1. Introduction
Dental implantology has become a common practice for the restoration of the aesthetics and masticatory functions of millions of people every year. Restorative implant dentistry relies on the long-term integration of the implanted material in bone. This process is modulated by surgical factors such as the surgery plan and the prosthetic loading strategy; biological factors such as the patient’s health and the receiving bone conditions; and implant-related factors such as the base material characteristics, the surface physiochemistry, topography, final quality, and cleanliness of the manufactured implant [
1,
2]. Over the last decades, the evolution of implant designs, prosthetic constructions, and surface characteristics have facilitated surgeries and improved patient satisfaction in increasingly challenging situations [
3,
4].
Peri-implant bone regeneration begins with the placement of an implant and the quasi-instantaneous establishment of a new ionic balance between the surface and the receiving bed. In the quest for faster and better bone-tissue integration, implant surface designs have historically sought to imitate the structure and composition of bone tissue. Long story short: a bone-like structure at the implant surface should more easily fuse with the existing bone bed. Typically, these modifications consisted of calcium phosphates with or without collagen or other non-collagenous proteins with key roles in regeneration such as osteopontin and osteocalcin, which aimed at mimicking, as much as possible, the inorganic and organic part of the mature bone matrix of the later stages of bone regeneration. However, these solutions faced several limitations that have undermined their final clinical relevance [
2].
An alternative strategy consists of focusing on the early phases of implant–bone tissue interaction. Immediately upon implant insertion, the establishment of an ionic equilibrium at the implant–tissue interface is determined by the chemical composition of the implant surface and by the local ionic composition. The surface adsorption and exchange of proteins with the biological environment, which is a fundamental part of the process of hemostasis and inflammation [
5,
6,
7], follows. The ionic configuration of the implant surface is therefore key to the subsequent responses down the line [
8]. Importantly, ionic modifications allow a more straightforward application on an industrial basis, overcoming the limitations of the more complex bone-like coatings [
3,
5,
6,
9,
10].
In 1992, Ellingsen et al. postulated that calcium ions adsorbed from blood upon implantation onto the titanium oxide surface were initiators of the process of osseointegration at implant surfaces. The double-charged positive calcium ion would serve as an electrostatic bridge to bring together the negatively charged titanium oxides and some anionic residues of biomolecules of interest for early regeneration [
11]. However, calcium ions are fundamental in the coagulation process as well [
12]. For the success of the implantation, it is crucial to achieve a rapid stabilization of the implant with the surrounding tissues. The clot or provisional matrix generates this preliminary stability. It consists of a three-dimensional fibrin network that contains platelets and growth factors. A fully functional clot orchestrates the attraction, housing, development, differentiation, and function of the cells in charge of the synthesis of the mature extracellular matrix [
13]. Fibrin is an insoluble biopolymer formed from the progressive assembly of fibrinogen subunits. Thrombin allows the ends of fibrinopeptides to be separated from the main fibrinogen unit and the new ends to react with each other and form the three-dimensional fibrin network [
14]. Developing this scaffold intimately with the implant surface opens the possibility, among others, of improving angiogenesis, reducing inflammation, and accelerating tissue repair directly on the surface.
In this article, we set our objective to investigate the roles of the bioinorganic calcium ion in the apposition and formation of the fibrin clot at the implant surface and which may be the implications in the clinical integration of dental implants. To do this, a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) has been used to monitor the viscoelastic properties and settlement of the fibrin layer of surfaces modified with calcium ions (Ca) as compared to standard titanium surfaces (NoCa). The morphology of the resulting interfaces was characterized by Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM). Regarding the early and long-term regeneration events, two clinical cases are presented in which these types of surfaces are employed.
2. Materials and Methods
Unless otherwise stated, all reagents were purchased from Scharlab S.L., Barcelona, Spain. Nanopure water used in this study was obtained by purification with a Diamond UV water system (Branstead International, Dubuque, IA, USA).
Blood from the patient (surgeries) or healthy volunteers (in vitro experiments) was collected into 0.4% (wt./vol.) sodium citrate-containing tubes (BTI Biotechnology Institute S.L., Vitoria, Spain) and used immediately or centrifuged following the manufacturer instructions to obtain platelet-rich plasma in accordance with the PRGF-Endoret
® Technology [
4,
15].
2.1. Quartz Crystal Microbalance with Dissipation Analysis (QCM-D)
QCM-D experimental substrates were TiO
2 sputtered SiO
2 crystals with a 10 mm diameter on their working surface and gold-plated on the electrical contact surface (5 MHz Biolin Scientific, Gothenburg, Sweden). Immediately prior to each experiment, the surfaces were cleaned. First, the samples were sonicated in 2% sodium dodecyl sulfate solution (Sigma-Aldrich Chemie GmbH, Munich, Germany), filtered through a 0.2 mm pore diameter syringe filter (Millipore Sigma, Burlington, MA, USA), and rinsed under a stream of Nanopure water. The water was blown off with a filtered nitrogen stream. The dry surfaces were further treated with UV-Ozone for 30 min in a UV/Ozone cleaner (BioForce Nanosciences, Ames, IA, USA) that was pre-heated for 30 min immediately before use. The QCM-D measurements were performed on a Biolin Scientific Microbalance (Q-Sense). The TiO
2-coated QCM-D sensor plates were installed into two parallel QCM-D liquid chambers connected with a temperature controller at 37 ± 0.1 °C.
Figure 1 shows a scheme of the experiments. Briefly, 10 µL of 5 wt.% CaCl
2 was injected into the left QCM-D chamber (Ca) and 100 µL of plasma into the right (NoCa). Both liquids covered completely the sensor plates and were left for around 30 min for stabilization and thermal equilibrium. Thereafter, 190 µL of plasma was injected into the right chamber (Ca) and a freshly prepared mixture of 10 µL CaCl
2 5 wt.% and 90 µL of plasma into the left chamber (NoCa). Both sensor plates contained the same final volume (200 µL) and had the same concentration of CaCl
2 in the plasma (22.8 mM). During the QCM-D measurement, the frequency shift and dissipation change were simultaneously recorded at its first three overtones (
n = 3, 5, 7). Recording was stopped after the frequency and dissipation signals were stabilized. The resulting interfaces were visually and microscopically analyzed (SEM). The experiments were performed in triplicates (
n = 3 per surface type).
2.2. Blood Contact Experiments
For blood immersion experiments, commercial dental implants were employed. Ca-modified implants (BTI reference IIPUCA4010, unicCa®) and non-modified (BTI reference IIPU4010) followed the same proprietary process to convey roughness and cleanliness to the surfaces. Ca-modified samples were conditioned with 5% CaCl2 under clean room conditions prior to the sterilization of the implants (BTI). Freshly drawn blood from a young healthy patient in citrated tubes was poured into a borosilicate well. The implants were placed side by side and care was taken to avoid any contact with their surfaces at any point of the experiment. They were slowly introduced into the well leaving only the neck of the implants uncovered. After 20 min of incubation at room temperature, the implants were extracted, and their surfaces were analyzed visually and prepared for SEM examination. The experiment was repeated three times with identical results.
2.3. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM)
SEM images were taken with a Hitachi S-4800 (Hitachi High-Tech, Krefeld, Germany) at 15 kV acceleration voltage, around 10 mm working distance. After QCM and blood incubation experiments, respectively, QCM sensors and implants were immediately fixed for 1 h in 2 wt.% glutaraldehyde in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer (pH = 7.4) at room temperature, washed 3 × 10 min with the 6.5 wt.% sucrose in the same cacodylate buffer, stained with 1 wt.% OsO4 in 0.1 M cacodylate buffer for 1 h at 4 °C in the dark, and finally washed 3 × 10 min with cacodylate buffer. The fixed samples were dehydrated in a series of solutions of increasing ethanol concentrations (30, 50, 70, 96, 3 × 100 vol.%). Each step took 10 min. The dehydrated samples were immersed in hexamethyldisilazane for 2 × 10 min and allowed to dry. The dry samples were coated with gold by sputtering for 180 s immediately before observation in an argon atmosphere in a JFC-1000 ion sputter (Jeol SAS, Croissy-sur-Seine, France) mounted on one of the ports of the SEM. Three images per implant (n = 9) at 1000× magnification were analyzed using the software ImageJ (version 1.53a; National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA) to measure the Surface Coverage % (SC) of red blood cells, fibrin, and platelets on each surface.
2.4. Implant Surgeries
The patients subjected to implant surgeries were treated in the same private clinic by E.A. following the standard clinical practice. The first patient received implants due to severe lower jaw atrophy. The second patient was subjected to a maxillary sinus lift augmentation due to severe vertical bone resorption in the upper jaw. A more detailed description is provided later. A dental hygiene was performed prior to the surgery. For surgical planification, a computed axial tomography scan was used and analyzed by specialized software (BTI Scan
®, BTI Biotechnology Institute, Vitoria, Spain). Demographic and clinical data were recorded in the patients’ clinical reports. Pre-surgical prophylaxis was administered (2 g of amoxicillin/600 mg of clindamycin and 1 g of acetaminophen). The amoxicillin treatment was continued during the next 5 days at a dose of 500 mg, three times a day. For pain control, acetaminophen 1 g/8 h or ibuprofen 600 mg/8 h were prescribed. After infiltrative anesthesia, a full-thickness flap was elevated, and the implant sites were prepared using a low-speed 125 rpm drilling procedure without irrigation [
16]. The preparation of blood plasma (PRGF) obtained with the Endoret
® technology was performed following the manufacturer’s instructions [
4,
15]. Before implant insertion, the implant sites were filled with PRGF-Endoret
®, fraction 2. In both cases, two 5.5 mm diameter and 5.5 mm long titanium implants with their surface modified with calcium ions (unicCa
®, BTI Biotechnology Institute) were used. The insertion speed was 30 rpm. Finally, a panoramic radiograph was taken just after the intervention to verify the adequate placement of the implants.
For the post-surgical clinical assessment, patients attended the private clinic periodically, first after the surgical phase (10 days, 1, 3, 6 months, and 1 year) and then on a yearly basis, performing panoramic radiographs at each visit. Measurements on the panoramic radiographs were performed by computer software (Sidexis XG, Sirona Dental Systems, Bensheim, Germany). The radiographs were calibrated by the known implant length.
2.5. Data Analysis
The data are shown as means ± Standard Deviation. We confirmed data normality prior to comparisons (Shapiro–Wilk). We determined the differences between the means by a two-sample independent Student’s two-tailed homoscedastic t-test between surfaces. We considered statistical significance for p < 0.01. The software used for statistical analysis was Origin v7.5 (OriginLab Corporation, Northampton, MA, USA).
4. Discussion
In this work, we have evaluated the effects of exposing titanium to calcium ions prior to their contact with human blood and blood plasma. We have monitored the process of blood and blood plasma coagulation on these surfaces as compared to regular unmodified titanium implant surfaces. The QCM-D technique used permits evaluating the changes that occur at the adsorbed layer. The adsorbed mass and the thickness, viscosity, and hardness of the films formed are common outputs of this technique. The Sauerbrey equation relates the change of the resonance frequency (
f) proportionally to the added mass (m) [
18]. However, in the case of viscoelastic films, where the dissipation to frequency shifts ratio (D/
f) is typically below 0.2 × 10
−6 Hz
−1, the Sauerbrey equation is no longer considered a good approximation [
19]. Therefore, the mass and thickness of the deposited films could not be calculated. Looking into the future, the application of the Voigt model could allow us to obtain numerical data of the biofilms. The Voigt model has been already used in the past for the determination of the adsorbed mass and thickness of viscoelastic biofilms using a complex shear modulus. The storage modulus is the real part, and the loss modulus is the imaginary one [
19,
20,
21].
However, the qualitative data obtained are enough for the purpose of this work: on surfaces previously modified with calcium, coagulation occurs within the adsorbate at the surface. In contrast, when the calcium ions are not previously present at the surfaces but are presented together with the blood plasma solution, coagulation occurs, but the fibrin network does not stay attached to the surface. This observation agrees with previous research showing that at unmodified Ti surfaces, the fibrin clot slips over and does not attach to the surfaces [
22]. The macroscopic aspect of the surfaces obtained after the experiments in blood and blood plasma supports this observation, as well as the surface coverage measurements from the electron micrographs of the surfaces. Moreover, the first interaction of the implant surfaces with blood showed their respective wetting behavior. In contact angle experiments, typically, the frontier between hydrophilic (wetting) and hydrophobic (non-wetting) surfaces is set at an angle between water and the surface of 90° [
23]. Wettability studies at Ca-enriched surfaces have shown that this modification on titanium renders the surfaces completely hydrophilic or superhydrophilic (contact angles below 5°), while the control surface is only slightly hydrophilic (contact angles above 65°) [
10,
12]. Superhydrophilicity allows the implant to render its surface immediately available for the upcoming regenerative events. This is especially relevant in the case of small-sized implants with less available surface.
On the other hand, the formation of the provisional matrix directly on the surface of the implant can have advantageous effects on the generation of the definitive extracellular matrix as an early support for implant stability. The increased levels of platelet activation and clot formation were associated with higher levels of osseointegration in the femoral condyle of rabbits at 2 and 8 weeks post-implantation [
12]. Early healing also increased in surfaces with Ca-ions in the early periods of implantation in the dog mandible with respect to other hydrophilic surfaces [
24]. The effects of calcium ions in the protection of the native titanium oxide pureness were related to an increased osteoblast cell function and bone regeneration in a goat tibia model 3 months after implantation with respect to non-modified standard implants [
25]. Ionic calcium seems to be the key leading to the stimulation of the early healing events. Compared to surfaces with calcium in a non-ionic form as a part of a nanohydroxyapatite coating (DCD or Discrete Crystalline Deposition surfaces), Ca-ion unicCa
® surfaces resulted in significantly increased levels of new bone apposition, especially at 2 and 4 weeks post-implantation in the dog mandible [
26]. The effects of the protein adsorbate were recently investigated with respect to regular titanium implant surfaces. Ca-ion unicCa
® surfaces boost coagulation using the common pathway rather than the intrinsic or contact activation pathway as detected by the coagulation factors in these surfaces. These results were correlated with significantly higher levels of osseointegration in the rabbit model [
5]. In another study focusing on the reactivity of implants to peri-implant disease formation and progression in a dog model with ligatures and no plaque control, the marginal bone loss at Ca-ion unicCa
® surfaces was 33% lower than implants stored in NaCl solution (SLActive
®) [
27]. The results of this in vivo study are in accordance with previous in vitro experiments in which Ca-ion unicCa
® surfaces showed significantly less bacterial adhesion and better mammalian cell functions than unmodified controls in the presence and absence of natural saliva and blood plasma [
10].
In a recent clinical study with patients displaying systemic diseases of a different nature showed that rehabilitation with calcium ion-modified unicCa
® implants associated with plasma rich in growth factors proved to be a safe and effective treatment with results comparable to those found in healthy patients after 5 years [
3].
Another clinical study compared Ca-ion unicCa
® dental implants and the same implants without calcium ions. The clinical model was vertical bone atrophy in the posterior sector of the upper jaw. The implants were placed with the transalveolar sinus lift technique using the low-rev milling technique and the application of PRGF-Endoret
®. The results of this research indicate that modifying implants with calcium ions significantly improves bone stability around the dental implant and reduces its failure rate. This reduction was related to the improvement of osseointegration mediated by the release of calcium ions from the surface of the dental implant [
28].
In the two clinical cases here presented, we found vertical bone regeneration, coronally and apically, respectively. The effects of calcium ions on unicCa® surfaces allowed the use of minimally invasive techniques in challenging situations with severe vertical bone defect. Some weeks after the surgeries, the implants succeed in stimulating vertical bone growth and the thickening of the surrounding supporting bone, which is maintained throughout the following years. The use of the Ca-ion modified unicCa® implant surface represents a valuable tool in short or narrow implants to render all available implant surface functional in the quest for a fast implant stabilization in these challenging situations.