4.1. Literature Analysis
The current study aimed to assess the nature and extent of parental concerns regarding pediatric surgical care during the COVID-19 pandemic and identify the factors associated with increased parental anxiety or concern. Our findings indicate that parents whose children underwent emergent surgery during the pandemic experienced higher levels of concern, anxiety, and perceived stress compared to those whose children underwent elective surgery. These results are consistent with previous studies reporting increased anxiety among parents of children undergoing surgery during the COVID-19 pandemic.
In the study by Former et al. conducted during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic, it was found that parents with children awaiting elective, non-emergent surgery experienced significant psychosocial distress [
19]. The distress was not necessarily related to SARS-CoV-2 transmission but rather to prolonged wait times and hospital restrictions. In a previous study by Miller et al., the authors found that 95% of parents felt waiting for their child’s surgery caused emotional distress, with half of them perceiving their child’s health as deteriorating [
21]. Another study investigated the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on parental anxiety levels and explored the need for new forms of parenting. Using a quantitative descriptive method and the GAD-7 instrument, the results showed that 63.08% of parents experienced moderate to severe anxiety. Furthermore, parental satisfaction with current parenting forms was low at 67.12%, while interest in new parenting forms was very high at 98.51% [
22].
Our study found that the age of the children was significantly lower in the emergent surgery group compared to the elective surgery group (5.1 ± 2.8 vs. 7.0 ± 2.4,
p < 0.001). Other studies have also reported the association between children’s age and parental anxiety, stress, and concerns. For example, a study by Barkmann et al. [
23] found that younger children’s parents had higher levels of anxiety and concerns before their child’s surgery. Although our study did not find a significant difference in parental anxiety or concerns based on gender, other studies have reported that mothers tend to have higher anxiety and stress levels compared to fathers in the context of their children’s surgeries [
24].
Two factors contributing to increased psychosocial distress for parents were hospital restrictions and the quality of communication with the healthcare team. Parents experienced distress due to the inability to have a second support person with them during the perioperative period and poor communication with the healthcare team [
25]. The greatest burden of distress was experienced by parents of children who were required to travel from out of province and thus needed to self-isolate, had multiple delays, and had a perceived more severe disease with a higher risk of developmental delay [
26]. Additionally, parents who were more familiar with their child’s diagnosis and pending procedure expressed lower levels of distress. Additionally, studies suggest that improved parent education during initial pre-operative consultations may be an avenue for targeted support in reducing distress [
20].
A significant proportion of parents expressed concern about their child being exposed to COVID-19 during their surgical procedure or hospital stay, particularly in the elective surgery group. This finding is consistent with existing literature that reports heightened concern among parents about the risk of COVID-19 infection in healthcare settings [
27]. The difference in concern between elective and emergent surgery groups may be due to the perceived level of control over the situation; parents of children undergoing elective surgery may feel they have more choice in the timing of the procedure and thus may have heightened concerns about the risks of proceeding during the pandemic.
Our study also found that a significantly larger percentage of parents in the emergent surgery group reported delaying or considering delaying their child’s surgery due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. This is in line with previous research that suggests parents may weigh the risks and benefits of proceeding with surgery during a pandemic and may opt to delay procedures due to concerns about infection risk [
20,
28]. However, our study found a significant difference in COVID-19 vaccination status between the elective and emergent surgery groups (
p = 0.028). Parents in the elective surgery group had a higher percentage of COVID-19 vaccination. Although we did not find a direct association between vaccination status and the questionnaire scores, other studies have reported that vaccination status can influence parental anxiety and stress levels during the COVID-19 pandemic [
29].
Interestingly, there was no significant difference between the groups in terms of feeling adequately informed about the precautions taken by the hospital to prevent COVID-19 transmission during their child’s surgery. This suggests that healthcare providers may have been effective in communicating the measures in place to reduce the risk of infection during surgical procedures [
30,
31]. However, a significantly higher proportion of parents in the emergent surgery group were anxious about the possibility of restricted visitation policies affecting their ability to support their children during their hospital stay. This finding highlights the importance of family-centered care and the role of healthcare providers in addressing parental concerns and ensuring adequate support for families during hospitalization [
32].
The increased anxiety and stress levels among parents in the emergent surgery group may be attributed to several factors, including the urgent nature of the procedure, concerns about potential complications, and uncertainty about the outcome. Previous studies have reported that parental anxiety and stress are associated with their child’s surgery type, with higher levels observed among parents of children undergoing emergent surgery compared to elective surgery [
33]. Our study also found that parents in the emergent surgery group had significantly higher PCQ practical impact and emotional impact scores, indicating greater concerns related to the logistics of their child’s surgery and the emotional toll of the experience. These findings emphasize the need for healthcare providers to address the practical and emotional needs of families in the context of pediatric surgery during the pandemic.
Healthcare providers can address and alleviate parental concerns and improve the overall experience of pediatric surgical care during the ongoing pandemic and potential future outbreaks by enhancing communication and providing comprehensive information on COVID-19 precautions and personal protective equipment availability. They should also work with hospital administration to facilitate family support within visitation restrictions, offer access to mental health professionals, and utilize telehealth services for consultations and follow-up care [
34]. Furthermore, healthcare providers should educate parents on the importance of timely surgical intervention, encourage feedback and collaboration, and prepare for future outbreaks by developing and implementing protocols and guidelines for pediatric surgery departments that prioritize patient and staff safety while ensuring continuity of care.
4.2. Strengths and Limitations
The current study has several strengths. First, it adopted a cross-sectional design that allowed the researchers to capture a snapshot of the population during the COVID-19 pandemic, providing valuable insights into the concerns and anxiety levels of parents whose children required pediatric surgical care during this period. This design helped uncover specific factors related to heightened anxiety and concern among parents, facilitating the development of recommendations for healthcare providers to address these concerns. Second, the use of standardized questionnaires, such as the PCQ, HADS, and PSS-10, allowed for more systematic and consistent measurement of parental concerns and anxiety levels and enabled comprehensive and reliable data collection, which ultimately enhanced the study’s overall validity.
However, the study also has some limitations, such as the use of convenience sampling, which may have introduced sampling bias and limited the generalizability of the findings to the broader population of parents with children requiring surgical care. Additionally, the sample size, while adequate for the cross-sectional design, may not be large enough to detect more subtle differences between the elective and emergent surgery groups, potentially affecting the study’s statistical power. The study also relied on self-reported data from the parents, which could introduce response bias or inaccuracies due to recall bias. Lastly, the exclusion of parents or pediatric patients diagnosed with COVID-19 at the time of the survey may have limited the understanding of how COVID-19 itself influenced parental concerns and anxiety levels during the pandemic.