1. Introduction
Colloidal nanocrystals (NCs) offer a substantial promise for the design and fabrication of solid state structures and devices. Size-tunable electronic structure and optical properties render this class of materials attractive for various applications in photonics, optoelectronics, and sensors [
1]. The size and shape of colloidal NCs can be controlled
in situ by simply adjusting the synthesis conditions [
2], allowing for the exploitation of quantum confinement to manipulate their optical properties. Furthermore, colloidal NCs can be modified post-synthetically by functionalization and conjugation with organic or biomolecules [
3], or by forming a composite with polymers or other nanostructures [
4,
5]. This ability to combine solid state-like optical and mechanical properties of NCs with the opportunities for their chemical modifications in solution opens a number of possibilities to use them as building blocks in optical and photonic devices.
With increasing concerns about the global energy supply and sustainable use of natural resources, the search for new low-cost materials for energy efficient lighting has intensified in recent years [
6]. The total amount of electrical energy used for lighting exceeds 20% at the global level, with residential and commercial sectors being responsible for the majority of lighting electricity consumption [
7]. Light emitting diodes (LEDs) have emerged as a long-term alternative to traditional incandescent light bulbs, owing to their efficiency, durability, and reliability [
8]. The most promising approach to white LEDs has been to combine GaN blue LED with remote phosphors, most notably yellow-emitting yttrium aluminum garnet doped with cerium (Ce:YAG) [
9]. However, the adoption of such white LEDs for general lighting applications has been rather slow because of the high manufacturing cost, and non-optimal characteristics of light (low color rendering index and high correlated color temperature) [
10]. The deficiencies of the spectral properties have been addressed by the addition of other rare earth element-based phosphors to augment the spectral density in the red part of the spectrum [
11,
12], further increasing the complexity and cost of the final devices and making it difficult to obtain homogeneous white light in a reproducible manner. Colloidal II–VI NCs with selected average sizes have also been used in combination with remote phosphors to generate “warm” white light [
13].
We have recently demonstrated the ability to produce white light and tune its chromaticity by conjugating transparent metal oxide NCs with organic fluorophores (dyes) emitting in the complementary spectral range [
14,
15]. The core of this phenomenon is a defect-based photoluminescence of these metal oxide NCs. In the case of colloidal γ-Ga
2O
3 NCs the emission is based on electron donor-acceptor pair (DAP) recombination [
16]. It arises from the recombination of an electron trapped on an oxygen vacancy forming localized electron donor states with a hole trapped on a gallium–oxygen vacancy pair acting as an electron acceptor [
17,
18]. A range of distances between electron donor and acceptor sites, as well as coupling of the electronic transition with lattice phonons are likely reasons for significant broadening of this emission band [
17,
19]. Owing to the proximity of the NC surface-bound organic fluorophore to the DAP recombination sites, and the overlap of its absorption spectrum with the DAP photoluminescence (PL) band, the photoexcited Ga
2O
3 NCs can transfer the excitation energy to the conjugated dye molecules via the Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) mechanism [
20]. This approach has allowed us to obtain a hybrid nanoconjugate acting as a single white light-emitting fluorophore [
11,
12].
In this work, we demonstrate the design and preparation of new colloidal white light-emitting nanocomposite obtained by controlled conjugation of II–VI and γ-Ga2O3 NCs using a simple molecular linker. The ability to manipulate the PL spectra of CdSe/CdS (core/shell) NCs by changing the core size and/or shell thickness allows for fine tuning of the red side of the nanocomposite emission to generate white light with the desired chromaticity. The spectral overlap between the PL of the energy donor (Ga2O3 NCs) and the absorption of the energy acceptor (core/shell CdSe/CdS NCs) enables their electronic coupling by FRET. Using the PL quenching of the energy donor determined from the steady-state and time-resolved PL measurements, we quantified the contributions of the direct excitation and energy transfer to the emission of CdSe/CdS NCs. The nanocomposite demonstrated in this work represents an important step toward single-phased all-inorganic rare earth element-free white light-emitting phosphor.
2. Results and Discussion
The average size and morphology of colloidal Ga
2O
3 NCs used in this study were determined by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The NCs are quasi-spherical and have an average diameter of
ca. 5.5 nm (
Figure 1a). The X-ray diffraction (XRD) pattern confirms that these NCs exhibit cubic crystal structure characteristic for the γ-Ga
2O
3 (
Figure 1b). We chose CdSe/CdS core/shell NCs as a complementary solid-state emitter because they possess a strong size-tunable red emission, which could allow for the generation of white light when coupled with the Ga
2O
3 DAP PL. A typical TEM image of CdSe/CdS NCs is shown in
Figure 1c. As-synthesized CdSe NC cores have an average size of
ca. 2.2 nm, as determined from the band gap absorption energy [
21]. From the comparison of the average NC sizes before and after the shell growth, the average thickness of the shell was estimated to be
ca. 2.3 nm, consistent with the core/shell NCs prepared under similar conditions [
22]. These estimates were confirmed using the corresponding band edge absorption energy (
Figure 1d).
Figure 1.
(a) Overview transmission electron microscopy (TEM) image of colloidal γ-Ga2O3 nanocrystals (NCs) having an average dimeter of ca. 5.5 nm; (b) X-ray diffraction (XRD) pattern of the same NCs; vertical black lines represent a reference XRD pattern of bulk γ-phase Ga2O3; (c) Overview TEM image of ca. 6.8 nm CdSe/CdS core/shell NCs; (d) Absorption (red) and photoluminescence (PL) (blue) spectra of CdSe/CdS NCs (solid lines), and the absorption spectrum of the corresponding CdSe NC cores (red dashed line).
Figure 1.
(a) Overview transmission electron microscopy (TEM) image of colloidal γ-Ga2O3 nanocrystals (NCs) having an average dimeter of ca. 5.5 nm; (b) X-ray diffraction (XRD) pattern of the same NCs; vertical black lines represent a reference XRD pattern of bulk γ-phase Ga2O3; (c) Overview TEM image of ca. 6.8 nm CdSe/CdS core/shell NCs; (d) Absorption (red) and photoluminescence (PL) (blue) spectra of CdSe/CdS NCs (solid lines), and the absorption spectrum of the corresponding CdSe NC cores (red dashed line).
To facilitate the conjugation of Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs we used thioglycolic acid (TGA), which can bind to NC surfaces through both thiol and carboxylic acid functional groups [
23]. Thiols are known to bind strongly to the CdSe or CdS quantum dot surfaces [
24,
25], and in our previous studies we showed that carboxylic acid group reacts with the surface of Ga
2O
3 NCs [
15,
20]. An overview TEM image of the CdSe/CdS-conjugated γ-Ga
2O
3 NCs is shown in
Figure 2a. The NCs form extended networks owing to the strong binding of the linker to the NC surfaces.
Figure 2b shows a high resolution TEM image of conjugated NCs. The nanocrystals within a formed aggregate are identified by measuring their lattice spacing. The close proximity of Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs shown in
Figure 2b confirm their conjugation. To determine the overall homogeneity of the colloidal NC conjugate we performed energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) elemental mapping in the scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) mode. A STEM image and the corresponding maps of Ga and Cd are shown in
Figure 2c–e, respectively. The Ga and Cd maps are well correlated, indicating homogeneous distribution of both types of NCs within the aggregate.
CdSe/CdS NCs are excellent FRET acceptors because their absorption spectrum strongly overlaps with the emission spectrum of Ga
2O
3 NCs (
Figure 3), providing a basis for the FRET mechanism. Furthermore, the quantum yield of these NCs is very high, in some cases reaching over 90% [
26]. The spectral overlap is calculated as:
where
FD(λ) is the emission of the FRET donor with an integrated intensity normalized to unity, and ε
A(λ) is the molar extinction coefficient of the acceptor at wavelength λ. Spectral overlap is the key parameter determining the critical radius (
R0), also known as the Förster radius, which is defined as the separation at which the energy transfer efficiency is 50%.
In this expression
Q0 is the donor quantum yield in absence of the acceptor,
nr is the index of refraction of the solvent,
NA is the Avogadro's number and κ
2 is the dipole alignment factor which we define as 2/3. This value is appropriate when donor and acceptor dipole orientations are random and experience no ordering [
20,
27,
28]. In the case of Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs, the Förster radius was calculated to be 7.13 nm. In order to observe FRET in colloidal suspension, Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs must be within 21.4 nm (3
R0). This distance is much smaller than the average separation of free standing NCs in solution phase, which was estimated to be over 250 nm even for the highest NC concentrations used. To induce FRET in solution, the NCs were conjugated with a bifunctional TGA linker, as described in the Experimental Section. Based on the TEM images, the average sizes of Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs are
ca. 5.5 and 6.8 nm, respectively. Assuming the length of TGA of 0.5 nm, the center-to-center separation between bound NCs should be
ca. 6.7 nm, well within the limit of 21.4 nm.
Figure 2.
(
a) Overview TEM image of colloidal Ga
2O
3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugate obtained using NCs shown in
Figure 1; (
b) High resolution TEM image of the same sample. Orange and blue circles indicate CdSe/CdS and Ga
2O
3 NCs, respectively; the lattice spacings shown correspond to {002} and {311} planes of CdS and Ga
2O
3, respectively; (
c–
e) Scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) image of the nanocrystal conjugate (
c); and the corresponding Ga (
d) and Cd (
e) energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) elemental maps.
Figure 2.
(
a) Overview TEM image of colloidal Ga
2O
3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugate obtained using NCs shown in
Figure 1; (
b) High resolution TEM image of the same sample. Orange and blue circles indicate CdSe/CdS and Ga
2O
3 NCs, respectively; the lattice spacings shown correspond to {002} and {311} planes of CdS and Ga
2O
3, respectively; (
c–
e) Scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) image of the nanocrystal conjugate (
c); and the corresponding Ga (
d) and Cd (
e) energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) elemental maps.
Figure 3.
Absorption spectrum of CdSe/CdS NCs (orange line) and PL spectrum of Ga2O3 NCs (blue line). Excitation wavelength for Ga2O3 NCs is 250 nm. Shaded area indicates a spectral overlap, as an essential requirement for Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET).
Figure 3.
Absorption spectrum of CdSe/CdS NCs (orange line) and PL spectrum of Ga2O3 NCs (blue line). Excitation wavelength for Ga2O3 NCs is 250 nm. Shaded area indicates a spectral overlap, as an essential requirement for Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET).
Figure 4a shows PL spectra of Ga
2O
3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugates having different CdSe/CdS to Ga
2O
3 NC concentration ratio, upon excitation at 250 nm (corresponding to the Ga
2O
3 band edge). The concentration of CdSe NC cores was determined from the absorption spectrum using the extinction coefficient (ε) value reported for the samples prepared under similar conditions [
21], which allowed us to estimate the concentration of CdSe/CdS NCs as FRET acceptors by assuming quantitative extraction and uniform coating of the cores with CdS shell. The relative concentrations of Ga
2O
3 NCs in the conjugate samples were inferred from EDX elemental analysis, accounting for an average NC volume. The emission intensity of Ga
2O
3 NCs is quenched up to
ca. 40% concurrently with an increase in CdSe/CdS NC emission. Deconvoluted spectra of CdSe/CdS NCs in the nanocrystal conjugates are shown in
Figure S1 (Supplementary Materials). This observation is consistent with the FRET coupling of the two components. However, CdSe/CdS NCs also emit light upon excitation at 250 nm. The PL spectra of CdSe/CdS NCs, treated exactly as in the preparation of NC conjugates but without Ga
2O
3 NCs, are shown with dashed lines in
Figure 4a. Higher PL intensity of CdSe/CdS NCs in the conjugated form attests to FRET between Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs (
Figure S1, Supplementary Materials). In contrast to the NC conjugate, a suspension containing the same concentrations of Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs without the linker exhibits only about a 10% decrease in Ga
2O
3 DAP emission intensity (
Figure 4b). This reduction in the DAP emission occurs because of the direct excitation of CdSe/CdS NCs by a fraction of the excitation source, and is an unavoidable phenomenon when studying FRET between nanoparticles. Similarly, a solution containing Ga
2O
3 NCs and the relevant amount of TGA linker (
vide infra) leads to only a 7.5% reduction in the DAP emission. To determine the concentration of TGA bound to the surface of CdSe/CdS NCs, the absorbance of TGA in the supernatant obtained upon precipitation of TGA-bound NCs was measured. After the initial wash
ca. 94.5% of TGA remained in the supernatant. Additional washing resulted in further removal of the TGA loosely adsorbed on the NC surfaces, suggesting that only
ca. 0.3% of the original amount of TGA is actually bound to CdSe/CdS NCs. Hereafter, the concentration of TGA is given in terms of the equivalents of CdSe/CdS NCs added to Ga
2O
3 NCs (
i.e., the amount of TGA corresponding to certain acceptor to donor concentration ratio). It is evident that some of the reduction in Ga
2O
3 PL intensity also comes from competitive light absorption and/or quenching by the TGA linker (
Figure S2, Supplementary Materials), but the extent to which Ga
2O
3 NC emission is quenched by energy transfer is far greater (
Figure 4c). The existence of FRET is also evident from the excitation spectrum of CdSe/CdS acceptor in the NC conjugate (
Figure S3, Supplementary Materials).
Figure 4.
(a) PL spectra of colloidal Ga2O3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugates (solid lines) having different CdSe/CdS to Ga2O3 NC concentration ratio, as indicated in the graph. PL spectra of thioglycolic acid (TGA)-bound CdSe/CdS NC suspensions having the same concentration as in the NC conjugate are shown with dashed lines (λexc = 250 nm); (b) PL spectra of the mixtures of Ga2O3 and CdSe/CdS NCs prepared in the same way as the NC conjugate but without the TGA linker; (c) Quenching efficiency of the donor-acceptor pair (DAP) emission of Ga2O3 NCs in the conjugate (squares), mixed with CdSe/CdS NCs (circles), and mixed with TGA but without CdSe/CdS NCs (triangles).
Figure 4.
(a) PL spectra of colloidal Ga2O3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugates (solid lines) having different CdSe/CdS to Ga2O3 NC concentration ratio, as indicated in the graph. PL spectra of thioglycolic acid (TGA)-bound CdSe/CdS NC suspensions having the same concentration as in the NC conjugate are shown with dashed lines (λexc = 250 nm); (b) PL spectra of the mixtures of Ga2O3 and CdSe/CdS NCs prepared in the same way as the NC conjugate but without the TGA linker; (c) Quenching efficiency of the donor-acceptor pair (DAP) emission of Ga2O3 NCs in the conjugate (squares), mixed with CdSe/CdS NCs (circles), and mixed with TGA but without CdSe/CdS NCs (triangles).
The energy transfer efficiency is defined by the Förster theory as:
where
RDA is the average separation between donors and acceptors, and
n is the acceptor to donor ratio. FRET efficiency (η) can also be determined experimentally by measuring the donor lifetime shortening in the presence of the acceptors:
where τ
D and τ
DA are the lifetimes of the donor alone and in the presence of the acceptors, respectively. Since DAP emission does not follow a simple exponential time decay [
29], the integrated lifetimes were used to calculate η, instead of the time components obtained as the fitting parameters. The ligands bound to the Ga
2O
3 NC surface can compete with native defects for trapping of the photogenerated free carriers [
14]. Therefore, the DAP emission can also be affected by the molecules bound to the surface of the NCs. When TGA replaces TOPO on Ga
2O
3 NCs in the amount equivalent to that used to conjugate CdSe/CdS NCs, the DAP emission experiences a negligible reduction in lifetime (
Figure 5a). The original DAP PL lifetime is decreased by maximum of
ca. 3% for the amount of TGA corresponding to the highest CdSe/CdS to Ga
2O
3 NC ratio explored in this study (aqua blue trace). On the other hand,
Figure 4b shows progressive shortening of the Ga
2O
3 NC PL lifetime with increasing concentration of TGA-bound CdSe/CdS NCs, confirming that FRET is the dominant quenching mechanism.
Figure 5c compares the quenching efficiency (η) of Ga
2O
3 NCs conjugated with CdSe/CdS NCs via TGA with that of Ga
2O
3 NCs capped with TGA, for different concentrations of the corresponding quencher, calculated using Equation (4). CdSe/CdS-conjugated Ga
2O
3 NCs show significantly higher efficiency for all quencher concentrations confirming the FRET from Ga
2O
3 donor to CdSe/CdS acceptor NCs.
Figure 5.
(a) Time-resolved DAP PL decay of Ga2O3 NCs containing different amounts of surface-bound TGA without CdSe/CdS NCs. TGA equivalents and absolute concentrations (in parentheses) in Ga2O3 NC suspensions are indicated in the graph (aqua blue trace (0.84 mM) represents TGA concentration for the highest acceptor to donor ratio); (b) Time-resolved DAP PL decay of Ga2O3 NCs in the NC conjugates having different CdSe/CdS to Ga2O3 NC concentration ratio, as indicated in the graph; (c) Quenching efficiency of the DAP PL of Ga2O3 NCs in the NC conjugate (squares) and with bound TGA (triangles).
Figure 5.
(a) Time-resolved DAP PL decay of Ga2O3 NCs containing different amounts of surface-bound TGA without CdSe/CdS NCs. TGA equivalents and absolute concentrations (in parentheses) in Ga2O3 NC suspensions are indicated in the graph (aqua blue trace (0.84 mM) represents TGA concentration for the highest acceptor to donor ratio); (b) Time-resolved DAP PL decay of Ga2O3 NCs in the NC conjugates having different CdSe/CdS to Ga2O3 NC concentration ratio, as indicated in the graph; (c) Quenching efficiency of the DAP PL of Ga2O3 NCs in the NC conjugate (squares) and with bound TGA (triangles).
Förster resonance energy transfer efficiency between Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs, calculated using Equation (4), was corrected for possible quenching of the donor emission by TGA (triangle symbols in
Figure 5c), and displayed in
Figure 6 as a function of the acceptor to donor ratio (
n). The acceptor to donor ratio was determined to be 0.9 when 1 mL of CdSe/CdS NC suspension (the largest amount) was added to 1 mL of Ga
2O
3 NC stock suspension. The expression for FRET efficiency (Equation (3)) is an average approximation when the majority of binding sites are occupied or the stoichiometric ratio of the donor and acceptor can be controlled [
20,
28,
30]. The colloidal NCs generally have a large surface area, leading to a large number of possible binding sites, some of which are unoccupied, invalidating this basic model. Instead, the distribution of the acceptors per donor will obey Poissonian statistical model when most binding sites are unoccupied [
31,
32]:
where ξ is an average number of acceptors per donor, while
n is a whole-number acceptor to donor ratio. The FRET efficiency data in
Figure 6 were fit using Equation (5) (dashed line). The fit is of a reasonable quality, with
R2 value of 0.87. The Poissonian fit in
Figure 6 is distinctly different from the energy transfer efficiency predicted by the Förster theory (Equation (3)) using the
R0 and
RDA values of 7.13 and 6.7 nm, respectively (solid line).
The ability to control FRET efficiency in Ga
2O
3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugates by adjusting the acceptor to donor ratio can be used to control the overall chromaticity of the emitted light.
Figure 7 shows an International Commission on Illumination 1931 (CIE 1931) color space diagram of the NC conjugates consisting of different average number of acceptors per donor. The photographs of the colloidal suspensions of the conjugates corresponding to the symbols labeled in the graph are shown as insets. The non-conjugated Ga
2O
3 NCs emit blue light (inset 1). The addition of CdSe/CdS NCs increases the orange-red contribution to the spectral power distribution, owing to both energy transfer and direct excitation. For an optimal ratio of CdSe/CdS to Ga
2O
3 NCs the colloidal NC conjugate suspension has color coordinates in the white light emitting region (0.345, 0.282) (inset 2). The orange-red contribution becomes dominant for high concentration of the CdSe/CdS NCs (inset 3), reaching bright orange color for pure CdSe/CdS NC suspension (inset 4). The CIE 1931 diagram for the mixtures of Ga
2O
3 and CdSe/CdS NCs is shown in
Figure S4 (Supplementary Materials) for comparison. These results demonstrate the promise of using inorganic building blocks to generate tunable white light with characteristic spectral and color properties.
Figure 6.
FRET efficiency in Ga2O3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugate (circles) determined from the DAP PL lifetime data corrected for the lifetime shortenening due to TGA binding. The experimental data were fit using Equation (5) (dashed line). Solid line is the FRET efficiency predicted by the Förster theory (Equation (3)).
Figure 6.
FRET efficiency in Ga2O3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugate (circles) determined from the DAP PL lifetime data corrected for the lifetime shortenening due to TGA binding. The experimental data were fit using Equation (5) (dashed line). Solid line is the FRET efficiency predicted by the Förster theory (Equation (3)).
Figure 7.
International Commission on Illumination 1931 (CIE 1931) color coordinate diagram for Ga2O3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugate having different acceptor to donor ratio. The photographs of the colloidal nanoconjugates corresponding to data points labeled in the graph are shown as insets.
Figure 7.
International Commission on Illumination 1931 (CIE 1931) color coordinate diagram for Ga2O3-CdSe/CdS NC conjugate having different acceptor to donor ratio. The photographs of the colloidal nanoconjugates corresponding to data points labeled in the graph are shown as insets.