1. Introduction
As of May 2021, there were 4536 coal mines in China; among them 62 mines with a depth of more than one kilometer have an average depth of about 1092 m, involving an approved production capacity of about 148 million tons. Studies have shown that coal mining in China is extending to deep coal mining at an average speed of 8–12 m/a. It is foreseeable that the proportion of deep coal mines will become larger and larger. The deep mining of coal resources will become the norm [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6].
The occurrence environment of deep coal seam mining has the characteristics of “three high and one low”: high ground stress, high ground temperature, high gas pressure, and low permeability. Therefore, mining efforts have been increased by increasing the drainage diameter, strengthening drilling, increasing negative pressure, and prolonging drainage time [
7,
8,
9]. At the same time, the difference between deep coal seam mining and shallow coal seam mining is that the environment in which deep coal seams are located is a complex mechanical environment of “three highs and one disturbance”. The comprehensive environmental factors around the gas drainage boreholes can easily cause spontaneous combustion of the surrounding broken coal bodies. Mine fires have always been a major disaster that frequently occur in coal mine production and have serious consequences. During 2016–2020, roof and gas accidents are still the main major accidents with the largest number of gas accidents and fatalities in coal mines in the country, accounting for 18% and 62% of the total, respectively, as shown in
Figure 1.
The spontaneous combustion of coal bodies induced by gas drainage in deep coal seams is difficult to find and control. Determining the dangerous area will be the key to preventing spontaneous combustion in boreholes. Wang [
10] proposed the use of infrared detection technology to measure the spontaneous ignition source range within a range of less than 10 m from the coal roadway. Wang [
11] used a combination of theoretical analysis and engineering applications to establish a complete mathematical model, combined with a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model of the loose coal particle size and the fuzzy judgment model of the spontaneous combustion hazard area of the roadway. Liang [
12] used the gas concentration at some points to perform inversion using theoretical formulas and equations to obtain accurate dispersion coefficients and permeability coefficients, and use them as a basis to predict the location of the fire source. Qi [
13] determined that the fire position of the gas drainage borehole was on the inner side of the blocked section based on wind speed, and conducted engineering experiments to verify each. Zhou [
14,
15] established a borehole spontaneous combustion model and proposed a quantitative evaluation index for gas drainage. Huang [
16] studied the impact of periodical weighting by introducing weighting intervals into the coupled model of coal self-heating in the gob. Liu [
17] mastered the air leakage law for the coal pillars on both sides and the gob, and determined the distribution law of the dangerous area of spontaneous combustion in the gob. Huang [
18] completed a risk evaluation and located the spontaneous combustion in a fully mechanized gob.
The sealing depth and sealing length directly affect the sealing effect of the drilling. Liu [
19] and others established the loose circle model of the surrounding rock of the rectangular roadway, studied the shape of the loose circle of the rectangular coal roadway and its formation and development mechanism, determined the loose circle theory formula for the reasonable sealing depth of gas drainage, and established a theoretical basis. Wang [
20] studied the reasonable sealing depth of bedding boreholes using the cuttings method, and theoretical analysis showed that the reasonable sealing depth is between the boundary of the broken zone and the plastic zone of the surrounding rock. Xu [
21] proposed a roadway excavation model about the intermediate principal stress and shear expansion of coal and rock and proposed a change of coal stress around the borehole and the expression of the borehole-sealing depth. Hao [
22] used a fluid-solid coupling model to discuss the extraction time, seal length, and the influence of air leakage on gas concentration. Wang [
23] obtained a minimum seal length of 12 m from the ideal elastic-plastic model.
The plugging device is also an important part that affects the spontaneous combustion of coal around the borehole [
24]. The plugging method commonly used in domestic coal mines is called “two plugging and one injection” [
25,
26,
27,
28]. The plugging device has the advantages of simple downhole plugging operation, fast plugging speed, and grouting enabled to penetrate deep into the fractures. However, because the “two plugs and one injection” device’s two-capsule bags form a closed space during the grouting process, the internal gas pressure is too large to hinder the grouting of the grouting pump. When the internal and external pressures reach equilibrium, the gas in the grouting section cannot be completely discharged, and the slurry is not solidified, resulting in a reduction in the effective plugging length of the borehole.
In view of the various disasters caused by deep coal seams in the process of gas drainage, a single water injection method cannot fundamentally solve the problem of coal spontaneous combustion around the borehole. The study uses theoretical analysis, numerical simulation, and engineering applications to determine how to prevent the danger of coal spontaneous combustion around the borehole. Specifically, dividing the area, analyzing the influence of roadway shotcrete on the dangerous area around the gas drainage borehole, improving the “two plugs and one injection” plugging device, optimizing the plugging parameters, and scientifically predicting and adopting reasonable prevention and control measures to avoid disasters were determined. Safe and efficient gas drainage in deep coal seams is of great important for engineering practice.
3. Key Technologies for Prevention and Control of Coal Spontaneous Combustion around Boreholes
In areas with serious borehole fires, measures are taken to stop drainage and inject water into the coal body area, but these measures can only temporarily control the spread of fire. Therefore, this thesis mainly discusses the prevention and control of spontaneous combustion in boreholes by using roadway shotcrete, optimizing hole-sealing parameters, and improving the “hole-sealing device”.
3.1. Optimization of Roadway Shotcrete Length Parameters
Roadway shotcrete is the first line of defense that isolates the working face and the roadway, seals the cracks in the coal wall and the pores of the coal body itself, and reduces the interaction between the coal body and the air in the roadway. The length of roadway shotcrete affects the scope of the dangerous area around the borehole, so the method of combining numerical simulation and engineering is used to study the law of the influence of shotcrete on the oxygen concentration, fluid velocity, and the scope of the dangerous area around the borehole. According to the spontaneous combustion of the coal seam (Jia et al., 2021) in the 24,130 working face of Pingdingshan No.10 Mine, the numerical simulation set the plugging depth at 15 m, the plugging length at 8 m, the initial ground temperature of the coal seam at 48 °C, and the negative pressure of drainage at −23 kPa. For the model’s parameters and boundary conditions, refer to Jia et al., 2021 and Zhao et al., 2021.
3.1.1. Analysis of Oxygen Concentration and Wind Velocity
Figure 4 is a cloud map of oxygen concentration and air flow velocity for different roadway shotcrete lengths during gas drainage for 3 days.
Figure 4 shows that with the increase of roadway shotcrete length, the air flow velocity around the borehole shows almost no change at all and the area with a larger oxygen concentration changes a little. Oxygen is one of the factors that induces the spontaneous combustion of coal. Reducing the oxygen concentration around the borehole can effectively prevent gas drainage from inducing the spontaneous combustion of coal. The longer the distance of roadway shotcrete is, the greater the safe range of oxygen concentration around the borehole. It can be seen that when the roadway does not take roadway shotcrete measures, the characteristics of the wide range of oxygen concentration and the large oxygen concentration can easily cause the spontaneous combustion of coal in the fissures around the borehole during gas drainage. Because the roadway shotcrete has little effect on the air flow velocity, it can be obtained, from the perspective of oxygen concentration, that the roadway shotcrete can effectively prevent oxygen from entering the fractured coal around the borehole, thereby preventing the oxidation and exothermic reaction of the coal and reducing the possibility of coal spontaneous combustion.
Analysis of Roadway Shotcrete in the Dangerous Area around the Borehole
Figure 5 shows that, without taking any measures, the longitudinal length of the dangerous area around the borehole is close to 14 m, in the shape of “hands clasped together”, and the dangerous area is very large. When the shotcrete length of the roadway is 2 m, 4 m, and 6 m, the dangerous area of the fractured coal body around the borehole is reduced, and the range of the dangerous area near the roadway does not change much. When comparing different roadway shotcrete lengths, the hazardous area changes a little. Comprehensive analysis of the oxygen concentration, the fractured coal body around the borehole, and the hazardous area range, shows that the best roadway shotcrete length for a single borehole is 2 m.
3.1.2. Experimental Research on Shotcrete Engineering of Roadway
In the 24,130 working face, the tunnels around the experimental boreholes were cleaned by shotcrete, the spraying was even, and there was no “skirt wearing, barefoot” phenomenon; the spray thickness was 50 mm, and the experimental boreholes with shotcrete lengths of 0 m, 2 m, 4 m, and 6 m were set. Monitoring the CO concentration in the gas drainage borehole reflects the effect of roadway shotcrete.
Figure 6 below shows the shotcrete on site and
Figure 7 shows the monitoring result curve of the shotcrete length of different roadways.
The
Figure 7 shows that when no measures are taken on the roadway, the CO concentration rises more obviously within 50 days, and the maximum can reach 430 ppm. When the roadway shotcrete length is 2, 4, and 6 m, the CO concentration around the borehole increases with the gas drainage. The increase in time continues, but compared to the 0 m roadway shotcrete, the rise tends to be slower. The average gas concentrations within 50 days of drilling gas drainage were 266, 210, 179, and 170 ppm for each shotcrete length, and the decline rate slowed down. Therefore, the length of the shotcrete for a single borehole is between 2 m and 4 m.
3.2. Optimization of Drilling and Sealing Parameters for Gas Drainage
One of the main reasons for spontaneous fire in gas drainage boreholes is the poor plugging effect of boreholes. The main factors that affect the plugging effect of boreholes are the length of the hole, the depth of the hole, the grouting material, and whether the plugging is standardized. To specific coal mines, reasonable plugging length and plugging depth are the most important, direct, and effective method to improve the plugging effect, which can not only greatly improve the efficiency of gas drainage, but also prevent spontaneous combustion in deep coal seam drainage boreholes.
3.2.1. Experimental Research on the Stress Distribution around the Roadway Based on the Drill Cuttings Method
The drill cuttings method is one of the effective methods used to test the stress distribution of the coal seam (surrounding rock). In field applications, pneumatic hand-held drilling rigs are generally used to drill holes perpendicular to the coal wall. The stress distribution characteristics of the coal body can be analyzed by the changing law of the amount of drill cuttings discharged from drilling and the accompanying dynamic phenomena.
The yield of drill cuttings changes with the change of stress in the coal body characterized by a certain functional relationship. As the stress of the coal body increases, the elastoplastic deformation increases and the yield of drill cuttings also increases. The drill cuttings method is used to study the characteristics of the stress distribution of the roadside coal body. The drill cuttings method studies the relationship between the pressure on the coal body and the yield of drill cuttings.
It can be seen from the formula that the yield of drill cuttings is positively correlated with the pressure of the surrounding rock. When the stress concentration increases, the quality of drill cuttings per unit length increases. Therefore, the stress state of the surrounding rock can be judged by the change in the yield of drill cuttings.
3.2.2. Determination of Sealing Depth
At the lower part of the 24,130 wind tunnel near the stop line, 594 mm drill holes were drilled into the coal tunnel along the layer, and drill cuttings were taken to test the stress distribution around the tunnel. Two 10 kg and 50 kg spring scales and two plastic buckets were used for on-site crumb fetching and weighing, as well as one square woven bag with a side length of about 1 m. The field test is shown in
Figure 8.
The yield of drill cuttings from the 94 mm drill hole were plotted on a curve as shown in
Figure 9.
Figure 9 shows that the yield of cuttings in the first few meters of drilling does not change much, with only slightly increases. As the drilling depth increases, the yield of drill cuttings first rises sharply, then remains stable, then decreases, and finally stabilizes. Among them, 2#, 3#, 4# drill cuttings have a similar trend with the drilling distance. The 2# drilling hole enters the area where the yield of cuttings drops after the yield of cuttings reaches the maximum. The 4# drilling hole has the largest yield of cuttings, indicating that the stress here is the largest. Combining the yield of drill cuttings in each drill hole, it can be seen that the yield of drill cuttings in the range of 0~7.5 m is low, with only small fluctuations. At this time, the yield of drill cuttings should only be the quality of the drilled coal body; drilling in the range of 8~17 m, the yield of cuttings increases sharply and remains high in the range of 17~23 m. It decreases sharply in the range of 23~28 m and tends to be stable after about 28 m. At the same time, in the range of 8~28 m, there were different numbers of coal cannons during the drilling process and the sound was loud or quiet, accompanied by the phenomenon of spray holes, the particle size of coal cuttings becoming larger, and the maximum yield of drill cuttings appearing in the drilling hole at a distance of 20 m before and after. Combined with the on-site measurement of the stress distribution of the surrounding rock using the cuttings measurement method and the theoretical analysis of the loose zone, it can be concluded that 0~7 m is the broken zone, 8~19 m is the plastic zone, and 20~28 m is the elastic zone. The maximum yield of drill cuttings appear around 20 m and the maximum stress appears at about 20 m away from the roadway.
3.2.3. Determination of Sealing Length
According to the actual situation of the sealing parameters of Pingdingshan No.10 Mine, the sealing length is set to 8 m, 10 m, 13 m, and 15 m. For other physical parameters and boundary conditions, please refer to the paper by Jia et al., 2021; Zhao et al., 2021. The coal temperature cloud map at 90 days around the borehole is shown in
Figure 10.
Figure 10 shows the plugging depth of 20 m; the plugging lengths are 8 m, 10 m, 13 m, and 15 m, the gas drainage is 90 d, and there is coal temperature distribution around the borehole. It can be seen that when the sealing length is 8 m, 10 m, 13 m, and 15 m, the high temperature of the coal body around the borehole is 83.4 °C, 65.5 °C, 53.9 °C, and 48 °C, respectively, and the oxygen concentration around the borehole is greater than 8%. The area gradually decreases as the sealing length increases. From the perspective of temperature analysis, when the gas drainage is within 90 d, the sealing hole length should be no less than 10 m; when the gas drainage is greater than 90 d, the sealing hole length should be greater than 13 m. However, according to the gas drainage rules, it can be obtained that the working face gas drainage should last longer than 6 months, so the best sealing length is 13 m. From the perspective of oxygen concentration, although the area where the oxygen concentration is greater than 8% is the smallest when the sealing length is 15 m, considering that the sealing length is too long, it also increases the difficulty and cost of sealing and when the sealing length is 13 m, the area where the oxygen concentration is greater than 8% is still small. Combining temperature changes and oxygen concentration changes, the optimal sealing hole length is 13 m, which can prevent the spontaneous combustion of coal seams and ensure efficient gas drainage.
The test was carried out on the lower edge of the 24,130 wind tunnel at a distance of 500 m from the cut hole. The test involved parameters of (sealing depth-sealing length) 15-13, 18-13, 20-8, 20-10, and 20-13. Concerning drilling hole parameters, each group of drilling spacing is 2 m, the hole diameter is 94 mm, and the drilling depth is 90 m. There were five holes in each group of boreholes. Each borehole in each group was connected to the branch pipe and then connected to the main pipe. Each group of boreholes had a monitoring hole to monitor the average gas of each group of boreholes. To extract the volume fraction, the average gas extraction volume fraction of each group of extraction boreholes was monitored once a day and recorded and the six groups of extraction boreholes were continuously monitored for 60 days. The data are plotted in
Figure 11.
Comparing the sealing parameters of 20-8, 20-10 and 20-13, the average gas extraction volume fraction of boreholes with a sealing parameter of 20-8 is lower and the average gas concentration is 41%; when the sealing parameter is 20-10, the average gas drainage concentration accumulated within 50 days is 56.4% and when the drainage parameters are 20-13, the average gas drainage concentration reaches 70.8%. All comparative analysis shows that when the sealing depth is 20 m, the best gas drainage length of the sealing hole is 13 m. From the perspective of gas drainage concentration, it can prevent spontaneous combustion of the borehole. Comparing the three groups of holes with sealing parameters 15-13, 18-13, and 20-13, the average gas concentration of the drainage holes is 56%, 62.4%, and 70.8%, respectively, and the sealing length is the same, the deeper the sealing depth, the higher the gas drainage concentration. When the 50 d plugging depth is 20 m, the average gas drainage concentration reaches 70.8%, indicating that the plugging effect is better and there is almost no air leakage. The experimental analysis of the drill cuttings method results in the peak stress of 24,130 working face. The point is 20 m and the sealing depth is increased before the stress peak, which can improve the extraction effect.
Based on the above analysis, the plugging depth is 20 m and the inner end of the plugging section of the plugging position is just at the peak stress point, which will not cause a blind area for drainage. When the plugging length is 13 m, which can prevent the natural fire of the coal seam and ensure the efficient gas drainage pick. Therefore, in order to increase the extraction efficiency and avoid the spontaneous combustion of the fractured coal around the borehole, comprehensive numerical simulation and field engineering experiment analysis can determine the optimal sealing parameters of the coal seam at the 24,130 working face as 20-13.
3.3. New Prevention Technology of “Two Plugs, One Injection and One Row”
The most commonly used downhole “two plugs and one injection” hole plugging device is used to observe the pressure with a grouting pressure gauge, which does not indicate that the borehole is filled with slurry. The gas in the borehole cannot be completely discharged, and the slurry can easily gather around the borehole after solidification, causing the formation of gaps and gas segments.
3.3.1. Development of “Two Plugs, One Injection and One Row” Device
The “two plugs, one injection and one row” plugging device is composed of three main parts: inside and outside sealing pockets (two plugs), grouting pipe (one injection), and grouting pipe (one row); it is made with PVC-U special glue. After connecting the suction tube with glue, the outer sealing bag and the inner sealing bag were tied in a fixed position so that the suction pipe passes through the outer and inner sealing bags and the grouting pipe passes through the outer sealing bag. The bag and the inner sealing bag are parallel to the axis of the extraction pipe; the grouting pipe is located in the pipeline inside the outer sealing bag and the inner sealing bag. A one-way valve is provided in the pipeline and the pipe wall. There is a grout outlet on the grouting pipe so that the grout flows into the outer and inner sealing bags after the grout passes through the one-way valve in the grouting pipe; when the upward drilling hole sealer is arranged, the adjustment row, the distance from the position of the slurry pipe to the inner sealing bag, is 5~10 cm and the position of the blasting valve to the mouth of the slurry pipe is 20~30 cm, as shown in
Figure 12a; when the downward drilling and sealing device is arranged, the distance between the position of the discharge pipe and the outer sealing bag to 5~10 cm were adjusted. The position of the blasting valve to the mouth of the discharge pipe is 20~30 cm, as shown in
Figure 12b. The grouting process operates as shown in
Figure 13.
3.3.2. Analysis of the Effect of the “Two Plugs, One Injection and One Row”
Plugging Device
(1) Drilling and cutting analysis
The simulated drilling adopts a seamless steel pipe (specification is 12 m/piece, 100 mm diameter), the extraction pipe adopts a polyvinyl chloride pipe (specification is 3 m/piece, plug-in type, 50 mm bore diameter), and the hole sealer is designed to be 8 m long and 2 pcs. The length of the capsule band is 800 mm. Two sets of airtightness comparison tests were designed, using “two plugs and one injection” for up- and downholes and “two plugs, one injection and one row” for up- and downholes. The cutting machine separately cut two simulated drill holes near the capsule belt near the exhaust pipe. Whether the grouting is full is judged by whether the section is compact and complete, and the cross-sectional views are shown in
Figure 14 and
Figure 15.
Figure 14 shows the part of the traditional “two plugs and one injection” device that is not filled with grout. This part is in the shape of a three-quarter circle. The reason is partly because of cutting jitter and partly because the upward and downward drilling angles are 37°.
Figure 15 shows a cross-sectional view of the “two plugs, one injection and one row” device. The bottom and upward borehole grouting part is dense, the grout is completely filled with the plugging section, and there is no air leakage channel, illustrating that the grouting effect of the new process of “two plugs, one injection and one row” is obviously better than the traditional method of “two plugs and one bet”.
(2) Analysis of engineering test results
The lower side of 24,130 machine lane is constructed with 10 holes, the sealing depth is 20 m, and the sealing length is 8 m. The downward hole was sealed along the layer and the inclination angle was 25° with all adopting the technology of full screen mesh pipe. Hole 1–5# is grouted and sealed according to the new process of “two plugs, one injection and one row” and hole 1′–5′# was sealed according to the existing two plugs and one injection. After the sealing was completed, 10 pairs of two boreholes were connected to the extraction pipe, and the gas concentration was measured.
Figure 16 below shows the average gas concentration of two boreholes with different sealing methods in 90 days.
Through the similar simulation cutting experiment of the uphole plugging device, it can be obtained that the traditional “two plugs and one injection” has a part that is not filled with grout. This part is in the shape of a three-quarter circle. The “two plugs, one injection and one row” borehole grouting is partly dense; the grouting effect of the new “two plugs, one injection and one row” process is significantly better than the traditional “two plugs and one injection” method”. Through underground engineering tests, it can be obtained that the average gas concentration of “two plugs, one injection and one row” within 90 days is 75%, and the gas concentration of traditional sealing technology is 55%, which is an average increase of 36.4% compared with traditional technology.
4. Conclusions
In view of the problem that it is difficult to control the spontaneous combustion of coal around the borehole induced by gas drainage, the judgment criteria for a dangerous area of spontaneous combustion of fractured coal around the borehole were theoretically determined. The combined methods of experiment and simulation were presented in this paper. The comprehensive prevention and control technologies of shotcrete, sealing parameters, and the “two plugs, one injection and one row” device were introduced, resulting in the following conclusions:
(1) The critical oxygen concentration of coal spontaneous combustion was experimentally studied. A method of comprehensively dividing the spontaneous combustion risk area of fractured coal around the borehole induced by gas drainage was proposed based on the oxygen concentration and air leakage speed. The spontaneous combustion risk area was divided by the oxygen concentration of coal around the borehole at8% and the air leakage speed of 0.004 m/s. Scientific division of “dangerous areas of drilling holes” can enhance the pertinence of fire-fighting measures, improve the effect of fire-fighting projects, and effectively prevent spontaneous fire accidents. Production has very important practical significance.
(2) In view of the problem that it is difficult to control the spontaneous combustion of coal around the borehole induced by gas drainage, the optimal roadway shotcrete length was determined to be 2–4 m using the numerical simulation method. The sealing hole depth of 20 m and length of 13 m were determined by combining theory and experiment, which provides a scientific basis for preventing and controlling the spontaneous combustion of coal around the borehole.
(3) On the basis of the “two plugs and one injection” process, the “two plugs, one injection and one row of hole sealers” method was developed. The simulated drilling section was cut. The new process has a compact structure in the pocket part. The traditional process has a three-quarter circular blank section. The gas concentration of the traditional sealing process is 55% and the average gas concentration of the “two plugs, one injection and one row” method that accumulated within 90 days is 75%, which shows an average increase of 36.4% compared to the traditional process. The new “two plugs, one injection and one row” device is an effective method for improving gas drainage efficiency and preventing spontaneous combustion of gas drainage boreholes.