve into their corn cultivation methods, operational practices, and data. Based on input information from the interview, the process of corn cultivation begins with the preparation of the planting areas, where corn farmers enlist agricultural services for groundwork. Once the land is ready, corn seeds are sown. Early growth is enhanced, and the application of fertilizers and pesticides controls weeds. About four months are typically required for corn to mature. The harvesting of the crop is usually completed over a span of four to five days, with the collection of the corn ears from each field requiring at least three individuals. Once harvested, the corn ears are then transported to a sorting facility while others clear the farm area and prepare it for the next planting cycle. In the sorting facility, the corn is separated into two main products: corn seeds (88%) and corncobs (12%). These products are subsequently transported to a drying system to reduce their moisture content before storage. When the in-house raw materials are found to be insufficient to maintain production capacity, plant owners import additional corn ears from other regions.
The canning and preserving industry is usually where corn seed is consumed. The manufacture of biomass pellets is typically where most corncobs are utilized, with the remainder being consumed by the animal food industry. The allocation of corncobs between pellet plants and the animal feed industry is not fixed and depends on the purchase prices offered by buyers. Therefore, this research assumed that all corncobs are used as raw materials for the palletization of corn. The corncob is subjected to chopping and grinding systems at the pellet manufacturing stage to reduce its size. The fine particulate is then conveyed to the pelletizing system. The temperature of the product in this process varies from 100 to 120 °C. The product is introduced into a cooling system to reduce its temperature before being transferred to the packaging system.
For the wood pellet production process, fast-growing trees (Leucaena and Acacia) are used as raw materials by the first four plants for producing wood pellets, while the remaining four plants utilize waste wood from the Para rubber wood industry as raw materials. Wood pellet production is interconnected with three main aspects: tree plantation, the wood industry, and pelletizing. The tree plantation process comprises five steps, starting with soil preparation and monitoring of the initial step in wood plantation. Sprouts are needed as raw materials for tree planting, alongside fertilizers and pesticides for tree growth and weed removal. Diesel is consumed in transportation and operating agricultural machinery. Electricity is consumed in self-storage and small warehouses. A seven-year-old Para rubber tree can produce Para rubber latex, and these trees are typically felled when they reach twenty-five to thirty years of age. Para rubber logs are usually sent to Para rubber wood factories to be transformed into plywood. In comparison, fast-growing trees (FGTs) have a shorter life cycle, ranging from five to fifteen years. The production of wood pellets comprises six stages: treatment of raw materials, drying system, comminution system, pelletization, cooling, and packaging and storage. The demand for workers is determined by the scale of the plant. For example, the operation of a plant with an annual production capacity of 7840 tons requires five workers to manage.

3.2. Analysis of Input and Output Data

The annual production of the three pellet manufacturers is 55,125 tons. To achieve this production capacity, approximately 73,500 tons of corncobs are required annually. Consequently, the supply of corncobs necessitates approximately 612,500 tons of ears of corn. When considering the potential of Nan province to supply ears of corn to the manufacturers, according to the latest statistics published by the Office of Agricultural Economics, it was 388,937 tons in 2021. This implies that the biomass potential in the province is only 93,345 tons per year (using a residue-to-product ratio of 0.24 tons of residue per ton of corn to calculate the residual biomass from the total amount of corn). Therefore, 519,155 tons of ears of corn are needed from the nearest provinces to meet the production demand. Biomass potential in the northern part of Thailand in 2021 is depicted in Figure 4.
The same proportions of material consumption, energy usage in corn plantation and cultivation processes, and operating conditions observed in Nan province were applied to other provinces in the northern part of Thailand to achieve the total demand of 612,500 tons of ears of corn. The Thailand Alternative Power Development Plan 2015 [33] forecasted biomass demand for heat generation in 2036 to be 22,100 ktoe. Considering the biomass potential of the northern part of Thailand, the average growth rate from 2018 to 2021 was −1.34%. If the biomass production potential in this region continues to decline at this rate from 2021 to 2036, the accumulated biomass generation will be approximately 5286 ktoe. These figures indicate that the provinces located in the northern part of Thailand could be a significant supplier of biomass from agricultural residue for Thailand’s energy needs. Thus, the input and output quantities discussed in the following sections are related to the production of 55,125 tons of corn pellets.
To generate an annual output of 55,125 tons of corn pellets, the corn cultivation process needs to produce approximately 612,500 tons of ears of corn annually. This requires 3810 tons of corn seed as input material for growing corn, followed by 24,500 tons of fertilizer and 4.49 L of diesel per ton of corn for agricultural machinery. All ears of corn produced from the corn cultivation process are transported to the sorting plant. The sorting process requires 12,000 MWh of electricity to operate the sorting system. The 73,500 tons of corncobs sorted by the system are then conveyed to the pellet manufacturing plant. Table 3 provides a resource breakdown per ton of corn pellets produced. Within the corn cultivation process, it is necessary to use 0.01 tons of corn seed, 0.04 tons of fertilizer, and 7.33 L of diesel to produce one ton of ears of corn. The corn sorting process then takes these ears and, through the use of 0.02 MWh of electricity, sorts them into 0.88 tons of corn seed and 0.12 tons of corncob. Moving to the pelletizing phase, 1.33 tons of corncob are transformed into one ton of corn pellets, utilizing an additional 0.22 MWh of electricity, with no significant by-products. This systematic enumeration of inputs and outputs illustrates the resource efficiency across each stage of production.
Referring to input data derived from the sorting plant, the price of an ear of corn is THB 10 per kg (average annual exchange rate for 2023 was USD/THB 34.77) of product (THB 10,000 per ton of ear of corn). Therefore, the total value of the ear of corn in this research is 6125 mTHB. The average price of corncob sold to the pellet plant is THB 3 per kg of product (THB 3000 per ton of corncob), while the average price of corn seed sold to the animal feed industry is THB 11.50 per kg of product (THB 11,500 per ton of corn seed). The total economic value is calculated at THB 10,480. Of this amount, the economic value attributed to corn seeds is THB 10,120, comprising 96.6% of the total, while the economic value derived from corncobs amounts to THB 360, accounting for 3.4% of the total value. The cost of producing one ton of product is shown in Table 4, which presents a cost analysis for the production of corn-related products, segmented into the corn cultivation, corn sorting, and pelletizing stages. The costs of the corn cultivation process are broken down as follows: corn seed at THB 1026, fertilizer at THB 448, diesel at THB 256, and labor at THB 634, with the output, a ton of ears of corn, being valued at THB 10,000. The corn sorting process is characterized by the ear of corn, valued at THB 10,000, being processed with additional electricity and labor costs at THB 81.21 and 3, respectively, which yields corn seed and corncob valued at THB 11,500 and 3000, respectively.
For the pelletizing phase, corncob valued at THB 3000 is utilized, and when combined with the costs of electricity (THB 71) and labor (THB 79), corn pellets valued at THB 4200 are produced. The value addition at each phase of production is elucidated by this delineation of costs, tracing the financial transformation from initial inputs to the final product in a passive structure.
From an environmental perspective, the production of corn pellets emits 95.38 MtCO2e of GHG emissions. Table 5 presents the GHG emissions from the production of 55,125 tons of corn pellets. In the corn plantation process, GHG emissions are calculated based on activity data for consumption of fertilizer, diesel, and corn seed with their respective emission factors, resulting in 39.01 MtCO2e for fertilizer, 0.76 MtCO2e for diesel, and the lowest emissions of 1.08 MtCO2e for corn seed.
During the corn sorting process, the use of electricity is responsible for 6.00 MtCO2e of GHG emissions, and consumption of an ear of corn emits 40.85 MtCO2e of GHG emissions. At this stage, 3.4% is used as a factor for allocating GHG emissions from the cultivation process to corncobs. Lastly, in the pelletizing stage, electricity usage accounts for slightly higher emissions of 6.06 MtCO2e, and consumption of corncobs is responsible for 1.63 MtCO2e of GHG emissions. The total emissions calculated using the economic allocation method are 4.08% lower compared to those calculated using the mass allocation method, i.e., when distributing GHG emissions among different products or processes, the economic allocation method (which allocates emissions based on the economic value or revenue of products) results in 4.08% less GHG emissions than when using the mass allocation method (which allocates emissions based on the physical mass of products). Essentially, the way emissions are divided between products based on economic value shows a lower total emissions figure than when divided based on their mass. Table 6 details the input materials needed for the production of one ton of wood pellets, with the data divided into three categories: cultivation of Para rubber trees, cultivation of fast-growing trees, and production of wood pellets. In the cultivation of Para rubber trees, 2.258 tons of sprout, a minimal amount of fertilizer (0.001 tons), diesel (0.002 L), and electricity (0.013 MWh) are required to produce 0.89 tons of Para rubber logs and 0.11 tons of latex. For fast-growing trees, 6 tons of raw materials, 147 cubic meters of water, 0.21 tons of organic fertilizer, a substantial amount of chemical fertilizer (1837 tons), and significant electricity usage (13 MWh) along with 588 L of diesel are used to yield 0.66 tons of Leucaena logs and 0.34 tons of Acacia logs. The production ratio of fast-growing trees was calculated based on data obtained from the study of Saosee et al. When it comes to the actual production of wood pellets, the input of 1.01 tons of raw materials, 0.75 L of diesel, 0.06 tons of firewood, and 0.02 MWh of electricity results in the creation of one ton of wood pellets, with no dust as a by-product. This table systematically captures the resource inputs against their respective outputs for each step of the wood pellet production process.
Table 7 presents the quantification of a cost analysis for the production of wood pellets. Within the cultivation of Para rubber trees, expenses are incurred for raw materials (THB 794), labor (THB 3021), and electricity (THB 54), leading to outputs of Para rubber logs and latex valued at THB 2500 and 2075, respectively. The cultivation of fast-growing trees incurs costs for raw materials (THB 530.26), electricity (THB 24.35), diesel (THB 8.25), and fertilizer (THB 27.02), which result in outputs of Leucaena and Acacia logs, each valued at THB 800.
For the actual production of wood pellets, costs include raw materials (THB 1197.69), diesel (THB 26.30), firewood (THB 78.13), electricity (THB 36.99), labor (THB 69.20), and operations and maintenance (O&M; THB 120.05). These inputs contribute to the production of wood pellets valued at THB 2136. The table provides an itemized view of costs against the financial value of the outputs in each stage of the wood pellet production process.
Table 8 provides a comprehensive account of GHG emissions from the wood pellet production process, totaling 157.39 MtCO2e. For the cultivation of Para rubber trees, GHG emissions are calculated from the use of fertilizer (5.74 MtCO2e), diesel (26.39 MtCO2e), and electricity (17.28 MtCO2e), with each emission value derived by applying the respective emission factors to the activity data. In the cultivation of fast-growing trees, electricity, water, diesel, and chemical fertilizer contribute to emissions of 0.42, 3.03, 101.42, and 0.0002 MtCO2e, respectively.
The production of wood pellets sees further emissions from the use of diesel (0.47 MtCO2e), firewood (0.45 MtCO2e), and electricity (2.19 MtCO2e). The emissions for each input are derived by applying the respective emission factors to the activity data. This comprehensive calculation of total emissions demonstrates the environmental impact of the wood pellet production process, as captured in the table. Considering the total GHG emissions from biomass pellet production (including corn and wood pellets), the overall emissions throughout the process amount to 219.96 MtCO₂e. Each ton of biomass pellets emits 0.7602 tCO₂e.

3.3. Develop an Input–Output Table for Thailand’s Biomass Pellet Sector

The summary table presents monetary data of the items related to the production of biomass pellets as shown in Table 9.
The biomass pellet sector’s total value amounts to 731.78 mTHB, with its annual operating surplus reaching 13,063 mTHB. Unit cost of biomass pellet is THB 2529 per ton. Monetary data from the preceding activity were classified according to Thailand’s input–output identifier code to align new items obtained from the previous section with an existing sector. A list of economic sectors associated with the production of biomass pellets is shown in Table 10.
The assumption for selecting the demand industry was based on the payment for energy purchases and the list of industrial sectors that have the potential to use biomass pellets as fuel. It was assumed in this research that biomass pellets could partially replace the consumption of coal, electricity, petroleum, and natural gas. The expenditure on energy consumption by the demand sector was taken into account to calculate the sector’s percentage of energy demand. Consequently, the maximum percentage of the sectors that can consume biomass pellets was applied to estimate the cost of biomass pellets by sector. The breakdown of biomass pellet demand by sector, expressed as percentages, is shown in Table 11.
Table 11 displays the sectors with high expenditure on energy, including electricity (54.00%), plastic wares (7.59%), cement (7.30%), petroleum and natural gas (5.92%), and spinning (3.97%). The value of the biomass pellets sector was allocated to each industry based on the maximum percentage of biomass pellets that each sector can utilize as an alternative energy source in their processes. The price of biomass pellets by sector is presented in Table 12.
Symmetric input–output tables for the biomass pellet sector in Thailand were created in accordance with the IOT development principle initiated by EUstat. The sector was structured within the same economic framework as Thailand’s IOTs to ensure that integration of the biomass pellet sector into the existing IOTs is accurate and feasible. The biomass pellet sector comprises 45 × 45 inter-sectoral linkages. Intermediary transactions encompass sectors 002 to 190, representing the flow of goods and services in monetary terms. The value-added sector encompasses sectors 201 to 209, with Sector 210 indicating the total cost of the product inclusive of value-added. Final demand sectors, such as private consumption expenditure, government consumption expenditure, and gross fixed capital formation, are covered from sectors 301 to 309, with sector 310 representing the summation of final demand.

3.4. Verification of the Extended IOTs

Two approaches were employed to validate the model of extending the national IOTs by incorporating a new sector. Firstly, the difference between the original IOTs and the table with the integrated biomass pellet sector was examined. The last approach involved checking the gross domestic product (GDP) value. The result of the first approach is presented in Table 13.
The value of total intermediate transactions, representing the financial transaction of a product from one firm to another, experienced a 0.03% increase compared to conventional IOTs in Thailand. Additionally, the value of the control total, which signifies the total amount of financial transactions between industries when considering value-added, also saw a slight increase of 0.01%. No difference was observed in the value of total demand. These results imply that the input data collected from the survey, as well as the assumptions used for data allocation in this research, are aligned and applicable to the current economic system. The value of the biomass pellet sector is not substantial when compared with sectors of higher value, such as office and household machinery, petroleum refineries, electricity, and motor vehicles. Therefore, the GDP is not expected to be significantly affected by adding the biomass pellet sector. This approach also involves comparing the GDP value between two cases: the total GDP of the original IOTs and the total GDP of the extended IOTs. The result of the validation of the GDP value is shown in Table 14.

3.5. Biomass Pellet Demand

The year 2030, which is the target year for Thailand’s NDC (nationally determined contribution) targets, was chosen to estimate biomass pellet demand in alignment with the national goal of increasing the use of renewable energy and reducing GHG emissions. Forecasted data on biomass pellet demand for heat applications in Thailand, along with data on international market demand, indicates that national revenue from selling biomass will be generated from both domestic and international markets. Therefore, two scenarios were defined as matrix F to analyze the impact of changing demand on biomass pellet consumption. Biomass pellet demand in the international market was denoted as Scenario 1. This scenario assumed that all biomass pellets produced in Thailand will be exported to the international market. The international market in this study focused on biomass pellet demand in Japan and South Korea, which have high pellet demand when compared with other importer countries. Forecasted data by the Kasikorn Research Center (2020) and the Office of Foreign Trade Promotion in Seoul (2020) revealed that both markets will require biomass pellets from Thailand at approximately 430,000 tons in 2024 and 441,000 tons in 2025. The growth rate of biomass pellet demand for each country was used as a driving factor in forecasting the trend of biomass pellet demand from 2026 to 2030. The forecasted results of the scenario 1 were presented in Table 15.
The second scenario assumed that 10% of total production will be distributed to the domestic market, and 90% of total production will be exported to international markets. This scenario was defined based on the evaluation of wood pellet demand from the policy of importers and the fact that the Thai government mentioned that biomass pellet demand in Thailand will increase by 10% each year from 2020 to 2025. The growth rate of biomass pellet demand in the country was used as a key factor in forecasting the trend of biomass pellet demand in Thailand from 2026 to 2030. Table 16 illustrates the projected biomass demand for heat applications in Thailand.
The amount of biomass pellet demand presented in Table 15 and Table 16 was converted into a monetary unit by multiplying the unit cost of biomass pellets (THB 2529 per ton of product). The price of biomass pellets is shown in Table 17.

3.6. Forecasting of GHG Emissions According to Market Demand

The annual increase in market demand was applied to forecast the amount of GHG emissions from biomass pellet production under the assumption that production methods, efficiency, and input sources are held constant and the rise in demand is directly proportional to an increase in production. It was presumed that the emission intensity per ton of biomass pellets will not vary, allowing for a straightforward application of the growth rate to the current emissions to estimate future emissions. For multi-year forecasts, the growth rate was compounded annually.

3.6.1. GHG Emissions According to International Demand (Scenario 1)

An average growth rate of biomass pellet demand in the international market (4.59%) was applied to forecast GHG emissions from the production of corn and wood pellets from 2023 to 2030. The production of wood pellets is the larger contributor, starting at 164.62 MtCO2e in 2023 and rising to 255.40 MtCO2e by 2030. Corn pellet production emissions also increase but remain significantly lower, starting at 104.00 MtCO2e in 2023 and reaching 142.40 MtCO2e by 2030.
As shown in Table 18, The total emissions from both categories show a consistent year-on-year increase. This trend suggests an upward trajectory in cradle-to-gate GHG emissions driven by international demand for these biomass sources, indicating a need for strategies to mitigate emissions as production scales up.

3.6.2. GHG Emissions According to Domestic Demand (Scenario 2)

An average growth rate of biomass pellet demand in the domestic market (5.64%) was applied to forecast the GHG emissions from 2023 to 2030. The results of forecasted GHG emissions are shown in Table 19. The forecasted data suggests a rising trend in national demand for corn and wood pellet production, with a consequent increase in GHG emissions from 2023 to 2030. For corn pellets, the emissions start at 105.04 MtCO2e and show a steady increase each year, reaching 154.22 MtCO2e by 2030. Wood pellet production starts at a significantly higher emission level of 166.27 MtCO2e in 2023, escalating to 244.12 MtCO2e by 2030, which indicates a more pronounced impact on the total GHG emissions.
The aggregate GHG emissions from both categories are reflected by the growing trend, with a movement from 267.03 MtCO2e in 2023 to 392.06 MtCO2e by 2030. A significant rise in national demand for biomass is implied by this progression, resulting in increased emissions. The data highlight the importance of environmental impact consideration as biomass production expands and the potential necessity for more sustainable practices or emission-offsetting measures to manage the environmental footprint.
In Figure 5, GHG emission trends are presented for the period 2023 to 2030, segmented by national and international demand.

3.7. Recommendations

Based on comprehensive research into Thailand’s biomass pellet production and its associated greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, it is clear that biomass power plants using biomass pellets as fuel emit higher lifecycle emissions compared to other renewable energy technologies. This is primarily due to emissions from the cultivation, harvesting, processing, transportation, and combustion of biomass pellets. Although biomass is a renewable resource, its lifecycle emissions are still considerable. To integrate biomass as a solution for reducing GHG emissions and align with Thailand’s nationally determined contribution (NDC) targets, the following recommendations are proposed. Each recommendation is tied to specific numerical insights from the study to reflect their real contribution to GHG reduction efforts.

3.7.1. Policy Recommendations

  • Prioritizing Low-Emission Renewable Energy Sources:
    • The study found that emissions from wood pellet production are projected to rise from 210.30 MtCO2e in 2022 to 301.18 MtCO2e by 2030. In contrast, technologies such as solar PV and wind energy have far lower lifecycle emissions. By prioritizing these lower-emission technologies, Thailand could offset at least 20% of the forecasted GHG emissions from biomass by shifting focus to cleaner energy sources [34]. This would lead to a potential reduction of around 60 MtCO2e by 2030.
  • Monitoring and Improving Biomass Efficiency:
    • Current emissions from biomass pellet production, including both wood and corn pellets, are projected to reach 367.80 MtCO2e by 2030 under international demand scenarios. Improving biomass efficiency by adopting stringent environmental standards and best practices in biomass pellet production could reduce emissions by at least 10%. This would equate to a real reduction of approximately 36.78 MtCO2e by 2030. By increasing the quality and combustion efficiency of biomass pellets, the sector could lower its emission intensity from 0.7602 tCO2e per ton of biomass to around 0.6842 tCO2e per ton.
  • Promoting Sustainable Agricultural Practices:
    • Fertilizer use in corn pellet production alone accounts for 39.01 MtCO2e in GHG emissions. Implementing precision farming techniques, such as GPS-enabled fertilizer management, could improve fertilizer efficiency and reduce emissions from fertilizer application by 20–30% [35]. This would result in a real contribution of reducing emissions by approximately 7.80 to 11.70 MtCO2e by 2030. Substituting synthetic fertilizers with organic alternatives could further reduce emissions by 2–5 MtCO2e, contributing significantly to Thailand’s NDC targets.

3.7.2. Environmental Recommendations

  • Adoption of Lifecycle Emission Management:
    • The total emissions from biomass pellet production in Thailand are expected to rise significantly, with wood pellet production alone reaching 225.40 MtCO2e by 2030. Encouraging lifecycle emission management could help reduce emissions at every stage—from cultivation to end use. A full lifecycle approach could cut emissions by approximately 15%, resulting in a real reduction of around 33.81 MtCO2e by 2030 [36,37,38,39]. This is particularly crucial for Thailand as it seeks to maintain its role in the international biomass market while reducing its overall carbon footprint.
  • GHG Offsetting Initiatives:
    • Thailand could implement GHG offsetting initiatives such as reforestation or soil carbon sequestration to neutralize emissions from biomass production. For instance, the 154.22 MtCO2e projected from corn pellet production by 2030 could be offset by expanding reforestation efforts, potentially sequestering around 10–15% of these emissions [40,41], equating to roughly 15–23 MtCO2e.
  • Energy Efficiency Programs:
    • The study shows that energy consumption in pelletizing processes contributes significantly to emissions, with electricity use accounting for 6.06 MtCO2e in corn pellet production and 2.19 MtCO2e in wood pellet production. Introducing energy efficiency programs in biomass pellet manufacturing could reduce electricity consumption and lower emissions by up to 10% [42,43]. This would result in a reduction of about 0.82 MtCO2e for corn pellets and 0.22 MtCO2e for wood pellets, contributing directly to lowering Thailand’s biomass energy emissions.

3.7.3. Financial Recommendations

  • Financial Mechanisms for SMEs:
    • Small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) play a key role in Thailand’s biomass sector, but transitioning to greener technologies requires substantial investment. Offering low-interest loans or grants to SMEs could facilitate the adoption of cleaner technologies, which would reduce emissions from processing and transport. For instance, transport-related emissions from corn pellet production are currently 5.68 MtCO2e. If SMEs are able to invest in greener logistics and transportation technologies, this could lead to a 10–15% reduction in transport-related emissions [44], saving about 0.57–0.85 MtCO2e by 2030.
  • Economic Diversification within the Biomass Industry:
    • The biomass sector is projected to produce 560,262 tons of pellets by 2030 for the international market. Diversifying this industry to include other renewable energy technologies could help stabilize the sector against market fluctuations while reducing emissions. For instance, by integrating solar and wind power into the biomass production process, Thailand could reduce overall energy-related emissions by up to 5%, according to information published by the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation, contributing to a reduction of approximately 18–20 MtCO2e by 2030.

4. Conclusions

This study quantitatively assessed greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from Thailand’s biomass pellet industry, focusing on the production of corn and wood pellets. Using the extended input–output tables (IOTs) model, the analysis projected that emissions from corn pellet production will increase from 52.91 MtCO2e in 2022 to 75.77 MtCO2e by 2030, while emissions from wood pellet production will rise more sharply, from 210.30 MtCO2e to 301.18 MtCO2e during the same period. These trends reflect the growing demand for biomass energy, particularly in international markets such as Japan and South Korea, where total biomass pellet demand is expected to reach 560,262 tons by 2030.
The study highlights that while biomass pellets contribute to renewable energy targets, their lifecycle greenhouse emissions remain significant, with the total emissions for wood and corn pellet production estimated to reach 367.80 MtCO2e under international demand scenarios and 398.35 MtCO2e under domestic demand scenarios by 2030. These figures underscore the need for emission reduction measures within the biomass supply chain to align with Thailand’s nationally determined contribution (NDC) targets.
Policy recommendations include prioritizing low-emission renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind, over biomass and improving the efficiency of biomass production processes. For instance, the study estimated that improving combustion efficiency and reducing supply chain emissions could substantially reduce the 0.7602 tCO2e emitted per ton of biomass pellets. As Thailand aims to scale up biomass production to meet domestic and international demand, these findings stress the importance of optimizing the supply chain and adopting more sustainable production practices. Without such measures, the increasing GHG emissions from biomass production could undermine the country’s renewable energy and climate goals.

Author Contributions

Conceptualisation, P.B., B.S. and T.B.; methodology, P.B. and T.B.; calculation tools, P.B.; validation, B.S., T.B. and S.H.G.; formal analysis, P.B.; resources, P.B.; data curation, P.B.; writing—original draft preparation, P.B.; writing—review and editing, S.H.G.; visualization, P.B.; supervision, B.S., T.B. and S.H.G. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research received no external funding.

Data Availability Statement

The original contributions of this study are fully detailed within the article. For further inquiries, please contact the first author.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Ritchie, H.; Rosado, P.; Roser, M. Energy Production and Consumption. 2021. Available online: https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption (accessed on 23 November 2023).
  2. Energy Demand and Supply Outlook 8th Edition 2022. Available online: https://www.apec.org/publications/2022/09/apec-energy-demand-and-supply-outlook-(8th-edition)---volume-i (accessed on 23 November 2023).
  3. Renewable Energy Demand in APAC Countries. Available online: https://www.egeda.ewg.apec.org/ (accessed on 23 November 2023).
  4. APEC Energy Overview 2023. Available online: https://aperc.or.jp/file/2023/9/1/APEC_Energy_Overview_2023.pdf (accessed on 10 April 2024).
  5. Cosbey, A.; Baršauskaitė, L. Border Carbon Adjustments. Pivotal Design Choices for Policy-Makers. Available online: https://www.iisd.org/system/files/2023-08/border-carbon-adjustments-policy-makers.pdf (accessed on 24 November 2023).
  6. Japan’s 6th Strategic Energy Plan. Available online: https://www.enecho.meti.go.jp/en/category/others/basic_plan/pdf/6th_outline.pdf (accessed on 24 November 2023).
  7. Korea’s Renewable Energy 3020 Plan. Available online: https://policy.thinkbluedata.com/sites/default/files/Korea%27s%20Renewable%20Energy%203020%20Plan.pdf (accessed on 25 November 2023).
  8. Import and Export Flow by Country. Available online: https://santandertrade.com/en/portal/analyse-markets/import-export-flow?url_de_la_page=%2Fen%2Fportal%2Fanalyse-markets%2Fimport-export-flow&&actualiser_id_banque=oui&id_banque=0&memoriser_choix=memoriser (accessed on 24 November 2023).
  9. Import and Export Statistics of Japan. Available online: https://www.e-stat.go.jp/en (accessed on 24 November 2023).
  10. Situation of Wood Pellets Market in Japan 2020. Available online: https://www.kasikornresearch.com/InfoGraphic/Documents/z3000.pdf (accessed on 7 May 2024).
  11. Import and Export Statistics of Korea. Available online: https://www.kita.org/ (accessed on 24 November 2023).
  12. Situation of Wood Pellets Market in South Korea 2023. Available online: https://www.ditp.go.th/contents_attach/212428/212428.pdf (accessed on 7 May 2024).
  13. Power Development Plan Revision 2018 (PDP2018). Available online: https://www.eppo.go.th/images/Infromation_service/public_relations/PDP2018/PDP2018Rev1.pdf (accessed on 25 November 2023).
  14. Energy Development Plan (AEDP2018). Available online: https://policy.asiapacificenergy.org/sites/default/files/Alternative%20Energy%20Development%20Plan%202018-2037%20%28AEDP%202018%29%28TH%29.pdf (accessed on 13 October 2024).
  15. Pruitichaiwiboon, P.; Lee, C.K.; Baek, C.Y.; Lee, K.M. Development and Application of an Energy Input-Output Table for an Energy Demand and Supply Activities Analysis. Environ. Eng. Res. 2011, 16, 19–27. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  16. Luu, L.; Gibon, T.; Cellura, M.; Sanseverino, E.; Longo, S. Integrated hybrid multi-regional input-output for assessing life cycle air emissions of the Italian power system. Energy 2024, 290, 130109. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. Thailand Input-Output Tables. 2010; pp. 13–454. Available online: https://www.nesdc.go.th/nesdb_en/more_news.php?cid=158& (accessed on 25 November 2023).
  18. Yılmaz, S.; Selim, H. A decision model for cost effective design of biomass based green energy supply chains. J. Bioresour. Technol. 2015, 191, 97–109. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  19. Sharma, B.; Ingalls, R.; Jones, C.; Khanchi, A. Biomass Supply Chain Design and Analysis: Basis, overview, modeling, challenges, and future. J. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2013, 24, 608–627. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  20. Svanberg, M.; Ohlsson, I. Supply chain configuration for biomass-to-energy: The case of torrefaction. J. Energy Sect. Manag. 2013, 7, 1750–6220. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  21. Raychaudhuri, A.; Ghosh, H. Biomass Supply Chain in Asian and European Countries. Procedia Environ. Sci. 2016, 35, 914–924. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Solid Biomass Supply for Heat and Power. Available online: https://www.irena.org/Publications/2019/Jan/Solid-Biomass-Supply-for-Heat-and-Power (accessed on 2 March 2024).
  23. Karkania, V.; Fanara, E.; Zabaniotou, A. Review of sustainable biomass pellets production—A study for agricultural residues pellets’ market in Greece. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2012, 16, 1426–1436. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  24. Beamon, B. Supply chain design and analysis: Models and methods. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 1998, 55, 281–294. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  25. Vlachos, D.; Karagiannidis, E.; Toka, A. A strategic supply chain management model for waste biomass networks. In Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Manufacturing Engineering, Chalkidiki, Greece, 1–3 October 2008; pp. 797–804. [Google Scholar]
  26. Saosee, P.; Sajjakulnukit, B.; Gheewala, S.H. Environmental and Socio-Economic Sustainability Assessment of Wood Pellet Industry in Thailand. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Sustainable Energy and Green Technology, Bangkok, Thailand, 11–14 December 2019; p. 2. [Google Scholar]
  27. 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. Energy, Chapter 2 Stationary Combustion. 2023, Volume 2, p. 2.12. Available online: https://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/2006gl/vol2.html (accessed on 7 May 2024).
  28. Emission Factor for Carbon Footprint of Product (CFP) of Thailand. Available online: https://thaicarbonlabel.tgo.or.th/index.php?lang=TH&mod=Y0hKdlpIVmpkSE5mWlcxcGMzTnBiMjQ9 (accessed on 2 March 2024).
  29. Use and Input-Output Tables 2008. Available online: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/esa-supply-use-input-tables/database (accessed on 25 November 2023).
  30. Michael, R.; Blair, P. Input-Output Analysis; Cambridge University: Cambridge, UK, 2021. [Google Scholar]
  31. Miller, R.; Blair, P. Input-Output Analysis Foundations and Extensions, 2nd ed.; Cambridge University: Cambridge, UK, 2009. [Google Scholar]
  32. Kitzes, J. An Introduction to Environmentally Extended Input-Output Analysis. J. Resour. 2013, 2, 489–503. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  33. Alternative Energy Development Plan. Available online: https://www.eppo.go.th/index.php/en/policy-and-plan/en-tieb/tieb-aedp (accessed on 5 August 2024).
  34. Thailand’s Long-Term Low Greenhouse Gas Emissions Development Strategy. Available online: https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/resource/Thailand%20LT-LEDS%20%28Revised%20Version%29_08Nov2022.pdf (accessed on 12 June 2024).
  35. Thai Rice NAMA (Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Action) Program. Available online: https://www.thai-german-cooperation.info/en_US/topic/topic-agriculture-food/ (accessed on 5 August 2024).
  36. Tauro, R.; García, C.; Skutsch, M.; Masera, O. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, The potential for sustainable biomass pellets in Mexico: An analysis of energy potential, logistic costs and market demand. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2018, 82, 380–389. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  37. Mi-Rong, W.; Dingena, S.; Gabriel, L. Physical properties of solid biomass. J. Biomass Bioenergy 2011, 35, 2093–2105. [Google Scholar]
  38. Yılmaz, S.; Selim, H. A review on the methods for biomass to energy conversion systems design. J. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2013, 25, 420–430. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  39. Tun, M.; Juchelkova, D.; Win, M.; Thu, A.; Puchor, T. Biomass Energy: An Overview of Biomass Sources, Energy Potential, and Management in Southeast Asian Countries. Resources 2019, 8, 2019. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  40. Thailand National Communication. NC 4. Available online: https://unfccc.int/documents/624738 (accessed on 5 August 2024).
  41. Thailand. Biennial Update (BUR). BUR 4. Available online: https://unfccc.int/documents/624750 (accessed on 5 August 2024).
  42. Decarbonization Industrial Process Heat: The Role of Biomass. Available online: https://www.ieabioenergy.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Role-of-biomass-in-industrial-heat.pdf#:~:text=URL%3A%20https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ieabioenergy.com%2Fwp (accessed on 12 June 2024).
  43. Thailand Energy Efficiency Plan. Available online: http://berc.dede.go.th/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/20201021_EEP_2018_Final-1.pdf (accessed on 5 August 2024).
  44. Industry Outlook Analysis. Available online: https://www.kasikornresearch.com/en/analysis/k-econ/business (accessed on 5 August 2024).
Figure 1. Process flow for the study.
Figure 1. Process flow for the study.
Energies 17 05355 g001
Figure 2. Process flow of production of corn pellets.
Figure 2. Process flow of production of corn pellets.
Energies 17 05355 g002
Figure 3. Process flow of production of wood pellets.
Figure 3. Process flow of production of wood pellets.
Energies 17 05355 g003
Figure 4. Biomass potential of the northern part of Thailand in 2021.
Figure 4. Biomass potential of the northern part of Thailand in 2021.
Energies 17 05355 g004
Figure 5. Comparative analysis of projected national and international GHG emission trends.
Figure 5. Comparative analysis of projected national and international GHG emission trends.
Energies 17 05355 g005
Table 1. Data sources for the development of biomass pellet IOTs.
Table 1. Data sources for the development of biomass pellet IOTs.
CategoryData SourcesDetails
Biomass pellets sectorEurostat Manual of Supply, Use, and Input–Output Tables
-
Core principle for constructing use and supply tables
-
Process of IOT development
Office of the National Economic and Social Development Council (NESDC)
-
Thailand Input–Output Tables (version 2010)—180 × 180 economic sectors
-
Input–output classification
-
Input–output identifier
Table 2. A simplified structure of the IO model.
Table 2. A simplified structure of the IO model.
Selling SectorPurchasing SectorFinal Demand (F)Total
Output (X)
123nHGIE
1z11z12z13z1nh1g1i1e1X1
2z21z22z23z2nh2g2i2e2X2
3z31z32z33z3nh3g3i3e3X3
Nzn1zn2zn3znnhngninenXn
Laborl1l2l3ln L
Capitalk1k2k3kn K
GovernmentO1O2O3On O
Importm1m2m3mn M
Total supply (Z)Z1Z2Z3ZnHGIE
Table 3. Input materials required for producing one ton of corn pellets.
Table 3. Input materials required for producing one ton of corn pellets.
Input ItemQuantityUnitOutput ItemQuantityUnit
Corn cultivation process
 Corn seed0.01TonsEar of corn1Tons
 Fertilizer0.04Tons
 Diesel7.33Liters
Corn sorting process
 Ear of corn1.00TonsCorn seed0.88Tons
 Electricity0.02MWhCorncob0.12Tons
Pelletizing
 Corncob1.33TonsCorn pellets1Tons
 Electricity0.22MWhBy-products0Tons
Table 4. Cost analysis for producing corn pellets in THB per unit.
Table 4. Cost analysis for producing corn pellets in THB per unit.
Input ItemCostOutput ItemValue
Corn cultivation process
 Corn seed1026Ear of corn10,000
 Fertilizer448
 Diesel256
 Labor634
Corn sorting process
 Ear of corn10,000Corn seed11,500
 Electricity81.21Corncob3000
 Labor3
Pelletizing
 Corncob3000Corn pellets4200
 Electricity71
 Labor79
Table 5. Amount of GHG emitted in the corn pellet production process.
Table 5. Amount of GHG emitted in the corn pellet production process.
ItemsActivity DataUnitEmission Factor
(kgCO2e/unit)
GHG Emissions (MtCO2e)
Corn cultivation process
 Fertilizer24,500Tons1.592239.01
 Diesel4,491,667Liters0.35220.76
 Corn seed3810Tons0.28271.08
Corn sorting process
 Electricity12,000MWh0.49996.00
 Ear of corn612,500Tons66.686240.85
Pelletizing
 Electricity12,128MWh0.49996.06
 Corncobs73,500Tons0.02211.63
Note: emission factors refer to the values published by TGO [20].
Table 6. Input materials required for producing one ton of wood pellets.
Table 6. Input materials required for producing one ton of wood pellets.
Input ItemQuantityUnitOutput ItemQuantityUnit
Cultivation of Para Rubber Trees
 Sprout2.258TonsPara rubber logs0.89Tons
 Fertilizer0.001TonsLatex0.11Tons
 Diesel0.002Liters
 Electricity0.013MWh
Cultivation of Fast-Growing Trees
 Raw materials6TonsLeucaena logs0.66Tons
 Water147m3Acacia logs0.34Tons
 Organic fertilizer0.21Tons
 Chemical fertilizer1837Tons
 Electricity13MWh
 Diesel588Liters
Production of Wood Pellets
 Raw materials1.01TonsWood pellets1.00Tons
 Diesel0.75LitersDust0Tons
 Firewood0.06Tons
 Electricity0.02MWh
Table 7. Cost analysis for producing wood pellets in THB.
Table 7. Cost analysis for producing wood pellets in THB.
Input ItemQuantityOutput ItemQuantity
Cultivation of para rubber trees
 Raw materials794Para rubber logs2500
 Labor3021Latex2075
 Electricity54
Cultivation of fast-growing trees
 Raw materials530.26Leucaena800
 Electricity24.35Acacia 800
 Diesel8.25
 Fertilizer27.02
Production of wood pellets
 Raw materials1197.69Wood pellets2136
 Diesel26.30
 Firewood78.13
 Electricity36.99
 Labor69.20
 O&M120.05
Table 8. Amount of GHG emitted in the wood pellet production process.
Table 8. Amount of GHG emitted in the wood pellet production process.
ItemsActivity DataUnitEmission Factor
(kgCO2e/unit)
GHG Emissions (MtCO2e)
Cultivation of Para rubber trees
 Fertilizer3603Tons1.59225.74
 Diesel6382Liters2.708026.39
 Electricity52,794MWh0.499917.28
Cultivation of fast-growing trees
 Electricity842,680MWh0.49990.42
 Water9,362,867m30.32383.03
 Manure13,108Tons0.00000.00
 Diesel37,451,469Liters2.7080101.42
 Chemical fertilizer117Tons1.59220.0002
Production of wood pellets
 Diesel174,840Liters2.70800.47
 Firewood14,640Tons0.03040.45
 Electricity4375MWh0.49992.19
Note: The emission factor refers to the value published by TGO [23].
Table 9. Cost summary of Thailand’s biomass pellet sector.
Table 9. Cost summary of Thailand’s biomass pellet sector.
ActivityItemsOperation Cost
(THB 1000)
Value of Product
(THB 1000)
Corn pellets
PlantationFertilizer and pesticides274,4000
Diesel156,9390
Labor88,3680
Corn seed3180
Ear of corn06,125,000
Sorting Ear of corn6,125,0000
Electricity49200
Labor18000
Corn seed06,198,500
Corncob0220,500
PelletizingCorncob220,5000
Electricity38900
Labor27120
Corn pellets0231,525
Wood pellets
Plantation (FGT)Raw materials33,7690
Diesel51100
Fertilizer28090
Electricity15500
Leucaena033,769
Acacia 017,178
Plantation (Para rubber trees) Raw materials3,165,9170
Labor1,489,8430
Electricity216,5870
Latex022,017,590
Para rubber wood log08,911,583
PelletizingRaw materials280,5380
MA28,1210
Firewood18,3000
Labor16,2100
Electricity86630
Diesel61610
Wood pellets 0500,253
Table 10. Economic sector associated with the production of biomass pellet.
Table 10. Economic sector associated with the production of biomass pellet.
CategorySector
Supply002 Maize
016 Rubber
017 Other Agricultural Products
024 Agricultural Services
025 Logging
026 Charcoal and Firewood
085 Fertilizer and Pesticides
093 Petroleum Refineries
094 Other Petroleum Products
113 Agricultural Machinery
137 Water Supply System
145 Wholesale Trade
151 Road Freight Transport
152 Land Transport Supporting Services
153 Ocean Transport
154 Coastal & Inland Water Transport
155 Water Transport Services
157 Other Services
  Biomass Pellets
180 Unclassified
190 Total Intermediate Transaction
Demand industry031 Petroleum and Natural Gas
043 Canning Preserving of Meat
045 Canning of Fruits and Vegetables
046 Canning Preserving of Fish
059 Coffee and Tea Processing
060 Other Food Products
061 Animal Feed
067 Spinning
069 Textile Bleaching and Finishing
081 Pulp Paper and Paperboard
082 Paper Products
086 Synthetic Resins and Plastics
095 Rubber Sheets and Block Rubber
096 Tires and Tubes
097 Other Rubber Products
098 Plastic Wares
102 Cement
103 Concrete and Cement Products
104 Other Non-Metallic Products
105 Iron and Steel
108 Cutlery and Hand Tools
110 Structural Metal Products
132 Other Manufacturing Goods
Table 11. Demand for biomass pellets by sector.
Table 11. Demand for biomass pellets by sector.
Sector NameExpenditure (THB 1000)Total Expenditure (THB 1000)% Expenditure
CoalElectricityPetroleum and Natural Gas
135 Electricity29,277,09429,277,094115,693,142174,247,33054.00%
098 Plastic Wares024,480,683024,480,6837.59%
102 Cement9,018,13814,545,637023,563,7757.30%
031 Petroleum and Natural Gas03,078,08316,013,17019,091,2535.92%
067 Spinning012,798,704012,798,7043.97%
086 Synthetic Resins and Plastics010,541,78188,68710,630,4683.29%
084 Basic Industrial Chemicals1,636,5186,667,19808,303,7162.57%
105 Iron and Steel08,094,36108,094,3612.51%
107 Non-ferrous Metal5,658,9462,403,55608,062,5022.50%
106 Secondary Steel Products124,9485,164,89205,289,8401.64%
096 Tires and Tubes04,059,25704,059,2571.26%
081 Pulp Paper and Paperboard03,057,98403,057,9840.95%
045 Canning of Fruits and Vegetables03,030,18703,030,1870.94%
046 Canning Preserving of Fish02,880,86602,880,8660.89%
095 Rubber Sheets and Block Rubber02,243,52802,243,5280.70%
108 Cutlery and Hand Tools02,166,20702,166,2070.67%
134 Other Manufacturing Goods68972,125,37502,132,2720.66%
060 Other Food Products01,707,25701,707,2570.53%
110 Structural Metal Products01,677,51201,677,5120.52%
043 Canning Preserving of Meat01,579,66801,579,6680.49%
103 Concrete and Cement Products01,343,11301,343,1130.42%
061 Animal Feed01,332,82801,332,8280.41%
059 Coffee and Tea Processing0453,6520453,6520.14%
069 Textile Bleaching and Finishing0446,7360446,7360.14%
Table 12. Price of biomass pellet by sector.
Table 12. Price of biomass pellet by sector.
Demand SectorTotal Expenditure (THB 1000)Maximum % of Biomass Pellets Price Allocation (THB 1000)
135 Electricity174,247,33050%11,761
098 Plastic Wares24,480,68310%2919
102 Cement23,563,77550%5600
031 Petroleum and Natural Gas19,091,25310%5324
067 Spinning12,798,70410%838
086 Synthetic Resins and Plastics10,630,46810%3155
084 Basic Industrial Chemicals8,303,71610%9419
105 Iron and Steel8,094,36130%5115
107 Non-ferrous Metal8,062,50210%6549
106 Secondary Steel Products5,289,84030%1382
096 Tires and Tubes4,059,25710%2501
081 Pulp Paper and Paperboard3,057,98450%15,081
045 Canning of Fruits and Vegetables3,030,18730%5600
046 Canning Preserving of Fish2,880,86630%5324
095 Rubber Sheets and Block Rubber2,243,52810%838
108 Cutlery and Hand Tools2,166,20710%3155
134 Other Manufacturing Goods2,132,27230%2463
060 Other Food Products1,707,25730%2919
110 Structural Metal Products1,677,51230%5600
043 Canning Preserving of Meat1,579,66830%5324
103 Concrete and Cement Products1,343,11350%838
061 Animal Feed1,332,82830%838
059 Coffee and Tea Processing453,65230%3155
069 Textile Bleaching and Finishing446,73610%2463
Table 13. Difference between original IOTs and the extended IOTs.
Table 13. Difference between original IOTs and the extended IOTs.
SectorOriginal IOTs (mTHB)Extended IOTs (mTHB)Differentiate (%)
190 Total Intermediate Transaction19,044,01319,048,9850.03%
210 Control Total32,964,78332,967,7570.01%
310 Total Demand41,618,64141,618,6410.00%
Table 14. Comparison of GDP value of original IOTs and extended IOTs.
Table 14. Comparison of GDP value of original IOTs and extended IOTs.
Case301 Household & Private302 Government Spending303
Gross Fixed Capital Formation
304
Increase in Stock
305
Export (FOB)
306
Export (Special)
409
Total Import
GDP
Original IOTs (mTHB)8,174,7102,353,0423,371,070−537,1937,225,7231,987,276−8,653,85813,915,990
Extended IOTs (mTHB)8,174,7102,353,0423,371,070−537,1937,225,7231,987,276−8,653,85813,915,990
Table 15. Supply all products to the international market (Scenario 1).
Table 15. Supply all products to the international market (Scenario 1).
CountryUnit20232024202520262027202820292030
JapanTons171,000198,000209,000228,750250,366274,025299,920328,262
South KoreaTons232,000232,000232,000232,000232,000232,000232,000232,000
TotalTons403,000430,000441,000460,750482,366506,025531,920560,262
Table 16. Biomass pellet demand for heat application in Thailand (Scenario 2).
Table 16. Biomass pellet demand for heat application in Thailand (Scenario 2).
CountryUnit20232024202520262027202820292030
ThailandTons116,000128,000141,000154,000168,199183,706200,644219,143
Table 17. Price of biomass pellets according to forecasted demand from 2023 to 2030.
Table 17. Price of biomass pellets according to forecasted demand from 2023 to 2030.
CountryUnit20232024202520262027202820292030
Scenario 1
 JapanmTHB432501529579633693758830
 South KoreamTHB587587587587587587587587
Scenario 2
 ThailandmTHB293324357389425465507554
Table 18. Cradle-to-gate GHG emission trends based on international demand.
Table 18. Cradle-to-gate GHG emission trends based on international demand.
CountryUnit20232024202520262027202820292030
Corn pelletsMtCO2e104.00108.77113.77118.99124.45130.17136.15142.40
Wood pelletsMtCO2e164.62172.18180.08188.35197.00206.05215.51225.40
TotalMtCO2e268.61280.95293.85307.34321.45336.22351.65367.80
Table 19. Cradle-to-gate GHG emission trends based on domestic demand.
Table 19. Cradle-to-gate GHG emission trends based on domestic demand.
CountryUnit20232024202520262027202820292030
Corn pelletsMtCO2e105.04110.96117.22123.83130.82138.19145.99154.22
Wood pelletsMtCO2e166.27175.64185.55196.02207.07218.75231.09244.12
TotalMtCO2e271.30286.61302.77319.85337.89356.95377.08398.35
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Share and Cite

MDPI and ACS Style

Buasan, P.; Sajjakulnukit, B.; Bowonthumrongchai, T.; Gheewala, S.H. Greenhouse Gas Emission Estimation Using Extended Input–Output Tables for Thailand’s Biomass Pellet Industry. Energies 2024, 17, 5355. https://doi.org/10.3390/en17215355

AMA Style

Buasan P, Sajjakulnukit B, Bowonthumrongchai T, Gheewala SH. Greenhouse Gas Emission Estimation Using Extended Input–Output Tables for Thailand’s Biomass Pellet Industry. Energies. 2024; 17(21):5355. https://doi.org/10.3390/en17215355

Chicago/Turabian Style

Buasan, Prangvalai, Boonrod Sajjakulnukit, Thongchart Bowonthumrongchai, and Shabbir H. Gheewala. 2024. "Greenhouse Gas Emission Estimation Using Extended Input–Output Tables for Thailand’s Biomass Pellet Industry" Energies 17, no. 21: 5355. https://doi.org/10.3390/en17215355

APA Style

Buasan, P., Sajjakulnukit, B., Bowonthumrongchai, T., & Gheewala, S. H. (2024). Greenhouse Gas Emission Estimation Using Extended Input–Output Tables for Thailand’s Biomass Pellet Industry. Energies, 17(21), 5355. https://doi.org/10.3390/en17215355

Note that from the first issue of 2016, this journal uses article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Article Metrics

Back to TopTop