eIDAS Regulation and Its Impact on National Legislation: The Case of the Slovak Republic
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
author/s prepared great article on eIDAS Regulation and its Impact on National Legislation. there are not so many articles like this published, thus support this article to be published. also the methodology and literature used is well choosen.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for your positive review.
Best regards, authors
Reviewer 2 Report
The article examines the eIDAS Regulation as a key and groundbreaking legal regulation of the European Union. Above all, I appreciate the appropriate choice of methods, especially the critical analysis of the adopted eIDAS regulation, primarily examined through its impact on the existing legislation regarding electronic signatures and the adopted amendments, necessary for the unification of the legal framework for electronic signatures of the member states of the European Union. By analyzing the legal aspects of the electronic signature, the authors came to pain points, which had to be revised and incorporated into the new Act on Trusted Services due to the adopted regulation. I also appreciate, and for the result of the study was beneficial, that the authors incorporated selected application problems from practice, or scientific and doctrinal interpretations associated with the application of scientific and scientific literature. The authors of the study thus confirm the opinion of the village and professional community, and point out that there are still problems that need to be solved by amending the law. In general, the study is spaced very interestingly and stimulatingly with relevant overlaps in the application level. I therefore only propose to expand the background of international scientific opinions and also to discuss the results of these supplemented studies in the results section of the article.Author Response
Dear Reviewer 2,
Thank you very much for your positive review and constructive comment. We greatly appreciate your well-intentioned advice, which we have fully incorporated into the revised version of the manuscript.
Best regards, authors
