Scanning and transmission electron microscopy have been intensely used by several groups to analyze the structural organization of
G. duodenalis [
17,
20,
21,
22]. In all studies, the surface of trophozoites obtained from axenic cultures (
in vitro) showed a smooth appearance without any type of surface projections. Even when a high-resolution SEM is used, most of the time, the parasite surface appears, as shown in
Figure 1, where small protuberances can be seen, as well as some clumps of small vesicles. With TEM, no protrusions are observed (
Figure 1b). In this work, we used
G. duodenalis incubated with anti-VSP monoclonal antibodies in
in vitro experiments. For TEM, the parasite was incubated with an antibody against VSPH7 and immediately fixed. There was a homogeneous distribution on the membrane (
Figure 1b). However, when the parasites were incubated with an anti-VSP antibody and a more careful analysis was carried out, it was possible to visualize protrusions that appeared initially with a mean diameter of 150 nm and a variable height (
Figure 2,
Figure 3 and
Figure 4).
Figure 1.
Overview of the ultrastructure of G. duodenalis trophozoites. VSPH7 clones were stimulated with anti-H7 antibodies and immediately fixed. (a) The ventral region of a trophozoite observed by HR-SEM shows that the parasite’s membrane does not present extensions. The folds in the posterior region above the ventral disk (VD) correspond to the flange (FL). The four pairs of flagella (F1–F8) are visible. (b) The parasite observed by TEM reveals the two nuclei (N), peripheral vesicles (PV), the ventral disk (VD), and axonemes (A). The plasma membrane appears to be continuous, with a homogeneous anti-H7 labeling along its length.
3.1. TNT-like Structures Origin
As demonstrated by Tenaglia and collaborators [
15], the parasites can exchange VSPs on the plasma membrane, excluding one type of VSP, by forming extracellular vesicles on the membrane itself after incubation with anti-VSP antibodies. The incubation time with the antibodies favored the formation of projections on the membrane of the parasites
in vitro (
Figure 2). After 30 min of incubation, there was an accumulation of vesicles in a grape cluster-like arrangement [
15]. At the same time, plasma membrane projections were noted in the dorsal region (
Figure 2a,c), ventral region (
Figure 2b), and on the flagella (
Figure 2c) of the cell by HR-SEM. We observed the same growth pattern of the projections through TEM (
Figure 2a’,c’); note that these regions show the presence of labeling with anti-VSP antibodies. Hemphill and collaborators [
23] also used the mAb G10/4 on
G. duodenalis H7 clones and observed vesicle formation after 5 min of incubation with the antibody using transmission electron microscopy. They suggested that these vesicles were associated with membrane disintegration or “weakening”, potentially contributing to the cytotoxicity of anti-VSP mAbs. In contrast, our observations, along with those of Tenaglia and colleagues [
15], indicate that these vesicles are not a sign of cellular damage or death. Instead, they represent a process known as antigen removal coupled to switching (ARCS), where microvesicles selectively remove surface-bound antibodies while simultaneously inducing VSP switching [
15].
Figure 2.
Membrane protrusion and vesicle formation in G. duodenalis. Different cell clones were stimulated for 30 min with their respective antibodies before fixation for electron microscopy. Both HR-SEM and TEM show that all clones exhibit plasma membrane protrusions (arrows). Small vesicles can also be observed (arrowheads). Anti-VSP antibody labeling is observed on these membrane protrusions and vesicles by TEM (a’–c’). (a,a’) Clone VSP 1267 stimulated with mAb 7F5; (b,b’) clone VSPH7 stimulated with mAb G10/4; (c,c’) clone VSP417 stimulated with mAb 7C2.
Figure 2.
Membrane protrusion and vesicle formation in G. duodenalis. Different cell clones were stimulated for 30 min with their respective antibodies before fixation for electron microscopy. Both HR-SEM and TEM show that all clones exhibit plasma membrane protrusions (arrows). Small vesicles can also be observed (arrowheads). Anti-VSP antibody labeling is observed on these membrane protrusions and vesicles by TEM (a’–c’). (a,a’) Clone VSP 1267 stimulated with mAb 7F5; (b,b’) clone VSPH7 stimulated with mAb G10/4; (c,c’) clone VSP417 stimulated with mAb 7C2.
3.2. TNT-like Structures Growth
The growth of thin membrane projections occurs due to the accumulation of vesicles (
Figure 3). After 60 min of
G. duodenalis exposure to anti-VSP antibodies
in vitro, we observed a greater accumulation of extracellular vesicles (
Figure 3a,b), which appear disorganized (
Figure 3a’,b’).
It was observed that a similar process occurred
in vivo when gerbils (
Meriones unguiculatus) were infected with
Giardia clones expressing VSP417 [
15]. At the onset of the humoral immune response, large membrane extensions and vesicles identical to those observed after
in vitro treatment with antibodies were seen in trophozoites collected from the small intestine 12 days post infection. Here, we observed these large membrane extensions in more detail (
Figure 4). Occasionally, it was possible to see that some of these parasite membrane extensions, called TNT-like structures, display periodic strangulation (
Figure 4a–c). Through TEM analysis, we observed an organization of extracellular vesicles after 120 min of exposure of
G. duodenalis to anti-VSP antibodies
in vitro, which may suggest that the constriction of the TNT-Like structures is associated with the aligned vesicles (
Figure 4d). A similar profile of extracellular vesicle release was observed in
Trypanosoma brucei [
12]. However, the authors demonstrated that these vesicles are released from a formation via membrane nanotubes carrying virulence factors, facilitating resistance to the innate immune response. These data are consistent with those provided by Tenaglia and collaborators [
15], but we propose here that some of these vesicles may remain together, forming TNT-like structures. This hypothesis is based on our observations during late stages of post-infection
in vivo assays, where the constricted profiles seen in
Figure 4 were no longer evident. At this time, we do not believe that we are dealing with ECVs, but rather with membrane protrusions resembling the TNT structures observed in other cells. However, we cannot exclude the possibility that VSP switching
in vivo may exhibit similar characteristics to those observed
in vitro. In our most recent publication [
15], we demonstrated that VSP replacement occurs via vesicle release, but these vesicles are discharged in clusters. Utilizing an actin marker would be crucial for distinguishing the formation of these structures, although conducting such an analysis
in vivo would be challenging.
Figure 3.
Growth of TNT-like structures formed by extracellular vesicles. G. duodenalis clones VSPH7 (a,a’) and VSP417 (b,b’) were stimulated with their respective antibodies (mAb G10/4 and mAb 7C2) for 60 min before fixation for electron microscopy. HR-SEM (a,b) shows an increase in membrane projections in the flange region (FL), where a cluster of vesicles can be observed (arrows). This cluster of disorganized vesicles can be visualized by TEM (a’,b’). Note that in (b’), the vesicles are located in the flange (FL). There is specific anti-VSP antibody labeling in the vesicle accumulation region (a’,b’).
Figure 3.
Growth of TNT-like structures formed by extracellular vesicles. G. duodenalis clones VSPH7 (a,a’) and VSP417 (b,b’) were stimulated with their respective antibodies (mAb G10/4 and mAb 7C2) for 60 min before fixation for electron microscopy. HR-SEM (a,b) shows an increase in membrane projections in the flange region (FL), where a cluster of vesicles can be observed (arrows). This cluster of disorganized vesicles can be visualized by TEM (a’,b’). Note that in (b’), the vesicles are located in the flange (FL). There is specific anti-VSP antibody labeling in the vesicle accumulation region (a’,b’).
Therefore, we cannot exclude the possibility of two types of membrane arrangement: ECVs and TNT-like structures. Additionally,
Giardia does not have an organized actin filament cytoskeleton as observed in other cells [
24]; instead, it exhibits a globular actin organization, similar to what we have observed in the related protozoan
T. vaginalis [
25].
Figure 4.
Elongation of TNT-like structures through the sequential organization of vesicles. VSP417 clone parasites were obtained from experimental infection in gerbils at 12 days post infection and observed by HIM (a–c). Note that a long extension of aligned vesicles (arrows) is seen in the flange (FL) (a,b), on the flagellum (F) (b), and in the dorsal region of the parasite (c). (d) shows an alignment of vesicles by TEM in a VSP417 clone parasite stimulated in vitro for 120 min with mAb 7C2, where intense labeling is seen. In all images, the vesicles can be clearly visualized.
Figure 4.
Elongation of TNT-like structures through the sequential organization of vesicles. VSP417 clone parasites were obtained from experimental infection in gerbils at 12 days post infection and observed by HIM (a–c). Note that a long extension of aligned vesicles (arrows) is seen in the flange (FL) (a,b), on the flagellum (F) (b), and in the dorsal region of the parasite (c). (d) shows an alignment of vesicles by TEM in a VSP417 clone parasite stimulated in vitro for 120 min with mAb 7C2, where intense labeling is seen. In all images, the vesicles can be clearly visualized.
3.3. TNT-like Structures Are Present during In Vivo Infection
The presence of TNT-like structures is well evidenced
in vivo. Cytometric analysis of VSP expression in
Giardia populations within the gut of gerbils (
Figure 5) showed that antigenic variation occurs by day 12 post infection. At days 5, 7, and 10 post infection, over 94% of the population still expressed VSP417 at the time of euthanization, indicating that no specific antibodies were yet secreted in the gerbil’s gut. By day 14 post infection, however, no trophozoites expressed the original VSP417, indicating a complete antigenic switch (
Figure 5). The cytometry data align with the morphological analyses observed through high-resolution microscopy of the
in vivo infection. Since the antigenic switching occurs at 12 dpi and peaks at 14 dpi, there is a clear change in the phenotype observed in the TNT-like structures after 12 dpi. The parasites observed in the intestinal lumen of gerbils after 12–14 days post infection exhibit numerous nanotubes, some of which are notably extensive (
Figure 6 and
Figure 7). The characteristic periodic constrictions in the membrane extensions, commonly seen in earlier stages, are now observed much less frequently. Instead, the nanotubes present a more continuous and elongated projection (
Figure 6b,d). TNT-like structures can be observed in all regions of the parasite, with a preference for the flange (
Figure 6a,b). During the
in vivo infection, we observed the intense interaction of
G. duodenalis with the intestinal epithelial cells (
Figure 6). We noticed a specific contact between the TNT-like structures of the parasites and the intestinal microvilli (
Figure 6c,d). Mechanisms of interaction between the TNT-like structures and cytonemes of parasites and host cells have been reported [
14,
26]. It has been shown that contact between
Leishmania donovani and immune cells, such as B cells and macrophages, stimulates the formation of TNT-like structures in these immune cells, facilitating parasite transmission between them [
26]. The results of this study show that parasites can slide between the TNT-like structures of a macrophage to B cells and between B cells. This indicates that during
in vivo infection with
L. donovani, the transmission of parasites from infected macrophages to B cells and then their dissemination among B cells, leading to the activation of polyclonal B cells, may occur [
26]. It has been demonstrated in
T. vaginalis that cytonemes of these parasites are in intimate contact with host cells and that such membrane extensions might be related to increased adhesion of the parasite to the host cell, as
Trichomonas is an extracellular parasite and adhesion is a crucial event in its biology [
14]. Other studies with
T. vaginalis and
T. foetus show that membrane projections are important in contact with host cells and in establishing infection [
27,
28]. These results support our observation of the importance of contact between the TNT-like structures of
G. duodenalis and host cells.
Figure 5.
Representative cytograms showing the distribution shift from VSP417(+) to VSP417(−) populations during animal infections with a VSP417 clone. Quadrants were set to reflect positive staining for VSP417 (VSP417(+), horizontal axis), positive staining for VSPs other than VSP417 (VSP417(−), vertical axis), and positivity for both dyes. Density plots indicate the percentage of each population at 10, 12, and 14 days post infection (dpi).
Figure 5.
Representative cytograms showing the distribution shift from VSP417(+) to VSP417(−) populations during animal infections with a VSP417 clone. Quadrants were set to reflect positive staining for VSP417 (VSP417(+), horizontal axis), positive staining for VSPs other than VSP417 (VSP417(−), vertical axis), and positivity for both dyes. Density plots indicate the percentage of each population at 10, 12, and 14 days post infection (dpi).
In the
in vivo analyses, a proximity of parasites to each other is observed when adhering to intestinal cells (
Figure 7). Intimate contact between TNT-like structures emerging from the flagella of one parasite is seen with membrane extensions of an adjacent parasite (
Figure 7a,b). This may suggest that these structures could facilitate information exchange between
G. duodenalis populations. In
T. vaginalis, it was observed that contact between different strains of the parasite through their cytonemes contributed to a greater formation of cellular aggregates [
14]. There are several terms used to describe membrane protrusions involved in cell–cell contact. Two types of membrane protrusions that may be confused are cytonemes and tunneling nanotubes (TNTs). The main difference between them is that cytonemes are extremely thin, and their interaction with another cell ends with the membranes coming into close proximity [
4]. In contrast, TNTs can exhibit vesicular trafficking and, upon coming into contact with another cell, fuse their membranes to connect the cytoplasm of both cells [
29]. However, various organizations of TNT-like structures can be observed, where membrane fusion and cytoplasmic connection may not necessarily occur. This depends on the cell type and the cellular context [
30]. This variety of similar structures within the category of membrane protrusions has led to the use of several acceptable terms: thin membrane protrusions, membrane extensions, TNT-like protrusions, cellular bridges, specialized filopodia, and signaling filopodia [
30]. In this context, we include the TNT-like structures observed in
G. duodenalis. A similar role of communication between the same cell types through nanotubes was observed in
T. brucei, where membrane extensions in the form of nanotubes trigger the release of extracellular vesicles carrying the serum resistance-associated protein necessary for human infectivity from one
Trypanosoma to another [
12].
Figure 6.
Presence of TNT-like structures during in vivo infection. VSP417 clone parasites are observed by HIM 12 days post infection in gerbils. (a) Overview of parasites adhered to the intestinal epithelium. (b) TNT-like structures can be observed in all regions of the parasite, with a preference for the flange (FL). (c) Intimate contact of a TNT-like structure with the intestinal villi; this image is artificially colored to highlight the parasite in yellow and the villi in purple. This relationship can be seen in greater detail in (d), where the TNT-like structures are highlighted in blue, showing their projection on the flagellum (F) and contact with the villi (arrow).
Figure 6.
Presence of TNT-like structures during in vivo infection. VSP417 clone parasites are observed by HIM 12 days post infection in gerbils. (a) Overview of parasites adhered to the intestinal epithelium. (b) TNT-like structures can be observed in all regions of the parasite, with a preference for the flange (FL). (c) Intimate contact of a TNT-like structure with the intestinal villi; this image is artificially colored to highlight the parasite in yellow and the villi in purple. This relationship can be seen in greater detail in (d), where the TNT-like structures are highlighted in blue, showing their projection on the flagellum (F) and contact with the villi (arrow).
Figure 7.
Large extensions of TNT-like structures during in vivo infection. VSP417 clone parasites are observed by HIM 14 days post infection in gerbils. (a) Interaction between 3 artificially colored parasites for better visualization is observed in the intestine, each parasite is marked with a different color. (b) Contact is observed between TNT-like structures emerging from a flagellum (arrow) and the TNT-like structures of an adjacent parasite. (c,d) Large extensions of TNT-like structures (arrowhead) are observed in the dorsal region of G. duodenalis; these TNT-like structures can measure up to 4 µm in length. (e) Note that small vesicles can still form in the dorsal region (asterisks), as seen in the in vitro analyses. (f) TNT-like structures can emerge from any region of the flagella (arrows).
Figure 7.
Large extensions of TNT-like structures during in vivo infection. VSP417 clone parasites are observed by HIM 14 days post infection in gerbils. (a) Interaction between 3 artificially colored parasites for better visualization is observed in the intestine, each parasite is marked with a different color. (b) Contact is observed between TNT-like structures emerging from a flagellum (arrow) and the TNT-like structures of an adjacent parasite. (c,d) Large extensions of TNT-like structures (arrowhead) are observed in the dorsal region of G. duodenalis; these TNT-like structures can measure up to 4 µm in length. (e) Note that small vesicles can still form in the dorsal region (asterisks), as seen in the in vitro analyses. (f) TNT-like structures can emerge from any region of the flagella (arrows).
Moreover, the examination of trophozoites within the intestinal lumen of gerbils showed a larger number of TNT-like structures, some of which are very extensive and can reach up to 4 µm in length (
Figure 7c,d). TNTs were seen at the distal portion of the flagella (
Figure 7c–e) and show the formation of small vesicles as described above for trophozoites obtained from axenic cultures (
Figure 7e,f). As shown in
T. foetus, TNT-like structures can emerge from different portions of the parasite’s cell body [
13].