Next Article in Journal
Selected Serum Markers Associated with Pathogenesis and Clinical Course of Type 1 Diabetes in Pediatric Patients—The Effect of Disease Duration
Previous Article in Journal
The Development of New Agents for Post-Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation Non-Infectious Complications in Children
 
 
Search for Articles:
Title / Keyword
Author / Affiliation / Email
Journal
Article Type
 
 
Advanced Search
 
Section
Special Issue
Volume
Issue
Number
Page
 
Journals
JCM
Volume 12
Issue 6
10.3390/jcm12062150
jcm-logo
Submit to this Journal Review for this Journal Propose a Special Issue
► Article Menu

Article Menu

share Share announcement Help format_quote Cite question_answer Discuss in SciProfiles thumb_up
...
Endorse textsms
...
Comment
first_page
settings
Order Article Reprints
Font Type:
Arial Georgia Verdana
Font Size:
Aa Aa Aa
Line Spacing:
Column Width:
Background:
Systematic Review

Effect of Traditional Chinese Exercises on Patients with Chronic Heart Failure (TCE-HF): A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

by
Qinyi Bao
1,†,
Shuxin Lei
1,†,
Shitian Guo
1,
Zhuo Wang
1,
Jiaye Yu
1,
Yayu You
1,
Ning Zhang
2 and
Xiaojie Xie
1,*
1
Department of Cardiology, Second Affiliated Hospital, Zhejiang University School of Medicine, Hangzhou 310009, China
2
Department of Cardiology, First People’s Hospital, Zhejiang University School of Medicine, Hangzhou 310006, China
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
†
These authors contributed equally to this work.
J. Clin. Med. 2023, 12(6), 2150; https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm12062150
Submission received: 27 January 2023 / Revised: 24 February 2023 / Accepted: 1 March 2023 / Published: 9 March 2023
(This article belongs to the Section Cardiology)
Browse Figures
Review Reports Versions Notes

Abstract

:
Exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation is safe and effective for chronic heart failure (CHF) patients. The present study aimed to investigate the effects of traditional Chinese exercise (TCE) on patients with CHF and the impact of exercise types and duration. Evaluation of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of TCE in patients with CHF published since 1997 from PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, the Cochrane Library, Chongqing VIP, Wanfang Databases, and the China National Knowledge was performed. A total of 41 RCTs, including 3209 patients with CHF, were included. It showed that TCE significantly increased 6-min walk distance (6MWD) [mean difference (MD) = 72.82 m, p < 0.001] and left ventricular ejection fraction (MD = 5.09%, p < 0.001), whereas reduced B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP) (MD = −56.80 pg/mL, p < 0.001), N-terminal pro-BNP (MD = −174.94 pg/mL, p < 0.05), and Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire scores (MD = −11.31, p < 0.001). However, no significant difference was found in the effects of TCE on peak oxygen consumption. The increase in TCE weekly duration and program duration significantly improved 6MWD (MD = 71.91 m, p < 0.001; MD = 74.11 m, p < 0.001). The combination of TCE and conventional aerobic exercise significantly improved 6MWD (MD = 19.86 m, p < 0.005). TCE improves exercise capacity, cardiac function, and quality of life in patients with CHF, which might be an optimal and available pattern of exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation.

1. Introduction

Heart failure (HF), the terminal stage of various cardiovascular diseases, is a complex, serious clinical syndrome. Patients with chronic heart failure (CHF) usually suffer from lower exercise tolerance, reduced quality of life (QoL), mental health, and a high risk of hospitalizations [1,2]. The 1-year mortality and 1-year hospitalization rate of patients with CHF are reported to be 7.2% and 31.9%, respectively [3]. The mortality may be even higher in patients with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF) [4]. There is increasing awareness that exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation (ExCR) is safe and effective for patients with CHF. Clinical trials and meta-analyses have also shown that ExCR could improve exercise tolerance, reduce all-cause and HF-related hospitalization rates, and enhance QoL [2,5,6,7].
The effect of ExCR may rely on high compliance with the exercise program [8]. Therefore, traditional Chinese exercise (TCE) could be an alternative option. TCE is a type of low-intensity aerobic exercise, which mainly includes Tai Chi, Baduanjin (eight silken movements), Yijinjing (changing tendons exercises), Wuqinxi (five animals play), and Liuzijue (six tips). The characteristics of each type of TCE are detailed in Supplementary Materials, Table S4. TCE can be practiced with minimal time investment without the limitation of place, time, or specialized equipment. This characteristic makes TCE to be easily incorporated into daily routines and eventually improves patient adherence. With the increasing global popularity of TCE, it is more widely utilized in cardiac rehabilitation (CR) programs for HF patients. Reported benefits of TCE include improvements in clinical symptoms, QoL, exercise tolerance, cardiac function, sleep quality, and the alleviation of depressive symptoms in patients with HF [9,10,11,12,13,14,15]. Several randomized controlled trials (RCTs) reported that left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) and N-terminal pro-B natriuretic peptide (NT-proBNP) had no noticeable improvement within 3 months of Liuzijue exercise [16]. However, B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP) levels could dramatically decline after 1 year of exercise [17,18]. Additionally, there was an RCT to evaluate the therapeutic effect of Baduanjin which enrolled 63 patients with CHF due to coronary heart disease and ultimately reported no significant difference after 3 months of Baduanjin on plasma NT-proBNP compared to the control group [19].
Considering that consensus regarding the effect of TCE on patients with CHF has not been reached, the primary aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis is to assess the potential benefits of TCE on patients with CHF. The present study further explored whether different types of TCE and various study characteristics had different effects on CR in HF patients, thereby providing references for further application of TCE in HF patients.

2. Materials and Methods

This study adheres to the guidelines for systematic reviews according to the Cochrane Handbook and Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) [20]. The study protocol has been published previously in INPLASY (registration number: 202190027; DOI number: 10.37766/inplasy2021.9.0027) [21]. There were a few minor changes to the title and the anticipated dates of the literature completion.

2.1. Search Strategy

Three reviewers independently conducted a systematic literature search of articles published from the inceptions of the following electronic data sources to 11 August 2022: PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, the Cochrane Library, Chongqing VIP, Wanfang Databases, and the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI). The search was limited to RCTs with human subjects, which were published in either English or Chinese. Additional clinical trials which were not identified by the electronic search were retrieved by searching the reference lists of relevant articles. A complete search strategy is provided in Supplementary Methods.

2.2. Eligibility Criteria

The titles and abstracts of all identified articles were scanned first. Full-text articles using RCTs design, incorporating TCE intervention, among participants with all types of CHF were included. There were no limits according to age, sex, country, outcome, the type of control groups, or TCE intervention type, time, frequency, or intensity. Studies that lacked data for outcome evaluation, had a high bias or were published as reviews, comments, letters, editorials, historical articles, meta-analyses, and guidelines were excluded.

2.3. Data Extraction and Management

The following data were independently extracted from the included studies by two reviewers and checked by a third: (1) study characteristics: authors, publication year; (2) participant characteristics: number, age, country; New York Heart Association (NYHA) class; baseline LVEF; (3) description of the intervention and control groups; (4) duration; (5) main outcomes: 6-min walking distance (6MWD), BNP, NT-proBNP, QoL [e.g., Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire (MLHFQ), 36-Item Short Form (SF-36)], peak oxygen consumption (peakVO2), LVEF.

2.4. Quality Assessment

The risk of bias in the included studies was independently evaluated by two reviewers with the Cochrane Collaboration’s recommended tool [22]. The following domains were assessed: random sequence generation (selection bias); allocation concealment (selection bias); blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias); blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias); incomplete outcome data (attrition bias); selective reporting (reporting bias); and other sources of bias.

2.5. Statistical Analysis

The Review Manager (RevMan) software Version 5.3. (Cochrane Collaboration, Copenhagen, Denmark) was used to conduct the meta-analysis. Given that all variables in the included studies were continuous data, the mean difference (MD) or standardized mean difference (SMD) with corresponding 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated in this study. The MD was used when all studies assessed the same outcome using the same scale. The sample mean and standard deviation were estimated if the continuous data were reported as median and interquartile range. Specific estimation methods were reported in a previous study [23]. According to the Cochrane Handbook, studies with change-from-baseline outcomes and final measurement outcomes were combined in analysis using the (unstandardized) mean difference method in RevMan [22].
The chi-square test and I2 statistic were employed to analyze heterogeneity, with p < 0.10 indicating evidence of heterogeneity. The I2 statistic was used to measure the degree of heterogeneity, with suggested thresholds for low (25–49%), moderate (50–74%), and high (75%) values. A fixed-effect model was used for low heterogeneity (I2 < 50%), and a random-effect model was used for higher heterogeneity. Funnel plots and Begg’s and Egger’s tests were used to detect potential publication bias. Sensitivity analysis was conducted by removing each study individually to estimate the consistency and quality of the results. Subgroup analyses were undertaken to identify potential sources of heterogeneity and investigate the influence of various study characteristics on the observed effect. p < 0.05 was statistically significant.

3. Results

3.1. Search Results

The literature search yielded a total of 424 titles. Following the review of titles and abstracts, 168 publications remained for full-text evaluation. In a more detailed review, 127 additional studies were excluded due to the following reasons: non-RCTs, non-HF, protocol articles, review articles, or other interventions. Finally, 41 studies that fulfilled all inclusion criteria of the TCE-HF study were included in this systematic review and meta-analysis (Figure 1).

3.2. Study Characteristics

The 41 RCTs included 3209 patients (1615 for the TCE group and 1594 for the control group). The TCE groups received usual care in addition to different types of TCE, which included Tai Chi (n = 19), Baduanjin (n = 14), Liuzijue (n = 2), and a combination of two of the exercise types (n = 6). Usual care (n = 36) included routine treatment and nursing, therapeutic drugs, dietary and exercise advice, standard medical supervision, lifestyle guidance, mental health advice, and an education program. A total of 33 studies (80.49%) were conducted in Asian countries [12,13,15,16,17,18,19,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36], five (19.23%) in the United States [14,37,38,39,40], one (3.85%) in Italy [11], one (3.85%) in the United Kingdom [10] and one in Sweden [41]. The time and frequency of exercise varied among studies. The weekly exercise volume of the TCE group varied widely between 60 and 420 min (Supplementary Materials, Table S1). Patients in 10 control groups performed aerobic exercise (including walking training and cycling) for 30–60 min, twice to 14 times a week [11,14,26,27,42,43,44,45,46]. Detailed characteristics are displayed in Supplementary Materials, Tables S1–S3.

3.3. Risk of Bias and Sensitivity Analysis

Two reviewers independently assessed the quality of the selected studies according to the Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for RCTs. All studies had a high risk of performance bias, 23 had an unclear risk of detection bias, and two had a high risk of selection bias. A summary of the risk of bias is provided in Supplementary Materials, Figure S1. Visual inspection of the funnel plot for each outcome suggested no visible publication bias (Supplementary Materials, Figure S2). This was further confirmed by Egger’s linear regression asymmetry test for each overall outcome (for 6MWD, p = 0.671; for LVEF, p = 0.838; for MLHFQ, p = 0.068; for BNP, p = 0.092; for NT-proBNP, p = 0.269; for peakVO2, p = 0.437). Sensitivity analyses confirmed the robustness of the results (Supplementary Materials, Figure S3).

3.4. Overall Outcomes

3.4.1. Exercise Tolerance

A total of 29 studies were used to assess the effect of TCE on 6MWD, including 2270 patients. Significant improvements were found when comparing exercise tolerance by 6MWD. The meta-analyses showed a significant improvement in 6WMD of 72.82 m (random-effects model: 95% CI 53.49, 92.16; p < 0.001) (Figure 2A).

3.4.2. Cardiopulmonary Exercise Capacity

Four studies reported data on cardiopulmonary exercise capacity (peak VO2, mL/min/kg). The intervention of the TCE group in three studies was Tai Chi [14,37,39], and one was Baduanjin [31]. However, no significant change in peak VO2 in the TCE group was found compared with the control group (1.28 mL/min/kg, 95% CI: −0.72, 3.27; p > 0.05) (Figure 2B).

3.4.3. Cardiac Function

LVEF has been wildly utilized to evaluate cardiac function. A total of 19 studies in HFrEF patients [12,15,16,19,25,27,28,29,30,32,44,46,47,48,49,50,53,54] and two studies in HFpEF patients [14,34] provided results on LVEF, containing 1703 patients. Pooled results showed significantly improved LVEF in the TCE group compared with that of the control group (random-effects model: MD = 5.09%, 95%CI 2.93, 7.24; p < 0.001) (Figure 2C).

3.4.4. Serum Biomarkers

An amount of 12 studies assessed BNP as an outcome indicator, including 803 HFrEF patients [17,18,37,39,44,45,48,53,55] and 207 HFpEF patients [14,34]. Four Tai Chi studies [11,41,47,54], four Baduanjin studies [12,19,27,46] and one Liuzijue study [16] assessed NT-proBNP as an outcome indicator in 607 HFrEF patients. The meta-analyses demonstrated that TCE was significantly associated with decreased BNP (fixed-effects model: MD = −56.80 pg/mL, 95%CI −78.26, −35.33; p < 0.001) (Figure 3A) and decreased NT-proBNP (random-effects model: MD = −174.94 pg/mL, 95% CI −318.14, −31.73; p < 0.05) (Figure 3B).

3.4.5. QoL

An amount of 21 studies reported data on MLHFQ, with lower scores indicating better QoL. Given the absence of the total MLHFQ scores, two studies were excluded from the analysis [30,50]. The aggregate results suggested that TCE was associated with a significantly decreased MLHFQ score (random-effects model: MD = −9.21, 95%CI −10.99, −7.42; p < 0.001) (Figure 3C), which indicated that TCE could improve the QoL of patients with CHF.

3.5. Subgroup Analysis

3.5.1. TCE Types

Few meta-analyses explored the effect of different types of TCE on patients with CHF; thus, a subgroup analysis was performed to compare the effects of different kinds of TCE on 6MWD with usual care. A total of 10 studies of Tai Chi, three of Baduanjin, and two of Liuzijue were included, with 891, 243, and 75 patients, respectively. The subgroup analyses showed that Tai Chi, Baduanjin, and Liuzijue could significantly lead to an increase of 65.30 m (random-effects model: 95% CI 42.71, 87.90; p < 0.005), 63.31 m (random-effects model: 95% CI 36.53, 90.10; p < 0.001), and 90.58 m (random-effects model: 95% CI 43.85, 137.31; p < 0.001) on 6WMD, respectively (Figure 4).

3.5.2. TCE Duration

The weekly duration varied widely from 60 to 420 min per week, while the total program duration varied from 3 to 12 months. Therefore, a subgroup analysis was performed to assess the effect of TCE duration on CHF compared with usual care. In terms of weekly time, subgroup analyses showed that patients of the TCE group who performed over 150 min weekly had significantly longer 6MWD of 71.91 m (random-effects model: 95% CI 55.26, 88.56; p < 0.001) compared to those who exercised between 60 to 150 min weekly (54.77 m, 95% CI 27.40, 82.15; p < 0.001) (Figure 5A). TCE with a program duration of ≥6 months significantly elongated 6MWD (random-effects model: 74.11 m; 95% CI 56.13, 92.09; p < 0.001) (Figure 5B).

3.5.3. Exercise Program

The preponderance compared the rehabilitation effect between TCE and usual care among the included studies. However, six studies compared TCE with traditional aerobic exercise [14,26,27,36,43,44], and two studies compared combined exercise programs (TCE and conventional aerobic exercise) with aerobic exercise alone [11,46]. Therefore, subgroup analysis was performed to compare the effect of different exercise programs on the exercise capacity of patients with CHF. Patients who performed TCE had longer 6MWD than those who only received usual care (random-effects model: 68.46 m; 95% CI 55.75, 81.17; p < 0.001) or aerobic exercise (random-effects model: 95.57 m; 95% CI 34.96, 156.19; p < 0.001) (Figure 6). In addition, a combined exercise program was more effective than conventional aerobic exercise alone in improving 6MWD (random-effects model: 19.86 m; 95% CI 7.65, 32.06; p < 0.05) (Figure 6).

4. Discussion

HF has been recognized as a major global public health issue with high mortality, morbidity, and a heavy medical burden. In the past few decades, the prognosis of HF patients has improved; however, this improvement remains poor and confined [51]. This meta-analysis was conducted to evaluate the benefits of TCE interventions among patients with CHF. This study extended previous systematic reviews and meta-analyses by exploring the potential effect of different types of TCE and exercise duration on HF patients. The meta-analysis indicated that TCE led to significantly better exercise capacity, improved cardiac function, higher QoL, and lower serum BNP/NT-pro BNP levels. Longer exercise duration (>150 min weekly, ≥6 months) could lead to even better improvements in 6WMD. TCE or combined exercise programs (TCE and conventional aerobic exercise) can improve exercise tolerance to a greater extent than aerobic exercise alone.
The results of 6WMD from this study suggested that TCE could improve the exercise tolerance of HF patients. Our findings are consistent with other systematic reviews and meta-analyses of TCE for HF patients [52,57,58]. However, a meta-analysis has reported that Tai Chi did not significantly improve 6MWD in patients with CHF [59]. This inconsistent result might be due to the shorter weekly and program duration, which were less than 150 min and 6 months, respectively. Muscle strength is of good predictive value in the long-term survival of patients with CHF. The reduction of muscle mass and shift of muscle fiber are major muscle abnormalities in CHF. Training has been shown to resolve the alteration in mitochondrial content, increase the cytochrome oxidase activity in patients with CHF, and thereby increase exercise tolerance [60]. Aerobic exercise has important advantages, particularly in increasing endothelial function and improving vasodilatory capacities [14]. It has been demonstrated that Tai Chi, a type of low-intensity aerobic exercise, could significantly enhance isokinetic quadriceps strength [11] and knee extensor muscle strength [52] in HF patients. Yeh et al. have found that, compared to conventional aerobic exercise, Tai Chi showed more significant improvements in 6MWD in HFpEF patients [14]. The potential mechanism of Tai Chi or other TCEs might be strengthening skeletal muscle, stretching, and enhancing neuroregulation.
In HFrEF patients, the peak VO2, an indicator of cardiopulmonary exercise capacity, is the strongest prognostic predictor of survival. For every 1 mL/min/kg lower peak VO2, there is a 16% greater risk of all-cause mortality [61]. Although several meta-analyses reported that ExCR [62], Tai Chi, and Qigong practices [58] improved peak VO2, these findings were inconsistent in the present meta-analysis and other previous studies [52,59,63]. Reduced oxygen consumption during TCE might be related to the lower heart rate since oxygen consumption is partly based on heart rate responses [14]. This divergence could also partially be elucidated by the substantial heterogeneity of study participants, including age, gender, disease history, etiology, myocardium damage, and cardiorespiratory fitness.
The results for BNP/NT-pro BNP and LVEF in this study are comparable to those of Ren’s [63], Pan’s [59], and Taylor-Piliae’s [57] studies, illustrating a significant reduction in circulatory BNP/NT-proBNP levels and improvements in LVEF. TCE, such as Tai Chi, Wuqinxi, Baduanjin, and Liuzijue, could activate muscles, dredge meridians, and collaterals, and regulate the circulation of Qi and blood [64]. In addition, TCE has been substantiated to inhibit sympathetic activity, activate the parasympathetic nerve, and increase coronary collateral circulation, cardiac output, and cardiac stroke volume [63]. Baduanjin could decrease inflammatory factors and reverse ventricular remodeling in patients with CHF [25]. Therefore, TCE has sound regulative effects on BNP/NT-pro BNP and LVEF.
QoL is evaluated by a variety of instruments, with MLHFQ being one of the most commonly used. The result of MLHFQ in this study is somewhat consistent with published systematic reviews that examined the effects of Tai Chi [57,59,63] and Qigong [58] on patients with HF, showing an improvement in QoL. It has been reported that ExCR could counteract the adverse effects of HF on psychological health, further stabilize physical fitness, and increase QoL in patients with CHF [62]. TCEs are characterized by a steady rhythm, inherent slowness and stillness, gentle movement, and breathing techniques in a harmonious manner [10,25,39], resulting in less cardiopulmonary stress and total body relaxation. Subsequently, TCE could alleviate HF symptoms, thus improving QoL.
Like other exercise programs, longer TCE duration has a better effect on exercise tolerance and cardiac function, which confirms the previous hypothesis [16,17,18]. In long-term CR for HF, lower intensity form exercise may produce less ventricular wall stress and lower risk of malignant arrhythmias [65]. In addition, long-term low-intensity activity appears to be as effective as that of moderate- to high-intensity in promoting muscle strength, autonomic nervous function, aerobic capacity, and QoL [66].
Breathing exercises could reduce the risk factors of cardiovascular disease through relaxation techniques and breathing modification [63]. Six sounds (Xu, He, Hue, Si, Tap, and Xi) are produced with different body movements when practicing Liuzijue. This type of breathing could slow the expiratory flow rate, especially facilitating gas exchange in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases [67]. Reduced breathing rate during Tai Chi indicated that the training effects differed from that of aerobic exercise [14]. A recent study found that diaphragmatic (abdominal) breathing, a fundamental procedure during meditation in Tai Chi, could improve dyspnea and daily physical activity, and further maintain or improve the cardiorespiratory fitness of patients with HF [68].
Distinguished from conventional aerobic exercises, such as the treadmill or bicycle workouts, TCE incorporates both physical and meditative elements [37], which are diverse and complex means of mind-body intervention [69]. TCE emphasizes the combination of physical postures, mind, and breathing techniques in a harmonious manner [70]. By practicing TCE, trainers can increase their self-awareness and self-efficacy, improve concentration, and relax [71]. These characteristics might impact the effect of cardiac rehabilitation in patients with CHF. Moreover, compared to aerobic exercise, TCE’s relatively lower intensity and meditative qualities may help accessibility and promote longer-term exercise adherence [14,72,73]. According to the study by Belardinelli et al., the LVEF of exercise-trained patients with CHF increased after 5 years of training duration [74]. It may be one of the reasons why the increases in LVEF presented in patients with CHF who received TCE rather than those who received conventional aerobic exercise. A previous study has explored that both aerobic and resistance training and TCE could improve the cardiopulmonary aerobic exercise capacity (e.g., peak VO2) of patients with stable coronary heart disease at different degrees [75]. Subgroup analysis of our study’s exercise program provides evidence that combining TCE with traditional aerobic exercise improves the exercise tolerance of patients with CHF more efficiently than aerobic exercise alone. Since only two studies performed combined exercise programs, further studies are still required.
This meta-analysis has several limitations. Except for two studies [14,40], blinded assessors were not recruited to evaluate echocardiographic results in most of the selected studies, which could increase interpretation bias. Adherence might be an essential factor and might be culture-dependent since the predominance of studies were performed in Asian countries. Limited by the number of studies, we could not analyze the effect of TCE on different phenotypes of CHF. Although the robustness of the results has been confirmed in a sensitivity analysis, some studies might have a bigger impact, especially in the subgroup analysis of exercise programs; therefore, more TCRs are required. Some factors may influence the results of this study, including the heterogeneity of TCE models in selected studies, short intervention and follow-up time, and the lack of data on recurrence rate, mortality rate, and cardiovascular endpoint event rate in follow-up data of patients in the TCE group. Therefore, this study failed to systematically evaluate TCE’s long-term clinical effects. Given that the sample size of some forms of exercise (e.g., Liuzijue, combined exercise program) is limited, there is a dire need for further studies to expand our knowledge.

5. Conclusions

As a safe and effective form of exercise, TCE significantly improves exercise capacity, cardiac function, and QoL in patients with CHF. With prolonged exercise duration, 6MWD was significantly elongated. TCE or TCE combined with conventional aerobic exercise improves the exercise tolerance of patients with CHF more efficiently than aerobic exercise alone. Thus, TCE might be an optimal and promising pattern of exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation for patients with CHF.

Supplementary Materials

The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https://www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/jcm12062150/s1, Supplementary Methods; Table S1: Characteristics of selected studies; Table S2: The baseline and final values of the TCE group in selected studies; Table S3: The baseline and final values of the control group in selected studies; Table S4: The characteristics of each type of TCE; Figure S1: Risk of bias assessment of included studies; Figure S2: Publication bias of all the outcomes; Figure S3: Sensitivity of all the outcomes.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, X.X., Q.B. and S.L.; methodology, S.L.; software, S.L.; validation, Q.B. and S.G.; formal analysis, Q.B. and S.L.; investigation, Q.B. and S.L.; data Curation, Q.B., S.L., S.G., Z.W., J.Y., Y.Y. and N.Z.; writing—original draft preparation, Q.B.; writing—review and editing, X.X., Q.B. and S.L.; supervision, X.X.; project administration, X.X.; funding acquisition, X.X. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This research was supported by the grant from the National Health Commission, key program of science and technology of the Medical and Health of Zhejiang Province (WKJ-ZJ-2028).

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Informed Consent Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

The protocol was registered in the International Platform of Registered Systematic Review and Meta-analysis Protocols (INPLASY): Invoice Number: 202190027.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Long, L.; Mordi, I.; Bridges, C.; Sagar, V.; Davies, E.; Coats, A.; Dalal, H.; Rees, K.; Singh, S.; Taylor, R. Exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation for adults with heart failure. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2019, 2019, CD003331. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  2. Schopfer, D.W.; Forman, D.E. Growing Relevance of Cardiac Rehabilitation for an Older Population with Heart Failure. J. Card. Fail. 2016, 22, 1015–1022. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  3. Maggioni, A.P.; Dahlström, U.; Filippatos, G.; Chioncel, O.; Leiro, M.C.; Drozdz, J.; Fruhwald, F.; Gullestad, L.; Logeart, D.; Fabbri, G.; et al. EURObservationalResearch Programme: Regional differences and 1-year follow-up results of the Heart Failure Pilot Survey (ESC-HF Pilot). Eur. J. Heart Fail. 2013, 15, 808–817. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  4. Pocock, S.; Ariti, C.; McMurray, J.; Maggioni, A.; Køber, L.; Squire, I.; Swedberg, K.; Dobson, J.; Poppe, K.; Whalley, G.; et al. Meta-analysis global group in chronic heart failure, predicting survival in heart failure: A risk score based on 39,372 patients from 30 studies. Eur. Heart J. 2013, 34, 1404–1413. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  5. Haykowsky, M.; Daniel, K.; Bhella, P.; Sarma, S.; Kitzman, D. Heart Failure: Exercise-Based Cardiac Rehabilitation: Who, When, and How Intense? Can. J. Cardiol. 2016, 32, S382–S387. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  6. Taylor, R.; Walker, S.; Smart, N.; Piepoli, M.; Warren, F.; Ciani, O.; Whellan, D.; O’Connor, C.; Keteyian, S.; Coats, A.; et al. Impact of Exercise Rehabilitation on Exercise Capacity and Quality-of-Life in Heart Failure. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2019, 73, 1430–1443. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  7. Taylor, R.; Walker, S.; Smart, N.; Piepoli, M.; Warren, F.; Ciani, O.; O’Connor, C.; Whellan, D.; Keteyian, S.; Coats, A.; et al. Impact of exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation in patients with heart failure (ExTraMATCH II) on mortality and hospitalisation: An individual patient data meta-analysis of randomised trials. Eur. J. Heart Fail. 2018, 20, 1735–1743. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  8. Cooper, L.; Mentz, R.; Sun, J.-L.; Schulte, P.; Fleg, J.; Cooper, L.; Piña, I.; Leifer, E.; Kraus, W.; Whellan, D.; et al. Psychosocial Factors, Exercise Adherence, and Outcomes in Heart Failure Patients: Insights from Heart Failure: A Controlled Trial Investigating Outcomes of Exercise Training (HF-ACTION). Circ. Heart Fail. 2015, 8, 1044–1051. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  9. Jiang, W.; Liao, S.; Chen, X.; Lundborg, C.; Marrone, G.; Wen, Z.; Lu, W. TaiChi and Qigong for Depressive Symptoms in Patients with Chronic Heart Failure: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis. Evid. Based Complement. Alternat. Med. 2021, 2021, 5585239. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  10. Barrow, D.; Bedford, A.; Ives, G.; O’Toole, L.; Channer, K. An evaluation of the effects of Tai Chi Chuan and Chi Kung training in patients with symptomatic heart failure: A randomised controlled pilot study. Postgrad. Med. J. 2007, 83, 717–721. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  11. Caminiti, G.; Volterrani, M.; Marazzi, G.; Cerrito, A.; Massaro, R.; Arisi, A.; Franchini, A.; Sposato, B.; Rosano, G. Tai Chi enhances the effects of endurance training in the rehabilitation of elderly patients with chronic heart failure. Rehabil. Res. Pract. 2011, 2011, 1–6. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  12. Jiao, Y.; Wu, P.; Dong, X.; Yang, D. The effect of Baduanjin on the cardiac function and daily life of patients with chronic heart failure. J. Pract. Tradit. Chin. Med. 2020, 36, 1635–1636. [Google Scholar]
  13. Zhou, H.; Chen, Q. The effect of six-tips on cardiac function in patients with chronic heart failure. Yiayao Qianyan 2015, 5, 286–287. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  14. Yeh, G.; Wood, M.; Wayne, P.; Quilty, M.; Stevenson, L.; Davis, R.; Phillips, R.; Forman, D. Tai Chi in patients with heart failure with preserved ejection fraction. Congest. Heart Fail. 2013, 19, 77–84. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  15. Zhou, B.; Zhang, J.; Li, C.; Bai, Z. Effects of Taijiquan and cardiac rehabilitation exercise training on heart function, depression and sleep quality in patients with heart failure. J. Int. Psychiatry 2020, 47, 1016–1018, 1031. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  16. Zheng, L.; Zhang, C.; Wu, X.; Gao, A.; Li, H.; Wang, X. Influence of healthcare qigong-6-character formulas (Liuzijue) on heart function in patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. J. Evid.-Bases Cardiovasc. Med. 2017, 9, 656–662. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  17. Yang, X.; Huang, F.; Shi, Y.; Wang, Y.; Ye, L. The effect of traditional Chinese exercises on exercise tolerance in patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. J. Nurs. 2015, 50, 193–197. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  18. Yan, X. Effect of Six tips and Baduanjin training exercise on exercise tolerance in patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. Med. Mod. Distance Educ. China 2016, 14, 126–128. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  19. Xiong, X.; Deng, X. Observation on the therapeutic effect of Baduanjin on patients with chronic heart failure due to coronary heart disease. Mod. Med. J. China 2016, 18, 55–56. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  20. Moher, D.; Liberati, A.; Tetzlaff, J.; Altman, D.; PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. BMJ 2009, 339, b2535. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  21. Qinyi, B.; Shuxin, L.; Xiaojie, X. Effect of traditional Chinese exercises on cardiac rehabilitation in heart failure: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Inplasy Protoc. 2021, 202190027. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  22. Higgins, J.P.T.; Thomas, J.; Chandler, J.; Cumpston, M.; Li, T.; Page, M.J.; Welch, V.A. (Eds.) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 6.2 (Updated February 2021). Cochrane. 2021. Available online: www.training.cochrane.org/handbook (accessed on 28 February 2023).
  23. Wan, X.; Wang, W.; Liu, J.; Tong, T. Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from the sample size, median, range and/or interquartile range. BMC Med. Res. Methodol. 2014, 14, 135. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  24. Chen, D.-M.; Yu, W.-C.; Hung, H.-F.; Tsai, J.-C.; Wu, H.-Y.; Chiou, A.-F. The effects of Baduanjin exercise on fatigue and quality of life in patients with heart failure: A randomized controlled trial. Eur. J. Cardiovasc. Nurs. 2018, 17, 456–466. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  25. Ke, J.; Zhang, L.; Chen, B.; Qiu, F.; Fan, W.; Wei, Q. Effects of Baduanjin exercise on ventricular remodeling and cardiac function in patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. Med. Mod. Distance Educ. China 2020, 18, 74–76. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  26. Li, R. Observation on the effect of Baduanjin on cardiac function and quality of life in elderly patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. Manip. Rehabil. Med. 2017, 8, 23–25. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  27. Pan, W.; Zhou, H.; Wang, Y.; Zhou, Y.; He, H.; Lu, X.; Liu, L. Effect of Baduanjin in cardiac rehabilitation of patients with chronic heart failure. Guangming J. Chin. Med. 2019, 34, 3354–3356. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  28. Wei, D.; Liu, H. Effect of simplified Taijiquan exercise on improving cardiac function in patients with heart failure. Chin. J. Clin. Rehabil. 2003, 7, 1460. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  29. Yao, C.; Li, F.; Ma, Y. Effects of Shadow boxing on rehabilitation in patients with chronic heart Failure. Chin. J. Cardiovasc. Rehabil. Med. 2010, 19, 364–367. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  30. Yao, L.; Zhang, G. The effect of simple Baduanjin on Cardiac function and quality of Life in patients with chronic Heart failure. Yishou Baodian 2020, 69, 71. [Google Scholar]
  31. Ye, L.; Jin, J.; Yang, G.; Ying, Y. The effect of Baduanjin on cardiopulmonary function rehabilitation in patients with chronic heart failure. Zhejiang J. Tradit. Chin. Med. 2021, 56, 423. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  32. Yu, D.; Jiang, Z. Shadowboxing and Eight-section Brocade has effect on exercise tolerance and the quality of life of patients with chronic heart failure. J. New Chin. Med. 2019, 51, 274–277. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  33. Yu, J. Research on the effect of TCM calisthenics exercise on endurance in patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. Med. Mod. Distance Educ. China 2015, 13, 12–14. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  34. Yu, M.; Jiang, H.; Li, B.; Chai, L.; Shen, H.; Shi, F.; Xie, D.; Lin, X. Application of Tai Ji Quan exercise in heart rehabilitation for elderly patients with heart failure after myocardial infarction. Chin. J. Rehabil. Theory Pract. 2020, 26, 969–974. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  35. Zhang, Z. Effect of Taijiquan on cardiopulmonary function and aldosterone level in elderly patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. J. Conval. Med. 2021, 30, 956–958. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  36. Zhou, H.; Zheng, R.; Pan, W. The effect of Baduanjin on cardiac rehabilitation in patients with heart failure. Guangming J. Chin. Med. 2019, 34, 2248–2250. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  37. Yeh, G.; Wood, M.; Lorell, B.; Stevenson, L.; Eisenberg, D.; Wayne, P.; Goldberger, A.; Davis, R.; Phillips Russell, S. Effects of tai chi mind-body movement therapy on functional status and exercise capacity in patients with chronic heart failure: A randomized controlled trial. Am. J. Med. 2004, 117, 545–548. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  38. Yeh, G.; Mietus, J.; Peng, C.-K.; Phillips, R.; Davis, R.; Wayne, P.; Goldberger, A.; Thomas, R. Enhancement of sleep stability with Tai Chi exercise in chronic heart failure: Preliminary findings using an ECG-based spectrogram method. Sleep Med. 2008, 9, 527–536. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  39. Yeh, G.; McCarthy, E.; Wayne, P.; Stevenson, L.; Wood, M.; Forman, D.; Davis, R.; Phillips, R. Tai Chi exercise in patients with chronic heart failure: A randomized clinical trial. Arch. Intern. Med. 2011, 171, 750–757. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  40. Redwine, L.; Wilson, K.; Pung, M.; Chinh, K.; Rutledge, T.; Mills, P.; Smith, B. A randomized study examining the effects of mild-to-moderate group exercises on cardiovascular, physical, and psychological well-being in patients with heart failure. J. Cardiopulm. Rehabil. Prev. 2019, 39, 403–408. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  41. Hägglund, L.; Boman, K.; Brännström, M. A mixed methods study of Tai Chi exercise for patients with chronic heart failure aged 70 years and older. Nurs. Open 2018, 5, 176–185. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  42. Lu, H. Effect of sitting-style Ba Duan Jin on quality of life in patients with heart function III~IV stable heart failure. Cardiovasc. Dis. J. Integr. Tradit. Chin. West. Med. 2019, 7, 1–4. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  43. Xu, M. Effect of horizontal Baduanjin rehabilitation exercise on the quality of life in patients with heart function III~IV stable heart failure. Electron. J. Clin. Med. Lit. 2019, 6, 33–34. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  44. Yu, T.; Yang, H.; Yang, Z.; Duan, J. The influence of Tai Chi rehabilitation program with different training time on cardiac function of patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. J. Integr. Med. Cardio/Cerebrovasc. Dis. 2019, 17, 1772–1775. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  45. Deng, L.; Peng, X.; Wu, S.; Tian, D. Analysis of intervention effect of Baduanjin on patients with chronic heart failure. Shenzhen J. Integr. Tradit. Chin. West. Med. 2021, 31, 59–61. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  46. Kang, Z.; Liu, C.; Wang, Y.; Tao, H. Analysis of the effect of Baduanjin combined with aerobic endurance training on elderly patients with stable coronary heart disease complicated with chronic heart failure. Chin. J. Front. Med. Sci. (Electron. Version) 2021, 13, 39–42. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  47. Deng, X.; Yu, D.; Zhang, X. Effect of Taichi on heart function and psychological state in MI patients with heart insufficiency. J. North Sichuan Med. Coll. 2018, 33, 545–547. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  48. Pan, X. Effects of Tai Chi exercise on heart function and quality of life in patients with chronic heart failure. Chin. J. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2016, 38, 51. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  49. Sang, L.; Liu, Z.; Lang, F.; Tian, Y.; Zhang, H. Effect of Tai Chi rehabilitation exercises on heart function and quality of life in elderly patients with chronic heart failure of coronary heart disease. Chin. J. Gerontol. 2015, 35, 3957–3958. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  50. Zhou, Y.; Li, S.; Xia, W.; Liu, Y.; Cao, G.; Wu, K. Effect of Baduanjin exercise on cardiac function and quality of life in patients with heart failure after myocardial infarction. China Morden Med. 2021, 28, 73–75, 79. [Google Scholar]
  51. Metra, M.; Adamo, M.; Gardner, R.; Baumbach, A.; Butler, J.; Chioncel, O.; Cleland, J.; Coats, A.; Farmakis, D.; Gilard, M.; et al. 2021 ESC Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic heart failure. Eur. Heart J. 2021, 42, 3599–3726. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  52. Chen, Y.-W.; Hunt, M.; Campbell, K.; Peill, K.; Reid, W. The effect of Tai Chi on four chronic conditions—Cancer, osteoarthritis, heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A systematic review and meta-analyses. Br. J. Sports Med. 2016, 50, 397–407. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  53. Sang, L.; Liu, Z.; Tian, Y.; Lang, F.; Zhang, H. Effect of Tai Chi rehabilitation exercise on plasma angiotensin II and brain natriuretic peptide levels in elderly patients with chronic heart failure of coronary heart disease. Chin. J. Gerontol. 2015, 35, 4599–4600. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  54. Yang, H.; Yu, D.; Zhou, S.; Deng, X. Influence of Tai Chi rehabilitation exercise on cardiac function and blood lipid levels in aged CHF patient. Chin. J. Cardiovasc. Rehabil. Med. 2021, 30, 382–387. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  55. Li, C.; Yu, Y.; Fang, Y. Effect of exercise tolerance in patients with chronic heart failure exercise training. Nurs. Pract. Res. 2015, 12, 36–37. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  56. Yuan, L.; Zhang, H.; Zhou, F.; Xue, X.; Fang, S. Effect of Tai Chi on improvement of depression, sleeping quality and quality of life in elderly patients with chronic congestive heart failure complicated with depression. Guangxi Med. J. 2016, 38, 1547–1550. [Google Scholar]
  57. Taylor-Piliae, R.; Finley, B. Benefits of Tai Chi Exercise Among Adults with Chronic Heart Failure: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J. Cardiovasc. Nurs. 2020, 35, 423–434. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  58. Chen, X.; Savarese, G.; Cai, Y.; Ma, L.; Lundborg, C.; Jiang, W.; Wen, Z.; Lu, W.; Marrone, G. Tai Chi and Qigong Practices for Chronic Heart Failure: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Evid.-Based Complement. Altern. Med. 2020, 2020, 2034625. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  59. Pan, L.; Yan, J.; Guo, Y.; Yan, J. Effects of Tai Chi training on exercise capacity and quality of life in patients with chronic heart failure: A meta-analysis. Eur. J. Heart Fail. 2013, 15, 316–323. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  60. Hülsmann, M.; Quittan, M.; Berger, R.; Crevenna, R.; Springer, C.; Nuhr, M.; Mörtl, D.; Moser, P.; Pacher, R. Muscle strength as a predictor of long-term survival in severe congestive heart failure. Eur. J. Heart Fail. 2004, 6, 101–107. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  61. Keteyian, S.; Patel, M.; Kraus, W.; Brawner, C.; McConnell, T.; Piña, I.; Leifer, E.; Fleg, J.; Blackburn, G.; Fonarow, G.; et al. HF-ACTION Investigators, Variables Measured During Cardiopulmonary Exercise Testing as Predictors of Mortality in Chronic Systolic Heart Failure. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2016, 67, 780–789. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  62. Bjarnason-Wehrens, B.; Nebel, R.; Jensen, K.; Hackbusch, M.; Grilli, M.; Gielen, S.; Schwaab, B.; Rauch, B. for the German Society of Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation (DGPR), Exercise-based cardiac rehabilitation in patients with reduced left ventricular ejection fraction: The Cardiac Rehabilitation Outcome Study in Heart Failure (CROS-HF): A systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur. J. Prev. Cardiolog. 2020, 27, 929–952. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  63. Ren, X.; Li, Y.; Yang, X.; Li, J.; Li, H.; Yuan, Z.; Sun, Y.; Shang, H.; Xing, Y.; Gao, Y. The Effects of Tai Chi Training in Patients with Heart Failure: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Front. Physiol. 2017, 8, 989. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  64. Ge, L.; Zheng, Q.-X.; Liao, Y.-T.; Tan, J.-Y.; Xie, Q.-L.; Rask, M. Effects of traditional Chinese exercises on the rehabilitation of limb function among stroke patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement. Ther. Clin. Pract. 2017, 29, 35–47. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  65. Demopoulos, L.; Bijou, R.; Fergus, I.; Jones, M.; Strom, J.; LeJemtel, T. Exercise training in patients with severe congestive heart failure: Enhancing peak aerobic capacity while minimizing the increase in ventricular wall stress. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 1997, 29, 597–603. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  66. Coats, A.; Adamopoulos, S.; Radaelli, A.; McCance, A.; Meyer, T.; Bernardi, L.; Solda, P.; Davey, P.; Ormerod, O.; Forfar, C. Controlled trial of physical training in chronic heart failure. Exercise performance, hemodynamics, ventilation, and autonomic function. Circulation 1992, 85, 2119–2131. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed] [Green Version]
  67. Xu, S.; Zhang, D.; He, Q.; Ma, C.; Ye, S.; Ge, L.; Zhang, L.; Liu, W.; Chen, Z.; Zhou, L. Efficacy of Liuzijue Qigong in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Complement. Ther. Med. 2022, 65, 102809. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  68. Hamasaki, H. Effects of Diaphragmatic Breathing on Health: A Narrative Review. Medicines 2020, 7, E65. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  69. Wang, X.; Huang, L.; Liu, Y.; Li, J.; Wu, X.; Li, H.; Wang, L. Effects of Tai Chi Program on Neuromuscular Function for Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis: Study Protocol for a Randomized Controlled Trial. Trials 2013, 14, 375. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Green Version]
  70. Xue, X.; Jin, X.-M.; Luo, K.-L.; Liu, X.-H.; Zhang, L.; Hu, J. Effectiveness of Yijinjing on cognitive functions in post-stroke patients with mild cognitive impairment: Study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials 2021, 22, 265. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  71. Song, J.; Liu, Z.; Huang, J.; Wu, J.; Tao, J. Effects of Aerobic Exercise, Traditional Chinese Exercises, and Meditation on Depressive Symptoms of College Student: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Medicine 2021, 100, e23819. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
  72. Lan, C.; Lai, J.-S.; Chen, S.-Y. Tai Chi Chuan: An ancient wisdom on exercise and health promotion. Sports Med. 2002, 32, 217–224. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  73. Wu, G. Evaluation of the effectiveness of Tai Chi for improving balance and preventing falls in the older population—A review. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 2002, 50, 746–754. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  74. Belardinelli, R.; Georgiou, D.; Cianci, G.; Purcaro, A. 10-Year Exercise Training in Chronic Heart Failure. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 2012, 60, 1521–1528. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
  75. Liang, C.; Gao, C.; Zhang, J.; Ye, Q.; Zhai, L.; Zhao, F.; Ma, Y. Traditional Chinese Medicine Training for Cardiac Rehabilitation: A Randomized Comparison with Aerobic and Resistance Training. Coron. Artery Dis. 2019, 30, 360–366. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
Jcm 12 02150 g001 550
Figure 1. PRISMA flow chart of studies through the review. CNKI: the China National Knowledge Infrastructure; HF: heart failure; RCT: randomized controlled trial; PRISMA: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses.
Figure 1. PRISMA flow chart of studies through the review. CNKI: the China National Knowledge Infrastructure; HF: heart failure; RCT: randomized controlled trial; PRISMA: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses.
Jcm 12 02150 g001
Jcm 12 02150 g002 550
Figure 2. Forest plot for the effect of TCE on patients with CHF: (A) 6-min walk distance (6MWD) [11,12,13,14,16,17,18,19,26,27,29,32,33,34,36,37,38,39,41,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52], (B) peak oxygen consumption (peak VO2) [14,31,37,39], (C) left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) [12,14,15,16,19,25,27,28,29,30,32,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,53]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; CHF—chronic heart failure; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Figure 2. Forest plot for the effect of TCE on patients with CHF: (A) 6-min walk distance (6MWD) [11,12,13,14,16,17,18,19,26,27,29,32,33,34,36,37,38,39,41,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52], (B) peak oxygen consumption (peak VO2) [14,31,37,39], (C) left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) [12,14,15,16,19,25,27,28,29,30,32,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,53]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; CHF—chronic heart failure; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Jcm 12 02150 g002
Jcm 12 02150 g003 550
Figure 3. Forest plot of meta-analysis in other effects of TCE on patients with CHF: (A) B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP) [14,17,18,34,37,39,44,45,48,53,55], (B) N-terminal pro-B natriuretic peptide (NT-proBNP) [11,12,16,19,27,41,46,47,54], (C) Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire (MLHFQ) [10,12,14,15,16,19,24,26,29,31,34,37,38,39,42,43,46,49,56]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; CHF—chronic heart failure; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Figure 3. Forest plot of meta-analysis in other effects of TCE on patients with CHF: (A) B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP) [14,17,18,34,37,39,44,45,48,53,55], (B) N-terminal pro-B natriuretic peptide (NT-proBNP) [11,12,16,19,27,41,46,47,54], (C) Minnesota Living with Heart Failure Questionnaire (MLHFQ) [10,12,14,15,16,19,24,26,29,31,34,37,38,39,42,43,46,49,56]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; CHF—chronic heart failure; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Jcm 12 02150 g003
Jcm 12 02150 g004 550
Figure 4. Forest plot for the subgroup analysis of TCE types on 6MWD: (A) Tai Chi [29,34,37,38,39,41,47,48,49,54]; (B) Bauduanjin [12,19,50]; (C) Liuzijue [13,16]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; 6MWD—6-min walk distance; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Figure 4. Forest plot for the subgroup analysis of TCE types on 6MWD: (A) Tai Chi [29,34,37,38,39,41,47,48,49,54]; (B) Bauduanjin [12,19,50]; (C) Liuzijue [13,16]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; 6MWD—6-min walk distance; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Jcm 12 02150 g004
Jcm 12 02150 g005 550
Figure 5. Forest plot for the subgroup analysis of TCE weekly duration and program duration on 6MWD: (A) weekly duration [12,13,17,18,29,33,34,47,48,54,55], (B) program duration [16,19,32,37,38,39,41,49,50]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; 6MWD—6-min walk distance; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Figure 5. Forest plot for the subgroup analysis of TCE weekly duration and program duration on 6MWD: (A) weekly duration [12,13,17,18,29,33,34,47,48,54,55], (B) program duration [16,19,32,37,38,39,41,49,50]. TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; 6MWD—6-min walk distance; CTL—control; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Jcm 12 02150 g005
Jcm 12 02150 g006 550
Figure 6. Forest plot for the subgroup analysis of exercise program on patients with CHF on 6MWD: (A) TCE compared with usual care [12,13,16,17,18,19,29,32,33,34,37,38,39,41,47,48,49,50,54,55], (B) TCE compared with conventional aerobic exercise [14,26,27,36,43,44,45], (C) TCE and conventional aerobic exercise compared with conventional aerobic exercise [11,46]. CHF—chronic heart failure; 6MWD—6-min walk distance; TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; CTL—control; UC—usual care; AE—aerobic exercise; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Figure 6. Forest plot for the subgroup analysis of exercise program on patients with CHF on 6MWD: (A) TCE compared with usual care [12,13,16,17,18,19,29,32,33,34,37,38,39,41,47,48,49,50,54,55], (B) TCE compared with conventional aerobic exercise [14,26,27,36,43,44,45], (C) TCE and conventional aerobic exercise compared with conventional aerobic exercise [11,46]. CHF—chronic heart failure; 6MWD—6-min walk distance; TCE—traditional Chinese exercises; CTL—control; UC—usual care; AE—aerobic exercise; SD—standard deviation; CI—confidence interval. The green square represents the point estimate of each study. The size of the square represents the “weight” of the study. The black rhombus represents the pooled effect estimates and CI from all studies included in the meta-analysis.
Jcm 12 02150 g006
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Share and Cite

MDPI and ACS Style

Bao, Q.; Lei, S.; Guo, S.; Wang, Z.; Yu, J.; You, Y.; Zhang, N.; Xie, X. Effect of Traditional Chinese Exercises on Patients with Chronic Heart Failure (TCE-HF): A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J. Clin. Med. 2023, 12, 2150. https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm12062150

AMA Style

Bao Q, Lei S, Guo S, Wang Z, Yu J, You Y, Zhang N, Xie X. Effect of Traditional Chinese Exercises on Patients with Chronic Heart Failure (TCE-HF): A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Journal of Clinical Medicine. 2023; 12(6):2150. https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm12062150

Chicago/Turabian Style

Bao, Qinyi, Shuxin Lei, Shitian Guo, Zhuo Wang, Jiaye Yu, Yayu You, Ning Zhang, and Xiaojie Xie. 2023. "Effect of Traditional Chinese Exercises on Patients with Chronic Heart Failure (TCE-HF): A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis" Journal of Clinical Medicine 12, no. 6: 2150. https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm12062150

APA Style

Bao, Q., Lei, S., Guo, S., Wang, Z., Yu, J., You, Y., Zhang, N., & Xie, X. (2023). Effect of Traditional Chinese Exercises on Patients with Chronic Heart Failure (TCE-HF): A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Journal of Clinical Medicine, 12(6), 2150. https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm12062150

Note that from the first issue of 2016, this journal uses article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Article Metrics

Back to TopTop