3.1. Chemical and Metallurgical Characterization of Raw Materials
The chemical analysis of the samples G_SF and H_SF are shown in
Table 2 and
Table 3, respectively. In comparison to the iron content in Brazilian iron ores [
1,
7], sample G_SF can be classified as a low-grade iron ore, while sample H_SG can be classified as a high-grade iron ore. Despite the higher sulfur and phosphorus contents in the sample G_SF, the results suggested that all types of pig iron (basic, foundry, and nodular) could be produced by using this ore as a blending raw material in the sinter pot.
The coke and limestone utilized in the experiments are current materials used for the sintering of the sample H_SF, leading to the production of a high-quality sinter, based on the typical supply for the ironmaking industry. The characterization results of these materials are presented in
Supplementary Materials (Tables S6 and S7).
Figure 1 displays the observed and calculated diffractograms for the G_SF sample, while
Table 4 presents the content of the main minerals identified by the RM. It can be observed that FeO·OH was the major constituent of the sample. The results revealed that the total iron content, 52.2% in weight, was distributed among the following carriers in terms of weight:
- (i)
35.5% of goethite (FeO·OH) corresponding to 22.3% of Fe content in the sample;
- (ii)
33.3% of hematite (Fe2O3) corresponding to 23.3% of Fe content in the sample;
- (iii)
9.1% of magnetite (Fe3O4) corresponding to 6.6% of Fe content in the sample.
Based on these results, it can be said that XRD findings agree with XRF, as the latter showed a total Fe content of 54.8% in weight.
On the other hand,
Figure 2 exhibits the observed and calculated diffractograms for the sample H_SF, while
Table 5 displays the content of the main minerals identified. The principal mineral constituent of the sample H_SF was Fe
2O
3, and among the identified minerals, iron was exclusively present in it. Based on the mineralogical analysis, the total iron content in the sample was 62.7% in weight. This inference is also in agreement with the values obtained by XRF (60.3% in weight).
Finally, the minor difference between the iron content calculated by XRF and the one determined through RM using XRD can be attributed to the presence of Fe as an element of substitution within the crystalline structure of other mineral constituents of the sample.
Thermal analysis results are presented in
Figure 3. The TGA curve for the sample G_SF exhibited three thermal decomposition events, labeled here as [A], [B], and [C], while for the DTG curve, these same events were marked as [A′], [B′], and [C′].
The event [A] was attributed to the thermal decomposition of the mineral goethite through Equation (4).
The temperature range, between 120 and 600 °C, for the thermal decomposition of this mineral is consistent with the values reported in literature [
22,
23,
24,
25]. Utilizing the calculated mass loss value in the TGA curve for event [A], it was possible to determine that the content of goethite in the sample was 34.6% in weight. This value aligns with the results obtained through RM (see
Table 4). The slight disparity observed between the TGA and RM results (2.2% wt.) could be attributed to the potential presence of amorphous goethite in the sample, which could not be quantified through XRD, and/or the presence of water in the chemical structure of this mineral.
The literature indicates that certain goethite samples exhibit low crystallinity [
22,
26,
27]. The event (B), on the other hand, was attributed to the thermal decomposition of the mineral hematite through Equation (4).
The values of standard Gibbs free energy to the reaction, as observed in the literature [
25], indicate that the thermal decomposition of Fe
2O
3 will be spontaneous at temperatures higher than 1451 °C. This temperature level is considerably higher than the one observed in the experiments (near 1140 °C). Since the experiments were carried out using pure N
2 (99.9990% in volume), the implemented partial pressure can be estimated as 10
−5. Thus, it is possible to estimate the thermal decomposition temperature of the hematite through Equation (6).
Considering the activity of the pure solid as 1, pO
2 = 10
−5, and under equilibrium conditions, the calculated temperature value was 1072 °C, which is much closer to the level of temperature observed in the TGA curve for event [B]. This value was following the findings reported in literature [
28,
29]. Furthermore, considering the total thermal decomposition of the mineral goethite, the hematite content in the sample was 67.6% in weight, with 33.1% produced by the thermal decomposition of goethite, while the remaining 34.5% was already present in the sample. These values were calculated by RM and adjusted, considering the 3.5% mass loss observed in the event [A]. Thus, the mass loss resulting from the thermal decomposition of the mineral hematite in the sample was 2.25% in weight for the calculated mass loss for event [B]. This value is very close to those observed on the TGA curve.
Finally, event [C] was attributed to the thermal decomposition of the mineral magnetite, as described by Equation (7).
The values of standard Gibbs free energy showed that the reaction was spontaneous at temperatures higher than 1912.8 °C. However, considering a maximum partial pressure of oxygen of 10
−5, following the same approach applied for event [B], the temperature values were calculated as 1480 °C for event [C]. This value follows the one observed in the experiment conditions and also agrees with values reported in the literature [
26].
3.2. Chemical and Metallurgical Characterization of Materials after Batch Sintering Experiments
Batch sintering experiments were conducted with varying quantities of G_SF (see
Table 1). The production of sinter using only the sample H_SF, as an iron-containing raw material, is a daily routine experiment performed by the ironmaking site; an experiment without the sample G_SF (labeled 0%G_SF) was carried out and used as a reference experiment. XRF determined the chemical compositions of the sintering beds, and a reduction in iron content and an increase in silicon (Si) content with a higher amount of G_SF in the sintering bed were observed (
Supplementary Material—Table S8). It is important to mention that the chemical composition of all sintering beds studied in this manuscript fell within the typical range usually applied by various Brazilian ironmaking companies.
Table 6 shows the GI values before and after the granulation process for the studied sintering bed compositions, while
Table 7 shows the chemical analysis of products using different sintering beds.
It can be observed that the GI increased after the granulation process for all conditions. Furthermore, the increase in the quantity of G_SF contributed to the observed elevation in GI after the granulation process. The rise in the GI can be attributed to the presence of argillaceous minerals (e.g., kaolinite) (see
Figure 1 and
Table 6) and their capacity to retain moisture [
30]. According to the literature, the granulation of the sintering mixture increases when ores with high iron content are mixed with ores exhibiting a high loss of ignition (LOI) [
30]. Moreover, some researchers also declare that incorporating goethite in the sintering bed enhances the GI of the sinter product [
31].
The results in
Table 7 show that when the amount of G_SF was increased, the Fe content in the sinter mix decreased, due to the lower iron content in this ore. Since the raw material that feeds the BF must contain at least 59% in weight of Fe, the sintering bed of 40% G_SF cannot be employed in the current process.
The mineral phases identified by XRD were hematite, magnetite, and quartz, and the contents of these minerals in the different sinters produced are shown in
Table 8. (Diffractograms are presented in
Supplementary Materials—
Figure S4). The RM refinement parameters for the calculated diffractograms were determined to be satisfactory, as the goodness-of-fit (GOF) and weighted R profile (Rwp) consistently registered values below 1.48 and 3.7, respectively.
The total Fe percentage was calculated using the stoichiometric relation of this element in the minerals quantified by the RM and compared with values measured by XRF. The values obtained were remarkably similar; specifically, the maximum and minimum differences between these values were 1.9% and 0.02% for the samples 0%G_SF and 10%G_SF, respectively.
The results showed that the percentage of Fe in the sinter decreased when the amount of G_SF in the sintering bed was increased; this reduction can be attributed to the low content of iron in the G_SF when compared with the H_SF. (The chemical composition of sintering bed can be found in
Table S8.) In addition, increasing the amount of G_SF in the sintering feed promoted the formation of a sinter richer in magnetite. This result suggests that the Fe
2O
3 formed from the thermal decomposition of FeO·OH is easily reduced, due to its higher porosity.
The content of SiO
2 measured using both techniques (XRF and RM refinement) differed significantly. This disparity arises because the RM quantifies only the crystalline phase, while the XRF determines the total content of silicon in the sample. This difference between the analytical techniques explains the higher values obtained when determining the Si content using XRF. There was a clear correlation between the percentage of slag calculated by XRF and the content of the amorphous phase in the sinter (see
Supplementary Material—Figure S5). The results suggest that RM refinement can be used as an analytical method to estimate the content of slag in sinter products. It is observed that the amorphous phase is consistently overestimated; this discrepancy could be attributed to the presence of unaccounted crystalline phases [
32].
The negative pressure and exhaust gas temperature were measured as a function of the time in various sintering experiments (see
Supplementary Materials—Figure S6).
Figure 4A,B presents the corresponding values for sintering time, maximum temperature, and initial and final negative pressures.
The initial and final negative pressure values indicated that, for all studied sintering experiments, the permeability of the bed increased after the process. Furthermore, an increase in the amount of G_SF led to an additional increase in the permeability of the sintering bed. As shown in the granulation results, the rise in the content of G_SF in the sintering bed promoted an increase in the GI. The final negative pressure value measured in the exhaust gas pipe decreased slightly with an increase in the amount of G_SF. This suggests that the presence of G_SF could promote a slight improvement in the porosity of the sinter. The sintering time decreased with an increase in the quantity of G_SF in the sintering bed. This can be attributed to the improved permeability promoted by the higher amount of G_SF. The maximum temperature of the sintering bed increased when the percentage of G_SF was raised in the process. This is a consequence of the improved permeability of the bed promoted by the addition of G_SF, i.e., the increased permeability of the sintering bed, resulting from the addition of G_SF, allowed for the more efficient combustion of the coke. Furthermore, according to previously published literature, the formation of magnetite increases when sintering is performed at temperatures higher than 1300 °C [
33]. Thus, it is possible that the rise in the amount of G_SF in the sintering enhanced the permeability, leading to higher temperatures. Consequently, an increase in the percentage of magnetite in the sinter was observed (
Table 8).
Finally, the results showed that, despite the increase in the percentage of adherent particles in the sintering bed promoted by the addition of G_SF, the effective performance of this sample in the granulation process allowed for a better permeability of the sintering bed to be reached. Consequently, the produced sinter exhibited chemical proprieties as satisfactory as those displayed by the sinter currently used by the company. The results of the shatter test are shown in
Table 9. The shatter indexes revealed that approximately 80% of the sinter retained a particle size greater than 9.5 mm, and overall, the shatter index values remained consistent. Furthermore, all the sinters produced exhibited sufficient mechanical resistance for transportation within the company and to support the charge inside BFs.
Finally, it is crucial to highlight that the cost of the sintering process was reduced when the G_SF sample was used as raw material. The reduction in this value was estimated based on the cost of a sintering process operation performed using only H_SF as raw material (X).
Table 10 shows the reduction in the value brought about by this alteration, which is a consequence of the low price of G_SF when compared to H_SF.