1. Introduction
In recent decades, pollution of the planet’s water resources has become increasingly threatening. This situation is mainly related to human activity, which lead to the fact that a significant amount of pollutants enters aquatic ecosystems, and subsequent resuspension, caused by natural or human-made situations contributes to secondary pollution. All this negatively affects the production and destruction processes in aquatic ecosystems. The study of the natural mechanisms of hydrodynamic processes, taking into account the variability of meteorological conditions, makes it possible to choose a strategy to minimize damage from water pollution or prevent pollution of the aquatic ecosystem.
In the Russian Federation, scientific research on the creation and research of complex marine systems mathematical models has more than half a century history. Many scientists actively researched the issue of optimal exploitation of water resources, the development of models for the transport of contaminants in water bodies and the study of assessing their impact on the biological resources of a water body. In the work of Matishov G.G. [
1], the water exchange between the Black and Azov seas on the basis of long-term ship observations of the Azov–Black Sea basin is being investigated. In the work of Ilyichev V.G., the evolutionary stable characteristics of the Azov Sea are investigated with variations in the flow of the Don River [
2]. The development and research of basic spatially heterogeneous pollutant transport mathematical models of a continuous type for different types of pollutant sources, including areal, point and linear, in terms of action—instantaneous and continuous, are described in the article by Berlyand M.E. [
3].
Despite a significant number of publications, many effects related to spatial heterogeneity of the environment, interspecies interaction, hydrodynamic characteristics of the environment, temperature and oxygen conditions, salinity, and other characteristics were not included in the models of the hydrobiological processes of the reservoir. Accounting for these effects can make a significant contribution to improving the accuracy of forecasts of dangerous natural and human-made phenomena. The widely used models of hydrodynamics and biological kinetics are often subjected to processes of linearization, simplification, and idealization. At the same time, some of the factors that can affect the spatial distribution of the researched processes are neglected, which, in turn, can affect the accuracy of mathematical modeling of the researched objects and phenomena. Simplification of the parametrization of mathematical models, the use of ordinary differential equations in the formulation of the Cauchy problem, a point description of the researched processes are fundamentally incorrect in systems in which the homogeneity of space is significantly violated, which was noted in the Svirezhev Yu.M. and Logofet D.O. work [
4].
The results of an experimental study of the process of solid particles gravitational settling in a wide range of Reynolds numbers are presented in the works [
5,
6]. The authors of these works compared the obtained experimental data with the data on the particle settling rate calculated for based on the Stokes formula at different concentrations of particles, liquid density and Reynolds number. In this case, the results of experimental studies obtained at low concentrations of particles (less than 7.5%) are consistent with the theoretical data obtained by the Stokes formula. As the concentration of particles increases, contradictions are observed between the experimental and theoretical results, which can be explained by the ability of particles to coagulate; therefore, when clustered, the particles settle at a higher rate. In this case, the greater the concentration of particles, the more intense the process of coagulation, and, consequently, the rate of deposition increases.
In the work of Tishkin V.F., Gasilov V.A., and others, modern methods of mathematical modeling are used to study turbulent mixing and the development of hydrodynamic instabilities [
7]. The calculation results obtained using qualitative models of hydrodynamic processes are widely used to study hydrophysical processes, which significantly improves the accuracy of their predictive modeling. Klaven A.B. in their work carried out experimental studies on the basis of hydraulic modeling of the channel process and the movement of river flows [
8]. Cea L., Vazquez-Cendon M.E. engaged in mathematical modeling of the convective flow movement when calculating the transport of dissolved substances in it. The shallow water equation was used in this case [
9]. The work of Li S., Duffy C.J. is devoted to the mathematical modeling of the hydrodynamics of shallow water and the transport of contaminants [
10]. In this case, unstructured grids were used to discretize the continuous problem. Kang S., Sotiropoulos F. developed methods and tools for numerical modeling of three-dimensional turbulent free surface flow [
11]. The study of the effect of turbulence on the transfer of individual particles in the form of a load in a river bed with a gravel layer was the goal of the work of scientists Paiement-Paradis G., Marquis G., Roy A. Paiement-Paradis G. [
12]. Pu J.H., Shao S.D., Huang Y.F. in their work [
13] described the numerical and experimental studies of turbulence in shallow flows with an open channel. Hou J. with co-authors have developed a conservative mathematical model of hydrodynamics, numerically implemented on unstructured grids for shallow water flows, taking into account important factors affecting the nature of the studied processes, including wind stress, evaporation, complex bathymetry of the reservoir [
14]. The numerical experiments on simulation of particle-laden flows are described in [
15]. Lambert B., Weynans L., Bergmann M. propose the Navier–Stokes equations for incompressible flow and partitioned volume penalization-discrete element method solver for ellipsoidal particle motion. Unstructured Cartesian grid three-dimensional hydrodynamic model coupled with a laterally averaged model for estuaries in [
16]. Chen XJ. proposes the methods for shallow water models, which solve unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes equations. Experiments were carried out with an idealized estuary case which has a large basin and two narrow tributaries. In the work [
17] Bradford S.F. describes the model based on Navier–Stokes equations with using of a modified sigma coordinate transformation. This model allows us to simulate free surface flows and is used for simulating fluid–structure interactions.
A study of the current achievements of Russian and foreign scientists in the field of mathematical modeling of aquatic ecology processes has shown that the mathematical models that are part of the software systems used to predict changes in the state of aquatic ecosystems when natural and technogenic phenomena occur in them do not take into account important factors that have a significant impact on the nature of the course of the processes under study. Simplifying hydrodynamic models does not consider turbulent exchange, the Coriolis force, the complex geometry of the coastline and the bottom, wind stresses and friction against the bottom, wind and surge phenomena, evaporation, and river flows. In the coastal areas of shallow water bodies, salt and fresh waters mix and there is a significant difference in depths. The problem of constructing discrete analogs of the developed mathematical models with the property of stability arises when modeling the hydrophysical processes of shallow water bodies. The hydrophysical processes can be described by non-stationary and spatially non-homogeneous mathematical models, including a 3D model of the hydrodynamic processes of a reservoir, models for the transport of salts, heat, and suspension, which can be represented as systems of nonlinear partial differential equations. Such problems can be solved based on the methods for solving diffusion-convection equations. Another urgent task in the construction of mathematical models of hydrodynamics for the prediction of storm events, the transport of pollutants, and other dangerous natural and human-made phenomena is the development of difference schemes under the condition that convective transport prevails over diffusion transport [
18,
19,
20,
21]. When modeling hydrodynamic processes in channel systems, large values of grid Péclet numbers arise, therefore, the accuracy of convective transport modeling decreases. It is also necessary to use models that consider changes in the density of the medium due to a significant change in salinity. Such systems are difficult to model, as re-suspension occurs and the structure of the bottom changes dynamically due to sedimentation. Standard difference schemes do not work. In this paper, methods of mathematical modeling are proposed that allow to improve the accuracy of modeling the listed processes.
The purpose of this work is to build a three-dimensional non-stationary hydrodynamics model coupled with the model of multicomponent suspended matters transport, as well as to develop effective methods for the numerical implementation of these problems. In this work, proposed hydrodynamics model which considers evaporation and precipitation as in the continuity equation, and in the motion equations, along with the complex shape of the coastline, the Coriolis force, wind stress and friction on the bottom, which has a complex relief, etc. This model based on 3D Navier–Stokes equations and the continuity equation for an water medium with variable density. The particles diameter, the difference between the particle density and the liquid density and the dynamic medium viscosity consider in the model of multicomponent suspended matters transport. In the numerical implementation of hydrophysics models, which can be reduced to problems of the diffusion-convection type, a developed difference scheme is used. A proposed difference scheme is an optimized scheme based on the Standard Leapfrog and Upwind Leapfrog schemes. The modified difference scheme contains weight coefficients equal to 2/3 and 1/3. When calculating the coefficients, the order of the approximation error was minimized. If the grid Péclet number is sufficiently large, it becomes difficult to construct a difference scheme of a high order of accuracy in the mathematical modeling of hydrophysical processes in reservoirs with complex bathymetry. Such cases arise when modeling water flows in river beds. The method of filling of rectangular cells with a material medium, in particular, with a liquid, is used to improve the smoothness and accuracy of the approximation of solving hydrodynamic problems in a region of complex shape. The above methods help to improve the accuracy of numerical simulation of hydrodynamic processes in a region of complex shape. As an illustrative example of the proposed methods using, the problem of transporting suspended matter from the riverbed to the sea in the estuary areas is solved.
3. Results of Numerical Experiments
Software package in C++ for the numerical solution of problem (
1)–(
4) was developed. This software considers such physical parameters as: turbulent exchange, complex bathymetry, the influence of wind and friction on the bottom surface of the study area, and the presence of a significant density gradient in the aquatic environment. The software package allows us to calculate three-dimensional water flow velocity fields based on the model (
1) and (
2), the model of transport of suspended particles (
3) and the model of transport of suspended particles, taking into account the movement of the aquatic environment (
1)–(
4).
3.1. Numerical Implementation of the Hydrodynamic Model
In the numerical implementation of the model (
1) and (
2) based on the developed software package, the following functions associated with the calculation are performed:
water flow velocity fields, while pressure will not be considered;
hydrostatic pressure, which in the numerical implementation of the considered mathematical model can be used as an initial approximation when calculating the values of the hydrodynamic pressure function at the nodes of the computational domain of the considered uniform rectangular grid;
hydrodynamic pressure;
fields of water flow velocity in the three-dimensional case.
Consider modeling the movement of the aquatic environment using a test problem. The uniform rectangular grid
computational nodes is introduced. The parameters of the computational domain are:
(length, width and depth are determined). The horizontal steps were 0.5 m, the vertical—0.1 m. The calculations were carried out for a time interval of 1 min with a time step of 0.25 s. The input data for the calculation according to model (
1) and (
2): pressure is 1.29 Pa, water density is 1000 kg/m
, the horizontal and vertical components of the turbulent exchange coefficient are 0.01 m
/s and 0.0005 m
/s, respectively, and the acceleration of gravity is 9.81 m/s
.
Determine the geometry of the computational domain using a depth map (
Figure 1). In
Figure 1, legend on the right the depth values in meters are shown.
Figure 2 shows a numerical experiment based on the developed software package. The color reflects the values of the water flow velocity vector (three-dimensional case). A part of the computational area, the estuary area, has been identified. The calculations were carried out on the basis of the developed software package for various time intervals: 15 s, 30 s, 45 s and 1 min.
The considered scenario (
Figure 2) allows us to observe the complex dynamics of the water flow movement process in process of time, which is quite typical for the researched phenomena.
The developed software package allows us to predict the appearance of flooding and drainage areas in the estuary area of the river.
3.2. Suspended Particle Transport Modeling
Describe the software implementation of the suspension transport model for the test problem of hydrophysics of the estuary area, in which the process of sedimentation of two fractions with different properties and characteristics is studied. For fraction A, set the deposition rate to 2.4 mm/s. Let the percentage of fraction A in dusty particles be 36%. In this case, we set the sedimentation rate of fraction B to 1.775 mm/s. Let the percentage of fraction B be 64%. Computational domain parameters: length 1 km; width 720 m. In the experiment, the horizontal and vertical steps were 10 and 1 m, respectively. The calculated interval within the considered experiments was 2 h. In the framework of the described experiment, the suspension source is placed at a distance of 5.5 m from the bottom. Determine the average flow velocity in the area with the suspension source, its value is 0.075 m/s.
Build graphs of changes in the granulometric composition of the bottom. We will set different initial concentrations of suspended particles (
Figure 3). As part of the experiment, we believe that a horizontal axis passes through the dredging area, directed along the current. On the vertical axis of
Figure 3a,b show the depth of the reservoir (m). Let us direct the Oz axis down vertically. The level of bottom sediments (in mm) is plotted along the vertical Oz axis directed vertically upwards (
Figure 3c,d). During the experiment, the concentrations of fraction A in water were determined (
Figure 3a).
Figure 3b shows the change in the concentration values of the second fraction (fraction B) in water. Within the framework of the experiment, the percentage composition of fractions A and B in bottom sediments was calculated (
Figure 3c,d).
The scenario approach allows us to study the dynamics of changes in the geometry and granulometric composition of the bottom. The software package allows us to model the process of formation of sediments and structures of complex shape, to analyze the transport of suspended matter in a shallow water body, including the estuary area. The developed software package allows us to study the effect of hydrophysical processes on hydrobiocenoses, control the level of water pollution, and also determine the trophic status of a reservoir.
3.3. Numerical Implementation of a Hydrophysical Model with Significant Density Gradient in the Aquatic Environment
Consider the results of software implementation of numerical solution of the mathematical model of estuary area hydrodynamics in the form (
1)–(
4). This model is characterized by of a significant density gradient of the aquatic environment. Define the input data: flow speed is 0.2 m/s; deposition rate is 2.042 mm/s (by Stokes); fresh water density under normal conditions is 1000 kg/m
; suspension density is 2700 kg/m
. Let the volume fraction of the suspension is 1/17. Define the calculation area. Consider that its length and width is 50 m; the depth is 2 m. In the calculations, horizontal and vertical steps were used, their values were 0.5 and 0.1 m. The time step was set equal to 0.25 s. The time interval was 5 min.
Analyze the results of a numerical experiment of suspended matter transport for the following scenario: we believe that there is a significant gradient in the density of the aquatic environment in the area under consideration. The results obtained are shown in
Figure 4 and
Figure 5, where the density is reflected on the right in the cross section of the computational domain by the xOz plane. Consider that this plane is located in the center, while
y = 25 m.
Figure 4 and
Figure 5 show the values of the suspended matter concentration averaged over depth on the left. The calculated interval was 1 min and 5 min after the start of the computational experiment.
Figure 4 and
Figure 5 allow to study the hydrophysical processes of the estuary area, including the transport of suspended matter, the vertical sections on the right show the change in the concentration of suspended matter. Consider that the layers of the aquatic environment are stratified. The density of the aquatic environment changes dynamically over time.
The software package developed on the basis of the proposed mathematical models of hydrodynamics and suspension transport has a fairly wide range of applications. The developed software allows us to analyze the transport of suspensions lighter than water, and with appropriate parameterization allows us to predict the spatial change in the concentrations of heavy impurities in a shallow water body.
4. Discussion
After analyzing the existing models and methods intended for modeling hydrodynamic processes and suspension transfer, it was found that the developed complex of 4D mathematical models allows us to increase the accuracy of modeling the processes under study. Many existing models are developed to simulate hydrodynamic processes in deep water bodies and cannot be used for coastal systems that are characterized by a large difference in depths, salinity, significant influence of winds and river runoff. The proposed model of hydrodynamics is more accurate than the known ones, since it considers the bathymetry of the bottom surface, surge phenomena. When constructing a mathematical model of the hydrophysics of the estuary area, important factors were considered that affect the nature of the researched processes, including wind stresses and friction on the bottom, turbulent exchange, the Coriolis force, evaporation, etc.
For calculations, schemes were used that consider the filling of the cells [
28]. The method of volume of fluid (VOF) of rectangular cells with a material medium (liquid) was applied in order to improve the accuracy of calculations.
An estimate of the accuracy of solving the hydrophysics problem of the estuary area for different computational grids (for different discretization parameters) is obtained. As a result, it was found that the relative error of the solution with stepwise approximation of the boundaries can reach up to 70%. The development of the proposed numerical method for solving the problem described in the study allows us to reduce the calculation error to 6%. Thickening the computational grid by a factor of 2–8 horizontally and vertically is less efficient, because does not provide such a result. If the central-difference scheme is used to construct a discrete analogue of the considered problem of impurity transport in a shallow water body, researchers have the problem of loss of accuracy if the grid Péclet number takes large values. The problem can be solved by grid thickening, which is often not efficient enough and significantly increases the computational work. Let us take a simple example. In the numerical implementation of the three-dimensional problem of diffusion-convection, a decrease in the Péclet number by 2 times entails the need to reduce the steps in spatial variables by 2 times, and by 4 times for the time step. It is easy to determine that this will lead to an increase in labor intensity by 32 times. On the other hand, the indicated problem can be solved by developing a new class of difference schemes. In the framework of the study, a modified difference scheme is used to discretize the proposed model of hydrophysics of the mouth area in the case of large values of the grid Péclet number. The scheme takes into account the cell occupancy function [
18]. It is based on the Upwind Leapfrog and Standard Leapfrog schemes known in the literature, it is their linear combination of a special type. The novelty of the developed scheme is that it includes weight coefficients calculated by minimizing the approximation error.
This difference scheme, when solving diffusion-convection problems, practically does not have grid viscosity and, as a consequence, more accurately describe the behavior of the solution in the case of large grid Péclet numbers, and also preserves the smoothness of the solution at the interface when solving hydrodynamic problems with a complex shape of the boundary surface (no oscillations associated with the stepwise approximation of the boundaries). The use of these schemes in solving hydrodynamic allows us to describe more accurately the dynamics of the aquatic environment in estuary areas, then the classical schemes.
The software package is implemented on the basis of a difference scheme with the optimal value of the weight parameter, which made it possible to increase the time step in comparison with the classical approaches.