3.2. Metal Levels and Ionic Components
Summary data (mean, minimum and maximum) of 16 metals’ concentrations determined in PM
10 air samples are reported in
Table 4 and
Table 5 for the urban-background site (NA01) and the urban-traffic site (NA02), respectively. The metals represented, on average, 3%–4% of the PM
10 concentrations at both sites (NA01, NA02). Fe and Al were the most abundant among the metals at both sites and can be associated with soil resuspension and long-range transport of crustal dust [
19]; followed by Cu and Zn, especially associated with traffic and combustion [
20].
In autumn, Al, Fe, Cu and Mo showed great variation (p < 0.01) between the sites. Many elements (Cr, Cu, Fe, Al, Zn, Mn, Mo, Ag, Ba) demonstrated great variation (p < 0.01) between the four seasons at both sites. Particularly, Al, Fe, Mn and Mo showed significantly higher (p < 0.01) concentrations during autumn, while Ba and Ag exhibited a higher concentration, due to industrial and traffic emissions, during summer.
Furthermore, the concentrations of toxic metals (Pb, Ni, As and Cd), associated with PM10 and classified by International Agency for Research on Cancer IARC as carcinogenic to humans (Group 1), did not exceed the EU’s limits (500, 20, 6 and 5 ng∙m−3, respectively). Moreover, Cd and As were below the detection limit values.
In
Table 6 and
Table 7 are reported the water-soluble ions’ concentrations determined in PM
10 air samples for the urban-background site (NA01) and the urban-traffic site (NA02), respectively. At NA02, many elements (F
−, Cl
−, K
+ SO
42−) showed significant (
p < 0.01) differences between seasons; at NA01, other than the above-mentioned elements, also NO
3− showed significant (
p < 0.01) differences. In autumn, F
−, Cl
−, K
+ NO
3− and SO
42− showed higher concentrations (
p < 0.01) at NA02 than NA01; as the exception, Ca
2+ and Mg
2+ did not demonstrate significant seasonal variations at any of the sites, thus suggesting constant emissions throughout the year.
Ionic soluble species were about 30% of PM
10 concentrations. In particular, the sum of SO
42−, NO
3− and NH
4+ (SIA) represented about 20% of PM
10 mass at both sites. This suggests that a significant part of aerosol is associated with the formation of secondary inorganic particles (SIA). The presence of dominant anions (SO
42− and NO
3−) is due to the oxidations of NO
x and SO
2 (gaseous precursors) emitted from anthropogenic activities, particularly present in the urban ambient atmosphere. In both sites, during the summer, the higher concentrations (
p < 0.01) of SO
42− suggested an additional photochemical formation, based on meteorological conditions [
9], but it could also be related to the increase of ships docking in the port, which use sulfur-rich fuels. During the summer, the numbers of cruise ships, private and public ferries increase because Naples is a touristic location, and the ferries link the city to the islands of Capri, Ischia, etc. Otherwise, the concentrations of nitrate were lowest in summer; this could be attributed to the low thermal stability of the nitrate in the hot season [
21]. The greater concentrations of Na
+ and Cl
− (
p < 0.01) in the cold seasons, with respect to spring and summer, could be due to a larger contribution of marine aerosol. The increase in the concentrations of sea salt species in the cold seasons might be attributed to local meteorological conditions, such as the occurrence of fresh wind (speed above 10 m/s) from the south with the transport of salt-enriched air mass from the sea to the land. As is well established, the sea salt species are produced at the sea surface by the bursting of air bubbles as a result of air retention induced by wind [
22,
23].
Ionic concentrations in Naples are comparable to those previously found in other cities, as well as to those reported for other urban sites in Europe and Asia [
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22,
23,
24].
Statistical software (XLSTAT 2015) [
25] was used to verify the possible correlations between the different metal and ionic species in PM
10 at the NA01 (
Table 8) and NA02 (
Table 9) sites.
The analysis of the single correlation coefficients showed that at both sites, there is a good correlation between Na+ and Cl− (0.662 for NA01 and 0.79 for NA02) and, to a lower extent, with Mg2+. This result evidenced the presence of a marine contribution to the measured PM10 concentrations and it also supported the hypothesis of a double origin of Mg2+: crustal matter and marine aerosol. The correlation between NH4+ and SO42− (0.690 for NA01 and 0.660 for NA02) indicated their secondary origin. Finally, at both sites, there was a clear correlation between Fe, Al, K+, Ca2+ and, to a lesser extent, Mg2+, and only for NA01 was the correlation extended to Na+ .This suggested a possible common origin of these species, that is crustal mineral.
3.3. Carbon Species
The mean and range concentrations of the carbon species (OC, EC and IC) determined in PM
10 at the two sites (NA01 and NA02) are shown in
Table 10 and
Table 11, respectively.
EC is a good indicator of primary anthropogenic air pollution, while OC has a double origin; both emitted from primary emission sources and formed from chemical reactions of primary gaseous organic compounds in the atmosphere [
26]. The sources of carbon aerosols can be qualitatively estimated by studying the relationship between OC and EC mass concentrations.
The OC/EC ratios (seasonal averages) at the two sites were in the range of 2.1–4.3 showing a clear prevalence of organic compared to elemental carbon species, which indicates potential secondary organic aerosol formation. The seasonal OC/EC ratios, at both sites, were comparable to those reported in the literature for other European cities [
27,
28].
At NA02, OC and EC concentrations showed significant seasonality (p < 0.01). Furthermore, OC and EC levels in the collected samples were significantly higher (p < 0.01) in autumn and summer. Surprisingly, in summer, the concentrations of OC were 7.3% and 4.8% higher than those registered in winter, at NA01 and NA02, respectively.
3.5. Reconstruction of the Chemical Composition
For reconstructing the particulate mass (mass closure), the chemical components were divided into six categories as follows: mineral dust (MD), organic matter (OM), elemental carbon (EC), sea salt (SS), secondary inorganic aerosol (SIA) and trace elements (TE). At each site, the contributions showed the differences in emission sources [
31].
Mineral dust (MD) represents the sum of typical crustal materials, including Al, Si, Mg, K, Ca and Fe. Each of these species was multiplied by an appropriate factor (Equation (2)) to account for its common oxides (Al
2O
3, Fe
2O
3, CaO, MgO, K
2O) following the approach reported in the literature by several authors [
8,
32,
33,
34]:
K
2O was calculated as total (Fe) times 0.6. Organic matter (OM) was found by multiplying the concentration of organic carbon (OC) with a factor of 1.4 for an urban-background site and 1.3 for an urban-traffic site, as proposed by Harrison et al. [
35]. The EC contribution was reported as determined by the elemental analyzer. In this study, the marine contribution (SS) (Equation (3)) was calculated, assuming that soluble Na
+ in PM
10 samples was obtained solely from sea salt. The latter was the sum of Na
+ concentration and fractions of the concentrations of Cl
−, Mg
2+, K
+, Ca
2+ and SO
42− based on the standard sea water composition and ignoring atmospheric transformation [
8].
Ss-Cl− is calculated as total [Na+] times 1.8, [ss-Mg2+] as total [Na+] times 0.12, [ss-K+] as total [Na+] times 0.036, [ss-Ca2+] as total [Na+] times 0.038 and [ss-SO42−] as total [Na+] times 0.252.
Secondary inorganic aerosol (SIA) contribution was calculated as the sum of non-sea salt nss-SO
42− (calculated by subtracting ss-SO
42− from total SO
42−), NO
3− and NH
4+ [
8,
36].
Trace elements (TE) were also added to the analysis for their relevant toxicity and anthropogenic origin [
37]. TE (Ba, V, Cr, Mn, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, As, Sb, Se, Mo and Pb) represented only a small percentage (less than 1%) of the PM
10 total mass.
The results of the chemical mass closure for PM
10 at the two sites (NA01 and NA02) are shown as seasonal mass concentrations and relative percentage contributions in
Table 12 and
Figure 2.
Figure 2 shows that organic matter, secondary inorganic aerosols, mineral dust and sea salt were the main contributors to PM
10 mass concentrations at both sites.
In particular, organic matter (OM) dominated the PM
10 profiles at the NA02 site with percentage contributions in the range of 21.3%–32.6% of total PM
10 mass. The contribution of OM at both sites was higher in summer (
p < 0.01) (32.6% and 26.7%, respectively) than in other seasons. This could be explained by the position of both sites (NA01 and NA02), which are located not far away from the harbor (about 2 and 1 km, respectively). The number of docked ships increases during the summer. In addition, the higher temperatures and lack of rain foster the process of man-triggered illegal combustion of waste, which is characteristic of the “land of fires” [
38].
The mineral dust (MD) showed significant differences (p < 0.01) between the seasons and sites and represented a percentage between 9.8% and 16.8%. Secondary inorganic aerosol (SIA) represented a percentage between 13.1% and 23.8% of PM10 mass. In NA02, the concentrations were significantly higher (p < 0.01) in autumn and summer than NA01. Due to the location of Naples, sea salt (SS) showed greater concentrations (p < 0.01) in the cold seasons than in the hot seasons, at both sites. In summer the percentage concentrations were lower with a value of 9.7% for NA01 and 7.1% for NA02, because the salt was dissociated into gaseous compounds more in summer than other seasons. Elemental carbon (EC) showed a percentage contribution between 3.3 and 8.1%. In NA02 during summer and autumn, the percentage contribution was higher (p < 0.01) than NA01. EC showed a comparable trend with OC.
On average, the calculated total mass explained about 70%–80% of the total PM
10 mass, determined gravimetrically, for both urban-background (NA01) and traffic sites (NA02). Therefore, the unknown PM
10 fractions mass (~20%–30%) at both sites might be attributed to the factor of conversion used for the estimation of the organic matter amount and mineral dust [
39].
Figure 3 shows a linear regression of the daily reconstructed and gravimetrically-measured mass concentrations for the two sites.
Good correlations (R2 > 0.8) were found between reconstructed mass and gravimetric mass, indicating overall good accord at both sites.
3.6. Principal Component Analysis
Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to identify the possible sources of the PM
10 at the two sites. The main purpose of this method is to reduce the matrix of individual species into groups of data (factors). The factors can be associated by similar characteristics and therefore connected with specific sources. The varimax rotation method was used in order to identify the factor. The eigenvalue for extracted factors was more than 1.0. The number of factors is detected so that they explain the highest maximum total variance of the data. In the literature, it is recommended to use 50–200 samples subject to variable ratios (STV) of 3–20 [
40].
In this study, statistical analyses were obtained using XLSTAT 2015. Factor analysis was applied to a population with the following data: N = 74, p = 24 and STV = 3.1. The considered components (p) were: Al, Ag, Ba, Cr, Fe, Mn, Mo, Ni, Pb, Cu, V, Zn, F−, Cl−, NO3−, SO42− Na+, NH4+ K+, Mg2+, Ca2+, OC, EC, IC.
Six factors were extracted as principal components (eigenvalue >1) that explained 75.7% and 79% of the variance of the data at NA01 and NA02, respectively.
The sources identified were crustal, sea salt, secondary inorganic, combustion source, road-side dust, industrial emissions and were based on the loadings of the variables in the factors (
Table 13).
The first factor (F1) is responsible for 21% and 23% of the total variance at NA01 and NA02, respectively. F1 was designated as crustal origin by the observation of the major contribution of Al, Fe and Mn and Ca2+ at both sites; however, at NA02, there was an extra IC and K+.
The second factor (F2) is responsible for 9.2% and 10% of the variance at NA01 and NA02, respectively. F2 was characterized with large amounts of Cl
− and Na
+, suggesting a sea salt origin. The third factor (F3) is responsible for 10% of the variance at NA01 and NA02, respectively, and was designated as secondary inorganic by the observation of the major contribution of NH
4+ and SO
42−. The fourth factor (F4) is responsible for 14.5% and 16% of the variance at NA01 and NA02, respectively, and was attributed to combustion sources because of the exhibition of high loading of EC and OC. The fifth factor (F5) was attributed to road-side dust, re-suspended (from metalled roads and road pavement) by anthropogenic factors (e.g., traffic). The metals (Ba, V, Cu, Cr and, to a smaller extent, Mo and Mg
2+) were characteristic of NA01 and accounted for 12% of its variance, while (Ni, Cu, Zn and, to a smaller extent, Ba, Mn and V) were responsible for 14% of the variance at NA02. The sixth factor (F6) indicated a mixture of industrial emissions (Zn and Pb, for NA01, and Ag and Pb, for NA02) [
41] and explained 9.0% and 6.0% of the total variance.