2.1. Optimization of the Procedure for Matrix Separation and Pre-Concentration
Continued development of a methodology for the quantification of Ag, Pd, Pt and Au at ng L
−1 and sub-ng L
−1 concentrations, respectively, in higher mineralized natural waters, which cannot be measured directly/undiluted by ICP-MS, was based on an off-line matrix separation/pre-concentration method for the analysis of dissolved Ag and Pt in seawater [
28]. In brief, in this method, a four-channel manifold with pre-concentration columns filled with the strong anion exchanger Dowex
® 1x8 was used to manually process volumes of each 100 g of seawater acidified with 0.024-mol L
−1 HCl. Elution with 2.5 g of a mixture of 4-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 0.5-mol L
−1 HCl led to enrichment factors of 40–45, which allowed an open ocean seawater analysis.
The present study aimed at automation and the operation of the automated system in an online mode, hence direct coupling to the ICP-SFMS for transient signal data acquisition. Compared to the off-line matrix separation/pre-concentration manifold, <10 mL of sample volume was loaded onto the column; however, the flow rates for sample loading, rinsing and pre-conditioning remained at 2 mL min
−1 (see
Section 3.3.1).
As more and novel anion exchanger resins, respectively, have been available recently, these were also tested for extraction of the selected metals—in particular, the TK201 resin B (tertiary amine), TEVA® Resin (aliphatic quaternary amine), DGA resin (N,N,N’,N’-tetra-2-ethylhexyldiglycolamide) and the CL resin. Aliquots of diluted (1:10) seawater samples were spiked with 10 ng L−1 of Ag, Pd, Pt and Au and extracted under identical conditions on the different resins. A comparison of the elution profiles showed a low signal response and wide and tailing peaks when using the DGA and CL resins (results are not shown), indicating a weaker affinity for the target analytes and/or a very strong retention and weak elution with the used acid solution.
In contrast to Dowex
®1x8, the signal responses strongly increased after extraction of the target metals on the TEVA
® Resin, and the elution profiles showed higher and narrower symmetric peak shapes compared to those after extraction on Dowex
®1x8.
Figure 2 shows the elution profiles obtained for Ag, Pd, Pt and Au (10 ng L
−1) in 10% seawater. Additionally, TK201 resin B was tested, and similar characteristics with respect to the signal response and peak width were obtained (elution profile not shown). The only differences between TEVA
® resin and TK201 resin B were the peak shapes of the Pd isotopes, which showed a slight tailing when using TK201 resin B. Hence, the TEVA
® resin was chosen for further experiments to optimize the matrix separation and pre-concentration procedures for the quantification of Ag, Pd, Pt and Au in ground water samples.
Initial experiments were performed to study the effects of the column length and the sample volume loaded onto the column. Therefore, PEEK columns of different sizes (50 × 2.1-mm inner diameter; volume ≈ 173 µL and 30 × 2.1-mm inner diameter; volume ≈ 104 µL) packed with resin were used. Seawater samples (1:10 diluted) spiked with 10 ng L−1 of a standard containing Ag, Pd, Pt and Au were analyzed with both columns. Signal intensities of eluted interfering matrix components and Sr and Mo significantly decreased when the smaller pre-concentration column (104-µL volume) was used, whereas those of the target elements increased by a factor of two. Signal intensities resulting from sample volumes of 4 mL and 8 mL were compared, and the highest intensities were obtained when 8 mL of sample were loaded on the smaller column; hence, good matrix separation and pre-concentration of the target analytes could be achieved.
A series of experiments was further conducted, including parameters such as sample acidity, composition and acidity of elution reagents and matrix effects.
The chloride concentration in water is one of the main factors influencing the speciation of the target metals and, hence, retention of the respective chloro complexes with the anion exchange resin. The modeling of inorganic Ag speciation, as performed by Barriada et al. [
29], showed an increase of double and triple negatively charged Ag chloro complexes (AgCl
32−, AgCl
43−) at increased salinities (chloride concentrations ranging from 0 to 0.55 mol L
−1 representing low-salinity riverine and estuarine waters and seawater) and, hence, increased Ag signal response with increasing salinity after the extraction of Ag from seawater on the strong anion exchanger Dowex
® 1x8. This effect was also investigated by another study [
13], whereby sample solutions with different NaCl concentrations (0–10% NaCl and seawater spiked with Ag) were adjusted with varying concentrations of HCl (0–2 mol L
−1). The authors reported the most efficient Ag retention at chloride concentrations from 0.05 to 0.5 mol L
−1 and decreased retention at lower or higher total chloride concentrations as a result of incomplete Ag chloro complex formation and an excess of chloride in the sample, respectively. We studied this effect by extracting aliquots of 10% (
v/v) seawater spiked with 10 ng L
−1 of Ag, Pd, Pt and Au with HCl at concentrations ranging from 0.024 to 0.200 mol L
−1 on the TEVA
® Resin. The results of this experiment are shown in
Figure 3. The highest signal response for Ag and Au could be obtained with a HCl concentration of 0.024 mol L
−1 in the sample, whereas the effect was most significant for the response of Au, as the signal intensity was increased by 70% compared to these obtained with higher HCl concentrations. Though the speciation of gold in the aqueous environment is very diverse [
24], the Au chloro complexes Au(III)Cl
4− and Au(I)/(III)Cl
2− are considered to be the dominant species in oceanic waters, but the AuOH(H
2O) complex is also present in oxygenated ocean waters [
30], and consequently, it can be assumed that the chloro complex formation is driven by the chloride content in the sample. The response for Pd and Pt was not affected by this extent, as the signal intensities obtained at different acidities were in the range of ±20%.
Furthermore, it could be shown that the signal response for Mo and Sr, whose oxides and hydroxides form polyatomic interferences on the Ag
− and Pd
− isotopes, and Cd, which is isobarically interfering on the Pd isotopes
106Pd,
108Pd and
110Pd, decreased with increasing HCl concentrations in the sample (see
Figure 4). This finding has been also published earlier for Mo, Zr and Nb [
13], and thus, the researchers chose a higher HCl concentration to minimize polyatomic interferences on the Ag isotopes. Our results showed that an increase in the HCl concentration from 0.024 mol L
−1 to 0.1 mol L
−1 resulted in a decrease of the interfering species of approximately 65% and further decreased with further increasing the HCl concentration in the sample solution. However, aiming at the highest possible response for Au, an HCl concentration of 0.024 mol L
−1 was chosen, and the reduction of oxide-based interferences by using membrane desolvation sample introduction as an alternative to a conventional glass or Teflon
® PFA spray chamber was applied (see
Section 2.2).
The elution conditions were optimized with respect to the acid strength and composition. Previous experiments were performed with an elution acid containing 4-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 1-mol L
−1 HCl. The eluted metals extracted on the TEVA
® Resin showed high and narrow peaks, with a peak width of only 25–30 s compared to 55–110 s when Dowex
® 1x8 was used (see
Figure 2). Hence, we tested weather weaker elution acids also led to an effective elution. Seawater was spiked with 10 ng L
−1 of Ag, Pd, Pt and Au, and for the elution, three different eluent solutions were tested: 3-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 1-mol L
−1 HCl, 2-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 0.5-mol L
−1 HCl and 1-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 0.5-mol L
−1 HCl. The obtained elution profiles are shown in
Figure 5. It could be seen that the eluent composition with the lowest acid strengths resulted in significantly lower signal intensities and broadening of the peaks. This could be observed for all the target elements to a similar extent. However, the use of an elution acid mixture of 3-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 1-mol L
−1 HCl or 2-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 0.5-mol L
−1 HCl, respectively, did not show significant differences compared to the initially used 4-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 1 mol L
−1. As a result, a mixture of 2-mol L
−1 HNO
3 + 0.5-mol L
−1 HCl was chosen for the elution of the target analytes.
To conclude, the extraction of Ag, Pd, Pt and Au on the TEVA
® Resin showed advantages with respect to the signal response, the peak width and the shape and the elution conditions.
Table 1 shows a comparison of the sensitivities obtained estimated from standard addition curves in 1:10 diluted seawater (concentrations ranged from 0 to 10 ng L
−1). It can be clearly seen that the sensitivities increased by a factor of approximately two (Au) to five (Ag) when using the strong anion exchange resin TEVA
® Resin. While the peak tailing was severe when using Dowex
®1x8, resulting in broad signals with 55 s (Ag) to 110 s (Pt, Pd and Au), narrow and symmetrical peaks only 25–30-s wide were obtained for Ag, Pd and Pt with the TEVA
® Resin; hence, theoretical pre-concentration factors of approximately 9–16 could be obtained from a sample volume of 8 mL. It has to be pointed out that, for elution on TEVA
® Resin, only half the acid strength, compared to Dowex
®1x8, was required for an efficient elution of the target analytes. The elution time was set to 5 min at a flow rate of 1 mL min
−1 to sufficiently clean the resin to prevent carryover. In a follow-up project, where this method was applied for the analysis of Ag in seawater, the eluent flow rate was reduced to 400 µL min
−1 without sacrificing the performance, which made splitting of the eluent unneeded (not published yet).
2.2. Interferences
Using conventional glass or Teflon
® PFA spray chambers and applying plasma conditions, resulting in an oxide formation of 2–5% oxide-based interferences on some of the investigated elements and, in particular, on the Pd isotopes do not allow the accurate quantification of these elements. Inefficient separation of Sr and Mo from the target analytes on the anion exchange resin resulted in a contribution of the respective oxide species, which were much higher compared to the low concentrations expected for the target analytes. We studied this effect by analyzing a standard curve containing 1–100-µg L
−1 Mo in 0.024-M L
−1 HCl (total Mo concentrations from 0.01 to 78.72 µg L
−1 were measured in the investigated ground water samples; published in Reference [
27] (the version in German language only)) with the matrix separation/pre-concentration method directly coupled to ICP-SFMS using a Scott-type Teflon
® PFA spray chamber. From the slopes of the resulting standard curves, a contribution of approximately 0.25% from Mo (as
92Mo
16O
+) on the
108Pd
+ isotope was calculated. Considering the Pd concentrations in the samples being lower by at least a factor of 1000, this interference would have severe effects on the quantitative results. By using the APEX Ω membrane desolvation unit, the oxide formation rate, evaluated on the
238U
16O
+/
238U
+ ratio, could be reduced to ≤0.05%; hence, the oxide-based interferences were significantly reduced for all the elements prone to oxide formation. This was verified by the repeated measurement of a Mo calibration standard curve (0–100 µg L
−1 in the eluent matrix) by flow injection using the SC
oneFAST six-port valve and a small sample loop (100-µL sample volume) instead of the matrix separation/pre-concentration system; a simulation of the “worst case”, viz., Mo, was quantitatively introduced into the ICP-MS (not only the fraction, which was retained on the anion exchange resin as the molybdate ion). The results did not show any detectable signal for
108Pd
+; thus, the formation of oxide-based interferences could be sufficiently suppressed. The advantages of using a membrane desolvation unit could also be shown by Turretta et al. [
31] for the direct determination of Pt in diluted seawater, which was hampered by the formation of
179Hf
16O
+ on
195Pt
+.
However, mathematical interference correction of the isobarically interfering Cd isotopes on
106Pd
+ and
108Pd
+, referring to
111Cd
+, was performed as described in Method 200.8, Revision 5.4 (1994) [
32] to obtain accurate
106Pd/
108Pd isotope ratios (the accuracy was evaluated based on the published values by IUPAC [
33] for a natural abundance isotope standard and the certified abundances for the isotopically enriched standard). In 26 of the total 55 investigated ground water samples, total Cd concentrations of 0.004–0.47 µg L
−1 were determined [
27]. The contributing
106Cd (1.25% abundance) and
108Cd (0.89% abundance) signals were in the range of 1–33% (in two samples, even 258 and 378%) and 1–3% of the measured
106Pd and
108Pd isotopes, respectively. This approach was necessary, as uncorrected intensities, resulting in incorrect isotope ratios, would have increased the concentrations—depending on the Cd concentration—up to 27% and, in some samples, even by a factor of 2.5–8.3.
2.3. Matrix Effects
As already discussed earlier, the chloro complex species formation of the target analytes clearly depends on the chloride concentration in the sample, and the retention on the anion exchange resin depends on the fraction of negatively charged chloro complexes [
13,
29].
The total matrix content and composition (major ion concentration) may be important factors also, which influence the complexing characteristics and, consequently, retention on chelating sorbents and anion exchangers, respectively. As shown in
Figure 1, the mineral waters investigated showed highly varying matrix compositions and concentrations (sum of the cations and anions), ranging from 26 mg L
−1 to 7011 mg L
−1. Approximately 30% of the samples showed major ion concentrations <100 mg L
−1, which corresponds to the salinity of crystalline waters. Concentrations >1000 mg L
−1 were measured in 12 samples; this can be attributed to saline aquifers. Thus, the effects of varying matrix compositions on the retention of Ag, Pd, Pt and Au were studied.
Standard additions of concentrations ranging from 0 to 10 ng L
−1 to the selected ground water samples (US 13: 6100 mg L
−1, Cl
−: 2004 mg L
−1; US 22: 14.0 mg L
−1; Cl
− <0.5 mg L
−1; US 36: 1461 mg L
−1, Cl
−: 297 mg L
−1) with varying characteristics (all acidified with 0.024-mol L
−1 HCl) and an external calibration standard curve at 0.024-mol L
−1 HCl were quantified. The results obtained are exemplarily shown for Ag and Pt (see
Figure 6). As can be seen, the obtained sensitivities varied significantly. These results were expected due to the strong dependence of the chloride concentrations on the chloro complex formation—in particular, for Ag. An additional experiment was performed with samples with more similar characteristics (US 28, US 29 and US 31 with a maximum concentration of the major ions of 300 mg L
−1 and <0.5–2.2-mg L
−1 Cl
− concentration), and similar results were obtained. No clear trend, for instance, increasing/decreasing sensitivity with increasing/decreasing chloride concentrations and total major ion concentrations, respectively, could be observed. These results indicate that quantification by external calibration does not give accurate results, and therefore, an isotope dilution analysis is a prerequisite to compensate for this matrix effect. Due to the monoisotopic characteristics of Au, the application of standard additions had to be applied to obtain reasonable concentrations.
2.4. Validation
Validation parameters for the method, including instrument sensitivity, background equivalent concentrations (BEC) and detection and quantification limits (DL and QL), trueness and precision are summarized in the following tables.
Table 2 shows the sensitivity of the method, determined from the slope of an external calibration in 0.024-M L
−1 HCl and standard additions in seawater for comparison. As already discussed in
Section 2.3, the matrix effects resulting from varying major ion compositions and concentrations were severe, leading to different slopes of the standard curves. The procedural blank concentrations (background equivalent concentrations—BEC, calculated based on the blank intensity and the intensity of a 1-ng L
−1 standard in 0.024-M L
−1 HCl), DL and QL, calculated as three and 10 times the standard deviation of the blanks (
n ≥ 6) based on the sensitivity of the external calibration and from the blank concentrations of
n = 8
108Pd spiked blank samples, respectively, were given in ng L
−1.
In
Table 3, the quantification accuracy, based on a spike recovery experiment, is shown. Quantification was performed by IDA and matrix-matched external calibration for Au, respectively, on the native sample (
n = 3) and the sample with a known concentration of the standard added. The recoveries were in the range of 97.4–119%.
Due to the lack of matrix reference materials certified for precious metals, we used the environmental matrix reference material TM 35 (Lake Ontario water), which is certified for Ag (3.7 µg ± 0.44 µg L
−1), and repeatedly measured it using gravimetrical dilution by a factor of 500. The target value was 7.40 ± 0.88 ng L
−1 and, hence, more in the range of the expected Ag concentrations in the investigated ground water samples. Quantification by IDA resulted in a mean Ag concentration of 7.46 ± 0.114 ng L
−1, indicating trueness and high precision; however, in the diluted reference materials, Pd, Pt and Au could not be detected (see
Table 4).
To estimate the quantification accuracy of Pd, Pt and Au, two Gabbro rock PGE reference materials (WGB-1 and WMG-1), certified for Pd, Pt and Au, were used after mineralization by microwave-assisted aqua regia/HF digestion and further dilution in 0.024-mol L−1 HCl. The approximate dilution factors, resulting from digestion and gravimetrical dilution of the digest, were 20,000 and 200,000, and the target values were calculated accordingly based on the certified values. Quantification was performed by external calibration in 0.024-mol L−1 HCl and IDA (Ag, Pd and Au) and IDA, respectively. The average concentrations ± 1 SD measured in the WGB-1 and WMG-1 reference samples were in agreement with the derived concentrations within the respective uncertainty, except for Pd in WMG-1, as the recoveries were 89% (external calibration) and 119% (IDA), respectively. Noticeably, the Pd- and Ag- concentrations (in WGB-1) quantified based on the slope of the external calibration curve were significantly lower than those measured by IDA; this might not be related to the matrix effects though, as the concentration of major constituents affecting sensitivity was regarded as negligible due to the high dilution in pure 0.024-mol L−1 HCl. The overall precision ranged from 0.5% to 9% relative standard deviation, but no relation could be seen with the type of quantification or values close to the QL.
The ratio precisions, estimated from the elution profiles of certified natural abundant standards for
107Ag/
109Ag,
106Pd/
108Pd and
159Pt/
196Pt, are shown in
Table 5. Short-term precision was calculated from
n = 3 consecutive measurements and was in the range of 0.05%–0.66%, whereas that of Pd was significantly poorer than those obtained for Ag and Pt. Long-term precision was calculated from
n = 20 measurements during a sequence of approximately 52 h. The ratio precisions increased up to 3.67%, and again, for Pd, the lowest precision was obtained. The mass bias per mass unit (MB) in percentage was calculated according to Xie and Kerrich [
34] (MB–calculated as MB (%) = (R
true/R
measured − 1) * 100) considering the “true value”, as defined in the isotopic compositions of the elements from 1997, as defined by IUPAC [
33]. The deviations from the “true value” were low (max—1.30%).
The repeatability of the measured isotope ratios of the natural abundance standards and of the measured isotope ratio of the enriched standards was taken into account for the calculation of the concentrations by the equation; hence, a correction factor K (K = measured ratio of the natural solution/natural abundance ratio) was not considered. Correction of the MB during the measurement sequence was performed by standard bracketing every sixth sample using the certified natural abundant standards; however, due to the low differences and the high precision, the impact on the result was negligible.