1. Introduction
Ceramic corundum abrasives have smaller grain size and higher mechanical properties such as hardness, toughness, self-sharpening, wear resistance, and smaller grain size compared to traditional fused corundum abrasives. Moreover, their cost is lower than that of superhard abrasives, namely diamond and cBN [
1,
2,
3]. These abrasives fill the gap between traditional fused corundum abrasives and superhard abrasives in terms of price and performance, and therefore have broad application prospects in the field of grinding [
4,
5,
6]. To accelerate the grain growth and densification process, additives and seeds are typically added to these abrasives. These substances affect the microscopic morphology and improve the mechanical properties of abrasives. Thus, by controlling the introduction of additive substances, the controllability of abrasives can be achieved to a certain extent [
7,
8,
9].
The main component of ceramic corundum abrasives is α-Al
2O
3, which is the most stable phase among all the phases of alumina. All other crystalline alumina will be converted into α-Al
2O
3 above 1200 °C. The α-phase transition is the phase transition of lattice reconstruction, and the process of nucleation and growth occurs at the same time [
10,
11,
12]. Seeds provide more nucleation sites for grain growth, thus facilitating the sintering process and affecting the morphology and properties of the samples [
13,
14,
15]. The addition of seeds can also promote sintering compaction and reduce the grain size. Additives play an important role in the sintering process. The bond energy between the Al and O of Al
2O
3 is very high. Although the phase change temperature is above 1100 °C, compaction requires a temperature above 1600 °C. On one hand, high temperature not only increases energy consumption and production cost, but also has high requirements on production equipment; on the other hand, high temperature frequently results in irregular grain development or recrystallization, which impairs the effectiveness of ceramic corundum abrasives. Due to the introduction of additives, the sintering temperature or phase transition temperature is lowered, and the grain boundary structure is changed, affecting the microstructure of ceramics [
16,
17]. The mechanism of action between additives and alumina can be divided into the following three types: forming a solid solution, forming a low-temperature liquid phase, and forming an intermediate or second phase [
18]. For instance, SiO
2 can form a low-temperature liquid phase with alumina and other metal oxides, thereby promoting the sintering of Al
2O
3 ceramics [
19,
20]. TiO
2 can create a limited solid solution with Al
2O
3, increasing lattice defects, allowing the activation energy of sintering, and promoting the sintering of Al
2O
3. The introduction of TiO
2 accelerates the sintering process of Al
2O
3 ceramics and significantly reduces the sintering temperature. As long as the added amount is appropriate, the impact on the performance is small, which has practical significance in the production. However, the content of additives should be controlled within an appropriate range. Otherwise, the excess additives will accumulate at the grain boundaries, and abnormal grain growth (AGG) will happen when the content exceeds the solubility limit. Park and Yoon [
21] found AGG when adding 100 ppm of SiO
2 and 50 ppm of CaO.
Moreover, ball milling is an effective mechanical activation method that can reduce alumina’s alpha transformation temperature. During the ball milling process, grain refinement, phase transformation, and the creation of internal defects occur [
22]. The strain energy in the powder particles is effectively released during the ball milling process, reducing the activation energy of the phase transition and thereby lowering the phase transition temperature. Additionally, the powder produces mass nuclei during ball milling, which increases the nucleation density. Furthermore, ball milling allows for more uniform mixing of raw materials, seeds, and additives. Thus, it is widely used to prepare ceramic corundum abrasives, although it may limit preparation efficiency in some cases.
Previous research has yielded outstanding results but overlooked the quantity requirements for actual production. Due to the difference between the actual production and laboratory preparation processes, the abrasives’ performance obtained by the same system will vary greatly. Therefore, we used the mixing method to introduce additives to simulate the actual production mixing method and solve the problem of relatively lower production efficiency. The synergistic effect of the adopted additive systems dramatically improves the abrasive performance and outperforms the effect of unitary and binary additive systems. Moreover, the chosen additives are safe and pollution-free, and their price is relatively lower. CaO can develop a liquid phase with the Al
2O
3 matrix or form a low-temperature liquid phase under the combined action of SiO
2 or TiO
2, promoting the sintering of alumina ceramics [
23]. In this work, we analyzed the effects of different contents of the CaO-TiO
2-SiO
2 system on the morphology and properties of the prepared ceramic corundum abrasive, while keeping the molar ratio of TiO
2 and SiO
2 constant. We also analyzed the relationship between abrasive morphology and mechanical properties. Our findings aim to provide a reference for production in practical quantities.
2. Results and Discussions
SEM micrographs of S0–S5 are shown in
Figure 1. As shown in
Figure 1a, in the absence of additives (sample S0), the thermal energy alone may not be sufficient to promote complete grain growth. Incomplete growth of the grains results in numerous stomata between the grains, which weakens the properties of ceramic corundum abrasives.
Figure 1b–f shows that the addition of additives can significantly promote grain growth and affect the morphology. CaO acts together with SiO
2 and TiO
2 to form a low-temperature liquid phase that can promote sintering when the addition amount is low. However, exceeding a limit concentration will lead to AGG [
24]. When the content of CaO is low, the growth promotion effect of SiO
2 and TiO
2 is more apparent, and the abrasive shows a rod-like and flake-like complex structure (
Figure 1b–d). When the content of SiO
2 is too high, the grains are slender and needle-like/rod-like. The joint action of SiO
2 and CaO causes AGG, while the solo addition of CaO will not cause AGG. With the increase of CaO content, the anisotropy of the abrasives decreases, showing a trend of equiaxed grains (
Figure 1e). However, the grains grow abnormally when CaO is excessive, which is caused by the accumulation of excess additives at the grain boundaries (
Figure 1f). Hong et al. [
25] found that anisotropic grain growth only occurs in a relatively limited range of liquid phase content. Altay and Mehmet [
26] also observed that when excessive amounts of calcium impurities at the grain boundaries reached a threshold level, this resulted in elongated grain morphology.
When the amount of liquid phase formed is too large, a large number of grains grow rapidly at the same time. Therefore, grains collide and stop growing. Overall, it is more difficult for anisotropic grain growth when the liquid content is higher, and the grains of Al
2O
3 tend to grow normally. This shows that when the molar ratio of CaO, SiO
2, and TiO
2 is 3:4:9, more liquid phases are formed during the sintering process, which can ensure that the grains grow normally (
Figure 1e). On the other hand, SiO
2 forms a glass phase during the sintering process, which affects the viscosity of the liquid phase. When its content is too high, the liquid phase viscosity will increase, hindering the densification process. The addition of TiO
2 weakens the strength of the glass network structure, assists crystallization in the glass phase, and decreases the viscosity [
27]. However, high liquid phase viscosity is not conducive to the liquid phase mass transfer process, which can also lead to reduced compactness. The increase in CaO content reduces the liquid phase viscosity and promotes liquid phase mass transfer. The additives promote the sintering process by a synergistic effect.
Because the molar ratio of TiO
2/SiO
2 is constant, and to facilitate the calculation, the ratio of CaO/TiO
2 was used as a variable to explore property changes.
Figure 2 shows the single-particle compressive strength, density, and Vickers hardness of ceramic corundum abrasives as a function of CaO/TiO
2. The results show that with the increase of calcium oxide content, the compressive strength of single particles increases first and then decreases, which is consistent with the changes in density (
Figure 2b,c). This is mainly because the grains inside the abrasive gradually change from needle/flake with lower strength to massive grain with higher strength. Compared with
Figure 1c, grains in
Figure 1b have better consistency, making them more tightly bound with fewer pores, resulting in higher density. When CaO is added, a small number of flake grains appear, resulting in some pores, causing the density to decrease. Due to the combination of lamellar and other grains, some pores are excluded. The density reaches its maximum when pores are almost eliminated (
Figure 1e). On the other hand, the grain size in
Figure 1e is smaller, resulting in a higher single-particle compressive strength of up to 51.45 N, and the density is 3.94 g·cm
−3. Excessive CaO results in AGG and a lamellar structure, so the density decreases again, consistent with the microstructure features exhibited in
Figure 1. The compactness of abrasives is reduced due to the existence of pores, making them easily fractured from these pores when subjected to external pressure. Therefore, there is a close relationship between single-particle compressive strength and density. As for Vickers hardness, it continues to increase until it stabilizes at a certain extent of about 16.75 GPa (
Figure 2c). Compared with the sample without additives (S0), the Vickers hardness of samples increased by about 100%, significantly improving the mechanical properties. The density, single-particle compressive strength, and Vickers hardness of S2, S3, and S4 show the same trend, indicating that Vickers hardness is affected by additives and microstructure. The change in ball milling toughness is shown in
Figure 2d. When the additive content changes, the ball milling toughness change curve of S1–S4 is similar to its density and single-particle compressive strength, while the change curve of S2–S5 is similar to its Vickers hardness, indicating that ball milling toughness is affected by multiple factors such as grain size and density. We obtained abrasives with higher strength and density than some previous studies. You et al. [
28] reported that with the inclusion of the ternary compound additive Na
3AlF
6-CaO-SiO
2, corundum abrasives were created in a two-step sintering process with plate-like grains; however, the single-particle compressive strength was 49 N. Hu et al. [
29] also investigated the synergistic effect of ZnF
2-TiO
2-SiO
2 and seeds on the sintering behavior and microstructure of corundum abrasives. By contrast, we prepared abrasives with higher strength by adding fewer additives. Reducing the cost and improving performance are of great significance in the actual production, and could significantly improve the preparation efficiency of ceramic corundum abrasives.
Figure 3 shows XRD diffraction result of S1-S5. It’s confirmed that the main component of the samples is corundum. It can be a preliminary illustration that homogeneous ceramic corundum abrasives were obtained by combining
Figure 1.
Figure 4 shows SEM micrographs and element distribution of the S4 sample. The grain composition and structure are homogeneous, and there is no second phase. Ca, Ti, and Si are evenly distributed on the surface of the grain to form a thin film. The thin film can inhibit the growth of the grain and prevent the initiation and expansion of microcracks, reduce the stress concentration inside the abrasive, and thus improve the strength of abrasives.
To investigate the influence of the introduction method of the additives on the microstructure and mechanical properties of abrasives, samples with the same additives were prepared using ball milling (M1 to M5, as shown in
Figure 5). The mechanical properties of M1 to M5 increase continuously as the ratio of CaO/TiO
2 increases, in contrast to S1 to S5 (
Figure 2). Ball milling results in smaller abrasive grain sizes. The highest density, Vickers hardness, and single-particle compressive strength are 3.95 g·cm
−3, 18.30 GPa, and 40.55 N, respectively. For example, when comparing S4 to M4, it is evident that M4 has finer grains and a more uniform distribution of grain sizes (
Figure 6). The grain size distribution of M4 is mainly between 0.4 μm and 0.8 μm, and it has approximately normal distribution. In contrast, S4’s grain size distribution is primarily between 0.4 μm and 1.4 μm, with an average grain size of 0.98 μm. Abrasives fabricated through ball milling exhibit higher density and Vickers hardness, while those fabricated through stirring have higher single-particle compressive strength. Generally, finer grains have better mechanical properties due to their smaller size and better compactness, resulting in higher density and Vickers hardness (
Figure 2b,c). However, fracture occurs during single-particle compressive strength testing. The fracture surface and the partially enlarged view of abrasives are shown in
Figure 7a,b, respectively.
Figure 7a depicts a rough fracture surface, indicating toughness fracture, and
Figure 7b shows the intergranular fracture of small-size grains and the transgranular fracture of large-size grains, which work together to improve ball milling toughness and safety during the grinding process. With a larger grain size, transgranular fracture occurs during fracture, while intergranular fracture occurs when the grain is smaller, thus absorbing less energy. Therefore, abrasives with larger grain sizes possess higher single-particle compressive strength and ball milling toughness in some cases. However, the safety problems caused by crystal fracture should be paid attention to, and grinding tools should be checked regularly. Microcracks, transgranular fractures, and intergranular fractures improve the strength by joint effect. It can also be concluded that samples obtained from the same additive system will be affected by the process. The preparation process can be chosen depending on practical use. The change in the Vickers hardness follows a different pattern than that of compressive strength and density in
Figure 1, but it is consistent with
Figure 5. It is worth noting that when the molar ratio of CaO-TiO
2-SiO
2 is 3:4:9, the microstructure and mechanical properties of ceramic corundum abrasives could achieve good results with whatever method of additive system is adopted, which indicates that the effect of the additives is more obvious and can play a good role when the introduction mode is changed.
When choosing additives, the price and stability are also factors worth considering. Although some precious metal oxides can effectively promote or inhibit the growth of grains, the high cost is not conducive to industrial mass production, which limits the application of ceramic corundum abrasive. It also requires that additives are easy to store and transport, and their physical and chemical properties are stable to ensure the accurate content of metal ions introduced. The additives used in this paper can meet the above requirements well, and can reduce the production cost while promoting sintering by producing a liquid phase. SiO2 is a cheap and common oxide; the formation of bonding in sintering plays an important role relative to improving the density of abrasives. Although the selected CaO may have the problem of water absorption in storage, choosing CaCO3 as the introduced substance of Ca2+ could solve this problem. Both TiO2 and SiO2 are additives that obviously promote the growth of ceramic corundum abrasive grains, and they could effectively improve the microscopic density of the abrasives when added alone. Through complementary advantages, the three additives can produce ceramic corundum abrasives with dense structure and excellent performance at a low level of addition content.
4. Conclusions
In this study, CaO-TiO2-SiO2 was used as an additive system to prepare ceramic corundum abrasives via the sol-gel method. Compared to the samples without additives, the structure of the prepared abrasives was denser, and their single-particle compressive strength and Vickers hardness were significantly improved. The synergy effect of TiO2, SiO2, and CaO promoted the sintering process of ceramic corundum abrasives. The morphology of the grains varied with the changes of molar ratio of additives. As the content of SiO2 and TiO2 increased, the grains tended to form needle-like/rod-like anisotropic grains. A moderate content of CaO facilitates the formation of equiaxed grains, whereas excessive addition of CaO led to AGG. Equiaxed grains improved the density and Vickers hardness of abrasives, while anisotropic grains increased single-particle compressive strength. Ball milling had a mechanical activation effect, which improved the mixing uniformity and nucleation density, leading to smaller equiaxed grains. However, abrasives with higher compressive strength were prepared without ball milling. Low-cost, high-strength ceramic corundum abrasives have broad application prospects. These findings provide a theoretical basis and practical guidance for the batch preparation of ceramic corundum abrasives. Meanwhile, some important conclusions are as follows:
The samples with the best morphology and performance were obtained when adding CaO-TiO2-SiO2 with a molar ratio of 3:4:9. The single-particle compressive strength was 51.45 N, density was 3.94 g·cm−3, Vickers hardness was 17.03 GPa, ball milling toughness was 97.4%, and average grain size was 0.98 μm.
The method of additive introduction can also affect the mechanical properties of ceramic corundum abrasives. The performance of the scale method is slightly better than that of the ceramic corundum prepared by the ball grinding method, but it has overall reached a high level, which meets the requirements of practical application.