1. Introduction
The shaping of public opinion but also the cultivation of cultural standards and ideologies are highly affected by TV broadcasts (news, content, etc.) and mass media in general, particularly by the increased use of the internet, by advertising, and by wider providers of information (
Buckingham 2020).
Moreover, as
Hagedoorn et al. (
2021) mentioned, adolescents are “
moving away from traditional broadcast television, turning instead to other screens and formats” (p. 83). This indicates the need for the recognition of “
new viewing cultures” and the differences in content dissemination between the variety of media used by different audiences (
Hagedoorn et al. 2021).
Mass media, including television, operate at a multidimensional level (societal, national, and local). At the same time, they are considered important factors of a social nature, the moment in which they influence and are influenced by social groups (
Swart 2021).
At this point, it is worth mentioning the fact that Gen Z and Gen Y audiences do not present differences in their behaviors and in the basic components that influence their TV viewing choices (
Patch 2018). It is also argued that in modern eras, there has been a shift in the value patterns of post-industrial democracies where citizens, especially the younger ones, tend to show a greater interest in monitoring lifestyle-related issues rather than politically oriented programs and ideologies (
Bennett 2008). ‘’Value’’ is defined as the importance or worth that an individual places on something, such as, for example, a principle, behavior, or object (
Eccles 2005). The process of decision making is usually guided by an individual’s values, and they help the determination of what is meaningful and desirable in individuals’ lives. Values might be influenced by multiple factors, such as culture and personal experiences (
Roccas and Sagiv 2010).
New studies, like the ones of
Ku et al. (
2019),
Dumitru (
2020), and
Nygren and Guath (
2019), identified low levels of critical thinking and reflection among young people regarding the information they receive from mass media. That is why media literacy is an especially important skill in today’s digital age (
Jolls and Johnsen 2017). This term refers to the understanding of how messages transmitted through mass media are created and why they are disseminated, but also the impact they have on individuals and society. When media literacy is combined with critical public thinking, it enables individuals to critically evaluate media content, as well as question its sources and motives (
Silverblatt et al. 2014).
However, after studying the Greek and international literature, no study was found investigating the different beliefs of young people in different aspects of watching programs on television. “Belief” is a conviction or acceptance that something is true or exists, often without proof or evidence (
Stevenson 2003). There are many types of beliefs, such as religious, philosophical, or beliefs that are related to someone’s personal experiences (
Phan et al. 2020). Beliefs can shape how people perceive the world and make sense of the experiences that they have. They can also impact someone’s behavior and attitude (
Smith 2001).
Though some meritorious studies have been conducted about Greek adolescents, such as the ones of
Kourti (
2002),
Podara et al. (
2021), and
Podara et al. (
2019), there is still a significant gap in this field for Greece. While
Podara et al. (
2021) aimed to characterize the TV viewing habits of Greek adolescents and
Podara et al. (
2019) aimed to define Greek adolescents’ audiovisual consumption practices,
Kourti (
2002) mentions that little research has been conducted about adolescents and media use, which is a subject in which a research gap still exists. This study, therefore, aims at examining Greek young audience perceptions, beliefs, and reflections about different aspects of TV watching and not at identifying their TV-watching habits.
More precisely, the purpose of this study is to investigate the correlations between the beliefs of Greek youths aged 15–18 and their demographic characteristics, the educational level of their parents, their school performance, and the frequency of daily television viewing. Conclusions will therefore be drawn regarding their reflective thinking and the aforementioned correlations.
Thus, the following research question is expected to be covered: What correlations are found in youngsters’ beliefs with their demographic characteristics, their school performance, their parents’ educational levels, and the frequency of viewing television programs daily?
2. Related Literature
Undeniably, the current era is overwhelmed by a combination of digital and traditional media. Given the flood of information citizens receive daily from different media, they need to learn to evaluate the information transmitted and to handle each medium by applying their abstract and reflective thinking (
Moon and Bai 2020). This need is even more imperative in the case of young people, who must know how to interpret every message and piece of information they receive from the mass media, including television (
Costera Meijer 2007).
Young people must develop knowledge, skills, abilities, and specific attitudes so that they come into safe contact with the messages transmitted by the mass media and, by extension, with political, social, and cultural events. They must also develop an understanding of how the media and information providers work (
Nygren and Guath 2019). At this point, “attitude” is defined as a person’s overall outlook or way of thinking and feeling about something or someone. Attitude encompasses a set of beliefs, emotions, and behaviors that determine how a person approaches and responds to different situations and interactions. It plays a significant role in influencing an individual’s decisions and actions, thereby impacting his/her relationships and overall well-being (
Breckler and Wiggins 2014).
The research of
Dumitru (
2020) proved that youngsters, due to the huge implementation of new technology in all aspects of their daily lives, are facing serious problems in distinguishing between fake and authentic news. They often fail to recognize trustworthy news sources from the untrustworthy ones, a situation that makes them vulnerable to fake information.
Ku et al. (
2019) also found low levels of critical thinking in young people in terms of their ability to reflect on whether the information they receive from the media is correct and how it might affect their personal beliefs, attitudes, and perceptions toward social, political, and cultural issues.
Podara et al. (
2021) characterized Greek adolescents’ media screen behavior as “
mobility-centered” and “
algorithmically naïve”. However,
Nygren and Guath (
2019), who conducted a similar study focusing on teenagers found that despite the generally low levels of reflection among young people regarding the information they receive from the mass media, those who showed a greater interest in searches of scientific topics also showed higher levels of reflective thinking.
According to the literature, the public’s political beliefs tend to be inextricably intertwined with whether there is reflective thought about the information disseminated by the mass media (
Kahan 2013). This is explained by the fact that people’s political beliefs influence the way they interpret and interact with mass media content and how they are influenced by it. In any case, reflective thinking helps members of the public be more aware of the purpose behind any information conveyed by the media or whether that purpose is to influence their political beliefs towards specific directions to cover specific interests (
Blumler and Gurevitch 2005). The literature focuses more on political beliefs than on social or economic ones, as global policies, whether at a socio-economic or any other level, are predominantly influenced by political parties and competent governments.
Furthermore, there are reports suggesting a potential correlation between the frequency of watching talk shows and the development of reflective thinking among the public. For instance, individuals who regularly engage with talk shows are exposed to a variety of opinions and perspectives, thereby fostering a greater capacity for reflective thought compared to those who infrequently watch such programs and consequently lack exposure to diverse viewpoints on recurring issues (
Ho and Chuah 2022;
Livingstone and Lunt 2002).
After all, it is considered necessary for young people to search, evaluate, utilize, and create information for the fulfillment of their personal, social, professional, and educational goals. It is also important that they possess basic skills of critical and reflective thinking and utilize them for purposes of promotion of their expression so that they become well-informed citizens and participate in the governance and democratic processes of society with responsibility and prudence (
UNESCO 2011).
Finally, though
Hobbs et al. (
2022) underlined that “self-report measures can be useful, too, but some subjects may not be able to self-assess their media literacy competencies and others may choose a more socially acceptable answer rather than one that reflects their lived experience” it should be mentioned that many researchers (
Nelson 2016;
Stanley and Lawson 2020) use self-report questionnaires to measure both adolescents’ media literacy and critical thinking on media use.
Based on the literature review above, it is evident that due to the limited research conducted on the topic, a comprehensive understanding is currently unattainable. This underscores the significant research gap pertaining to the perceptions and beliefs of young audiences regarding various aspects of television viewing. The present study aims to address this gap by focusing on the perspectives of Greek youths.
4. Results and Discussion
The demographic results show that 51.5% of the participants are girls, while 48.5% re boys; 27.9% of participants are 16yearolds, 25% are 17yearolds, 25% are 18yearolds, and finally, 22.1% are 15yearolds. In addition, 52.5% of participants stated that their father attended university, and 55.9% stated that their mother attended university. Finally, 54.9% of the participants do not consider themselves good students.
The results about the participants’ TV personal viewing show that 35.8% of them watch less than half an hour of TV daily, while 33.8% said they watch more than 3 h of TV every day. Similarly, 35.8% of participants stated that their parents do not watch TV with them; 34.8% said they never watch the news, while 33.8% declared that they watch the news every day. In addition, 35.3% of participants said they watch documentaries daily, and 34.3% of them do not watch documentaries at all. Finally, 34.3% of the participants stated that they do not watch talk shows at all, while 32.8% watch them every day.
As seen in
Table 1, participants somewhat agree with the following statements. The highest mean, however, is shown for the sentence “
Documentaries present facts and pictures in such a way that together they make up a believable story” (M = 3.39/5.00). Since these questions suggest the existence of adolescents’ reflective attitude towards media, this result shows moderate reflective thinking.
As shown in
Table 2, statistically significant correlations were found if the displayed
p-values are less than 0.05. In the cases where statistically significant correlations were found, it is pointed out that the highest levels of agreement with the statements concerning documentaries were found in participants who watch TV more often, whose parents watch TV with them more often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows more often.
Also, it was found that higher levels of agreement with the statements regarding the documentaries occur in the participants who consider themselves to be good students.
The results of
Table 3 indicate that the participants moderately agree with the following statements. The highest mean, however, was found for the sentence “
News stations can be different in how they present a story because of differences in their political preference” (M = 3.21/5.00). As these questions show the existence of adolescents’ reflective attitudes towards media, this result shows moderate reflective thinking.
As shown in
Table 4, statistically significant correlations were found if the displayed
p-values are less than 0.05. In the cases where statistically significant correlations were found, it is pointed out that the highest levels of agreement with the statements concerning politics were found in participants who watch TV more often, whose parents watch TV with them more often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows more often. Also, it was found that higher levels of agreement with the statements regarding the documentaries occur in the participants who consider themselves to be good students.
The results in
Table 5 indicate that participants agree with the following statements a little to moderately. The highest mean, however, was found for the sentence “
TV influences how younger children treat their parents” (M = 3.21/5.00), and the lowest mean was found for the sentence “
TV has nothing to do with how young people think about drugs” (M= 2.30/5.00). As these questions indicate the existence of adolescents’ reflective attitudes towards media, this result shows moderate reflective thinking.
As shown in
Table 6, statistically significant correlations were found if the displayed
p-values are less than 0.05. In the cases where statistically significant correlations were found, it is pointed out that the highest levels of agreement with the statements “
TV influences how younger children treat their parents”, “
TV influences how children our age treat their parents”, “
Children who watch the news know more about politics than children who do not watch the news”, and “
Parents have the same opinions about TV programs, such as the news, as their children do” concerning politics were found in participants who watch TV more often, whose parents watch TV with them more often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows more often. Also, it was found that higher levels of agreement with these four statements regarding the documentaries occur in the participants who consider themselves to be good students.
The highest levels of agreement with the statements “TV has nothing to do with how young people think about drugs” and “TV has nothing to do with what young people wear to parties” concerning politics were found in participants who watch TV rarely, whose parents watch TV with them less often, and who watch news, documentaries and talk shows less often. It was found that higher levels of agreement with these two statements regarding the documentaries occur in the cases of participants who consider themselves to be bad students.
As seen in
Table 7, participants somewhat agree with the following statements. The highest mean, however, was found for the sentence “
When an event is presented on the news, it looks the same as when you were there and saw it yourself” (M = 3.13/5.00). As these questions show the existence of adolescents’ reflective attitudes towards media, this result shows moderate reflective thinking.
As shown in
Table 8, statistically significant correlations occurred if the displayed
p-values are less than 0.05. In the cases where statistically significant correlations were found, it is pointed out that the highest levels of agreement with the statements “
News programs are too short to show all the important stories of that day”, “
Whether a TV station has to make money off its programs or not will influence the kind of news programs it makes”, “
Every TV station will present news on the Islam the same way”, “
When an event is presented on the news, it looks the same as when you were there and saw it yourself” and “
News about gay marriages is presented in the same way in different countries” concerning presentations were found in participants who watch TV more often, whose parents watch TV with them more often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows more often. Also, higher levels of agreement with these four statements regarding the documentaries were found in the cases of participants who consider themselves to be good students.
What is more, the highest levels of agreement with the statements “The description of an event on the news is complete” concerning presentations were found in participants who watch TV rarely, whose parents watch TV with them less often, and who watch news, documentaries and talk shows less often. Higher levels of agreement with these two statements regarding the documentaries were also found in the cases of participants who consider themselves to be bad students.
The results of
Table 9 indicate that the participants moderately agree with the following statements. The highest mean, however, was found in the sentence “
All TV stations have to make money off their programs” (M= 3.09/5.00). As these questions show the existence of adolescents’ reflective attitudes towards media, this result shows moderate reflective thinking.
As shown in
Table 10, statistically significant correlations occurred if the displayed
p-values are less than 0.05. In the cases where statistically significant correlations were found, it is pointed out that the highest levels of agreement with the statements “
The stories you see on the news are about the only important events that took place that day”, “
All TV stations have to make money off their programs”, “
Every TV station will present news on the Islam the same way", and “
Fans of a TV program can influence what happens on that show” concerning TV in general were found in participants who watch TV more often, whose parents watch TV with them more often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows more often. Also, higher levels of agreement with these four statements regarding the documentaries are shown in the participants who consider themselves to be good students.
The highest levels of agreement with the statement “TV news presents a complete picture of what’s going on in the world” concerning TV in general were found in participants who watch TV rarely, whose parents watch TV with them less often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows less often. Also, it was found that higher levels of agreement with these two statements regarding the documentaries were found in the cases of participants who consider themselves to be bad students.
Table 11 indicates that the participants moderately agree with the following statements. The highest mean, however, was found for the sentence “
When you watch a news program because you have to for school, you’ll have a different opinion of that program than when you watch it because you want to” (M = 3.29/5.00). As these questions show the existence of adolescents’ reflective attitudes towards media, this result shows moderate reflective thinking.
As shown in
Table 12, statistically significant correlations occurred if the displayed
p-values are less than 0.05. In the cases where statistically significant correlations were found, it is pointed out that the highest levels of agreement with the statements “
Differences in TV content is one of the reasons why people in different countries think differently about issues such as gay marriages” and
“When you watch a news program because you have to for school, you’ll have a different opinion of that program than when you watch it because you want to” concerning watching TV were found in participants who watch TV more often, whose parents watch TV with them more often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows more often. Also, higher levels of agreement with these four statements regarding the documentaries were found in the participants who consider themselves to be good students.
The highest levels of agreement with the statements “People with a lower education will understand the news just as well as people with a higher education” and “People who live in the city react the same to news about diseases as people who live in the countryside” concerning watching TV were found in participants who watch TV rarely, whose parents watch TV with them less often, and who watch news, documentaries, and talk shows less often. Also, higher levels of agreement with these two statements regarding the documentaries were found in the cases of participants who consider themselves to be bad students.