Bridging Gaps, Fostering Inclusion: A Gendered Look at Disability Support for Women in Higher Education
Abstract
:1. Introduction
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Study Design
2.2. Participants and Sample Selection
2.3. Techniques, Instruments, and Procedures for Information Gathering
2.4. Ethical Consideration
2.5. Data Analysis and Interpretation of Results
3. Results
3.1. Institutional Resources: Resources Offered by the University of Seville
3.2. Institutional Resources: Communication and Dissemination of Available Policies
3.3. Institutional Resources: Difficulty in Accessing Resources. Complex Bureaucratization of Processes
3.4. Academic and Work Conditions: Communication of Special Needs
3.5. Academic and Work Conditions: Visible Disability versus Invisible Disability
3.6. Academic and Work Conditions: Support among Peers
3.7. Academic and Work Conditions: Institutional Response
3.8. Disability and Gender: Interrelation Being Female/Having Disabilities
3.9. Disability and Gender: Gender Roles, Reconciliation, and Co-Responsibility
4. Discussion
Limitations
5. Conclusions
Author Contributions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Acknowledgments
Conflicts of Interest
References
- Wolbring, G.; Lillywhite, A. Equity/Equality, Diversity, and Inclusion (EDI) in Universities: The Case of Disabled People. Societies 2021, 11, 49. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- UN-WOMEN. The Empowerment of Women and Girls with Disabilities Towards Full and Effective Participation and Gender Equality [Internet]. 2018, pp. 1–44. Available online: https://www.unwomen.org/en/digital-library/publications/2018/12/the-empowerment-of-women-and-girls-with-disabilities (accessed on 21 May 2023).
- UNESCO. Incheon Declaration Framework for Action for the Implementation of Sustainable Development Goal 4 Ensure Inclusive and Equitable Quality Education and Promote Lifelong Learning Opportunities for All [Internet]. 2016, pp. 1–83. Available online: https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000245656_spa (accessed on 21 May 2023).
- Comité Español de Representantes de Personas con Discapacidad (CERMI). 2020. Universidad y Discapacidad. La Inclusión de las Personas con Discapacidad en la Universidad Española. Available online: https://www.cermi.es/es/colecciones/universidad-y-discapacidad-la-inclusión-de-las-personas-con-discapacidad-en-la (accessed on 8 March 2022).
- Braun, V.; Clarke, V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual. Res. Psychol. 2006, 3, 77–101. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Mejía-Cajamarca, P.E.; Pallisera Díaz, M. Las Personas con Discapacidad Intelectual y la Inclusión en la Universidad: Una Investigación Centrada en las Opiniones de Responsables Académicos y Personas con Discapacidad Intelectual. Rev. Nac. E Int. Educ. Inclusiva 2020, 13, 40–61. [Google Scholar]
- European Commision. Committee and the Committee of the Regions Union of Equality: Strategy for the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 2021–2030. 2021, pp. 1–30. Available online: https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=1484&langId=en (accessed on 8 March 2022).
- Mosia, P.A.; Phasha, N. Access to curriculum for students with disabilities at higher education institutions: How does the National University of Lesotho fare? Afr. J. Disabil. 2017, 6, 257. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Ocampo, J.C. Disability, Inclusiveness and Higher Education in Ecuador: The Case of Universidad Católica de Santiago de Guayaquil. Rev. Latinoam. Educ. Inclusiva 2018, 12, 97–114. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Castaño Morcillo MPHS Alba María. La formación universitaria como garantía del derecho a una calidad de vida óptima de jóvenes con discapacidad intelectual. Derecho Discapac. 2020, 5, 259–275. [Google Scholar]
- Universidad de Sevilla. II Plan Integral de Atención a las Necesidades de Apoyo para las Personas con Discapacidad o con Necesidad de Apoyo por Situación de Salud Sobrevenida (acuerdo 9.1/CG 23-6-17). 2017. Available online: https://www.us.es/bous-numeros/numero-4-24-de-julio-de-2017/acuerdo-91cg-23-6-17-por-el-que-se-aprueba-el-ii-plan (accessed on 21 May 2023).
- Gonzalez, H.C.; Hsiao, E.-L. Disability Inclusion in Nursing Education. Teach. Learn. Nurs. 2019, 15, 53–56. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Lorenzo-Lledó, G.; Carreres, A.L.; Lledó, A.L.; Vera, G.A. La acción tutorial como acompañamiento en el alumnado universitario con discapacidad: Hacia una educación inclusiva. Int. J. Dev. Educ. Psychol. 2017, 4, 137. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Marks, B.; McCulloh, K. Success for Students and Nurses with Disabilities: A Call to Action for Nurse Educators. Nurse Educ. 2016, 41, 9–12. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Munsuri Rosado, J.; Sacramento, P.H. Actitudes de los estudiantes de enfermería hacia las personas con discapacidad. Análisis y propuestas. Index Enferm. Inf. Bibliogr. Investig. Humanidades 2016, 25, 114–118. [Google Scholar]
- González Alonso, M.Y.; Martínez Martín, M.Á.; Juan Barriuso, M.N. Atención a Estudiantes con Discapacidad en la Universidad. En: Investigación en Docencia Universitaria: Diseñando el Futuro a Partir de la Innovación Educativa. 2017, pp. 795–803. Available online: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/extart?codigo=6180963 (accessed on 19 May 2023).
- ECOAULA. El talento Femenino, los Empleados en Zonas Rurales y las Personas con Discapacidad, los Colectivos más Benefi-ciados por el Teletrabajo. Eleconomista.es. Available online: https://www.eleconomista.es/ecoaula/noticias/11951908/09/22/El-talento-femenino-los-empleados-en-zonas-rurales-y-las-personas-con-discapacidad-los-colectivos-mas-beneficiados-por-el-teletrabajo.html (accessed on 19 May 2023).
- Lorenzo, G.; Lledó Carreres, A. Dificultades Percibidas por los Docentes Universitarios en la Atención del Alumnado con dis-Capacidad. En: Investigación en Docencia Universitaria: Diseñando el Futuro a Partir de la Innovación Educativa. 2017, pp. 804–813. Available online: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=6180999 (accessed on 5 February 2023).
- Valenzuela-Zambrano, B. La Inclusión de Estudiantes con Discapacidad en Educación Superior Chilena, Factores favo-Recedores y Obstaculizadores para su acceso y Permanencia [Internet]; University of Granada: Granada, Spain, 2017; Available online: http://hdl.handle.net/10481/44844 (accessed on 20 May 2023).
- Aparicio Payá, M. Accesibilidad universal: Sentido normativo e implicaciones en la educación y la práctica pro-fesional. Rev. Esp. Discapac. REDIS 2017, 5, 25–41. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Valenzuela-Zambrano, B.; López-Justicia, M.D. Autoconcepto de Estudiantes Universitarios Chilenos con Discapacidad. Diferencias en Función del Género. Rev. Nac. E Int. Educ. Inclusiva 2015, 8, 153–170. [Google Scholar]
- Serrano, E.L.; Gutiérrez, V.F.; de la Fuente Robles, Y.M. Enfoques y Políticas Dirigidas a la inserción Socio-Educativa de las Personas con Discapacidad. Análisis Comparado Entre Bolivia y España. En: Actas del VII Congreso de la Red Española de Política Social (REPS): ‘Políticas Sociales ante Horizontes de Incertidumbre y Desigualdad’. Zaragoza. 2018, pp. 848–861. Available online: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=6833602 (accessed on 5 May 2023).
- Rodríguez Molina, G.A.; Valenzuela Zambrano, B. Acceso y permanencia de estudiantes con discapacidad en las universidades chilenas. Sinéctica Rev. Electrónica Educ. 2019, 1–16. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Martins, M.H.; Borges, M.L.; Gonçalves, T. Attitudes towards inclusion in higher education in a Portuguese university. Int. J. Incl. Educ. 2018, 22, 527–542. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Valle-Flórez, R.-E.; Fuertes, A.M.d.C.; Baelo, R.; García-Martín, S. Faculty of Education Professors’ Perception about the Inclusion of University Students with Disabilities. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2021, 18, 11667. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Neal-Boylan, L.; Smith, D. Nursing Students With Physical Disabilities: Dis-pelling Myths and Correcting Misconceptions. Nurse Educ. 2016, 41, 13–18. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Beatson, P.; Perry, P. Disability and Gender: Querying the «Double Handicap» Assumption. N. Z. Sociol. 2002, 17, 300–321. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rudman, L.A.; Glick, P.; Phelan, J.E. From the laboratory to the bench: Gender stereotyping research in the courtroom. In Beyond Common Sense: Psychological Science in the Courtroom; Wiley: Hoboken, NJ, USA, 2008; pp. 83–102. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- University of Seville. Guía de Programas y Medidas de Conciliación y Corresponsabilidad de la Universidad de Sevilla. 2018, pp. 1–28. Available online: https://igualdad.us.es/wpblog/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Guia-de-Programas-y-Medidas-Conciliacion-Corresponsabilidad-US_v20181213.pdf (accessed on 20 May 2023).
- Universidad de Sevilla. III Plan de Igualdad (Acuerdo 6.1/CG 20-126-21). 2021, pp. 1–24. Available online: https://igualdad.us.es/?page_id=817 (accessed on 20 May 2023).
Interviewee | Profile | Age | Years at the US | Area of Knowledge | Type of Disability | Relatives with Disability | Belongs to Any Association |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. María | Student | 46 | 2 | Health Sciences | Physical and mental | No | No |
2. Lola | Student | 49 | 2 | Social and Legal Sciences | Physical | No | Yes |
3. Carmen | Student | 26 | 5 | Social and Legal Sciences | Physical | No | Yes |
4. Esther | Student | 25 | 6 | Social & Legal Sciences | Hearing loss and deafness | No | No |
5. Juana | Lecturer | 39 | 21 (9 as PDI) | Social and Legal Sciences | Physical | Yes | No |
6. Ana | Lecturer | 46 | 23 | Engr. & Arch. | Others | No | Yes |
7. Marina | Administrative staff | 48 | 1.5 | Arts & Humanities | Mental | No | No |
8. Marta | Administrative staff | 47 | 15 | Physical and mental | Yes | No | |
9. Mercedes | Lecturer | 44 | 8 months | Engr. and Arch. | Physical | No | No |
10. Violeta | Administrative staff | 48 | 12 | Engr. and Arch. | Others | Yes | No |
11. Sara | Administrative staff | 62 | 35 | Social and Legal Sciences | Hearing loss and deafness | Yes | No |
12. Cecilia | Administrative staff | 47 | 14 months | Social and Legal Sciences | Physical | No | No |
Subcategories | Verbatims |
---|---|
Resources offered by the University of Seville | “Virtuality has somehow helped me to feel more ‘normal’, because all people were experiencing a similar situation, and now, I feel even less normal than before.” (JUANA) “Once you try online courses, comfortably at home, with mi headphones which makes everything quiet and nice. It is the best way to take a course.” (SARA) “I had no idea, and I do not think… It is not something they say to you once you enroll the university, like ‘Hey, we have psychologists and jurists if you need them’. It is not something we remember to have been talked about.” (CARMEN) |
Communication and dissemination of available policies | “I think you must find out by yourself, as the University does not tell you that there is this department which helps with this or that. Basically, I entered the page [refers to Google search] and searching ‘disability’ at the University of Seville site, the results showed SACU [the university community student support service].” (LOLA) “I had no idea, and I do not think … It is not something they say to you once you enroll the university, like ‘Hey, we have psychologists and jurists if you need them’. It is not something we remember to have been talked about.” (CARMEN) “The general feeling is that everything is posturing, that is all. The feeling is like, ‘We are principled, we are very aware’. But everything remains on the paper.” (JUANA) “You must be initiative-taking. There is no passive dissemination coming to you.” (ANA) “I think it would be necessary to inform about the different disabilities. For example, if in my unit I have a mental disability, we can have a seminar on metal disability attended by people with and without this type of disability and share our experiences …”. (MARINA) |
Difficulty in accessing resources. Complex bureaucratization of processes. | “She asked for it several times [a specific type of table] and finally she stopped signing up as the battle seemed a lost cause.” (MARÍA) “I have seen how this classmate in wheelchair is now in her third year and has been asking for a height-adjustable table since her first year, and three years after she is still waiting.” (MARÍA) “Besides, for example, a chair. I cannot use normal chairs because my body does not let me. It needs back support and a particular shape … When I informed the University, my Master tutor lent me her own office chair until I got one from social services. The chair from social services arrived just a month before I left, though.” (CARMEN) “A year ago, I asked if they could adjust one of the bathrooms of the professors’ floor so I could avoid going down to the first floor every time, and they said me they would see how to do it. And it is still there, unadapted.” (JUANA) “The truth is that everything depends on people’s goodwill” (…) “as no one knew who had to give the order, no one took any decision.” (JUANA) |
Subcategories | Verbatims |
---|---|
Communication about special needs | “So, I would ask that every time someone with disabilities enrolls, it should be the university the one telling the department responsible, ‘Hey, this is what needs to be done.” (JUANA) “Everything is fine, really. As I said before, I cannot complain about my colleagues or professors.” (ESTHER) “The truth is that the relationship and contact with mi colleagues has been excellent, I have had any issues with no one. However, when trusting me with different tasks maybe they have perceived me more insecure, and I have been relegated from some type of works, so this is something I have been observing, that they do not trust so much in my capacities.” (MARINA) “I feel constantly compensating. It is a mixture of pleasing and compensating people which is hard to manage. It is hard to comply with that all the time.” (JUANA) “And they may think my exam was easier when it is exactly the same and the grade scale as well. As if someone gave me the job. But I think they have already realized that I do the same work as everyone else, with no difference at all.” (CECILIA) |
Visible disability versus invisible disability | “Because if you force someone with disabilities to explain their situation again and again, you are not letting them to it leave aside and forget about it a single moment.” (ANA) “‘So, what is what you have?’, they say. And when I tell them my condition they say, ‘Well, you seem to be fine …’”. […] “It seems like you have to match this stereotype of sad, dying person. If they see you as positive, smiling… I have had a lot of issues regarding my appearance. Because I reflect my appetite life, as from the moment I wake up to the time I go to bed I am in pain, so I have to be really passionate about living, feeling, and making others feel fine. So, yes, I feel restricted just for not giving that impression.” (ESTHER) “Mine is not visible, so many people just do not get it, and only if you tell them, ‘hey, I am disabled’” […] “The problem is mainly that, when people realize you have a disability, because mine are in no way visible, not the physical or mental, so then they start asking, because they love asking, and they say, ‘Oh, so you are disabled? Does not seem so’ and ‘So, what is it?’ And it is really annoying because people think you are pretending, and in fact it is the other way round, never in my life I said, ‘I cannot do this’, no way, just the other way round.” (MARTA) “Sometimes, I also felt, now you have mentioned it, that when I just get off the car at the parking [exclusive for people con reduced mobility] people like, ‘You do not seem to need the disabled parking space’. And this is why I even say to myself, ‘I am going to force my limp to show them what is my condition’ but then I think that if it is not hurting so much at that moment as to limp, why do I have to make obvious my disability, so people are satisfied? Do I have to justify myself in front of everyone?” (CECILIA) |
Support among peers | “Very good, very good. As I’ve already told you, I can’t complain about my colleagues or my teachers.” (ESTHER) “The truth is that the treatment from my colleagues has been excellent; I haven’t had any problems with anyone. However, when it comes to trusting me for different tasks, they probably see me as more insecure, and of course, they ended up sidelining me from small jobs. That’s what I really see, that they don’t have much confidence in my abilities.” (MARINA) “And they think that my exam is easier when it’s the same and when the grading scale is the same. And of course, it’s as if they’re just giving me the position. But they have realized that I work just like everyone else and I don’t have any kind of difference.” (CECILIA) |
Academic and work conditions: institutional response | “Individualize support a bit more and focus on the needs of each of us” […] “It should be generally acknowledged that there are as many disabilities as people with disabilities, and that no condition is identical to any other, so the aim should be to explore a bit more what people with disabilities really need at the University. That means that more individualized adaptations are needed according to the circumstances of each individual, and not by following a pattern that will never adjust to what each of us needs.” (CARMEN) “Each of us is different, and disabilities cannot be managed with a series of general policies, there must be a specialized team”. (ANA) |
Subcategories | Verbatims |
---|---|
Interrelation being female or having disabilities | “I think both [women and men] are discriminated in the same way, not because women have more difficulties, no.” (LOLA) “Even more, I think that, maybe if I was a boy instead of a girl, with my academic background, my situation would be very different right now.” (CARMEN) “To be honest, I have not felt discriminated at the University on the basis of being a woman. Outside the University is different, I have worked in some places where you did not have the same chances.” (MARINA) “I think that the difference is more related to the type of disability than to gender, though maybe it is true that overprotection placed on women may affect you.” (ESTHER) “No, she is not managing the project because she will be constantly on leave” or “She is not going to coordinate this course because reasons” and I felt terrible. I have been saying no to things out of panic, I mean that my problem truly has been physical obligation, the rest does not matter to me. I do not mind working at night, I may be whacked and then working at 3 am. I am like that, but I need that flexibility. I have felt excluded from certain things, due to my disability.” (ANA) “Girls with disabilities have their freedom much more curtailed. I think it affects you completely, in your studies, relationships, aspirations …” […] Besides, we must be aware of the fact that we are talking of people with disabilities in the context of an heteropatriarchy, a society with stereotypes shared also by people with disabilities, and particularly applied to women.” (ESTHER) “Normally, at the University, something I generally feel is that being a woman is like being very obliging, very collaborative, cooperative, and tending to show less of our character than me, who are less assertive. So, I wondered, with regard to my disability, what is my perception? And, apart from being obliging, which I believe it is associated to gender perspective, there is a part of the disability which tries to compensate. This means that, as you cannot certain things, you feel you must square in the sense that, ‘I have been attending less classes than you, so I will finish that article’ or ‘I will submit it’ or ‘I will be second author’. I am always compensating. So, it is a combination, oblige and compensate, which is hard to balance.” (JUANA) |
Gender roles, reconciliation, and co-responsibility | “It is like the fact of being a woman will limit you to the care of your relatives or children because it is expected that you stay at home.” (CECILIA) “It is like women, particularly in the case of the University, are expected to be brilliant researchers, make a great professional career, struggle to reconcile, and if on top of that you add a disability, that in most of the cases it has to be very obvious to be recognized, as normally all support is scarce, even more if your disability is invisible. And you have always the feeling of having the imposter syndrome, which I personally never felt being haughty myself, but it is quite common to suffer from the imposter syndrome because you feel that everything you attain is been given to you.” (ANA) |
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2024 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Share and Cite
Leon-Larios, F.; Benítez-Lugo, M.-L.; Almendros-Caballero, C.; Meyer, L.S.; Corrales-Gutierrez, I.; Casado-Mejía, R. Bridging Gaps, Fostering Inclusion: A Gendered Look at Disability Support for Women in Higher Education. Women 2024, 4, 241-253. https://doi.org/10.3390/women4030018
Leon-Larios F, Benítez-Lugo M-L, Almendros-Caballero C, Meyer LS, Corrales-Gutierrez I, Casado-Mejía R. Bridging Gaps, Fostering Inclusion: A Gendered Look at Disability Support for Women in Higher Education. Women. 2024; 4(3):241-253. https://doi.org/10.3390/women4030018
Chicago/Turabian StyleLeon-Larios, Fatima, María-Luisa Benítez-Lugo, Cristina Almendros-Caballero, Linnéa Stamatía Meyer, Isabel Corrales-Gutierrez, and Rosa Casado-Mejía. 2024. "Bridging Gaps, Fostering Inclusion: A Gendered Look at Disability Support for Women in Higher Education" Women 4, no. 3: 241-253. https://doi.org/10.3390/women4030018
APA StyleLeon-Larios, F., Benítez-Lugo, M. -L., Almendros-Caballero, C., Meyer, L. S., Corrales-Gutierrez, I., & Casado-Mejía, R. (2024). Bridging Gaps, Fostering Inclusion: A Gendered Look at Disability Support for Women in Higher Education. Women, 4(3), 241-253. https://doi.org/10.3390/women4030018