1. Introduction
Global warming has become a critical issue in recent years. According to the latest report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, average temperatures between 2001 and 2020 were 0.99 °C higher than those between 1850 and 1900 [
1]. Global warming has also had a significant impact on polar regions by significantly reducing the ice masses of glaciers, ice sheets, and ice caps [
2].
Glaciers are indeed one of the most important facets of the Earth’s ecosystem [
3]. Together with icebergs, ice sheets, and the permanent snow cover in the polar regions, glaciers account for 1.7% of the water on Earth [
4]. Glaciers are also an important indicator of climate change since their advancing/retreating dynamics are clear proof of changes in temperature and precipitation [
5]. Therefore, monitoring the time evolution of glaciers is a critical issue that can support predictions about how changes in glacier control can affect both the local and global environment [
6].
In this context, due to the characteristics of the polar regions, which are mostly inaccessible due to harsh conditions and limited sunlight, microwave satellite remote sensing is an irreplaceable observation tool that provides information on glaciers during both the day and the night, regardless of cloud cover and other adverse weather conditions [
7]. One of the most well-established methods for estimating the surface motion of glaciers and ice sheets is interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR), which allows for the measurement of ice movements with very high accuracy [
8,
9]. The InSAR technique was the basis of some studies that estimated glacier motion in polar regions [
9,
10,
11]. The main challenges associated with InSAR approaches to monitoring glacier dynamics consist of limited accuracy in the case of fast-moving glaciers or when low coherence applies [
12,
13,
14]. Together with the estimation of glacier motion using InSAR approaches, SAR imagery is used to extract the ice fronts of glaciers, ice sheets, and ice tongues and to analyse their behaviour over time. This topic was addressed in [
15,
16,
17,
18,
19], where different methodologies were proposed.
In this study, we analyse the recent dynamics of one of the most important marine-terminating Arctic glaciers, the d’Iberville glacier in Ellesmere Island in the North Canadian state of Nunavut (80.53°N, 77.77°W) (see
Figure 1a). This study area represents a challenging scenario compared to the ones traditionally considered for the application of coastline/shoreline extraction methods. The reason is twofold: on one side, the d’Iberville glacier is a marine-terminated glacier, characterised by a particular coastal morphology and orography, i.e., it significantly differs from conventional “open areas” such as coastal harbours, ice tongues, rocky cliffs, and sandy beaches; and on the other side, the sea-surface conditions significantly vary from winter to summer (see the Sentinel-2 true-colour optical images in
Figure 1b,c), with the sea surface being completely frozen for most of the year due to the very low temperatures [
20]. These issues make the extraction of the glacier’s ice front and its temporal analysis very challenging.
For this purpose, we apply a methodology to extract the d’Iberville glacier’s ice front from the multi-polarisation C-band SAR imagery, whose backbone relies on a global threshold constant false alarm rate (CFAR) method approach. The latter is applied to the single- and dual-polarisation features, namely the HH-polarised normalised radar cross-section (NRCS) and a combination of the HH- and HV-polarised scattering amplitudes. It must be pointed out that even though the core of this technique has already been applied and validated for different coastal scenarios including the Drygalski ice tongue in Antarctica [
18], inland artificial water bodies [
21], marshlands/wetlands [
22], and rocky cliffs/sandy beaches [
23], this is the first time that it is applied and analysed in such a challenging environment. In addition, even though the dynamics of the d’Iberville glacier have already been studied in the past [
24,
25,
26], there is no updated information on its recent behaviour, i.e., the time evolution of the d’Iberville glacier has been studied up until 2004 and, to the best of our knowledge, the only large-scale glacier information that has been provided in recent years refers to the glaciers of the Northern Hemisphere [
2].
The novel contributions of this study with respect to the existing literature can be summarised as follows:
An analysis of the scattering behaviour of multi-polarisation SAR features and their ability to monitor marine-terminated glaciers.
An accuracy assessment of the coastline extraction algorithm in a challenging environment characterised by ice-infested seawater.
The provision of updated quantitative information on the time evolution of the d’Iberville glacier ice front.
The remainder of the paper is organised as follows: the satellite data set collected over the d’Iberville glacier is presented in
Section 2, whereas the methodology applied to extract the ice front and analyse its time evolution is described in
Section 3; the experimental results are presented in
Section 4 and are critically discussed in
Section 5; and the conclusions are drawn in
Section 6.
4. Experimental Results
In this section, the experiments undertaken by applying the methodology described in
Section 3 to the data set presented in
Section 2 are shown. Three experiments were performed. The first experiment consisted of analysing the sensitivity of the single- and dual-polarisation features (see (
1) and (
2), respectively) to the different scattering scenarios, i.e., frozen and ice-free sea surfaces (see
Figure 3a,d, respectively). The second experiment aimed to investigate the accuracy performance of the ice front extraction of
and
under both sea conditions in order to find the feature that achieved the lowest root mean square error (RMSE) between the extracted ice front and the reference one manually extracted from the corresponding Sentinel-2 optical images. The third experiment consisted of analysing the temporal behaviour of the d’Iberville glacier ice front using quantitative indicators such as the ice front surface velocity and the amount of ice surface gain/loss.
For the purpose of the first two experiments, two SAR scenes collected under different sea-surface conditions were selected from the data set according to the shortest time gap between the SAR and MSI acquisitions (see
Figure 3). The first one refers to the observation in May 2021 during the winter season when the sea surface was completely frozen due to very low temperatures (see the Sentinel-2 true-colour optical image in
Figure 3a). The corresponding
and
images are depicted as graytones and false-colour images at the decibel (dB) scale in
Figure 3b,c, respectively. The second scene is relevant to the acquisition in July 2020 during the summer season when the sea surface was completely ice-free due to relatively higher temperatures (see the Sentinel-2 true-colour optical image in
Figure 3d). The corresponding
and
images are shown in
Figure 3e,f, respectively.
The first experiment consisted of the analysis of the sensitivity of
and
to ice-free and ice-infested sea surfaces. By visually inspecting
Figure 3, it can be seen that the separability between the marine-terminating d’Iberville glacier and the frozen sea surface is challenging, even in the Sentinel-2 optical image, making the extraction of the ice front not straightforward. When dealing with the HH-polarised NRCS images, it can be observed that both the frozen and unfrozen sea surfaces appear as almost homogeneous areas that are darker than the terminus of the glacier, which, instead, shows some roughness in the surface pattern. In addition, the difference in backscattering between the sea surface and the glacier appears larger in the unfrozen case than in the case when the sea surface is ice-infested. In fact, in the latter case, the two regions look very similar, except for on the ice front, which appears as a brighter edge. When dealing with the
images, similar comments apply.
To perform a quantitative multi-polarisation backscattering analysis, two equal-sized regions of interest (ROIs) consisting of 100 × 100 pixels were randomly selected from the sea and glacier areas close to the ice front (see the cyan and white squares, respectively, which are annotated in
Figure 3a,b). The statistical behaviours estimated for
and
for the selected ROIs under both frozen and unfrozen sea conditions are shown in
Figure 4, where experimental histograms are depicted using blue (sea ROI) and orange (glacier ROI). In
Figure 4, the rows refer to the unfrozen and frozen cases, whereas the columns refer to
and
. The corresponding mean and standard deviation values of
and
are listed in
Table 2. The mean contrast is also annotated as a rough indicator of the separability between the sea and glacier ROIs in terms of multi-polarisation backscattering.
When dealing with the unfrozen case, for the seawater ROI, and had average values of about dB and dB, whereas they increased to approximately dB and dB, respectively, for the glacier ROI. This resulted in a mean contrast, which was no lower than 4.5 dB on average for both features. Nonetheless, it is worth noting that the mean contrast between the seawater and glacier ROIs provided by , i.e., 8.1 dB, was more than 3.5 dB higher than the one evaluated from (4.5 dB).
When dealing with the frozen case, and were characterised by average sea (glacier) ROI values of about dB and dB ( dB and dB). This resulted in a mean contrast of 6.1 dB and 4.8 dB for and , respectively, proving that even in this case, the HH-polarised NRCS provided a higher glacier/ice-infested seawater separability.
A deeper analysis was undertaken by evaluating the behaviour of
and
along four randomly selected transects crossing the sea/glacier boundary. They are annotated as red dashed lines in
Figure 3a,d. The transects consisted of 100 pixels each, where pixels “1” and “100” refer to the transect’s sea and glacier pixels farthest from the ice front, respectively (see yellow labels in
Figure 3a,d), whereas the latter was at pixel number “50”. The results relevant to the ice-free and ice-covered sea surfaces are shown in
Figure 5 and
Figure 6, respectively, where black and blue dashed lines refer to the
and
values obtained after averaging along the four transects, respectively. In addition, for reference purposes, the mean values evaluated for the sea and glacier ROIs are shown in
Figure 3a,d and
Table 2, and they are annotated using the same colour coding but with continuous lines.
When dealing with the unfrozen case, it can be observed that the
values were in the range of about
to
dB for the ice-free sea surface, whereas for the glacier, they increased to approximately
to
dB (see
Figure 5). Considering the dual-polarisation feature, i.e.,
, values from about
to
dB were observed for the unfrozen sea, whereas they increased to a range of approximately
to
dB for the glacier.
Considering the frozen case, different comments apply (see
Figure 6). In fact, even though the glacier area was closer to the ice front (pixel number “50”), the
and
values were almost the same as those observed for the unfrozen case; the freezing of the sea surface resulted in a different multi-polarisation backscattering that yielded slightly higher values (about +2 dB) for both the single- and dual-polarisation features.
The second experiment consisted of evaluating the accuracy of the methodology used for extracting the d’Iberville glacier ice front. The performance of the and features were analysed under both frozen and unfrozen sea conditions. The quantitative assessment was based on the RMSE values estimated between the ice front extracted from the SAR imagery and the ice front manually traced from the corresponding reference Sentinel-2 true-colour optical images.
The results relevant to the unfrozen case are shown in
Figure 7, where the ice fronts extracted from
and
, which are depicted in red and green, respectively, are overlapped on the reference optical image. An inset is also shown to better appreciate the results (see the yellow box). It can be seen that the ice fronts extracted from both features resulted in a good visual agreement with the actual ice front profile obtained from the optical image, even though some non-negligible false alarms occurred along the north-eastern edge of the d’Iberville glacier ice front. A visual inspection also suggests that
resulted in a slightly better accuracy with respect to
, as already inferred from the outcomes of the first experiment. To perform a quantitative analysis, 20 points were randomly selected along the ice fronts and the RMSE was evaluated between the peer points belonging to the ice fronts extracted from the SAR image (
and
) and the ones manually traced from the corresponding Sentinel-2 optical image. We found that
had an RMSE of 1.18 pixels, whereas
had an RMSE of 2.97 pixels. The same analysis was performed for the frozen case (see
Figure 8). As expected, due to the more challenging scattering conditions, larger RMSE values were obtained, i.e., 3.35 pixels for
and 4.56 pixels for
.
The third experiment consisted of investigating the temporal behaviour of the d’Iberville glacier ice front from 2010 to 2022. On the basis of the results of the previous experiments, the ice front was extracted from the HH-polarised NRCS images of the whole SAR data set. The results are shown in
Figure 9, where the study area is masked in white, except for the 10 ice fronts extracted from
, which are depicted using different colours.
Figure 9 clearly shows that the d’Iberville glacier exhibited a net retreat over the last 12 years (see the red and yellow ice fronts that refer to 2010 and 2022, respectively). To quantitatively analyse the retreating rate of the d’Iberville glacier, the average surface velocity was estimated by measuring, for each couple of consecutive years in the SAR data set, the distance between the two ice fronts computed from the same points randomly selected for the evaluation of the RMSE divided by the number of years. The average surface velocity estimated in such a way is listed in
Table 3. It can be seen that the retreating rate of the d’Iberville glacier varied significantly over time. In fact, the very fast retreat during 2010–2011, when the d’Iberville glacier had an average surface velocity of 514 m/year, corresponds to the almost stable behaviour of the d’Iberville glacier during 2021–2022, when it was characterised by an average surface velocity of 28 m/year. However, on average, from 2010 to 2022 the d’Iberville glacier retreated with an average surface velocity of 160 m per year. Together with the average surface velocity, the net ice loss from the glacier’s surface was estimated by measuring the area between the ice fronts extracted in 2010 and 2022 (see
Figure 10), where the extent of the retreat is highlighted in cyan. The latter corresponds to an ice area of about 2.2 km
2, meaning that, on average, the d’Iberville glacier experienced an ice loss of about 0.18 km
2 per year from 2010 to 2022.
5. Discussion
In this section, the experimental results presented in
Section 4 are critically discussed. First, the results of the first two experiments are discussed to analyse the characteristics and the potential of the method used for the ice front extraction. Then, the outcomes of the third experiment are discussed against state-of-the-art studies that provided information on the time variability of the d’Iberville glacier using remote sensing tools. The latter are first presented with respect to the average surface velocity of the d’Iberville glacier and, then, the behaviour of the d’Iberville glacier over time is contrasted on a larger scale by comparing it with the temporal trends exhibited by other marine-terminated glaciers in the same area, i.e., Ellesmere Island and the whole North Canadian Arctic. Nonetheless, it must be pointed out that very few studies have addressed the temporal trend of the d’Iberville glacier’s morphological features and none of them covers the same analysis period investigated in this study.
The first experiment dealt with a sensitivity analysis of the ice front extraction to multi-polarisation backscattering features and sea-surface conditions. Accordingly, the behaviour of the single- and dual-polarisation parameters, i.e.,
and
, was investigated for ice-free and ice-infested seawater to gain deeper insights into the ice front extraction capabilities. The experimental results are shown in
Figure 3,
Figure 4,
Figure 5 and
Figure 6 and listed in
Table 2.
With respect to the sea-state conditions, the results suggest that both the single- and dual-polarisation features provided a remarkable mean contrast, i.e., ≥4.5 dB, for both the frozen and unfrozen cases, proving that they allow for a robust and accurate ice front extraction. However, the results also suggest that the extraction of the ice front was more challenging when the sea surface was frozen, independent of the considered SAR feature. In fact, the presence of sea ice resulted in a larger multi-polarisation backscattering at sea. As a result, when moving from the ice-free to the sea-ice-infested case, the mean contrast reduced by about 25% when dealing with
and remained almost stable, i.e., it increased by less than 7% when
was considered. This makes the ice front extraction of the d’Iberville glacier using satellite imagery a challenging task since there are likely to be frozen sea-surface conditions in the study area. In fact, according to the average temperature records obtained for the Nunavut area for the last 30 years, the minimum temperature is below the seawater freezing point for 9 months each year [
20]. Hence, the sea-ice-infested seawater case can be considered the most frequent case when extracting the d’Iberville glacier ice front.
With respect to the SAR feature, the results suggest that the HH-polarised NRCS provided, on average, a larger scattering separability compared to
, regardless of the sea-state conditions. In fact, the mean contrasts estimated for
were 80% and 27% higher than those of
under ice-free and ice-infested conditions, respectively. Hence, since
was constructed by adding the cross-polarised information (HV channel) to the co-polarised information (HH channel) (see (
2)), by moving from the single- to the dual-polarisation feature, the cross-polarised information contributed to the sea and glacier
values being closer than those in the case of
. In fact, even though for the sea surface,
values lower than about 2.5–3 dB with respect to
ones were advisable, this was no longer the case for the glacier’s surface, where the
values were significantly lower, i.e., about 4.5–6 dB, compared to those of the corresponding
. This proves that including the cross-polarised information according to (
2) does not allow for a larger contrast under any sea-state conditions, as found in [
21,
22,
28] but for different coastal scenarios such as sandy beaches, cliffs, and marshlands. Hence, worse ice front extraction performance was expected when
was considered.
The second experiment dealt with an accuracy assessment of the ice front extraction performance. Accordingly, the ice front of the d’Iberville glacier was extracted from both the single- and dual-polarisation parameters, i.e.,
and
, and, then, the RMSE was evaluated with respect to the reference ice fronts manually traced from the corresponding Sentinel-2 optical images. The experimental results are shown in
Figure 7 and
Figure 8, which refer to the unfrozen and frozen cases, respectively. They confirmed that (1) the methodology used in this study to extract the ice front of the d’Iberville glacier was effective and accurate regardless of the sea-state conditions and SAR features since an RMSE lower than 5 pixels was obtained in any case; (2) the ice front extraction was more challenging during the winter season, i.e., when the sea surface was frozen since the RMSE increased by approximately 184% and 54% for
and
, respectively; and (3)
resulted in a better extraction accuracy compared to
since RMSEs lower than about 60% and 27% were achieved under unfrozen and frozen sea-state conditions, respectively. The accuracies reported in
Section 4 represent fairly good results compared with similar approaches presented in the literature to extract the coastline from C-band SAR imagery using multi-polarisation features. In fact, mean distances of 4.6 pixels and 5.4 pixels were achieved in the extraction of the coastal profile from
for a sandy beach and a marshland/mudflat area in [
22,
28], respectively, whereas an RMSE of 2.3 pixels was obtained in [
18] when extracting the ice front of an ice tongue from
under ice-free sea conditions.
The third experiment dealt with a time-variability analysis of the ice front. To this aim, two quantitative indicators were provided, i.e., the average surface velocity and the average ice area variation. The experimental results are shown in
Table 3 and
Figure 9 and
Figure 10.
In this study, we estimated that the d’Iberville glacier was retreating with an average surface velocity of about 160 m per year in the period 2010–2022. We found that the retreat velocity significantly changed over time and that the most remarkable and fastest retreat was observed between 2010 and 2011 (see red and orange ice fronts in
Figure 9, respectively). This behaviour is compatible with recent global warming, which is becoming increasingly more intense than that in the past [
29]. In fact, temperature records relevant to the Nunavut area provided an average annual temperature for 2010 of −10.7 °C, i.e., 2.5 °C higher than the mean temperature measured for the period 2010–2021.
The retreat of the d’Iberville glacier was also observed in [
24] where a significantly much larger surface velocity, i.e., about 480 m per year, was estimated. Nonetheless, it should be pointed out that the results were obtained from aerial photographs and for the year 1975 only. A lower surface velocity, i.e., 300 m/year, was estimated using a C-band SAR for the year 1991 [
30]. The average surface velocity in a more recent period, i.e., from 1999 to 2004, was estimated using optical and C-band SAR satellite instruments, respectively, in [
25,
26]. Their outcomes matched quite well with our results since they found that the ice front of the d’Iberville glacier retreated with a surface velocity ranging from 30 m (1999–2003) to 105 m (2003–2004) per year. A longer and more recent period, i.e., 1999–2015, was investigated using optical and C-band SAR satellite imagery in [
29] where, even though the surface velocity was not explicitly estimated, they found that the d’Iberville glacier experienced an average ice mass discharge of 0.01 Gt per year over that period.
When comparing the behaviour of the d’Iberville glacier with other marine-terminated glaciers in the Northern Hemisphere, reference is made to [
2,
29], where a comprehensive analysis was provided for 16 glaciers in Ellesmere Island over the period 1999–2015 and for 252 glaciers in the North Canadian Arctic over the period 2000–2020. The retreating trend with an average surface velocity of 160 m per year that we estimated for the d’Iberville glacier in the period 2010–2022 is compatible with the large majority, i.e., 75%, of the glaciers in Ellesmere Island, for which an average ice front retreat of about 150 m per year was observed [
29].
The average ice surface loss rate we found for the d’Iberville glacier, i.e., 0.18 km
2 per year, agrees quite well with the findings presented in [
2] for the marine-terminated glaciers in the North Canadian Arctic. In fact, an almost constant net ice area loss of 0.12 km
2 per year was found on average for the 252 glaciers under analysis. This means that the d’Iberville glacier is experiencing an ice area loss that is 50% higher than those of the other North Canadian Arctic marine-terminated glaciers. By restricting this analysis to the overlapping period, i.e., 2010–2020, the average ice area loss rate of the d’Iberville glacier is about 54% higher than that of the one characterising the other marine-terminated glaciers in the North Canadian Arctic.
6. Conclusions
In this study, the recent time evolution of the marine-terminated d’Iberville glacier (Ellesmere Island, Canada) is addressed. To this aim, a time series of 10 dual-polarimetric HH + HV C-band SAR imagery collected by Radarsat-2 and Sentinel-1 satellite missions from 2010 to 2022 is exploited.
First, an unsupervised methodology based on the combination of a global threshold CFAR approach and Canny edge detection is applied for the first time in such a challenging scenario to extract the ice front of the d’Iberville glacier. Single- and dual-polarisation features, namely the HH-polarised NRCS () and a combination of the HH- and HV-polarised scattering amplitudes (), and two scattering scenarios, i.e., frozen and unfrozen sea surfaces, are considered for the analysis. Then, the accuracy of this methodology is assessed according to the RMSE metric by comparing the ice fronts extracted from the SAR images with the corresponding ice fronts manually traced from the independent cloud-free Sentinel-2 optical images timely collocated with the SAR scenes. Once the validation is performed, the dynamics of the d’Iberville glacier during the study period are quantified by evaluating, from the extracted ice fronts, the annual average surface velocity and the net ice area loss.
The experimental results show that the HH-polarised NRCS provides more reliable and accurate results in extracting the ice front in both the ice-free and ice-infested sea-surface cases. With respect to the reference ice front manually extracted from the Sentinel-2 optical images, the ice front automatically extracted from has an RMSE lower than 3.4 pixels, regardless of the sea-state conditions. The results also demonstrate that since 2010, the d’Iberville glacier has been experiencing a remarkable retreat with an average surface velocity of 160 m/year, with the most significant retreat observed from 2010 to 2011 due to the very warm local temperatures recorded for 2010. Overall, a net ice loss of 2.2 km2, i.e., about 0.18 km2 per year, is estimated for the last 12 years. These outcomes show that the d’Iberville glacier is retreating as with most of the marine-terminated glaciers in the study area, though with a larger ice loss.