A Golden Treasure from Korea: The Gilt-Bronze Bodhisattva Statue of Silla
Abstract
:1. Introduction
2. The Sŏllimwŏn Temple Site
3. Production Method, Materials, and Decoration
4. Dating the Sŏllimwŏn Bodhisattva
5. Conclusions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Conflicts of Interest
1 | For research detailing the excavations of the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site and the gilt-bronze standing bodhisattva statue discovered at the site, see the following scholarship (Im 2020, pp. 5–34). This paper published in 2020 revealed that the original name of the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site was actually Ŏksŏng Temple and identified the monks who visited the site. The research particularly focused on determining which monk commissioned and then enshrined the gilt-bronze bodhisattva statue. The present paper takes a different approach by primarily focusing on the results of the five-year conservation project and is based on an examination of the scientific analysis and production method of the statue. |
2 | The 59 examples of gilt-bronze Buddhist statues found in Kyŏngju are categorized by height as follows: less than 5 cm (15), 5 to 10 cm (16), 10 to 20 cm (14), 20 to 30 cm (12), exceeding 30 cm (2) (Yang 2011, pp. 262–63). Of the few extant gilt-bronze Buddhist images from the late Unified Silla period, none are similar in size to the Sŏllimwŏn bodhisattva statue. Thus, there are no suitable candidates for a stylistic comparison. Bodhisattva images from the Unified Silla period are rare in general and are not usually addressed in surveys of Korean Buddhist sculpture, such as the two representative publications penned by scholars Kang Woo-bang and Kim Lena. (Kang 1995, pp. 388–91; Kim 2007, pp. 83–99). |
3 | The Silla royal court also commissioned a large gilt-bronze statue of a standing bodhisattva measuring 5 m high for Hwangnyongsa, the designated royal temple. It was made by mixing copper and a small amount of tin and completed in 573 CE. Unfortunately, the statue disappeared during the Mongol invasion of 1238. Iryŏn 一然 (1206–1289), Samguk Yusa 三國遺事 (Legends and History of the Three Kingdoms) Taishō 49, no.2039:990a24. |
4 | Gilt-bronze Buddhist statues of the Silla kingdom measuring up to 5 cm high were commonly discovered in stupas, while statues taller than 10 cm have been uncovered from a variety of findspots. Examples are occasionally unearthed at the excavation sites of Main Halls but are more commonly found in stupas or at the sites of structures such as the Lecture Hall or monk’s living quarters. For research which examines gilt-bronze Buddhist statues in terms of the relationship between size and function, see the following scholarship (Kim 2014, pp. 7–41). |
5 | The four treasures are presently housed at the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site. They include the tortoise-shaped pedestal and dragon-shaped capstone of the Stele of Master Honggak. However, the stele itself was found in pieces, which are now in the collections of Dongguk University Museum and Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum. As the surviving fragments only make up a portion of the entire monument, it is not possible to restore the stele to its original appearance at this time. |
6 | This dharma bell is significant as it can be positively dated to 804 based on an inscription located on the interior of the bell. The bell was discovered at the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site in October 1948, then relocated to Wŏlchŏng Temple 月精寺 on 29 November 1949. Not even two years passed in January of 1951 and the bell was damaged during the Korean War. The surviving portions of the bell were placed in the collection of the Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum (Yi 1955, pp. 457–92). For scholarship regarding the dharma bell, see (Hwang 1998, pp. 7–14; Ch’oe 2002, pp. 55–81; Yi 2014, pp. 54–69). |
7 | With the exception of a gilt-bronze standing bodhisattva statue approximately 9.3 cm high, the first excavations of the site in 1985 did not produce any notable finds (Mun 1991, pp. 165–66). |
8 | Main History of Silla, Book 12, compiled by Kim Pusik 金富軾 (1075–1151), Samguk sagi 三國史記 [History of the Three Kungdoms]. King Sindŏk (r. 912–917) 4th. |
9 | The event of Yŏmgŏ’s sojourn in Sŏllimwŏn Temple is recorded in the following stele inscription. ‘Changhŭng Porimsa Pojosŏnsa ch’angsŏngt’appimun’ 長興 寶林寺 普照禪師 彰聖塔碑文 compiled by Kim Wŏn 金薳 (?–?). The following scholarship discusses the event in further detail (Im 2020, pp. 9–13). |
10 | For more information on Master Honggak as well as monks Sunŭng and Yŏmgŏ, see the following scholarship (Im 2020, pp. 9–10). |
11 | As discerned in endnote number 5, the surviving fragments of the Stele of Master Honggak are distributed across the collections of Dongguk University Museum and Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum. The stele’s tortoise-shaped pedestal and dragon-shaped capstone are registered as treasures number 446 and exhibited at the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site along with a replica of the stele. Scholarship on the stele and Master Honggak is as follows (Kwŏn 1992, pp. 637–43; 2002, pp. 5–16; 2008, p. 397; Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum 2014, pp. 112–21). |
12 | The characters read ‘Sŏllim 禪林’, which is a common noun that denotes a temple of the Sŏn School. This point is further discussed in the following scholarship (Im 2020, pp. 10–11). |
13 | Though I concur with the identification of ‘Ŏksŏng Temple’ as the structure’s original name, the more widely recognized term ‘Sŏllimwŏn’ is used throughout this essay to prevent any potential confusion. |
14 | There are two additional examples of Korean Buddhist sculptures that portray a figure exceeding a height of 50 cm. One is the gilt-bronze standing bodhisattva statue (54.5 cm) designated National Treasure number 129 at Leeum, Samsung Museum of Art. The other is a gilt-bronze standing statue of Vairocana (52.8 cm) in the collection of the Gyeongju National Museum. Notwithstanding the relatively large heights, both examples do not have established findspots (Im 2016, pp. 108–11). For scholarship on the gilt-bronze statues of standing bodhisattvas from the Unified Silla period, see the following (An 2012, pp. 65–95). |
15 | After conservation treatment, the bodhisattva figure measures 38.8 cm and 4 kg heavy, while the pedestal is 11.6 cm large and weighs 3.6 kg. |
16 | Refer to endnote number 2. |
17 | One exception to this rule is the Avalokitesvara bodhisattva from Baekje enshrined in the Treasure House of Hōryū-jiin Nara, Japan. The basic form of the bodhisattva figure was carved from wood. All other elements, such as the crown, necklace, and water bottle, are individual pieces separate from the body. The exception was borne of practical circumstances as the figure is 2.09 m tall and thus considerably large. The complexities of carving such intricate ornamentation would have posed a challenge to even the most skilled sculptors. A simple solution was to create any decoration as a separate component that could be attached at convenience. However, this was a highly unorthodox method of production during a period when Buddhist sculptures less than 1 m high typically came from a single block of the original material. |
18 | When the method of lost-wax casting was applied to the production of gilt-bronze Buddhist sculpture, a casting hole was created to connect and secure the inner mold to the outer mold. Upon completion of the sculpture, the inner mold was scraped away and removed from the final product through the hole. |
19 | There is also the possibility that the hole was covered using paper covered in gold as a way of hiding the cavity carved into the figure’s back. |
20 | Though trace amounts of silver have been detected, they amount to less than one percent of the overall composition, which suggests that the metal was probably not added intentionally (Hanbit Institute of Cultural Properties 2021, p. 284). |
21 | Though there is only a limited amount of data, the available analyses indicate that in the case of Buddhist sculpture of the ninth century, lead (Pb) is either absent or less than one percent of the overall composition (Sin and Kim 2020, pp. 11–12; Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum 2014, pp. 284–85). |
22 | Data is still being compiled, but the present analyses do not yet provide sufficient grounds to determine the production place or date of Buddhist sculpture based on the presence or absence of lead alone. |
23 | (Hanbit Institute of Cultural Properties 2021, pp. 284–85). Mercury (Hg) was detected on the surface of the statue, indicating the use of amalgam-plating with gold (Au) dissolved in mercury. This plating method is a common surface treatment technique used for small gilt-bronze statutes in ancient Korea (Sin and Kim 2020, pp. 1–16). |
24 | In China, the ch’ŏnŭi and nagaek are known as tianyi and luoye, respectively. |
25 | The bottom plate of the outer sarira reliquary consists of 99.39 percent copper and 0.49 percent silver. This particular combination is nearly identical to that of the halo decorating the Sŏllimwŏn bodhisattva (Pyŏn and Cho 2021, pp. 102–3). |
26 | Many Buddhist statues made of pure copper remain in Japan, where copper is an abundant resource (Min and Kwŏn 2017, pp. 473–74). |
27 | Glass beads that were embedded in the kwikkot ornamentation were also found at the site. |
28 | The Sŏllimwŏn bodhisattva has a nose with a prominent bridge, while the iron Vairocana Buddha of Porim Temple has a flat and low nose. Albeit this difference, the two Buddhist sculptures share an identical basic form and style. For scholarship on the iron statue of the seated Vairocana Buddha at Changhŭng Porim Temple, see the following (Pak 2020, pp. 7–31). |
29 | Ch’ejing became the disciple of Yŏmgŏ at Ŏksŏng Temple. The details of this event are recorded on the Stele of Master Pojo at Changhŭng, Porim Temple 長興 寶林寺 普照禪師塔碑 erected in 884 CE. |
30 | Of the various stone artifacts found at the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site, the three-story stone pagoda is dated to the latter half of the ninth century. It is thought to be the continuation of a sculptural and architectural tradition inherited from the three-story stone pagoda dated to the first half of the ninth century at the nearby Chinjŏnsaji Site (So 2002, p. 48). |
31 | The monk’s pagoda of the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site was disassembled during the Japanese occupation of Korea but restored to its original state in 1965 (Chŏng 1974, p. 232; Chŏng 1996, pp. 204–6). The pagoda’s current location is not original, as it was first erected in an area some 50 m above the midpoint of a mountain bordering the rear of the Sŏllimwŏn Temple site. The pagoda was likely constructed in 886 CE along with the Stele of Master Honggak. |
32 | For more information on Korean gilt-bronze Buddhist Images, see the following scholarship (An 2012, pp. 65–95; Im 2019, pp. 35–58; Im 2001, pp. 229–63). |
33 | Additional analyses and examinations may provide data that will allow future scholars to establish an accurate date and place of production based on the chemical composition of the Sŏllimwŏn bodhisattva. However, the current data is yet insufficient for such an endeavor. |
References
Primary Sources
Kim Pusik 金富軾 (1075–1151), Samguk sagi 三國史記 [History of the Three Kungdoms].Kim Wŏn 金薳 (?–?), ‘Changhŭng Porimsa Pojosŏnsa ch’angsŏngt’appimun’ 長興 寶林寺 普照禪師 彰聖塔碑文.Iryŏn 一然 (1206–1289), Samguk Yusa 三國遺事 [Legends and History of the Three Kingdoms].Secondary Sources
- An, Hyŏnchŏng. 2012. ‘T’ongil Silla kŭmdong posal ipsang ŭi yuhyŏng kwa t’ŭkching’ [Types and Features of Gilt-bronze Images of Standing Bodhisattva from Unified Silla Kingdom]. Tongyang misulsahak 12: 65–95. [Google Scholar]
- Ch’oe, Ŭngch’ŏn. 2002. ‘Sŏllimwŏnji pŏmjong ŭi pogwŏn kwa ŭiŭi’ [Making a Replica of the Bell from Sŏllimwon Site and Its Meaning]. Kangjwa misulsa 18: 55–81. [Google Scholar]
- Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum. 2014. ‘Honggak Sŏnsa pi’ [Stele of Master Honggak]. In Sŏllimwŏnjong Yŏmgŏ Hwasangt’apchi. Ch’unch’ŏn: Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum, pp. 112–21. [Google Scholar]
- Chang, Jŏngmin. 2015. ‘Yangyang sŏllimwŏnji chŏngmil balgulchosa’ [Excavation in Yangyang sŏllimwŏn site]. Chungbu gogohak’oe haksultaehoe nonmunjip 2: 125–30. [Google Scholar]
- Chŏng, Yŏngho. 1974. ‘Sŏllimwŏn Honggak Sŏnsat’ap ŭi ch’ujŏng’ [Deduction of Sŏllimwŏn Honggaksŏnsa Stupa]. In Hasŏng Yi Sŏn’gŭn Paksa kohŭi kinyŏm Han’gukhak nonch’ong. Seoul: Nonch’ong Kanhaeng Wiwŏnhoe, p. 232. [Google Scholar]
- Chŏng, Yŏngho. 1996. ‘Yangyang Sŏllimwŏnji e taehayŏ’ [On the Yangyang Sŏllimwŏn Temple site]. Misulsahak yŏn’gu 71: 204–6. [Google Scholar]
- Hanbit Institute of Cultural Properties. 2021. Yangyang Sŏllimwŏnji yujŏk [Remains of the Sŏllimwŏn Temple Site in Yangyang]. Seoul: Hanbit Institute of Cultural Properties. [Google Scholar]
- Hwang, Suyŏng. 1998. ‘Yangyang Sŏllimwŏnji ch’ult’o ŭi Silla pŏmjong’ [The Silla Temple Bell at the site of Sǒllimwǒn in Yangyang]. Munhwa sahak 10: 7–14. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2001. ‘9segi Silla wanggyŏng ŭi Pirojana pulsang’ [The Vairocana Buddha Images in Silla’s Capital in the 9th Century]. Ihwa sahak yŏn’gu 62: 229–63. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2011. ‘Samdan p’algak yŏnhwa taejwa ŭi T’ongil Silla suyong kwa chŏn’gae’ [Acceptance and Development of the ‘Octagonal Three-step’ Lotus Pedestal in Unified Silla]. Silla munhwa 38: 288–94. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2016. ‘Kŭmdong yŏrae ipsang’ [Gilt-bronze Standing Buddha Statue]. In Munhwajae taegwan pomul—Pulgyo chogak I. Taejŏn: Cultural Heritage Administration, pp. 108–11. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2017. ‘Ponghwa Ch’uksŏsa Sŏkcho Pirojanabul chwasang mit Mokcho kwangbae: Ch’uksŏsa wa wanggyŏng chin’gol kwijok, kŭrigo Hwangnyongsa’ [The Stone Seated Vairocana Buddha and Wooden Mandorla in Ch’uksŏ Temple, Ponghwa]. Ihwa sahak yŏn’gu 55: 41–75. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2019. “Pulguksa ŭi 9 segi Sillimgye pŭlgyo chogak” [The 9th Century Buddhist Sculptures of the disciples of Sillim in Pulguk Temple]. Misulsahak 37: 35–58. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2020. ‘Rock-Carved Buddhas at Ch’ilburam Hermitage in Namsan Mountain, Kyŏngju’. Buddhist Studies Review 37: 175–97. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2020. ‘Saero palgyŏndoen Sŏllimwŏnji kŭmdong posal ipsang: T’ongilgi Silla posalsang ŭi myŏngjak’ [Newly Discovered Gilt-bronze Standing Bodhisattva from Sŏllimwŏn Temple site: A Masterpiece of Unified Silla]. Misulsahak yŏn’gu 308: 5–34. [Google Scholar]
- Im, Yŏngae (Lim, Young-ae). 2021. ‘Tonghwasa Piroam ŭi tu Pirojana pulsang: Pogwan Pirojanabul chwasang kwa Purhyŏng sŏkcho Pirojanabul chwasang’ [The Two Vairocana Buddha Images of Piroam, Tonghwa Temple: ‘Crowned Vairocana’ and 565 ‘Buddha Image Vairocana’]. Pulgyo misul 23: 31–61. [Google Scholar]
- Kang, Woo-bang (Kang, Ubang). 1995. Han’guk Pulgyo chogak ŭi hŭrŭm [The stream of Korean Buddhist sculpture]. Seoul: Taewŏnsa. [Google Scholar]
- Kim, Lena. 2007. Buddhist Sculpture of Korea. Seoul: Hollym. [Google Scholar]
- Kim, Tongha. 2014. ‘Silla t’ongilgi Sogŭmdong pulsang ŭi yuhyŏng kwa yongdo e kwanhan siron-Kyŏngju chiyŏk palgul ch’ult’op’um chungsim ŭro’ [A Study on the Purposes of Small Gilt-bronze Buddha Statues of the Unified Silla Period]. Pulgyo misulsahak 18: 7–41. [Google Scholar]
- Kwŏn, Kijong. 2002. ‘Honggak Sŏnsa pimun ŭl t’onghae pon Sŏllimwŏn’ [Sŏllimwon as it appears in the Epigraph of Sŏn Master Honggak]. Kangjwa misulsa 18: 5–16. [Google Scholar]
- Kwŏn, Tŏgyŏng. 1992. ‘Silla Honggak Sŏnsa pimun ŭi pogwŏn sido’ [Attempt to Restore the Silla Sŏn Master Honggak Master’s epitaph]. In Kasan Yi Chigwan Sŭnim hwagap kinyŏm Han’guk Pulgyo munhwa sasangsa 1. Seoul: Kasan Nonch’ong Kanhaeng Wiwŏnhoe, pp. 637–43. [Google Scholar]
- Kwŏn, Tŏgyŏng. 1998. ‘Honggak Sŏnsat’ap pimun ŭl t’onghae pon Silla Ŏksŏngsaji ŭi ch’ujŏng’ [Estimation of Silla Ŏksŏngsa site as it appears in the Silla Sŏn Master Honggak’s epitaph]. Sahak yŏn’gu 55–56: 75–88. [Google Scholar]
- Kwŏn, Tŏgyŏng. 2008. ‘Silla Honggak Sŏnsa t’appi wŏnhyŏng t’amgu’ [Research into Original Form of the Stupa Monument of Sŏn Master Honggak]. Silla munhwa 32: 397. [Google Scholar]
- Kwŏn, Tŏgyŏng. 2009. ‘Silla Toŭi Sŏnsa ŭi ch’ogi pŏpkye wa Ŏksŏngsa’ [Early lineage of Silla Toŭi Master and Ŏksŏng Temple]. Sillasa hakpo 16: 197–224. [Google Scholar]
- Min, Pyŏngch’an, and Kangmi Kwŏn. 2017. ‘Han’guk kwa Ilbon Kŭmdong pan’ga sayusang ŭi t’ŭkching—Sŏngbun punsŏng kyŏlgwa rŭl chungsim ŭro-’ [Characteristics of Korean and Japanese Gilt-bronze Pensive Bodhisattva—Focusing on the Results of Component Analysis]. In Han-Il kŭmdong pan’ga sayusang—Kwahakchŏk chosa yŏn’gu pogo-. Seoul: Korea National Museum of Korea, pp. 473–74. [Google Scholar]
- Mun, Myŏngdae. 1991. ‘Sŏllimwŏnji palgul chosa yakpogo’ [Excavation Report of the Sŏllimwon Temple site]. Pulgyo misul 10: 164–72. [Google Scholar]
- Nam, Tongsin (Nam, Dongshin). 1992. ‘Sŏllimwŏn chongmyŏng’ [Inscription on the Sŏllimwŏn Bell]. In Han’guk kodae kŭmsŏngmun 3—Silla-Parhae p’yŏn. Seoul: Karak Kuksajŏk Kaebal Yŏn’guwŏn, pp. 394–96. [Google Scholar]
- Nam, Tongsin (Nam, Dongshin). 2012. ‘Kŭmsŏk ch’ŏngwan yŏn’gu’ [Research on the Book of Epigraphical Rubbings (Kŭmsŏk ch’ŏngwan)]. Han’guk chungsesa yŏn’gu 34: 361–434. [Google Scholar]
- Pak, Haksu. 2017. ‘Kŭmdong pan’ga sayusang ŭi sŏngbunbunsŏng kyŏlgwa’ [Result of Analysis of the Components of Gilt-bronze Pensive Bodhisattva]. In Han-Il kŭmdong pan’ga sayusang—Kwahakchŏk chosa yŏn’gu pogo-. Seoul: Korea National Museum of Korea, pp. 494–97. [Google Scholar]
- Pak, Sŏngyŏn. 2020. ‘Porimsa ch’ŏlcho Pirojanabul chwasang chosŏng chuch’e wa paegyŏng’ [The Principal Sponsor and Background of Iron Seated Vairocana Buddha of Porim Temple]. Misulsahak 40: 7–31. [Google Scholar]
- Pyŏn, Chinsuk, and Kyŏngmi Cho. 2021. ‘Tonghwasa Piroam samch’ŭng sŏkt’am ch’ult’o sarioeham minmyŏn yumul ilgwalp’um kwa mokche sot’ap ŭi kwahakchŏk chosa mit pojonch’ŏri pogosŏ’ [Base side of outer sarira reliquary and miniature wooden pagoda found from the Three-story Stone Pagoda at Piroam Hermitage of Tonghwa Temple: Scientific survey and preservation treatment]. Pulgyo misul 32: 102–3. [Google Scholar]
- Sin, Yongpi, and Chiho Kim. 2020. ‘Puyŏ Kyuam-ri ch’ult’o Kŭmdong Kwanŭm posal ipsang ŭi hyŏngsang kwa chejak kibŏp’ [The Structure and Production Technique of the Gilt-bronze Standing Avalokiteśvara from Kyuam-ri, Puyŏ]. Pangmulgwan pojon kwahak 23: 11–12. [Google Scholar]
- So, Chaegu. 2002. ‘Sŏllimwŏnji samch’ŭng sŏkt’ap ŭi chohyŏngjŏk t’ŭkching kwa ŭiŭi’ [Distinctive Modelling Characteristics and the Significance of the Three-story Stone Stupa in Sŏllimwon Temple site]. Kangjwa misulsa 18: 48. [Google Scholar]
- Yang, Ŭn’gyŏng. 2011. ‘Silla kŭmdongbul e taehan punsŏk kwa ch’ult’oji ŭi sŏngkyŏk kyumyŏng’ [An Analysis of Unified Silla Gilt-bronze Buddha Statues and an Investigation of the characteristics of the Excavation Site]. In Silla ŭi kŭmdongbul. Kyŏngju: Kyŏngju National Research Institute of Cultural Heritage, pp. 262–63. [Google Scholar]
- Yi, Hongjik. 1955. ‘Chŏngwŏn 20 nyŏn chaemyŏng Silla pŏmjong Yangyang Sŏlsan ch’ult’op’um’ [Silla Bell with Inscription -Excavation in Yangyang Sŏlsan]. In Paek Nakchun Paksa hwan’gap kinyŏm kukhak nonch’ong. Seoul: Nonmun Kanhaeng Wiwŏnhoe, pp. 457–92. [Google Scholar]
- Yi, Yonghyŏn. 2014. ‘Myŏngmun ŭro pon Sŏllimwŏnjong chosŏng’ [Production of Sŏllimwŏn’s Bell as it appears in the inscription]. In Sŏllimwŏnjong Yŏmgŏ Hwasangt’ap chi. Ch’unch’ŏn: Ch’unch’ŏn National Museum, pp. 54–69. [Google Scholar]
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. |
© 2022 by the author. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Share and Cite
Lim, Y.-a. A Golden Treasure from Korea: The Gilt-Bronze Bodhisattva Statue of Silla. Religions 2022, 13, 554. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel13060554
Lim Y-a. A Golden Treasure from Korea: The Gilt-Bronze Bodhisattva Statue of Silla. Religions. 2022; 13(6):554. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel13060554
Chicago/Turabian StyleLim, Young-ae. 2022. "A Golden Treasure from Korea: The Gilt-Bronze Bodhisattva Statue of Silla" Religions 13, no. 6: 554. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel13060554
APA StyleLim, Y. -a. (2022). A Golden Treasure from Korea: The Gilt-Bronze Bodhisattva Statue of Silla. Religions, 13(6), 554. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel13060554