3.1. Calorimetric Study of the Curing Process
To ascertain the influence of the different fillers selected in the curing evolution, proportions of 50, 60 and 70 wt % of each type of particle fillers were added to the epoxy resin/initiator formulations and studied by DSC. In the case of AlN, a higher proportion (75 wt %) was added after examining the rheological results obtained. As the curing system, we selected a thermal cationic latent epoxy system previously reported that consist in
N-(4-methoxybenzyl)-
N,
N-dimethylanilinium hexafluoroantimonate with a small proportion of triethanolamine that leads to the homopolymerization of the cycloaliphatic epoxy in a latent manner [
15].
Figure 1 presents the non-isothermal calorimetric curves of the different formulations studied, where we can see the different effects for the fillers selected.
In
Figure 1A, it can be seen that the addition of alumina produces a delay in the curing process on increasing its proportion in the formulation, which can be related to its basic character that interacts with the growing cationic species, deactivating them. By contrast, AlN shows in
Figure 1B a small acceleration of the reaction which is accentuated on rising its concentration. Thus, it seems that AlN structure favors the formation and stability of the cations. The addition of the third filler, SiC in
Figure 1C, leads to practically the same peak temperature as the neat epoxy, which means that it has an inert character in the reaction mechanism and that no interaction between the cationic species formed and the filler structure occurs. The interaction between growing polymer chains and fillers can also play a role in the thermal transmission, because in the interphase phonons are usually scattered, reducing the heat transfer.
The most representative data obtained from the calorimetric analysis are collected in
Table 1.
In addition to the onset and the temperature of the maximum of the peak, the heat evolved by gram or by epoxy equivalent was calculated. This value gives us valuable information about the conversion of epoxide groups achieved in all the composites prepared. The value of enthalpy should approach the one of the neat formulation. As we can see, the heat released in the neat formulation is the highest, which indicates that the addition of filler to the formulation reduces the conversion achieved, probably due to topological restrictions produced by the particles. However, the addition of alumina leads to the lowest enthalpy released, which can be related to the inactivation of the growing cationic species in the basic alumina surface. In previous studies with BN as the filler no effect was observed in the kinetics which agrees with the inert chemical character of the BN particles, but there was a reduction in the released enthalpy, independent of the filler content, related to topological hindrance to the homopolymerization reaction [
15]. All the cured samples were submitted to a second DSC scan but no T
g could be observed due to the high crosslinking achieved in the epoxy matrix because of the compact structure of the epoxy resin and the homopolymerization produced in the curing.
3.2. Rheological Behavior of Mixtures
Mixtures before curing were essayed by rheology to analyze their viscoelastic behavior. The particle size of the different fillers is in the same range, and the particle shapes are quite similar. These two properties are the ones having the strongest influence on the rheological behavior. Although density differences in the fillers selected lead to a variation on their volumetric content, the similarity between particles allowed us to perform the comparison among the different formulations [
16,
17]. The linear viscoelastic region (LVR) was determined in oscillatory tests, varying amplitude of deformation with a fixed frequency (1 Hz) at 30 °C. As in previous studies with BN [
4,
15,
18], the LVR is displaced to lower amplitudes when the filler proportion increases. This means that the mixture’s microstructure finds a critical strain above which the structure organization starts to breakdown at lower amplitudes when the amount of filler grows [
19]. Thus, the amplitude was set at the LVR for each mixture to carry out the frequency sweep experiments. The effect of the filler content for each type of filler on the complex viscosity (
η*) is represented in
Figure 2.
As we can see in all the mixtures, to a greater or lesser extent, shear thinning is observed. This is due to a diminution of viscosity on increasing the frequency applied, attributable to changes in the microstructure of the mixture, typical of filled blends. In contrast, the neat formulation represents an almost constant value on varying the frequency, which means that it has a Newtonian behavior. Mixtures with alumina and silicon carbide present a very large difference in viscosity between 60 and 70 wt % (3 orders of magnitude) and 5–7 orders of magnitude in reference to the neat formulation. On the other hand, the addition of aluminum nitride does not produce any large effect until the addition of 75 wt %. Thus, from the point of view of the application on surfaces or filling molds, aluminum nitride is the best suited.
Studies on micro and nanoparticle composites showed that the thermal conductivity of the composites is significantly smaller than that of their bulk counterparts due to phonon-interface scattering [
20]. Commonly, the used fabrication techniques, such as hot pressing, tend to produce randomly particle distributed composites, forming clusters of particles. When particles with high thermal conductivity are randomly dispersed in a matrix material with low transport properties, the largest cluster can form a percolation network [
21]. Thus, the largest cluster of thermally conductive material can connect the opposite boundaries when the volumetric concentration of particles reaches certain limit. This limit of volumetric concentration, defined as the percolation threshold, is determined by the geometric characteristics of particles. The percolating network can create a low resistance pathway for thermal transport and the conductivity of the composites can increase notably once reached percolation [
22]. The significant changes in the microstructure, related to the percolation threshold, can be evaluated by the study of storage modulus (G’) and loss modulus (G’’), which determine the elastic and viscous properties, respectively.
Figure 3 shows the plots of both moduli on changing the frequency for all the formulations studied.
An interpretation of Rouse-like behavior takes as a criterion that when G’ and G’’ at low frequencies become equal the percolation threshold has been reached [
18,
23]. This means the transition from non-percolated to percolated response must be accompanied by the change from the liquid-like behavior (G’ < G’’) to solid-like behavior (G’ > G’’). In
Figure 3A this change is observed between the mixtures of 60 and 70 wt % of alumina, as corresponds to the large increase in viscosity (
Figure 2A). In case of AlN blends (
Figure 3B) only liquid like behavior is exhibited until the 70% of filler added. For this reason, a new mixture with the 75% of AlN was also prepared to surpass the rheological percolation. It must be commented, that this is the practical limit for a hand-mixing procedure. Since all particle sizes are similar, the lower viscosity of AlN formulations could be attributed to the lower specific surface area (SSA) of AlN powder. Finally, the mixtures with 50 and 60 wt % of SiC (
Figure 3C) are very close to reach the percolation but this is not surpassed until 70% wt % of SiC. A high increase of viscosity is observed in the transition (
Figure 2C). Apart from the high volumetric ratio due to its low density, this high viscosity is assumed to be related to the high SSA.
3.3. Morphological Analysis
The appearance of the different fillers used in this study as well as the fracture surface of the prepared composites was analyzed by ESEM. Representative micrographs are shown in
Figure 4.
The morphological characteristics of the fillers used in the present study are shown in the first row of the figure. In the next two rows, two images of each type of composite with different filler contents and different magnifications have been also included. As we can see, SiC is formed by particles with a polyhedral shape with smooth surface. In the composite with a 70 wt %, these particles are not well bonded to the polymeric matrix, which agrees with the inert character of SiC in the DSC kinetic study. The particles are very close to each other, which confirms that the percolation has been reached.
The particles of alumina and AlN are like aggregates and polydisperse in size. However, AlN particles are much smaller and more polydisperse. Both type of particles seems to be quite well bonded to the epoxy matrix as can be seen in the micrographs of the bottom row, which accounts for an interaction of the surface groups with the growing chains, as was deduced from the retardation and acceleration of the curing process detected by calorimetric studies. The micrograph of AlN at 70 wt % composite show that some of the particles are isolated, since at this filler content percolation has not been reached. The inspection of the fracture surfaces of the samples with a 50 wt % of each filler allows confirming the homogeneous distribution of the particles on the epoxy matrix and the tough characteristics of the fracture, since the fracture cracks are very tortuous.
3.4. Thermal and Mechanical Characterization of Composites
The addition of filler can increase some thermomechanical properties of polymeric materials. Particles act as a reinforcement of the polymer network leading to the improvement of some properties as thermal stability, stiffness or hardness.
TGA, DMTA, TMA and microindentation experiments were performed in the composites prepared to evaluate these characteristics and to investigate the effect of each of the fillers on them.
The evaluation of the thermal stability performed by TGA analysis is represented in
Figure 5. As can be seen, the shape of the curves is similar which implies that the presence of fillers does not influence the degradation mechanism.
Table 2 collects the data of char yields and the temperature of 2% of decomposition (T
2%). A large difference can be observed in the T
2% between the neat epoxy and the composites, of around 100 °C. In a previous study [
15] using the same epoxy system but adding BN till 40 wt % this increase was more than 70 °C. The reason for this increase is the less resin content to be degraded and therefore T
2% occurs at higher temperature. However, on changing the type of filler these temperatures experiment small variations when the same proportion was added, which could be attributed to differences in the organic network structure. In fact, greater differences on changing the proportion are observable for alumina and AlN composites, in line with the effect of the filler on the curing process observed with DSC. As can be seen in the table, practically the total amount of ECC is decomposed in inert atmosphere and char residues agrees quite well with the proportion of filler added. What can be assumed is that the introduction of particles does not negatively affect the thermal stability of composites.
Thermomechanical behavior of composites was analyzed by DMTA.
Table 2 shows the rigidity and the temperature of the maximum of tan δ peak, related to T
g. Young’s modulus measured at 30 °C is highly increased with the addition of filler. This is due to the mechanical reinforcement role played by the particles within the matrix. In
Figure 6, the tanδ curves are shown.
It can be seen that the relaxation curves are very broad and have low intensity as in ECC-BN composites [
15], indicating a slow relaxation process and a low homogeneity in the network structure due the high crosslinking density and to the inherent inhomogeneity caused by ring-opening polymerization mechanism. As DMTA evaluates the thermomechanical characteristics, the results are influenced by the mechanical role played by the particles on the organic matrix. In this way, it can be seen a notable change in the T
g of the materials with alumina and SiC when it exceeds percolation. Conversely, materials with AlN show a gradual increase of T
g without major changes when percolation is achieved.
The values of the storage modulus (E’) in the rubber state could not be determined, since in the tan δ curves we can observe that the complete relaxation of the material is higher than 300 °C, and at this temperature the decomposition of the polymeric matrix has already begun.
The thermal expansion coefficient is an important parameter for the reliability and working life of epoxy materials when they operate as coatings or as thermal interface materials (TIMs) since changes in their working temperature can produce high internal stresses due to the mismatch between the CTE the epoxy coating or TIM, and the substrate, the former being larger [
24]. This can provoke de-adhesion between the interfaces they bond, wrapping or any type of defects that finally reduce the durability of the materials. Reducing the CTE of the epoxy coating or TIM would reduce the CTE mismatch and this would result in an enlargement of the working-life of the devices.
CTEs were evaluated by TMA and the results are given in
Table 2. As expected, on increasing the filler content CTE’s are notably reduced. The reduction of this coefficient is gradual with the percentage of filler added. The CTE of the ceramic filler does not affect much the values of the composite materials. However, the addition of 75 wt % of AlN, which has the lowest CTE, leads to the lowest value of 22 ppm/K in all the composites prepared.
Another characteristic that has an effect on the durability of composites is the surface hardness of the materials. By means of microindentation tests, the Knoop hardness of each composite was determined and the values are represented in
Figure 7.
As in the case of materials with BN [
4,
15,
18], the hardness increased with the filler loading. The change of the type of particles added should also affect in principle, the improvement reached. It is reported that the hardness of the ceramic fillers follows the order SiC > Al
2O
3 > AlN [
25]. However, this trend is not followed in our composites, since the greater effect on hardness is originated by AlN, which leads to more than 6-fold improvements on adding a 75 wt % of this filler to the epoxy formulation. These unexpected results could be rationalized in a better interaction between the organic matrix with the filler in case of AlN, or to the particle size and shape that undoubtedly should affect hardness characteristics. In a previous study on composites with the same polymer matrix but a 40 wt % BN filler, the maximum hardness value reached was only 26.6 KHN (Knoop Hardness) and the progressive improvement of the hardness with the filler content occurs more smoothly than in the present study [
15]. However, in that work the proportion of filler was lower, the percolation was reached at 14.4 wt %, because of the platelet-like shape of the particles. This leads to the conclusion that for hardness improvement, the fillers used in the present study are better than the previous studied h-BN filler, and among them, AlN is the most effective.
3.5. Thermal Conductivities
The main goal of the study was to increase the thermal conductivity of the cycloaliphatic epoxy matrix by the addition of thermal conductive particles. The results of the thermal conductivity determined for the composites prepared are represented in
Figure 8.
The highest conductivity values (1.21 W/m·K) were reached for the sample with a 75 wt % of AlN, followed by the composite with the highest proportion of SiC (1.12 W/m·K). However, it is quite curious that at the same filler content (70%) SiC leads to a higher value of this parameter, although pure AlN has a much higher conductivity than pure SiC. This unexpected result could be explained on the basis of the conductive pathways formed by the filler particles, which is related to the percolation phenomenon, which for AlN has not been achieved at this filler content.
The thermal conductivity obtained in the present study is higher than that obtained in BN composites (1.04 W/m·K) [
15]. However, in the present case a higher proportion of filler has been added to the formulation, since the addition of h-BN was limited to 40 wt %, because of the difficulty of the manual preparation of mixtures with a higher proportion of this filler. However, the different shape and size of the filler particles finally leads to big differences in the surface area and on the interactions with the organic matrix and makes it difficult to come to general conclusions. In a previous study, we could demonstrate the influence of the size and shape of the particles on the thermal conductivity of this type of composites [
18].
As we have seen, the higher the proportion of filler, the better is the thermal conductivity, but any big difference is observed between the different particles used, being the most important effect the achievement of the percolation. However, it should be taken into account that mechanical properties and processability can become worse with a high proportion of fillers and both characteristics should also be considered in the improvement of thermal management. For this reason, as an alternative, the use of nanofillers, with high specific surface area that can be chemically modified, will be attempted in the forthcoming studies of our group.