Disturbance Decoupling for a Single-Phase Pulse Width Modulation Rectifier Based on an Extended H-Infinity Filter

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

-       Remove the dot from the title;

-       Abstract: OK;

-       Introduction: OK;

-       P.3,Eq.(1): In the last eq.: Where is i2? Id (like Fig.1) or idc?

-       P.4, R.108: „Figure 2. Transformation of and reference frame.” What is that?

-       Pp.4-5: Eqs.(2)-(6): Verify carefully these eqs.

-       P.5, Table 1: How did you choose these values?

-       P.5, R.138: What is „(.)”?

-       P.7,R.223, Eq. (23): The first terms are not visible.

-       P.9, Rows 279-289: Where are those values ​​from the equations?

-       P.10, Fig.3: IMprove the quality of this picture!

-       P.10, R.318: „3000 V”? Why this value?

-       P.10, R.334: „to 0.8ts= 1ts=”. Why this value?

-       Put a new section: Discussion. Discussions about simulation and experiment results.

-       P.17,Section 5: What are the limitations of the method?

-       What new research results after the completion of this article?

 

-       References: OK.

English can be improved.

 

Author Response

Please, Find the response to your comments in the attached document.

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Reviewer 2 Report

The paper presents study of disturbance de-coupling for a rectifier.  Below I attached some questions, editorial mistakes etc., to which the Authors should to assume an attitude:

1. Some of sentences are too long eg. In lines 33-35. Please rephrase and split  these sentences.

The paper Is very well prepared. Results and conclusion are presented in clearly way. Let's hope for more articles like this

Minor editing of English language required

Author Response

Please, Find the response to your comments in the attached document.

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Reviewer 3 Report

A paper on the problem of interference in a controlled rectifier is proposed. Although this type of converters is very common, but the problem of electromagnetic compatibility is very important and relevant in our time, where there is a huge variety of loads. This method of solution proposed by the authors is original and has not been presented before. The only thing in the work is there are several typos, for example, there is no bracket in line 137, and there is something wrong with the characters in lines 159, 200, 225. After the correction, the article can be published. As for the conclusions and references, they are self-sufficient and do not require additions.

Author Response

Please, Find the response to your comments in the attached document.

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Round 2

Reviewer 1 Report

The paper is interesting.

 

English can be improved.