1. Introduction
Climate change is leading to an increase in the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events such as floods, heat waves (HW), droughts, and extreme rainfall [
1]. An increase in the frequency of overheating in buildings is one of the major projected effects of climate change on the built environment [
2]. Undoubtedly, one of the biggest risks is also the wide range of ill health effects and worsening of allergies when exposed to extreme temperatures [
3].
Figure 1 depicts the various impacts of climate change and the vulnerable population most affected by it. Categorically, children with developing physiologies and underdeveloped internal coping capabilities may be more vulnerable to these impacts [
3,
4]. Children’s health is not only significantly threatened by climate change but it also has a serious impact on their academic performance [
5]. “As the effects of climate change intensify, children in the tropics will face additional barriers to education” [
6].
Favorable learning environments are crucial, especially in light of the cascading impact that educational outcomes have on people’s future earning potential [
7]. Since the classroom is the anchor of students’ daily lives, it is crucial to comprehend and utilize the physical environment in which they study and learn in order to achieve optimal learning results. According to previous studies [
8], unfavorable comfort conditions in schools, such as higher temperatures, disruptive noise, inadequate lighting, and a higher occupant density in classrooms, can have a poor impact on kids’ academic performance as well as lead to health issues. Numerous studies have focused on the critical significance that Indoor Environmental Quality (IEQ) plays in primary school classrooms [
9,
10,
11,
12]. Focusing on the thermal comfort of students in a classroom, Jiang et al. [
13] highlighted the impact of thermal comfort on students’ test performance as well as the impact on their health. The effects of classroom indoor temperature on the academic performance of 10 to 12-year-old pupils’ regular schoolwork were examined by Wargocki et al. [
14]. The results showed that the students’ performance on assessments based on language and mathematics significantly improved when the temperature was lowered from 25 °C to 20 °C.
Research indicates that students’ health is negatively impacted by excessive heat, which inevitably affects their learning outcomes [
5,
15,
16]. The consequences of heat on cognitive development are anticipated to be more severe in countries such as India where temperatures and levels of poverty are both high [
17]. Further, as reported by [
6], exposure to excessive heat may make it more difficult for students to complete their secondary education in tropical regions of the world (such as India). An American student typically spends about 12 school days above 32 °C (90 °F) each year, whereas an average Indian student spends more than 100 such days annually [
17]. According to the Global Climate Risk Index, India stands tenth in the category of the most climate-affected countries in the world for 2022, with an average of 114 days of heat wave conditions recorded each year [
18]. Conforming to a Met Department analysis, India is experiencing an increase in heat wave days every 10 years [
19]. The research reveals that, mostly in inland locations, the number of days with exceptionally high temperatures is progressively increasing, going from 413 in 1981–1990 to 575 in 2001–2010 and 600 in 2011–2020 [
19].
India will experience more frequent and hotter heat waves in the future due to global warming, according to the World Weather Attribution [
20]. Considering that the majority of the nation—more than 90%—could experience severe heat waves and enter an extreme heat “danger” zone [
21], it is imperative to examine in detail the physical conditions that students in hot climatic regions are exposed to as heat waves are slotted to become more frequent and prolonged. Children’s heat risk is a pressing concern with such a high-temperature threat. According to previous studies [
22,
23,
24], children are more susceptible and vulnerable to heat-related illnesses since their bodies do not acclimatize to the heat as well as adults do. They also tend to not sweat as effectively and absorb more heat as compared to adults because of their smaller bodies and a higher ratio of surface area to body mass [
25,
26]. Along with adverse ramifications on students’ academic performance and learning capacity, prolonged exposure to hot environments can also bring about health symptoms of exhaustion and dehydration.
The majority of schools in India rely on natural ventilation when temperatures are high. Windows and doors may be kept open for cross ventilation, and almost all schools provide ceiling fans. However, due to limited infrastructure and financial restrictions, installing mechanical systems or the provision of air conditioners is not an option. In addition, on many occasions, due to power disruptions and load shedding, the use of electric fans in classrooms is restricted. Further, there are many students—about 35 to 40—in a rather small classroom (16 to 20 square meters), which can occasionally result in overcrowding. These factors, along with hot ambient temperature (particularly during heat waves), can make classrooms in primary schools feel uncomfortably warm. Therefore, to help mitigate the challenges of hot days and enable children to cope with hot temperatures in classrooms, a few measures are prescribed by schools, such as recommending schools to start earlier (7 A.M.) and end before noon while also limiting the number of schools hours; relaxing school uniform (discouraging neckties) and wearing canvas shoes instead of leather shoes; limiting outdoor activities, etc. While these measures may help in minimizing the threats caused by high temperatures to primary school students, the impact of heat disruption on learning and students’ performance must be studied further.
Understanding children’s responses to weather conditions and environmental changes can have a significant impact on teaching and learning, as well as behavioral concerns and parenting, in addition to health [
27]. Remarkably, research correlating the climate to effective and behavioral aspects in children is very limited [
27,
28]. Particularly in the setting of Indian classrooms, to date, there are insufficient studies on how heat stress and risks affect children. Under these circumstances, to better understand the connection between heat waves and children’s health in primary schools, a questionnaire survey was conducted by inquiring teachers about their observations and experiences with students during the hot summer school days. The survey offers a new perspective and highlights the challenges of heat stress and discomfort on students inside their classrooms.
2. Outline of Field Survey
In the month of February 2020, a questionnaire survey of primary school teachers was carried out, covering 35 elementary schools in seven Indian cities in hot climate regions. The cities were Delhi, Jaipur, Ajmer, Vadodara, Udaipur, Ahmedabad, and Pune. These cities were specifically chosen since heat waves generally occur over the plains of central and northwest India [
29].
Figure 2 illustrates where these cities are in relation to one another. The highest temperatures have consistently exceeded 40 °C for several days, especially over central and western parts of India.
Schools belonging to hot and dry climatic regions were chosen for the survey because these areas typically experience heat waves with temperatures hitting between a maximum of 45 °C and 50 °C. The survey’s specifics are displayed in
Table 1, together with information about the school’s location, its average maximum temperature, and the number of teachers who took part in the surveys. The 35 primary schools were a combination of both privately funded and government-supported institutions. None of the primary schools had air conditioning, and all of the classrooms were naturally ventilated with provisions of ceiling fans.
School authorities were approached via email after a preliminary introduction through coworkers and friends who worked at the relevant primary schools. After receiving formal approval from the school administration, survey dates were scheduled and schools were visited. Primary school teachers were requested to cooperate with the survey by the school administration. Teachers answered the questionnaire after their teaching session, or during their free classes to discourage class interruptions.
A total of 335 primary school teachers from seven cities participated in the questionnaire survey. The majority (58%) of the respondents were male teachers and 56% were in the age bracket of 30–40 years. A detailed distribution of teachers by age and gender is shown in
Figure 3.
The questionnaire comprised 37 questions about the teachers’ perspectives and observations on the illnesses and discomfort of students caused by heat inside the classrooms during the summer months. The questionnaire was translated into Hindi too, in the event that the teachers were less comfortable with English questions. The objective of the survey was to elucidate further the numerous negative impacts of heat waves and extremely hot classrooms on students’ overall health and academic performance.
Table 2 exhibits the various sections and details of the questions included in the survey. The paper-based survey contained questions that were designed as multiple choice questions (MCQ). The questionnaire also used a five-point Likert scale (1 = Strongly disagree to 5 = Strongly agree) to rate various thermal conditions. The surveys lasted 15 min maximum, and a few teachers further elaborated in the form of short interviews about the current conditions during summer months inside their classrooms.
Figure 4 shows teachers filling in the questionnaire.
4. Discussion
This study examined the direct and indirect effects of climate change, particularly heat waves, on Indian primary school students’ health, learning, and overall well-being. The findings of the current survey serve as a crucial first step in developing and implementing evaluation criteria for heat preparedness in primary schools.
It is worth noting that due to a lack of adequate cooling measures at home, children continue to be exposed to hot environments despite returning home after complaints of heat-related sicknesses. Vulnerable communities that lack access to or cannot afford air conditioning are particularly at risk due to this particular problem [
54]. Therefore, installing ACs in primary schools can be seen as a way to improve student learning outcomes and foster the best possible learning environment. Additionally, air-conditioned schools can provide temporary cooling places for vulnerable populations during heat waves, similar to certain European cities where air-conditioned public buildings can be used as evacuation centers or climate shelters. This is an important factor to take into consideration given the frequency and severity of extreme weather events around the world.
However, implementing such solutions within Indian contexts poses various challenges. There are funding limitations and maintenance expenses that prevent institutions from investing sufficient resources [
55]. The installation cost of an AC system is high and ongoing maintenance expenses add up over time. Additionally, power outages prevalent in many parts of India could further undermine the viability of AC systems. Moreover, cultural factors may pose significant challenges to implementing these solutions within Indian society. Therefore, more research is required on effective strategies for implementing such solutions within the Indian context while addressing various challenges such as costs, infrastructure requirements, and cultural factors.
Further, in this study, we focused on primary schools in the hot climatic region of India, and our findings provide valuable insights into the impacts of heat waves on children in this specific context. Moving forward, expanding the scope of our research to include kindergarten and secondary schools, along with elaborate surveys in different contexts (socioeconomic factors, and infrastructural conditions), and climatic regions will provide a better understanding to the specific vulnerabilities of children during heat waves.
6. Conclusions
The profound impact of climate change on children, particularly in developing countries such as India, poses a significant threat to children’s vulnerabilities and impedes their future development significantly. While various field surveys have investigated the indoor thermal environment in classrooms and children’s perceptions of temperature, the majority of them have primarily focused on determining the range of thermal comfort, rather than assessing the risks associated with excessive heat. There is a noticeable absence of quantitative research and longitudinal studies on children in primary schools and hot classrooms, restricting a clearer understanding to comprehend the effects of climate change on children’s well-being and health. To address these gaps, a field survey among primary school teachers was conducted to gain insights into children’s experiences with heat waves within their classrooms, as well as their susceptibility to heat exposure and potential health impacts. The results from the questionnaire contribute to an understanding of the challenges associated with heat discomfort for both students and teachers in classrooms.
According to the questionnaire surveys, primary school teachers agreed that students are significantly exposed to heat waves throughout the summer months. 96% of the teachers reported being sick and having their teaching work hindered by the excessive heat. 100% agree that as the temperature increased, the number of students who reported feeling sick also escalated. During the heat wave conditions, 74% of teachers characterized the indoor environment within their classrooms as uncomfortably hot and very hot, revealing that 96% of these times, at least 3–10 students have left school early due to heat exhaustion, while complaining of being drowsy, lethargic, and experiencing fatigue. The findings are consistent with studies that children are found to be considerably more susceptible to heat than the average population [
56]. In view of the fact that heat-related illnesses and symptoms are potentially a problem especially in schools with limited resources where providing air conditioners are not possible; and the limited awareness of ‘Guidelines for Prevention and Management of Heat Wave’ (82% of teachers were unaware), it is essential to educate students, parents and school faculties equally about the threat of heat waves and explain the undermining risks associated with it.