Regular Doses of Nature: The Efficacy of Green Exercise Interventions for Mental Wellbeing
, Jules Pretty 3, Patrick Schoenmakers 1, Dan Bloomfield 4 and Jo Barton 1Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
In my opinion, the amendments made by the authors to the manuscript are sufficient for publication. I found this study very important for promoting both physical activity and mental health among older people.
Author Response
We thank the reviewer very much for their expertise, time and effort in helping us to improve our manuscript.
Reviewer 2 Report
Thank the authors for addressing my concerns and for adding scale version as a moderator in particular. A main conclusion of this paper is "Compared to those reporting ‘average - high’ starting wellbeing, participants reporting ‘low’ starting wellbeing exhibited greater improvements (BCa 95% CI [-31.8, -26.5])" and I feel that at least this data should be presented in a Figure rather than less than one sixth of a table (Table 3).
Author Response
We thank the reviewer very much for their expertise, time and effort in helping us to improve our manuscript.
We have added the mentioned graph, and agree that this is a good addition, given the importance of the finding.
