5.1. Desertification Process of the Oasis in the Hexi Corridor
The Hexi Corridor is located in Northwest China, with an extreme arid climate, low precipitation, and sparse vegetation. The agricultural production is mainly concentrated in oasis areas in the lower reaches of rivers. In the past, desertification of oasis in the Hexi Corridor occurred frequently, causing the loss of agricultural land resources, a sharp reduction in biomass, and even the destruction of the whole oasis ecosystem. Therefore, the Hexi Corridor is one of the most severe desertification areas in Northwest China [
16,
17,
18].
There are ten large desertification areas that evolved from the oasis in the Hexi Corridor. These desert areas are all located in the lower reaches of rivers, with poor water resources and potential instability in ecosystems, meaning that they are prone to desertification. For thousands of years, strong winds swept across the ground like a comb, eroding the farmland into yardangs and nebkhas; some areas were almost completely swallowed by quicksand, and people’s homes became places where wind and sand raged. The Hexi Corridor in Gansu Province, through which the famous old Silk Road used to pass, is one of the areas with the most ancient city ruins. These ruins are considered to be the best historical specimens of China’s ancient civilization and Silk Road culture, as well as the most direct historical evidence of environmental changes in the ancient oasis.
Over the last 2000 years, the agricultural production and social development in the Hexi Corridor made brilliant achievements, especially in the Han, Sui, and Tang Dynasties (202 BC–AD 907). However, there have been stages of environmental changes with serious desertification in the Hexi Corridor. The desertification process is mainly concentrated in the Wei, Jin, and North–South Dynasties (AD 220–AD 589), the late Tang and Five Dynasties (AD 907–AD 960), and the Ming and Qing Dynasties (AD 1644–AD 1912). The desertification area was 1070 km
2 in the Wei, Jin, and North–South Dynasties, 1765 km
2 in the late Tang and Five Dynasties, and 6884 km
2 in the Ming and Qing Dynasties [
18]. Moreover, over the past 2000 years, among the 38 ancient cities abandoned through desertification in the Hexi Corridor, 21.05% were abandoned during the Wei, Jin, and North–South Dynasties, 21.05% were abandoned during the end of the Tang and Five Dynasties, and 57.9% were abandoned during the Ming and Qing dynasties [
16]. It has been reported that there is a good relationship between climate changes and desertification in history of the Hexi Corridor [
19]. The general characteristics of climate changes over the last 2000 years in China show that there have been four warm periods since the Qin Dynasty, namely, the western and eastern Han Dynasties (200 BC–AD 180), the Sui and Tang dynasties (AD 541–AD 810), the Song and Yuan dynasties (AD 931–AD 1320), and the 20th century (AD 1921–AD 2000). Moreover, there were three cold phases including the Wei, Jin, and North–South Dynasties (AD 181–AD 540), the late Tang and Five Dynasties (AD 811–AD 930), and the Ming and Qing dynasties (AD 1321–AD 1920) [
19].
Throughout China’s history, the warm period often brought a warm, wet climate, social stability, and prosperity, as well as a good ecological environment, while the cold period was often accompanied by a cold, dry climate. In addition, climate changes could bring about serious social and ecological problems, such as war and desertification. The relationship between climate and wars in the past 2000 years of China show that most of the wars occurred in low-temperature periods. There were seven relatively cold periods (AD 180–AD 360, AD 420–AD 540, AD 840–AD 960, AD 1110–AD 1200, AD 1290–AD 1500, AD 1560–AD 1680, and AD 1830–AD 1890) in Chinese history. Except for the period of AD 420–AD 540, the other six period all correspond to the high-frequency period of wars [
19]. The Wei, Jin, and North–South Dynasties and the Ming and Qing Dynasties were the two coldest periods in Chinese history, as well as the periods with the highest incidence of wars in Chinese history. In the former period, 595 wars occurred, while, in the Ming and Qing Dynasties, 810 wars occurred. Moreover, in cold periods, the ethnic minorities in border areas often moved inward, leading to wars breaking out [
19]. During the years of wars, people either died in the war or fled and moved to other places, while the nomadic lifestyle of the ethnic minorities usually replaced the agricultural lifestyle of the Han people. Therefore, large areas of farmlands in the oasis were abandoned and exposed to the surface, without the protection of vegetation; the ancient oasis then became desert land under strong wind erosion in cold periods, and the surrounding cities usually declined or were abandoned.
5.2. Desertification Process of the Suoyang City Oasis
The Suoyang City ruins are among the most representative desertified ancient city ruins in the Hexi Corridor. Suoyang City was built in the Western Jin Dynasty (AD 295) and was the capital of Guazhou county from the Tang Dynasty to Yuan Dynasty (AD 618–AD 1291). The Suoyang City oasis was a very prosperous area in history, especially flourishing during the Tang Dynasty [
17]. On 1 August 2022, People’s Daily Online of China reported that the latest archaeological evidence confirmed that the Ta er Temple in the Suoyang City ruins was a high-level temple on the old Silk Road, which was built during the Sui and Tang Dynasties (AD 581–AD 907) and flourished in the Western Xia Dynasty (AD 1038–AD 1227), indicating that the Suoyang City oasis should be a relatively prosperous area without desertification in this period, whereas Guazhou experienced some changes during the Yuan Dynasty. In the early Yuan Dynasty, Guazhou still existed. However, soon after, the residents of Guazhou were ordered to move out. In AD 1288, the government ordered the residents of Guazhou to move to Gan State, and, in AD 1291, the Guazhou residents were ordered to move to Su State. After these large migrations, the residents of Guazhou were very few, and historical document reported that Guazhou only existed in name [
17]. From then on, Suoyang City became empty; the surrounding farmland was abandoned and suffered from strong wind erosion. Therefore, we can infer that the desertification process of the Suoyang City oasis probably started in the mid-Yuan Dynasty (AD 1291).
In the early Ming Dynasty (AD 1368–AD 1644), the decline of Suoyang City and its surrounding oasis was very serious; the government reopened Suoyang City and repaired it twice during 1435–1494 [
17]. In 1472 AD, the Hami Wei (a military organization) moved to Suoyang City. In the third year of Jiajing (AD 1524), the government could not resist the attack of border ethnic minorities; hence, it officially abandoned the large areas west of Jiayuguan State (including Dunhuang and Guazhou) and moved all residents inland [
13]. In the following 200 years, Dunhuang and Guazhou were repeatedly occupied by nomadic tribes from Turpan, Hami, and Mongolia, and the oasis surrounding Suoyang City no longer operated [
17]. In 1738 of the early Qing Dynasty, it was recorded that there was little arable land around Suoyang City, and the former irrigation channels were all dry and covered with sand [
15], indicating that the Suoyang City oasis had evolved into desert land.
In the Qing Dynasty (AD 1644–AD 1912), the government gradually recovered vast areas west of Jiayuguan State and resumed the management of Guazhou, whereas the development of the drainage area of the Shule River focused on the east and north of the alluvial fan, and the waste land in the east and north of the alluvial fan was extensively reclaimed [
17]. It was recorded in the 58th year of Kangxi (AD 1719) that the government built Yumen City, blocked the Shule River estuary, and drove the water to the southeast to irrigate the newly reclaimed waste land. From then on, the river channel that originally flowed to Suoyang City in the west of the alluvial fan was cut off and dried up [
17]. The limited discharge of the Shule River was used to irrigate the newly reclaimed waste land to the east. Therefore, the Suoyang City oasis was completely dried up, and it quickly evolved into desert land with yardangs and nebkhas under strong wind erosion.
In conclusion, Suoyang City was first built in the Western Jin Dynasty (AD 295) and was the capital of Guazhou county from the Tang Dynasty to the Yuan Dynasty (AD 618–AD 1291). In 1291, the residents of Guazhou moved to Su State, after which Guazhou only existed in name. Hence, we suggest that the desertification of the Suoyang City oasis started in the mid-Yuan Dynasty (AD 1291), accelerated following the abandonment of Guazhou in the mid-Ming Dynasty (AD 1524), and completely evolved into desert land after the diversion of the Shule River in the early Qing Dynasty (1719 AD). Coupled with the OSL dating results, we suggest with some confidence that the occurrence of yardangs in the Suoyang City oasis started in the mid-Yuan Dynasty (AD 1291).
5.3. Environmental Significance of Desertification and the Occurrence of Yardangs Surrounding the Suoyang City Ruins
The Hexi Corridor is an important agricultural production base and a densely populated area in Northwest China. Therefore, desertification of the oasis and the ancient cities in the Hexi Corridor has important environmental significance. Over the last 2000 years, desertification of the Hexi corridor mainly occurred in the Wei, Jin, and North–South Dynasties, the late Tang and Five Dynasties, and the Ming and Qing Dynasties [
16]. Moreover, the abandonment of all 38 ancient cities through desertification in the Hexi Corridor in history also occurred in these cold periods [
16]. The reasons can be divided into natural factors and human factors. In terms of natural factors, climate change, especially a cold, dry climate, can easily cause desertification. With regard to human factors, war, river diversion, the increasing intensified human activities such as over-deforestation, overgrazing, reclaiming waste land, and building reservoirs for water storage are responsible for the desertification in the Hexi Corridor [
16]. In addition, population is also an important factor, especially for an arid area located in NW China with a weak environmental carrying capacity. In history, the population of the Hexi Corridor rarely exceeded 4 × 10
5 from the Han to Tang dynasties (202 BC–AD 907); even in the mid-Ming Dynasty, the total population was about 3.5 × 10
5, and water resources were mainly used to meet the needs of irrigation and everyday life. Thus, water and land resource exploitation did not play a leading role in environment changes of the Hexi Corridor [
16]. However, by the early Qing Dynasty, a great deal of immigrants came to the Hexi Corridor. It was reported that, during the Year of Jiaqing (AD 1796–AD 1820) in Qing Dynasty, the total population of the Hexi corridor was about 1.274 × 10
6 [
16]. For the first time, the population density in the Hexi region rose to 8.8 per square kilometer and broke through the critical index of population pressure in an arid region (seven persons per square kilometer set by the United Nations in 1977) [
16]. Human activities gradually replaced natural factors and became the primary factor on environmental changes in the Hexi corridor. Subsequently with the development of science and technology, human activities become the principal cause during the process of desertification over the last 300 years [
16,
19].
In history, Guazhou was rich in water resources, such as the Han Dynasty (202 BC–AD 220) and the Tang Dynasty (AD 618–AD 907) [
20]. It was reported that, during the Han and Tang Dynasty, a large tributary of the Shule River (named Ming River) flowed to the Suoyang City oasis area, forming a big swamp (namely a lake) 130 km long and 30 km wide in the downstream [
17]. The large tributary and the big swamp provided sufficient irrigation water for the Suoyang City oasis. By the mid-Yuan Dynasty, the ecological environment of Guazhou was much worse than the Tang Dynasty, with infinite dunes [
21]. Moreover, when the Swedish Explorer Sven Hedin passed through Guazhou in 1933, local people reported that the discharge of the Shule River was much larger 100 years ago; Sven Hedin believed that this change was not completely caused by the increase in irrigation [
21]. In history, the Shule River transported a large amount of water and would terminate in Lop Nur in Xinjiang. The Shule River became a seasonal river below Guazhou in the first half of the 19th century at the latest [
21], because Qi Yunshi and Lin Zexu recorded that the Shule River was dry near Guazhou when they were demoted to Ili of Xinjiang in 1810 and 1842, respectively, indicating a reduction in river volume and a more arid climate [
21].
Both natural factors and human factors are responsible for the desertification of the Suoyang City oasis and the occurrence of yardangs. In terms of natural factors, in the last 1000 years, the climate in China gradually turned cold and dry, and the discharge of rivers and lakes decreased as well [
16,
19], especially during the Ming and Qing dynasties, which occurred in the Little Ice Age. Historical records also show an obvious increase in sand and wind disasters all over the world in this period [
14]. On the other hand, the increasing intensified human activities also played an important role in the process of desertification [
16,
17,
18]. For example, after the construction of Shuangta reservoir in 1960, the river volume in the lower reaches of the Shule River was greatly reduced. Furthermore, once the oasis turned into a desert, people often left the oasis and moved to a new oasis [
22]. Over time, the area of desertification became larger and larger, as land resources in arid areas are very limited; desertification not only leads to a reduction in people’s living space but also seriously threatens human survival and sustainable development of the society. For example, the reduction in river discharge in the lower reaches of the Shule River caused the retreat of downstream lakes, the shrinkage of wetlands, a reduction in biodiversity, an increase in soil salinization, and other serious ecological and environmental problems [
23]. Therefore, we should reasonably develop and use land and water resources, effectively prevent and control desertification, and promote harmonious development between man and nature in arid areas.