1. Introduction
Analog switches, with their advantages of easy integration and isolation properties, are widely used for voltage and current signal transmission. In recent years, they have found extensive applications across various fields, including clinical ultrasound imaging systems, power management systems, motor drivers, battery management systems, and automatic testing systems [
1,
2,
3,
4].
In the design and application of electronic systems, switches serve as one of the core components of circuits, with their performance and characteristics directly influencing the efficiency and accuracy of signal processing. Particularly, switches that are structurally similar to low-voltage analog switches are widely utilized for signal path selection and switching due to their unique performance advantages. It is noteworthy that the variation range of analog signals is a critical parameter in practical operations, requiring strict control within the voltage limits that MOS transistors can endure to ensure the circuit’s stable operation and long-term reliability. Consequently, the introduction of high-voltage analog switches has become a crucial solution [
5,
6]. These switches significantly enhance the circuit’s adaptability to complex signal environments by expanding the voltage range for signal processing, thus providing robust support for the high-performance operation of electronic systems [
7,
8,
9,
10].
The high-voltage analog switch control circuit proposed in this paper is designed for PCB board automatic test equipment (ATE). The typical measurement scenario for PCB ATE systems is shown in
Figure 1, where the number of test probes connected to the device under test (DUT) can range from hundreds to thousands, and each probe requires two switches. Hence, in practical applications, the widespread deployment of high-voltage analog switch ICs, predominantly employed as signal transmission gateways to individual transducers or for discrete operational purposes, often involves thousands of units that must be independently managed. This vast array of switches inherently poses formidable challenges related to power consumption and space utilization, necessitating innovative strategies for effectively controlling and optimizing their high-voltage operation. Orchestrating seamless control of high-voltage analog switches with stringent power efficiency constraints, purely via electronic methodologies, holds paramount importance for the viable implementation of this circuitry in real-world settings. This endeavor necessitates a holistic approach that meticulously accounts for every switch attribute that could potentially impact the precision of ATE (automatic test equipment) measurements, ensuring that accuracy remains paramount amidst the complexity.
The innovative high-voltage analog switch control circuit, which we introduce in this paper, is ingeniously crafted atop the robust SOI (silicon on insulator) technology platform [
11,
12,
13]. This strategic foundation not only shuns the specter of latch-up effects but also bolsters the circuit’s resilience and reliability [
14,
15,
16]. By leveraging the exceptional high-voltage tolerance inherently possessed by the drain–source junction of the SJ-MOS (Super Junction MOSFET) transistor, our design enables a safely tolerable voltage differential of up to 300 V across the two data transmission terminals of the analog switch. This capability significantly expands the circuit’s operational envelope, catering to a wider range of demanding applications.
Moreover, cognizant of the pressing need for minimal power consumption in practical applications, we have devised a gate-source voltage control mechanism for the high-voltage analog switch that operates with unparalleled energy efficiency. This breakthrough addresses the long-standing challenge of isolating control logic from transmission signals in conventional designs, thereby enhancing signal integrity and reducing crosstalk. The result is a circuit that guarantees unparalleled transmission accuracy, coupled with exceptional circuit reliability, making it an ideal candidate for integration into a myriad of precision-critical systems and applications.
2. Traditional High-Voltage Analog Switch
Traditional high-voltage analog switches, as indispensable core control components in electronic devices, have a fundamental mission of precisely switching and effectively isolating signals under high-voltage environments. In particular, high-voltage analog switches based on solid-state relay (SSR) architecture have emerged as the preferred solution for scenarios requiring stringent high-voltage withstand capabilities, leveraging their unique advantages of no mechanical contacts, ultra-long service life, and exceptional reliability. These switches elegantly employ a pair of vertically mirrored NMOS transistors (such as LDMOS) with superior high-voltage tolerance, enabling flexible switching and precise control of the switch’s state through meticulous regulation of the transistors’ gate-source voltages [
17].
However, despite the numerous attractive advantages presented by this design concept in theory, traditional high-voltage analog switch circuits still face non-negligible challenges in practical applications. A primary challenge lies in maintaining the stability of the gate-source voltage, which serves as the cornerstone for ensuring stable switch operation. Unfortunately, fluctuations in input signals directly impact the voltage at the shared source of the two MOS transistors, subsequently causing variations in the gate-source voltage. This not only affects the switch’s conduction efficiency but also potentially threatens the safety margins of the MOS transistors’ voltage withstand capabilities.
To overcome this challenge, designers have to construct complex control circuits that dynamically adjust the gate voltage within safe limits, undoubtedly increasing circuit design complexity and manufacturing costs. Moreover, to achieve both high voltage withstand and stable performance, traditional high-voltage analog switches often necessitate the selection of high-quality components and intricate circuit layouts, further escalating product costs and posing significant challenges for subsequent maintenance and repair work.
For bidirectional high-voltage analog switches catering to high-voltage withstand requirements, the current mainstream adopts the SSR structure, centered on a pair of carefully designed, vertically symmetric, and high-voltage-tolerant NMOS transistors (e.g., LDMOS). During signal transmission, ensuring the stability of the gate-source voltage to maintain the switch’s conduction state and prevent voltage excursions beyond process limits emerges as a central challenge in circuit design.
Although there are various implementation approaches for traditional high-voltage analog switch control circuits, each method is accompanied by non-negligible defects, posing numerous challenges in practical applications. For instance, one of the traditional control methods demonstrated in
Figure 2 achieves physical isolation between the control circuit and the switch body through optocouplers, thereby establishing comprehensive electrical isolation between low-power input and high-power output circuits. While this solution effectively isolates the circuits, the complexity of optical components poses challenges to circuit design, not only elevating design difficulty but also reducing integration, as well as increasing the complexity and cost of system design.
On the path of pursuing integration optimization, we have to turn to pure circuit strategies to achieve precise control of high-voltage switches. As shown in
Figure 3, a gate-source voltage maintaining circuit based on Zener diodes has been proposed and applied in practice [
18]. However, the limitation of this method lies in the inherent current demand of Zener diodes, which inevitably introduces the challenge of current leakage [
19]. This not only disturbs the purity of analog signals in the control module but also, during drastic dynamic signal changes, may couple the analog signals back to the control loop, thereby weakening the overall system performance.
To overcome this bottleneck, researchers have taken an alternative path by leveraging the exceptional voltage endurance between gate and source exhibited by field MOS. Through meticulous adjustment of the oxide layer thickness beneath the gate, they successfully developed field MOS devices capable of enduring gate-source voltage differences as high as 300 V [
20,
21], as depicted in
Figure 4. This innovation has extended the analog switch architecture originally designed for low-voltage environments into the high-voltage domain. Nonetheless, amidst the excitement, challenges must be addressed: While field MOS boasts superior voltage endurance, its relatively high on-state resistance compels designers to increase chip area to reduce resistance, exacerbating parasitic capacitance accumulation and subsequently slowing down switching speeds. Furthermore, during turn-off instants, the issue of DC leakage in the common source discharge path becomes particularly pronounced due to limited response speeds.
Given these technical bottlenecks, we urgently need a gate drive solution that can dynamically track changes in source voltage to ensure a constant gate-source voltage, catering to the stringent requirements of high-voltage operating environments. Additionally, considering the critical role of MOS transistors in this scenario, the optimization of their drain-source voltage withstand capabilities, on-resistance, and parasitic capacitance becomes a core consideration in design. After comprehensive consideration of various factors, we have decided to employ SOI (silicon-on-insulator) technology to realize this design. This technology, through oxide buried layers and deep trench isolation techniques, minimizes area while ensuring dual advantages of high breakdown voltage and low leakage current, effectively avoiding the potential latch-up effect in traditional CMOS processes.
However, it is worth noting that despite the numerous advantages offered by SOI technology, it does not inherently achieve high voltage withstand between the gate and source. Therefore, the issue of gate-source voltage withstand must be taken into account during design, as SOI technology itself does not directly address this challenge. Consequently, we must replan and design aspects such as circuit layout, material selection, and process parameter adjustment, aiming to further enhance the performance and reliability of the overall circuit while maintaining high-voltage stability.
3. Voltage Holding Structure for Analog Switch Control
The gate drive circuit proposed in this paper for maintaining the gate-source voltage uses SJ-MOS based on SOI technology. It achieves high-voltage analog switch gate-source voltage holding under low gate-source voltage withstand conditions without relying on Zener diodes, avoiding DC leakage.
As depicted in
Figure 5, the proposed gate-source voltage holding circuit includes a high-voltage analog switch and its turn-on and turn-off control circuits. The control signals 1 and 2 are a pair of in-phase control signals generated by a level shifter, with control signal 1 having a logic high of VPP and a logic low of VPP-5V, while control signal 2 has a logic high of 0 V and a logic low of VNN. The Zener diode in the circuit does not work during the switch-on process and is only used for protection.
3.1. Switch-On Control
For the switch-on control part, MP1 and MP2 form a current mirror, and MP3 and MP4 control the circuit operation. When control signal 1 is at a logic low level, the common source potential VCS of the analog switch MOS transistor is sampled through the MP6 source follower, and the forward conduction voltage drop VD of the diode is utilized to achieve voltage boosting. The voltages at nodes
V1 and
V2 are obtained, and their values are determined through calculations based on the threshold voltage of SJ-PMOS:
When the common gate voltage VCG of the analog switch MOS transistor is lower than
V2 by a threshold voltage of SJ-NMOS, the current mirror charges the capacitor C1 through MN1. Similarly, when VCG is higher than
V1 by a threshold voltage of SJ-PMOS, C1 discharges through MP5. Therefore, the upper and lower limits of
VCG are:
where
is the threshold voltage of SJ-PMOS and
is the threshold voltage of SJ-NMOS
Under the SOI process, is about 0.8 V, is about 1.3 V, and is about 0.8 V. The expected gate-source voltage limits are . According to the conduction characteristics of SJ-MOS, the on-resistance remains constant when the gate-source voltage exceeds a certain value (about 3 V). Therefore, fluctuations within this range will not cause nonlinear effects on signal transmission.
3.2. Switch-Off Control
For the switch-off control part, MN5 and MN6 form a current mirror, and MN3 and MN4 control the circuit operation. When the gate-source voltage of SJ-MOS is less than 1 V, it can be considered completely off. When control signal 2 is high, the common gate and source of the switch MOS transistor discharge to VNN (−5 V power supply) through MN5 and MN6, reducing the gate-source voltage below the off threshold, achieving switch-off. Additionally, applying a fixed potential to the common source during switch-off can further improve isolation performance.
The switch-off process includes two states: gate-source voltage reduction to switch-off and discharge of the common gate and source. The size of MN6 is larger than MN5, ensuring that the common gate voltage drops faster than the common source during switch-off, allowing the gate-source voltage to quickly drop below the conduction threshold. When the gate-source voltage is below the conduction threshold, the switch is off, but the common gate and source still contain significant charges. From switch-off to discharge, the Zener diode protects against reverse bias voltage during discharge.
3.3. Simplified Application Diagram: Four-Wire Measurement
This paper employs the four-wire resistance measurement method to evaluate the device under test (DUT), with the circuit application diagram being depicted in
Figure 6. This diagram illustrates how the four-wire measurement is performed utilizing four probes, with switches PF1, NF2, PS3, and NS4 in the conductive (ON) state and the corresponding switches NF1, PF2, NS3, and PS4 in the non-conductive (OFF) state. The resistance calculation equation of the DUT is as follows:
where
dV represents the voltage difference across the device under test (DUT), and
Im is the current flowing through the DUT.
The four-wire resistance measurement method, also known as Kelvin resistance measurement, is a resistance measurement technique specifically designed for high precision and stability. This method ingeniously utilizes four wires to construct the measurement system, with two wires dedicated to injecting a constant current into the resistance under test (current-carrying wires), ensuring a stable and undisturbed current flow. The other two wires precisely capture the voltage drop across the resistance due to the flowing current (voltage-sensing wires), achieving a complete separation between current supply and voltage detection. The essence of this design lies in effectively eliminating interference factors that may be introduced during the test process, such as contact resistance and lead resistance, significantly enhancing measurement accuracy, particularly adept at capturing minute resistance value changes ranging from a few milliohms to several hundred ohms [
22]. Additionally, the four-wire method demonstrates outstanding resistance to external interferences, including temperature variations and electromagnetic interferences, which are effectively suppressed, thereby ensuring the stability and reliability of measurement results. As a result, it has become an indispensable high-precision resistance measurement tool in fields such as scientific research and industrial inspection.
5. Conclusions
This paper proposes a high-voltage analog switch and its control circuit, which adopts a current-mode controlled gate-source voltage-maintaining circuit based on the 0.18 μm SOI process to achieve stable control of the gate-source voltage of the analog switch MOS transistor under low gate-source voltage withstand conditions. The simulation results exhibited optimal isolation across the entire frequency range displayed, with the worst-case scenario exhibiting −72 dB at 10 MHz. Furthermore, even when operating at 10 MHz, the gate-source voltage consistently remained within the range of 4.5 V to 5 V.
Additionally, based on the SOI process, the contradiction between the internal resistance and area of the high-voltage analog switch is resolved, achieving a 24 Ω low on-resistance, fast response, and a high-voltage analog switch with a 300 V withstand voltage range. Despite a 6% deviation between the simulated and tested results of on-resistance, which is attributed to the cumulative effects of precision limitations in manufacturing equipment (such as photolithography machines, etching machines, and ion implantation machines) and precise control of parameters (including temperature, pressure, and time) during the chip manufacturing process, we have confirmed that the IC developed in this paper features a simple structure and stability, rendering it suitable for automated test equipment (ATE) on PCB boards and other high-voltage signal transmission applications.