3.2. Composite Characterization
The cross-sectional morphologies of continuous aramid fiber/PLA composites 3D-printed with different parameters are shown in
Figure 6a–i. In each figure, the stereo microscope image (top), optical microscope image (bottom left), and fiber fraction images obtained using ImageJ software (V 1.24) are shown. The reinforcing fibers are located close to each other, as expected with decreasing hatch spacing. A similar result was observed for decreasing layer thickness. With decreasing layer thickness and hatch spacing, the amount of reinforcement fibers deposited per unit area increased. The fiber volume fractions calculated by using optical microscope cross-sectional images are given in
Table 2. As the hatch spacing and layer height values decreased from 1 mm and 0.8 mm to 0.6 mm and 0.4 mm, the fiber volume fraction value of the composites increased from 11.297 vol.% to 26.851 vol.%, respectively. As seen in
Figure 6, fibers are located at the top of the deposited individual lanes rather than being centered. Ibrahim et al. [
25] indicated that the force exerted by the moving of the printing head and nozzle causes tension on the fiber and this situation results in the non-aligned settlement of the reinforcement fiber [
25]. In addition, gaps originating from the 3D printing process are observed at the contact points of the deposited individual lines in the cross-sections. Especially in the 06-08 sample, the gap between the layers is noticeable. The layer thickness being higher than the hatch spacing value resulted in the delamination of the layers. It is clearly seen that the gaps originating from the 3D printing became smaller with decreasing layer thickness and hatch spacing values [
26,
27].
The stress–strain curves and mean tensile strength values of specimens printed with different layer height and hatch spacing values are shown in
Figure 7a–f. The mechanical performance of continuous-aramid-fiber-reinforced PLA composites demonstrates the critical influence of additive manufacturing parameters, such as the layer height and hatch spacing, on the tensile strength. These findings underscore the importance of parameter optimization in tailoring the mechanical properties for advanced engineering applications. By analyzing the effects of individual parameters and their combined impact, this study provides a comprehensive understanding of how to achieve optimal composite performance.
The tensile strength of the composites increased markedly with decreasing layer height. At a constant hatch spacing of 0.4 mm, the tensile strength improved from 304.87 MPa at a layer height of 1.0 mm to 410.25 MPa at 0.6 mm. This improvement can be attributed to the enhanced interlayer bonding achieved with thinner layers, which provide a greater overlap between successive layers during the printing process. A thinner layer thickness increases the mechanical strength by enhancing the fiber–matrix interaction. In the study of Hou et al. [
28], it was reported that this effect was similarly observed on the compressive strength of continuous-Kevlar-fiber-reinforced PLA composites. The resulting denser composite structure minimizes void formation and enhances stress transfer efficiency. Moreover, Jiang et al. [
29] reported that a certain layer thickness gives the best results in tensile strength in continuous-aramid-fiber-reinforced nylon 12 composites, and it was stated that lower layer thicknesses improve interlayer bonding and minimize pore formation. However, it was also emphasized that very low layer thicknesses may lead to the uneven distribution of the resin around the fibers, which may adversely affect mechanical performance. Furthermore, smaller layer heights enable more precise fiber placement, promoting uniform stress distribution and reducing the likelihood of stress concentration zones. This trend highlights the significance of the layer height as a primary parameter in improving the composite strength. However, layer height alone does not dictate mechanical performance; the hatch spacing must also be considered in order to achieve an optimized structure.
On the other hand, a narrower hatch spacing significantly contributed to a higher tensile strength, complementing the benefits of a reduced layer height. For instance, at a layer height of 0.6 mm, reducing the hatch spacing from 0.8 mm to 0.4 mm resulted in an increase in tensile strength from 237.09 MPa to 410.25 MPa. A narrower hatch spacing promotes material continuity by increasing the overlap between deposition lines, thereby reducing the porosity and enhancing the fiber–matrix interface. This ensures better load transfer and mechanical stability within the composite. The interplay between the hatch spacing and layer height becomes evident when both parameters are optimized simultaneously, emphasizing the need for a holistic approach to parameter selection in additive manufacturing. The effect of hatch spacing on mechanical properties has been frequently emphasized in the literature. For example, Hou et al. [
30] reported that, by optimizing the hatch spacing, superior stability and a homogeneous force distribution were achieved in continuous-fiber-reinforced energy absorption tubes. In particular, it has been stated that a 0.4 mm hatch spacing plays a critical role in improving mechanical performance. Similarly, in our study, narrower hatch spacing values were observed to increase the tensile strength, and it was confirmed that optimizing this parameter has a significant effect on the strength.
The combination of a reduced layer height and a narrower hatch spacing is shown in
Figure 8. The best mechanical performance, with a tensile strength of 410.25 MPa, is achieved at a 0.6 mm layer height and a 0.4 mm hatch spacing. This combination minimizes void formation, enhances fiber alignment, and strengthens interlayer adhesion besides increasing fiber fraction, leading to superior mechanical properties. In contrast, the combination of larger layer heights and wider hatch spacing, such as 1.0 mm and 0.8 mm, resulted in the lowest tensile strength of 168.12 MPa, highlighting the detrimental effects of poor layer bonding and excessive void formation. In this study, the effectiveness of narrower hatch spacing and thinner layer height parameters in increasing tensile strength is in agreement with the findings of Rijckaert et al. [
13]. The results obtained confirm that optimized printing parameters are an important factor in improving mechanical performance.
The SEM images of the failure surfaces of the samples after the tensile test are shown in
Figure 9a–i. Similar failure mechanisms were observed for the analyzed fracture surfaces of the different specimens. The increase in the number of fibers is clearly seen with the decrease in the hatch spacing value and the decrease in the layer thickness value. Regardless of the printing parameters, all samples exhibited failure behavior in the form of ductile fracture with necked fibers, which is a typical fracture characteristic of the aramid fibers [
31,
32]. Another situation that can be stated as common for all samples is that the matrix penetration into the fibers is limited and the matrix penetration during the nozzle impregnation process is limited to the outer surface area of the yarn. In these regions, it is seen that the fibers which are surrounded by little or no matrix are pulled out from the matrix due to the weak fiber–matrix interfacial bonding.
The flexural strength results of continuous-aramid-fiber-reinforced PLA composites were evaluated under varying process parameters, including the layer thickness (0.4 mm, 0.6 mm, and 0.8 mm) and hatch spacing (1.0 mm, 0.8 mm, and 0.6 mm). These parameters significantly influenced the mechanical performance of the composites. Three specimens were produced for each set of production parameters for bending tests. After the bending test, the deformed samples are shown in
Figure 10. It should be noted that no fracture was observed in the samples. It is clearly seen that delamination was observed in the 06-08 samples. The layer thickness being higher than the hatch spacing value resulted in the delamination of the layers.
Flexural stress–stain curves and a bar chart of the mean strength values are shown in
Figure 11a–f. For composites printed with a layer thickness of 0.8 mm, the flexural strength ranged from 65.73 ± 8.57 MPa to 70.98 ± 2.88 MPa, showing relatively lower values compared to other layer thicknesses. This trend can be attributed to the reduced interlayer bonding and higher void formation observed at an increased layer thickness. The lowest flexural strength was recorded at a hatch spacing of 0.6 mm, likely due to the insufficient overlap between deposition lines at this parameter combination.
3.3. Effect of Atmospheric Plasma Treatment
When the layer thickness was reduced to 0.6 mm, the flexural strength improved significantly, ranging from 85.30 ± 2.79 MPa to 93.27 ± 4.55 MPa. The enhancement can be associated with an improved layer fusion and a reduced void content, providing better stress transfer during bending. The composites fabricated with the smallest layer thickness of 0.4 mm exhibited the highest flexural strength, ranging from 107.99 ± 3.40 MPa to 131.67 ± 5.79 MPa. The superior performance at this parameter is attributed to the enhanced interlayer adhesion and improved fiber alignment, which collectively minimize the stress concentration zones and maximize the mechanical load distribution. Among all configurations, the highest flexural strength was achieved at a layer thickness of 0.4 mm and hatch spacing of 0.6 mm, suggesting this combination as the optimal parameter set for maximizing flexural performance.
Overall, these results emphasize the importance of optimizing additive manufacturing parameters to tailor the mechanical properties of continuous-fiber-reinforced composites for specific applications. The interplay between the layer thickness and hatch spacing demonstrated a clear influence on the flexural strength, highlighting the critical role of process parameter optimization in achieving high-performance composite structures.
The bending strength results of the composites fabricated with the 06-04 production parameters (0.6 mm layer height and 0.4 mm hatch spacing) demonstrated superior mechanical performance compared to other tested configurations. Specifically, the bending strength achieved for the 06-04 configuration without surface modification was 133.77 MPa, marking it as the most optimized set of parameters in terms of the layer height and hatch spacing. These results highlight the critical role of a tighter layer stacking and narrower hatch spacing in enhancing interlayer adhesion and reducing void formation, which collectively contribute to improved bending performance.
SEM micrographs which are given in
Figure 12a–d show the morphology of non-modified and treated aramid fibers, respectively. A relatively clean and smooth surface was observed for non-modified fibers (see
Figure 12a,c) while the atmospheric-plasma-treated fiber has an uneven surface (see
Figure 12b,d). Surface etching and roughening are clearly visible in the aramid fiber following plasma treatment which is caused mostly by the bombardment of charged particles [
33]. The surface of fibers was partially etched by the bombardment of intense electrons and ions during plasma treatment. As is indicated in the literature, the etching causes the roughening and improved adhesion between the fiber and matrix, which can be formed by the enhanced surface energy and improved mechanical properties of composites, which can be achieved by the strong mechanical interlocking of the fibers and matrix [
33,
34,
35].
The FT-IR spectra of modified and non-modified aramid fiber are given in
Figure 13. The fact that no new peaks appeared suggests that the treatment may have primarily altered the existing functional groups on the fiber surface rather than introducing entirely new functional groups. And the chemical structure of plasma-treated aramid fiber did not change obviously when compared with the non-modified fiber sample, which demonstrates that atmospheric plasma treatment did not break the fiber bulk structure. The increased peak intensity at 1737 cm
−1, which is the characteristic absorption peak of the stretching vibration of C=O in the carboxyl group, was attributed to the number of -COOH groups on the fiber surface, which was increased by plasma treatment [
36]. Jia et al. [
23] indicated that the oxidation effect can be observed during plasma treatment which is confirmed by the increased oxygenic group on the surface. Polar bonds such as C=O and C–O are related to the improved wettability and increased surface energy [
35]. Besides oxygenic groups, the intensities of peaks related to N–H and C–N increased noticeably [
23].
The surface chemical compositions of treated and untreated aramid fibers were obtained by the XPS technique and the surface elemental composition results are given in
Table 3. The data revealed an increase in both the O
1S/C
1S and N
1S/C
1S ratios from 0.25 to 0.27 and from 0.016 to 0.019, respectively, following plasma treatment. The data revealed an increase in both the O
1S/C
1S and N
1S/C
1S ratios from 0.25 to 0.27 and from 0.016 to 0.019, respectively, following plasma treatment. These findings suggest that atmospheric air plasma treatment induces the formation of additional oxygen-containing functional groups, such as carboxyl and hydroxyl groups on the aramid fiber surface. These polar groups on the surface increase the hydrophilicity of the fibers, reducing the water contact angle. This can be attributed to the morphological changes induced by the plasma on the fiber surface and the formation of hydrogen bonds by the polar groups. The obtained results suggest that atmospheric plasma treatment can modify the surface properties of aramid fibers, enhancing the interfacial adhesion in composite materials and making them suitable for various applications.
Table 4 presents the deconvoluted C
1S core-level spectra of both untreated and plasma-treated aramid fibers. The deconvolution of the C
1S signal revealed three primary peaks: C-C/C-H (284.54 eV), C-O/C-O-C (286.15 eV), and O-C=O (288.52 eV). In untreated aramid fibers, the relative peak areas for C-C/C-H, C-O/C-O-C, and O-C=O were 75.0%, 19.2%, and 5.8%, respectively, yielding a polar-to-nonpolar group ratio of 0.33. Following atmospheric plasma treatment, the C-C/C-H peak area decreased to 70.8% while the relative abundance of polar groups increased to 29.2%, resulting in an elevated polar-to-nonpolar group ratio of 0.41. This observed decrease in the C-C/C-H peak area ratio, coupled with an increase in the C-O peak area, suggests an enhanced surface oxidation of the fibers. This oxidation, likely induced by ions, electrons, and UV radiation generated within the plasma, is expected to improve the adhesion properties of aramid fibers by modifying their surface chemistry, potentially reducing the chemical inertness and increasing the surface free energy.
The 3D-printed pull-out test samples and pull-out test setup are shown in
Figure 14. As seen in the figure, 3D-printed samples were again placed in the 3D-printed sample holder and the test was performed by pulling the aramid fiber from the tip.
The load–displacement curve was recorded during the test and this curve is shown in
Figure 15a and the mean force values are shown in
Figure 15b. As seen in the curves, typical pull-out behavior is clearly seen for both the raw and modified fibers. As the aramid fiber was pulled from the tip, the load increase was observed. The load peaked and then suddenly decreased. At this point, the fibers were detached from the matrix. After this point, the load value exhibited a decreasing behavior at a lower value. This behavior was observed due to the friction between the stripped fiber and the matrix [
37]. It is obvious that the matrix-fiber detachment peak load value increases in atmospheric-plasma-treated fibers. While the non-modified fiber pull-out load value was measured as 63.28 ± 7.31 N, the pull-out load value of the atmospheric-plasma-treated fiber was measured as 75.43 ± 6.81 N. This can be attributed to both the improvement in the matrix-bond by the change in functional groups on the surface after plasma treatment and the mechanical interlocking between the matrix and the roughened fiber surface.
The stress–strain curves of non-modified and atmospheric-plasma-modified aramid fibers are shown in
Figure 16. The mechanical performance of the 06-04 specimen, fabricated under optimized additive manufacturing parameters, serves as a reference point for understanding the effects of surface treatments on the tensile strength. The non-modified 06-04 specimen exhibited a tensile strength of 410.25 MPa, showcasing the effectiveness of a reduced layer height and hatch spacing in achieving superior fiber alignment and enhanced interfacial bonding within the composite matrix. These results highlight the significance of parameter optimization in additive manufacturing for continuous-fiber-reinforced composites.
In comparison, the atmospheric-plasma-treated 06-04 specimen achieved a significantly higher tensile strength of 442.78 MPa, representing a notable improvement of approximately 7.83%. This enhancement can be attributed to the atmospheric plasma treatment’s ability to modify the surface properties of the aramid fibers, improving the wettability and interfacial adhesion between the reinforcement and the PLA matrix. The treatment promotes the formation of functional groups on the fiber surface, as verified by FTIR facilitating a stronger chemical interaction at the fiber–matrix interface. The superior performance of the treated specimen underscores the critical role of secondary surface treatments in overcoming the interfacial bonding limitations inherent in additively manufactured composites. While the optimized layer height and hatch spacing ensure an efficient mechanical load transfer through the aligned fibers, the plasma treatment further mitigates the potential stress concentrations and delamination at the fiber–matrix interface. Consequently, the mechanical integrity of the composite under tensile loading is significantly enhanced. Bertin et al. [
38] reported that plasma treatment promotes the formation of free radicals on the surface, facilitating the addition of chemical groups to the polymer surface, which can contribute to the improvement of mechanical properties such as tensile strength. Similarly, Zarei et al. [
39] suggested that atmospheric plasma treatment enhances interlayer bonding, positively impacting the mechanical performance. Additionally, Chen et al. [
40] emphasized that the increase in surface energy after plasma treatment significantly strengthens the adhesion between fibers and the polymer matrix, further enhancing the composite’s mechanical characteristics.
The improvement in tensile strength of approximately 7.83% achieved through atmospheric plasma treatment demonstrates the potential of this method for enhancing the interfacial bonding in continuous-aramid-fiber-reinforced PLA composites. While this improvement may seem modest, its significance lies in the broader implications for long-term mechanical reliability and durability under repeated or extreme loading conditions. Atmospheric plasma treatment provides an environmentally friendly, solvent-free, and scalable solution that enhances fiber–matrix adhesion without altering the bulk properties of the fibers. This makes it particularly valuable for applications where interfacial bonding plays a critical role in performance, such as the aerospace and automotive sectors. However, we acknowledge that the additional processing cost associated with atmospheric plasma treatment could pose a challenge for widespread industrial adoption. Future research should aim to quantify the cost–benefit ratio more precisely by investigating the method’s impact on other critical performance metrics, such as fatigue resistance, impact strength, and thermal stability. Additionally, exploring process optimization, such as increasing the throughput of the plasma treatment system or integrating it directly into the additive manufacturing workflow, could help offset costs.
Regarding the limitations of this study, the inability of the PLA matrix to fully penetrate the fiber bundles due to the nozzle impregnation process is a critical aspect that warrants further exploration. This limitation likely restricts the effectiveness of the plasma treatment in reaching the inner fibers, which may reduce the overall mechanical benefits. Future studies could investigate alternative impregnation techniques or post-printing infiltration methods to enhance the matrix penetration and maximize the utilization of the treated fiber surface. Moreover, the use of alternative polymer matrices with lower viscosities or tailored rheological properties could improve fiber wetting and penetration, addressing the current limitations identified in this work. By discussing these limitations and opportunities, we aim to provide a roadmap for future research while emphasizing the significance of our findings in advancing the state of the art in continuous-fiber-reinforced composite materials.
The SEM image of the damage surface of the atmospheric-plasma-treated fiber composite after the tensile test is shown in
Figure 17. Although the fibers were damaged in the form of splitting and breaking similarly to the non-modified ones, the biggest difference here is that matrix residue was found on the fiber, which can be attributed to the improvement in the matrix-fiber interface bond with the plasma treatment.
To further enhance the mechanical properties of the 06-04 composite, an atmospheric plasma surface modification was applied to the reinforcement fibers prior to the additive manufacturing process. The surface-treated composite exhibited a significant improvement in bending strength, reaching a value of 157.42 MPa, representing an enhancement of approximately 17.67% compared to the non-modified composite. This improvement can be attributed to the atmospheric plasma treatment’s ability to modify the fiber surface by increasing surface roughness and introducing polar functional groups, as evidenced in prior studies.
The enhanced interfacial bonding between the aramid fibers and the PLA matrix, facilitated by atmospheric plasma treatment, contributes to a more efficient load transfer during bending stress. The treated fiber surface mitigates stress concentrations and reduces the likelihood of delamination or fiber pull-out, thereby improving the composite’s overall mechanical performance. Xu et al. [
41], in their study, reported that atmospheric plasma treatment significantly enhances the surface properties of aramid fibers and promotes the formation of polar functional groups. This process improves the surface roughness of the fibers, thereby increasing their wettability and interfacial bonding strength. The researchers highlighted that the combined effects of chemical bonding and mechanical interlocking facilitate the more efficient stress transfer from the matrix to the fibers, ultimately improving the overall mechanical performance of the composites. In another study, Ye et al. [
42] demonstrated that atmospheric pressure plasma treatment is highly effective for the surface modification of aramid fibers. The process was reported to enhance the surface morphology of the fibers and increase the density of polar functional groups on their surfaces. These improvements significantly elevated the surface energy and wettability of the fibers, resulting in stronger interfacial bonding with the epoxy matrix.
These findings underscore the synergistic effect of optimized printing parameters and advanced surface modification techniques in achieving high-performance continuous-fiber-reinforced composites. While the optimized 06-04 parameters already deliver excellent results, the addition of atmospheric plasma treatment further pushes the boundaries of mechanical performance, making this approach particularly promising for high-stress applications in the aerospace, automotive, and structural engineering domains. The flexural stress–strain curves of modified and non-modified bending test samples and the flexural modulus of all samples are shown in
Figure 18a and b, respectively. The atmospheric-plasma-treated 06-04-M sample, with a flexural modulus of 6.70 GPa, showed a comparable performance to the non-modified counterpart. This suggests that, while atmospheric plasma treatment enhances fiber–matrix adhesion through increased surface energy and improved chemical compatibility, the overall gain in the flexural modulus remains within a modest range. However, the standard deviation values indicate that the plasma-treated samples exhibited a more consistent performance, highlighting the process’s potential in achieving better reproducibility and reducing material variability.
Furthermore, samples with a larger hatch spacing and layer thickness, such as 1-08 and 08-08, displayed relatively lower flexural modulus values of 1.92 GPa and 2.06 GPa, respectively. This can be attributed to an increased void content and weaker interlayer adhesion, which limit the effective load transfer within the composite structure. The observed results align with previous findings in the literature, where optimizing printing parameters has been shown to significantly influence mechanical performance by minimizing defects and ensuring a uniform fiber distribution [
42,
43].
The results indicate a clear trend of an increasing flexural modulus with a decreasing layer thickness and hatch spacing. Among the tested samples, the 06-04 configuration exhibited the highest flexural modulus of 6.81 GPa, demonstrating the significant influence of optimized processing parameters on the mechanical performance of the composites. The reduction in layer thickness and hatch spacing resulted in improved interlayer bonding and enhanced fiber–matrix interaction, contributing to the superior flexural performance.
Failed specimens of 06-04-M after the three-point bending test and the compressive side of specimen are shown in
Figure 19. The predominant failure mode is layer buckling without fracture at the tensile side of testing.