1. Introduction
Radioactive contamination of forests remains one of the main ecological consequences of the Chernobyl and Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant (NPP) accidents [
1]. Currently, only long-lived radionuclides (
90Sr,
137Cs, and also transuranium elements) pose a radiological hazard in Ukraine [
2]. In total,
137Cs deposition exceeded 37 kBq m
−2 at the forest area of approximately 1230.7 thousand ha (38.6% total forest land of Ukrainian Polissya as of 1993) [
3]. Spatially distributed high-resolution data on levels of radioactive contamination
90Sr in forest are absent currently in Ukraine.
The most perspective (in terms of sanitary) types of use of abandoned contaminated lands are either natural afforestation (or closed to nature silviculture) or bioenergy production for local needs [
4]. Nowadays, forest management based on native tree species is likewise considered as an efficient way to use respective areas [
5]. Hence, studies focused on patterns of radionuclide migration and accumulation in forests will remain at a high level of significance for contaminated areas.
To date,
90Sr activity due to its physical half-life (~ 30 years) has been decreased twice. However, substantial areas will persist as highly contaminated for at least a century more [
6]. Consequently, the risk of contaminated wood being occasionally used by the people remains. Special consideration must be given for the firewood, since local inhabitants in rural areas typically use ash after firewood utilization as a fertilizer thus leading to the secondary contamination of soil and agricultural products as well. Despite all the villages in the Ukrainian Polissya region being electrified, settlers there hitherto prefer to use fuelwood to heat their homes [
1].
Nowadays, restrictions of the activity concentration of
90Sr in Ukraine forest are met only for the requirements of firewood and fuel bunches [
7]. Fuel bunches are the only forest products which hygienic standards set for them. The regulations to
90Sr activity concentration in timber are introduced in Russia [
8], whereas there is no any statutory restriction for
90Sr content of contaminated wood in Belarus (
Table 1) the territory of which was heavily contaminated after the Chernobyl disaster as well.
Biogeochemical
90Sr cycling in forest ecosystems is strongly dependent on the soil type (including fertility and water supply conditions), tree species, features of their growth and development, tree mortality patterns and dead organic matter (including litter) decomposition. While radionuclide fluxes in each ecosystem have certain features, and generalization of
90Sr migration and accumulation patterns will allow researchers to assess and simulate dynamics of concentration activity in ecosystem compartments including forest live biomass [
9]. Another important factor determining the magnitude of its root uptake is a content of exchangeable calcium in soil. Being the chemical analogue of Ca, strontium is absorbed from soil, translocated and accumulated in the tree organs, and is removed from the aboveground biomass by the same mechanisms of the Ca cycle.
90Sr soil-to-plant transfer factor (TF) declines with increase of the exchangeable forms of Ca in soil [
10].
Patterns of
90Sr migration due to root uptake, transferring into tree live biomass and returning through litterfall, rainfall and stem fluxes, is commonly shown by respective aggregated TF. Aggregated TF is the ratio of the mass activity concentration of radionuclide (Bq·kg
−1) in a specified object to the unit area of its activity density (for terrestrial surfaces, usually: kBq·m
−2). Compared to information on TF for
137Cs, there are a lack of such data for
90Sr and existing TF differ greatly. TF were estimated for
90Sr from soil in wood of Scots pine (
Pinus sylvestris L., arithmetical mean and standard deviation (AM ± SD): 39.1 ± 5.9 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1), Norway spruce (
Picea abies (L.) H. Karst., 9.0 ± 2.0 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1), European oak (
Quercus robur L., 1.92 ± 0.46 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1), Silver birch (
Betula pendula Roth., 16.9 ± 3.1 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1), Black alder (
Alnus glutinosa (L.) Gaertn., 1.91 ± 0.35 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1) and Common aspen (
Populus tremula L., 1.91 ± 0.35 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1) depending on forest type conditions, as well as TF expansion series for timber wood [
11].
Information on
90Sr TF for the stem wood of Scots pine (11.2–17.9 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1) and Silver birch (15.4–27.3 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1) published by Davydov et al. [
12], are rather consistent with data of Perevolotskiy [
10] for timber, but additionally contain TF for branches and foliage live biomass of these tree species.
Guidelines of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) for use of
90Sr TF from soil to stem biomass of Black alder (geometrical mean—GM: 0.95 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1), Silver fir (
Abies alba L., GM: 4.4 × 10
-3 m
2·kg
−1), Scots pine (GM: 1.6 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1), Common oak (GM: 1.3 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1), Common aspen (GM: 2.1 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1) and Silver birch (GM: 2.4 × 10
−3 m
2·kg
−1) are based on data from the Kyshtym [
13] accident and early studies by Scheglov (1986–1992), that substantially differ from the data of the majority of subsequent researchers [
9,
11,
12].
Estimation of concentration dynamics of
90Sr in forest live biomass compartments allows us not only to expand understanding of biogeochemical fluxes in forest ecosystems, but rather to develop information-support materials for decision-making in planning, organization and management of timber production, including wood for energy purposes. Such materials should sustain reasonable restrictions of wood utilization. Together with fostering the establishment of new naturally regrown mixed forests which are more resilient in terms of radiological sanitary, these are only reliable approaches to maintain contamination levels stable [
1].
According to accumulation of the highest dose rates that cause impact on humans due to external and internal exposure, forest ecosystems are especially significant, being characterized fundamentally another radionuclides’ behavior compared to agricultural, meadow and peatland ecosystems [
14]. Functioning of forests causes biogeochemical radionuclide cycling that define respective concentration in the soil, mushrooms, forest berries, live biomass of the trees, understory, forest litter (foliage and branches up to 1 cm in diameter), coarse woody debris (CWD: branches with
d > 1 cm) and other ecosystem compartments. Although there are several studies devoted to the migration of
137Cs and
90Sr [
15,
16], experimental assessment of their biogeochemical fluxes in forest ecosystems hitherto has crucial importance. We are hypothesizing that combining data on the growth and productivity of forest stands with patterns of radionuclide transfer from soil to the stemwood, it is possible to provide sufficient information on the accumulation of
90Sr in birch, alder and aspen wood. That is, the aim of such assessment is thus to predict forest ecosystem contamination in more credible manner and with perspectives to adjust respective knowledge for planning local management decisions and silviculture activities not exceeding implemented hygienic standards for
90Sr and
137Cs content in products.
4. Discussion
Based on (i) growth patterns of deciduous forests, (ii) dynamics of stemwood as well as on (iii) features of radionuclides transition from soil to the wood of tree, we developed empirical models of 90Sr content depending on different age of forest stands for respective tree species widely presented in forests of Ukrainian Polissya. Such data are crucial for understanding and modelling of radionuclide biogeochemical fluxes and depots within forest ecosystems and for prediction of changes in environmental contamination.
To date, information about updated TFs for different species typical for Ukrainian Polissya is limited. Davydov et al. [
12] developed transfer factors (TF) for Silver birch, while respective values for Black alder and Common aspen were studied by Perevolotskiy [
11]. Data provided by the IAEA [
23] which are obtained based on studying the Kyshtym accident, and early studies by Scheglov [
13], are different from the aforementioned studies by a large margin. If the first case (Kyshtym accident), the regional soil conditions cause this difference, while the contrast of our data to the results by Scheglov [
13] is a consequence of the lack of
90Sr ‘saturation’ in depot biomass compartments of the woody plants. Additionally, the content of
90Sr is given in a biologically inaccessible form in the matrix of fuel particles during the first period after Chernobyl accident [
24,
25]. The comparison of various TFs is presented in
Figure 4.
Geometrical means of developed TFs do not agree with data provided by the IAEA (
Figure 4b, [
23]), while arithmetical means are almost the same relating to [
12] data on Silver birch (
Figure 4a). Herewith, SD of TF arithmetical means range tremendously, when respective values for geometrical means do not exceed critical thresholds.
To date, while the ratio of bioenergy in global energy markets is likely to be increased, efforts to use forest live biomass for energy purposes in Ukraine are facing great challenges due to a high (exceeding restrictions) level of radioactive contamination that impacts environment and human well-being.
The stock of
90Sr is dependent on the growth potential, basic wood density, TF and level of the soil contamination (
Figure 2). The last two factors mentioned, typically being changed over time [
11], are the main features that determine whether stemwood from a given ecosystem can be used for utilization in various spheres.
To date, there are no legal restrictions for woody product use according to the level of
90Sr contamination in Ukraine. Using respective standards implemented in the Russian Federation (
Table 1, [
8]) and estimated TFs (
Table 4) for the stemwood, we can create a heatmap for all studied tree species (
Figure 5), different soil contamination levels (2–100 KBq·m
−2) and target commodities (use as a firewood, wood chips, sawn wood either for furniture or construction).
Only relatively high (>100 kBq·m
−2) soil
90Sr contamination levels thus can entail prohibition to use local timber for the lumber materials, while the highest restrictions are met only for Silver birch at 300 kBq·m
−2 soil contamination density (
Figure 5). On the other hand, such large levels of soil contamination are presented only in a few areas within the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone [
2], while forests of Ukrainian Polissya are mainly characterized by much lower
90Sr soil contamination level (IAEA, [
26]). However, aiming to avoid credible biases and thus provide sufficient level of safety for people, there is an explicit necessity to develop and implement national regulations for wood use from the contaminated areas.
Exceeding the permissible level of
90Sr activity concentration in fuelwood (>60 Bq·kg
−1) in Ukraine (
Table 6) can be observed practically throughout the entire territory of the Chernobyl exclusion zone [
10], as well as in the adjacent Ivankiv district of Kiev region and also Narodichy district of Zhytomyr region where
90Sr contamination density of soil is higher than 5.5 kBq·m
−2 [
2].
The data of dosimetry certification of the affected settlements as a result of radioactive contamination after the Chernobyl accident (Dosimetry certification, 1991) and field surveys [
2] made it possible to allocate territories with
90Sr content more than 60 Bq·kg
−1 in the stemwood for the studied species at a probability of 50% (
Figure 6). The map (
Figure 6) also shows sampling points of this research indicating the
90Sr activity concentration in wood and the density of soil contamination by radionuclide which was obtained as a result of laboratory measurements.
A deeper analysis of the geographical interpretation of the output data (
Figure 6) indicates a significant likelihood of exceeding hygiene standards for
90Sr content of fuelwood from tree stems beyond the conditional line on the map. This is caused by the variability of the spatial contamination of radionuclides (point spots), even at considerable distances from the Chernobyl nuclear power plant (NPP), as well as by the growth of these species on the typical mineral poor soils of the region, where high
90Sr TF are usually observed. Such a situation is especially true for Silver birch, which is simultaneously deemed by calciphyte, and at a low content of exchange calcium in the soil, in tree organs happens to replaces calcium on chemically similar strontium, including radioactive strontium [
11,
13]. We have several sampling points with values of
90Sr activity concentration for Silver birch stemwood more than 60 Bq·kg
−1 at a considerable distance from the Chernobyl exclusion zone. The real area with stem wood contaminated over the permitted level can be even larger, taking into account uneven distribution within the stem and higher level of
90Sr concentration in the bark [
15].
Nowadays there is an issue related to forest management on contaminated areas. Importantly, there are three groups of stands according to land management features that require certain decision making. The first group is represented by state forests protected and managed by the Ukrainian forest service. Those stands are likely to be harvested after reaching the age of maturity. Logging will lead to spatial spreading of
90Sr accumulated in the tree stems with wood products during their entire life cycle. Second group includes forests within the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone, both existed before the disaster in 1986 and appeared after due to recovering of abandoned agricultural lands [
17]. They accumulate
90Sr and its redistribution will be dependent on the fate of abovementioned stands.
The third group is presented by young forests that arose in Ukrainian Polissya after 1991 on abandoned arable land. Typically, these stands are owned by local settlers and do not have the official status of forest, and thus they do not have legal restrictions in their management and use. These occasionally can either reach maturity age or be cut with the aim to produce firewood or charcoal. The future of these three groups is likely to be different, and all of them will cause an impact on strontium redistribution in the environment. Thus, the study results confirm the hypothesis that by combining data of stand growth prediction and estimation of potential 90Sr content in the stemwood we can provide an informational basis for decision-making regarding radionuclide fluxes, and forest management and planning as well. Consequently, such an assessment opens the perspectives for further investigations of the secondary 90Sr environmental contamination emerged because of harvesting and other kinds of loggings.
Considering growth patterns of forest stands and transfer of
90Sr from the soil to wood biomass, we have predicted values of
90Sr content in the stemwood of studied tree species relating to soil contamination level, various site indexes and stand age (
Appendix B). Use of such tables can foster previous analysis of the total
90Sr amount stored in the stemwood of forest ecosystems or that may be removed to the environment during logging.
5. Conclusions
Silver birch, Black alder, and Common aspen are fast growing and storing GSV species of Ukrainian Polissya. The largest growth velocity of S. birch and B. alder trees matches 10–40 years of stand age, while after 50 years this process tends to slow down, reaching the natural maturity age. Trees of Common aspen perform similarly, having the highest growth rate in age of 10–30 years and reaching the maturity age at above 50 years old.
Transfer factors of 90Sr to wood obtained in this study are dampening following the tree species order: Silver birch → Common aspen → Black alder. According to potential site productivity and soil contamination level, Silver birch forests can deposit in stemwood live biomass up to 300 MBq·ha−1, while for other species this value will be lower due to more limited growth capacity.
IAEA guidelines regarding 90Sr transfer factors from different soil to the stemwood are should be reviewed, since this study overall agrees with previous papers of other authors, which demonstrate the relatively high values of the developed TFs.
The paper demonstrates that 90Sr activity concentration of fuelwood of deciduous species can exceed critical level (according to the Ukrainian legislation) even at considerable distances (more than 50 km) from the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone.