1. Introduction
Protective coatings have proven a high effectivity in extending the lifespan of metallic structures and in multiple sectors, including automation parts, with the recent trend to employ aluminum instead of steel due to its fuel economy benefits [
1]. These coatings include paints, organic and inorganic coatings, diffusion layers, metallic coatings, and galvanization [
2]. Thermal spray is a highly versatile technology to obtain ceramic and metallic coatings suitable for various applications and components. It is effective against wear, corrosion, and harsh high-temperature environments, and it enhances thermal efficiency, such as through insulation in aluminum engine cylinders [
3]. Additionally, it is ideal for the repair and restoration of components [
4].
Within the thermal spray techniques, several processes are noteworthy, including cold spray [
4], HVOF, twin wire arc spraying, powder or detonation flame spraying, atmospheric plasma spraying, and arc spraying [
5]. These methods differ in their application techniques, such as the form of feedstock, material generation, transport medium velocity, transport medium temperature, and the unique properties they impart.
Among the advanced thermal spray techniques, HVOF technology stands out. This innovative method employs a combustion system with high-pressure fuel and oxidizer gases to induce a detonation within the combustion chamber. This process partially or fully melts the material, accelerating it to adhere effectively to the substrate. The result is a high-velocity fluid haze with temperatures reaching up to 3000 °C and supersonic speeds ranging between 400 and 1.000 m/s [
6,
7]. By optimizing parameters, such as the fuel and oxygen flow rate, powder feed rate [
8], spray distance, and carrier gas flow rate, it is possible to produce compact coatings with excellent resistance to abrasion, heat, friction, and wear [
9,
10,
11]. Notably, thermally sprayed coating with a thickness of just 1 mm can achieve hardness values up to 2000 HV [
12].
Porosity, which influences corrosion alongside nanocrystalline amorphous phases and the hardness of the coating, will depend on the oxygen flow rate followed by the powder feed rate and spray distance [
13]. The spray distance will also affect the phase degradation, deposition efficiency, and bonding strength [
9]. Additionally, the angle of incidence impacts the final properties, with a higher preheating temperature and a lower angle of incidence enhancing the corrosion resistance of coatings [
14]. Also, gun speed can be important in the final properties of the coating. Faster gun movement reduces torch dwell time, spraying less powder and lowering the coating temperature [
15].
Compared to other thermal spray processes, HVOF coatings offer superior surface quality [
13]. Additionally, when compared to other high-performance techniques such as atmospheric plasma spraying (APS), HVOF reduces the thermal degradation of the material [
16].
Certain studies have reported the application of HVOF techniques on aluminum alloy substrates [
17,
18,
19,
20,
21,
22], using ceramic materials such as carbides and oxides as the primary coating material due to their high melting points. In some cases, carbides and oxides are combined with metals such as Co, Ni, and Cr to achieve a low oxygen content and excellent adhesion properties [
23].
The application of a WC10Co4C coating on an aluminum substrate resulted in reduced mechanical properties [
24]. Additionally, during friction tests, the carbide particles caused abrasion and fragmentation of the coating layers. The refinement of the microstructure, influenced by the feedstock powders, and the reduction of porosity led to an increase in hardness from 68 HV up to 920 HV in the Cr
3C
2 thermal spray coating on an Al-Si substrate [
25]. Another study [
26] demonstrated that an alumina coating up to 150 µm thick over an A6061 alloy resulted in hardness values ten times higher than the base. During the friction test, the substrate exhibited an abrasion wear mechanism with a secondary adhesion mechanism, causing severe plastic deformation and delamination, while the coating layer showed some cracks but no scratches or grooves, which are characteristics of abrasion wear. On AlZn5.5MgCu aluminum alloy, AlCuFe quasicrystal was deposited as a coating [
27], showing friction coefficient values between 0.92 and 1.00. For A390 aluminum alloys, the Al
2O
3 coating showed lower adhesion and an unstable friction behavior, with a dynamic coefficient of friction of 0.8, compared to around 0.6 of the WC-based coating. Hardness values exceeded 1000 HV for WC-based coatings, while Al
2O
3-base coatings reached 315 HV. Abrasion and adhesion wear mechanisms were observed in all cases [
28]. Combining Al
2O
3 with Y
2O
3 and TiO
2 in coatings has been reported to further enhance wear properties [
29].
Some studies have explored aluminum-based coating on aluminum substrates, but there is limited information on the wear characteristics of ceramic and metallic coating on aluminum alloys, especially for automotive applications. A noteworthy article [
30] discusses the use of a Ni-SiC-based composite on A356 aluminum alloy, which is commonly used in automobile cylinders and machine tool shafts. Under non-lubricating conditions, the friction coefficient averaged 0.55, and the wear rate ranged from 16 × 10
−4 mm
3/N·m to 39 × 10
−4 mm
3/N·m. The wear mechanism involved both abrasion and delamination. In a lubricating environment, the coefficient of friction was reduced by a factor of 5, and the wear rate was 10 times lower compared to dry friction. The addition of sericite improved the wear rate of 2024 aluminum alloy [
31]; however, this alloy is primarily used in aircraft structures. Other alloys, such as titanium alloys (Ti6Al4V), have employed ceramic coatings such as TiC [
32], which tripled wear resistance, although these alloys are mainly used in biological applications.
It has been demonstrated that metals such as aluminum are also beneficial for coating technologies, creating new demands for surface pre-treatment coatings for corrosion protection and paint adhesion in the automotive sector [
33]. A notable recent development is the Alcoat project, which focuses on creating a new recycled aluminum coating for steel products [
34].
A current trend and emerging opportunity that has garnered significant research attention over the past decade is the production of high entropy alloys (HEAs), also known as compositional complex alloys (CCAs) and multicomponent alloys [
35]. The distinctiveness of these new alloys lies in their substantial improvement in mechanical properties. One of the fundamental concepts is to achieve a more disordered structure with five or more elements at or near equimolar composition, forming a solid solution phase, in contrast to conventional alloys, which are based on the central areas of phase diagrams [
36]. Despite these new opportunities and their excellent mechanical properties [
37,
38], the large-scale production of Light High Entropy Alloys (LWHEAs) is limited, with vacuum die casting being the primary manufacturing process [
39]. In some special cases, the investigated alloys include expensive elements such as Ag, which increases hardness and yield strength by more than 10% and elongation by 21% [
40], or Nb [
41]. However, the addition of these elements results in non-cost-effective alloys. Recently, it has been reported that rapid solidification processes can enhance the single-phase microstructures in these alloys with the absence of a dendritic microstructure [
42], although, in some instances, this requirement is not met, resulting predominantly in intermetallic phases [
43]. New studies have demonstrated that, despite the limited understanding of intermetallics in HEA alloys, they can act as very effective secondary phases [
44].
The development of multi-component materials based on aluminum alloys holds promise. Aluminum matrix composite brake drums and rotors have been used in vehicles such as the Lotus Elise, Volkswagen Lupo 3L, Chrysler Plymouth Prowler, and General Motors EV-1 due to their thermal and wear properties [
45].
The use of HVOF technology is limited due to economic reasons stemming from relatively expensive equipment and operational costs, particularly for raw material powders [
46]. From this perspective, employing secondary aluminum alloys for thermal spray powders could yield cost-effective results.
In this research, a new thermal spray process combining HVOF and plasma technologies is employed. This new device utilizes a thermal plasma to enhance the combustion process within the HVOF spray torch and incorporates an auxiliary cold gas to assist in controlling the process temperature. The use of thermal plasma to assist combustion aims to increase the flexibility of the spray system in terms of operating parameters and the range of materials that can be sprayed [
47].
As the raw material grain size influences the final mechanical properties, gas atomization has been selected as the method to convert a new multicomponent cast alloy into powder. This process provides grain sizes ranging from 10 µm to 150 µm [
48]. Moreover, the alloy has been manufactured using the High-Pressure Die-Casting (HPDC) process, which also produces smaller grain sizes that are favorable for atomization [
49].
It is noteworthy that due to oxidation, accelerated by process temperatures, these coatings can serve as effective thermal barrier coatings for components exposed to hot gases. This characteristic renders them suitable for transportation applications. One of the properties of some multicomponent alloys is the capability of avoiding hydrogen fragilization in metals, so they can also be interesting for hydrogen utilization [
50,
51].
2. Materials and Methods Experimental
2.1. Materials Substrate and Coating
A new multicomponent aluminum alloy based on the Al80Mg10Si5Cu5 system was used in the experimental study. This new alloy was obtained by the HPDC foundry process, involving high solidification speeds, and promotes microstructures with superior mechanical properties [
52]. The initial as-cast condition phases included the aluminum matrix, primary and eutectic Mg
2Si particles of around 20 and 5 µm, respectively, and copper-rich phases (Al
2Cu and Al
2CuMg) with sizes around 10 µm.
The Al80Mg10Si5Cu5 alloy was converted into powder by gas atomization with a Leybold VIGA 2S atomizer (Leybold products, Cornellà de Llobregat, Spain) with Argon at a pressure of 2.4 MPa, and the melt temperature was set at 850 °C. Subsequently, a qualitative and semiquantitative analysis was performed by averaging the composition from three measurements, each covering over 100 particles.
Figure 1 illustrates the irregular morphology of the powder obtained after atomization.
Finally, before the multicomponent material thermal spraying on the substrate, a sieving process was carried out with an optimum target size distribution between 63 and 250 µm in 4 runs.
As part of the material substrate, a commercially extruded A6061 aluminum alloy was employed. This alloy is commonly used in components for the automotive industry [
53]. Commercial plates with dimensions of 40 mm × 30 mm and a thickness of 5 mm were used. Before the coating process, the samples were ground up to 800 grit with SiC paper, cleaned with propanol, and finally dried.
Table 1 collects the chemical composition and
Table 2 the mechanical, electrical, and thermal properties of the two experimental alloys.
2.2. Plasma Coating
A newly designed, self-manufactured system employing the HVOAF technology, a combination of HVOF and plasma, was employed to coat the prepared A6061 aluminum alloy. This system, named Kombus+, was engineered and produced by Tecnalia. The Kombus + system is based on a supersonic combustion projection system with oxygen and air. The mixture of gas + air/O
2 increases flows to maintain supersonic speed and pressure.
Figure 2 illustrates the plasma equipment with the robot applying a coating to a sample.
The experimental parameters were specified: the fuel flow rate was calibrated to 380 L per min, with methane as the fuel gas because its maximum flame temperature [
54] helped to reduce gas consumption and allowed the use of a fuel with a relatively low gross heating value [
47].
The oxygen flow rate was set to 300 L per min, while the airflow was regulated at 1500 L per min with an air pressure of 14 bar. The carrier flow was adjusted to 90 liters per min, and the powder feed rate was set to 25% with a 90-degree incidence angle. The spray gun was positioned 300 mm from the substrate, moving at 0.9 m per second. The system operated at 250 revolutions per min.
These parameters have been selected based on accumulated experience [
55,
56,
57] and as equipment manufacturers [
58], which determined that they were the most optimal for aluminum alloys. They are considered ‘cold’ parameters due to the low melting point of the new multi-component aluminum alloy compared with other coating materials such as WC [
59].
When measured with a pyrometer, the flame temperature reached 2000 °C while the substrate temperature was recorded at 200 °C.
2.3. Microstructural Analysis
The microstructure of the alloys was studied using a Leica DMI5000M optical microscope (LEICA, Wetzlar, Germany) and an EI Quanta 450 scanning electron microscopy (SEM) with Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (EDX) analysis. The composition of the alloy produced by HPDC was determined using X-ray diffraction (XRD) with a Philips X’Pert Pro MPD PW3040/60 diffractometer (Malvern Panalytical Ltd., Malver, UK), equipped with a copper anode operating at 40 kV and 40 mA (1.6 kW). Scans were performed in a 2θ range from 10° to 90°, with a step size of 0.02° 2θ and a duration of 2 s per step. The X-ray diffraction patterns were indexed with the PDF-2 database from the International Center for Diffraction Data (ICDD).
2.4. Hardness Study
Vickers indentations were employed to evaluate the hardness of the new material with the coating. The Vickers hardness was determined using a Vickers hardness tester model FV-700 (Mitutoyo, Kawasaki, Japan), selecting after several trials the load of 10 kgf as the best option. Measurements were taken at the top, bottom, and interface areas of the coating. Additionally, hardness measurements were taken on the substrate to ensure that the thermal process did not affect the mechanical properties of the base material. In total, 3 samples were analyzed.
2.5. Dry Sliding Wear Behavior
To investigate the tribological properties of the new coated aluminum alloy, dry sliding wear friction tests were conducted using a sphere-on-plate reciprocating configuration with a ball-on-disk (BOD) setup, following ASTM G99-05 standard without any lubricant. Tests were performed using a tribometer (MT2/60/NI/HT, Microtest S.A., Madrid, Spain). A total of 6 tests were performed: 3 tests on the coated material and another 3 on the substrate without the coating.
The testing parameters employed during the sliding wear friction tests are summarized in
Table 3. The selection of these parameters aligns with tribological studies conducted on other high-wear performance aluminum alloys [
60].
Alumina balls with a diameter of 6 mm and hardness values ranging between 1250 and 1700 HV were used as counter-face bodies. The use of alumina spheres as a counterface ensures that the mechanically mixed layer (MML), which is common when steel balls are used and typically contains Al-Fe-O, is not formed. This minimizes chemically driven aspects of adhesive wear due to reduced chemical adhesion [
61], thereby facilitating the determination of wear properties [
62].
After completing the BOD tests, the determination of the wear coefficient rate was conducted using 3D laser scanning confocal microscopy (DCM 3D, Leica, Madrid, Spain). A total area of 20.8 mm × 20.2 mm and a height of 684 µm were measured using a 5X objective. At least 16 2D profiles were obtained using Leica map software version 3.2. Additionally, for comparison, four radii of 2.5 mm × 1.8 mm and a height of 275 µm were measured using the same 5X objective. The total volume loss was calculated, and wear coefficients were obtained in mm
3/N·m [
63,
64].
Images of the wear track and cross-sections of the wear tracks were captured and analyzed to identify the wear mechanisms, using optical microscopy (OM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and confocal microscopy (CM).
2.6. Electrical Conductivity
The electrical conductivity (EC) was assessed with a portable conductivity meter, an Autosigma 3000 model (Jess W Jackson & Assoc., Buford, GA, USA). This device employs the Eddy Current method to gauge conductivity and reports the results in the standard unit of %IACS (International Annealed Copper Standard). Conductivity measurements were performed on the newly coated material, with a minimum of five readings taken from the sample.
2.7. Corrosion Test
The general corrosion rate was determined using electrochemical techniques. Two different experiments, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and potentiodynamic polarization in the TAFEL region, were conducted on the new as-cast multicomponent Al80Mg10Si5Cu5 alloy. The combined use of these two techniques has been reported in some studies as an alternative to avoid practical issues that often reduce their reliability [
65]. The tests were performed in a 3.5 wt.% sodium chloride solution. Before each test, the samples were grinded and stabilized for open circuit potential (OCP) for 60 min, adhering to ASTM G5 guidelines.
4. Discussion
It has been demonstrated that using new multicomponent Al80Mg10Si5Cu5 aluminum alloys as a coating material for aluminum alloys improves mechanical, electrical, and tribological properties. Additionally, there was a slight improvement in corrosion resistance. The newly designed HVOAF process provided a high-quality coating with a thickness of up to 130 µm, though some pores were present at the bottom of the coating, accounting for less than 2% of the area. These pores are characteristic of this process. This thermal process requires experienced handling and optimization of parameters to achieve consistent coating quality. Parameters such as oxygen flow rate, spray distance, and powder feed rate can be optimized to improve porosity and coating thickness.
Microstructure and chemical analysis results indicated good adhesion between the substrate and the coating. The high solidification rates led to fewer phases and a finer microstructure, resulting in the disappearance of the Al2Cu phase and the precipitation of Mg2Si throughout the matrix. In the interface area, a high presence of elemental copper precipitated as the Al2CuMg phase, providing high hardness without cracking.
Hardness results demonstrated a 50% increase in the new multicomponent-based coated material compared to the A6061 substrate alloy, reaching values up to 220 HV.
Tribological property results showed that the friction coefficient decreased by more than 20% in the new multicomponent alloy-based coated material compared to the A6061 substrate alloy, achieving a steady-state friction coefficient value of 0.40. This value was similar to that observed for the new multicomponent alloy in its as-cast state. Additionally, the wear coefficient decreased also significantly, being approximately 2.5 times lower than that of the uncoated sample.
The wear rate coefficient and the examination of the microstructure of the wear track surface and cross-sectional surface in the new coated material indicated mild wear conditions, characterized by abrasion as the principal wear mechanism. In contrast, the substrate without the coating exhibited moderate to severe wear, showing delaminated areas alongside ploughed areas attributed to a combination of abrasion and delamination mechanisms.
Comparing the hardness values of the experimental alloys revealed that samples with higher hardness demonstrated a lower COF during the sliding process. Additionally, it was observed that samples with significantly higher values for the coefficient of friction corresponded to the highest wear rate. However, it was noted that samples with a similar COF did not necessarily exhibit a linear relation with the wear rate.
The electrical conductivity results showed a significant increase (×3 times) compared to the multicomponent alloy in an as-cast state. The conductivity values approached those of the A6061 substrate and were comparable to a pure aluminum alloy. The analysis demonstrated a strong influence of the cooling rate and morphology of the constituents on electrical conductivity.
Corrosion resistance results demonstrated that the multicomponent alloy had higher values compared with other conventional and multicomponent aluminum alloys and were also higher than those of the heat-treated A6061 alloy. However, they were higher than the values for A6061 alloy in its as-cast state. Parameters such as preheating and angle of incidence should be investigated for a further increase in the corrosion resistance of the coating.
5. Conclusions
This study has explored the advanced properties of multicomponent alloys, clarified wear mechanisms, and showcased the benefits of a new thermal spray system for high-quality coatings.
A new coated material based on a new multicomponent aluminum alloy has been developed, featuring enhanced mechanical, electrical, and tribological properties.
Future work will focus on optimizing some thermal spray parameters to enhance specific properties. To achieve thicker coatings, a higher powder feeding rate will be investigated. Additionally, the angle of incidence and preheating will be optimized, as a lower angle of incidence and higher preheating have been shown to improve corrosion resistance.
Furthermore, the application of the Al80Mg10Si5Cu5 multicomponent alloy on the other types of aluminum substrates will be investigated. Extruded aluminum parts such as A5754 or A6060 and casting aluminum parts such as AlSi9Cu3 could benefit from increased electrical conductivity and improved wear properties. This presents a significant opportunity for the automotive industry, especially in developing electric vehicles and their batteries. It could lead to increased speed and greater load-bearing capacity.
Finally, studies are anticipated to evaluate these high-performance properties under real conditions and in casting parts, as well as the behavior against hydrogen fragilization.