1. Introduction
Worldwide, about 85 million units of red blood cells are transfused annually [
1] and an increasing need for blood is observed. However, the transfusion of red blood cells holds risks and limitations. Mismatched transfusions as well as transmissible infections present a major health hazard [
2]. Additionally, the storage time of red blood cells is limited, cold chain principles must be respected and the logistics are highly demanding. Clearly, there is a highly and fast growing demand for an artificial oxygen carrier which is able to carry and deliver oxygen at the sites of need.
The search for an artificial blood substitute based on oxygen carriers has presented a great challenge in transfusion medicine for more than three decades. In the focus of research are hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs) [
3]. However, clinical applications of such agents in humans is not yet possible due to several issues which need to be solved to ensure the patients’ safety. As free hemoglobin (Hb) induces strong vasoconstriction and hypertension [
4], modified hemoglobin has been intensely investigated. Several modifications were based on intra- or intermolecular cross-linking or encapsulation. Diaspirin cross-linked hemoglobin (DCHb) or polymerized bovine hemoglobin showed potential for surgical patients in clinical trials, but also limitations caused by severe side effects like pulmonary hypertension and cardiac depression [
5]. Oxygen oversupply due to low oxygen binding affinity and scavenging of nitric oxide (NO), respectively, might be the reasons [
6]. Stroma-free hemoglobin passes the endothelial gaps of the capillary walls leading to nitric oxide binding. The bioavailability of NO is crucial to maintain homeostatic vascular function. It enables direct and indirect vasodilation and can be responsible for anti-thrombotic, anti-inflammatory and anti-proliferative effects [
7]. Scavenging of NO can lead to vasoconstriction, thrombosis, inflammation, vascular hypertrophy and stenosis. Therefore, hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers should not be able to penetrate the endothelial gaps requiring that all their dimensions should exceed 100 nm [
8]. Furthermore, clearance by phagocytes must be avoided. Hence, the dimensions of particles in a blood substitute must be smaller than 1 µm. It follows that particles in the submicron size range are the most promising approach.
Besides encapsulated Hb, loaded into lipid microvesicles [
3], a promising method for fabrication of such hemoglobin particles is the co-precipitation–cross-linking–dissolution technique [
8,
9,
10]. This method allows the entrapment of hemoglobin by co-precipitation with inorganic salts like manganese chloride (MnCl
2) and sodium carbonate (Na
2CO
3) forming the Hb-containing template followed by a coverage with human serum albumin (HSA). Subsequently, hemoglobin and albumin molecules are cross-linked with glutaraldehyde. The dissolution of the template with ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) results in hemoglobin microparticles (HbMPs) with an average diameter of 700 nm with a narrow size distribution and a nearly uniform peanut-shaped morphology. The particles are able to bind and release oxygen. They show a low immunogenicity and no vasoconstrictive effects on afferent arterioles of mouse kidney glomeruli [
10].
The approval of HBOCs for animal experiments and (pre-) clinical studies requires, besides investigations of toxicology and biocompatibility, also the characterization of the physical and physicochemical properties of the respective material. Morphological features of the particles, i.e. size, shape, density as well as the methemoglobin (metHb), oxyhemoglobin (oxyHb), deoxyhemoglobin (deoxyHb) amounts and the oxygen binding capacity need to be determined. It is important that these quantities are accessible for quality control by a rapid and reliable method. This demand cannot be met by standard procedures applied in laboratory medicine. In particular, HbMPs cannot be lysed like erythrocytes, photometric measurements are disturbed by light scattering, oxygen release measurements are time consuming and the deoxyHb content cannot be determined at present. To address this gap and to establish a rapid and reliable characterization of suspensions of HbMPs, we apply spectral transmission measurement and data analysis and present results in this paper. Our method, designated as spectral extinction measurement in particle suspensions and analysis (SEMPA) was recently demonstrated to allow the determination of size and refractive index of sphered erythrocytes [
11]. By selecting the appropriate model for light scattering, i.e. Lorenz-Mie theory [
12] for spherical particles or the T-matrix [
13] method for small non-spherical particles with high symmetries, the ensemble averaged spectral extinction cross section of the particles is calculated. This measurand, i.e. the quantity to be measured [
14], sensitively depends on the complex refractive index (RI) [
15] and hence on the composition of the particles investigated. In our work, we analyze spectral extinction cross sections to determine the content of metHb, oxyHb as well as heme-free globins (Gl)/human serum albumin (HSA) of a specific batch of HbMPs.
For the validation of our spectral extinction measurements, we applied near edge X-ray absorption fine structure (NEXAFS) fluorescence measurements, being sensitive to the ratio of Fe(II) and Fe(III) thus allowing the determination of the relative concentrations of functional sum of oxyHb and deoxyHb and metHb. Alternatively, as demonstrated recently, the metHb fraction of the total Hb content and the total Hb concentration are accessible by NMR relaxometry [
16].
Our investigations were complemented to support the analyses of spectral extinction measurements and interpretation of results. For this purpose, we applied scanning electron microscopy (SEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), dynamic light scattering (DLS), analytical centrifugation (AC), flow cytometric measurements (FCM), high accuracy density measurement and spectrophotometric determination of the hemoglobin concentration after previous enzymatic digestion. In addition, the packed particle volume (PPV) was determined accounting for the elastic deformability of the HbMP.
The fundamental advantage of our approach is that intact microparticles are analyzed in suspension by extinction measurements. The straightforward access to the essential features of the particle ensemble stands in contrast to presently applied indirect methods. In particular, the ratio of oxyHb/deoxyHb as well as the content of metHb are not accessible by such indirect measurements, but can now be determined by SEMPA, since oxygenation and deoxygenation can be reversibly carried out.
We expect that our method can be used for the quantification of the function of various particles based HBOCs and possibly contribute to the optimization of their fabrication thus facilitating the initiation of pre-clinical studies.
2. Results and Discussion
2.1. Fabrication of Hemoglobin Microparticles
Hemoglobin microparticles particles (HbMPs) were fabricated as described previously [
10], a schematic of the production process is illustrated in
Figure 1a. Briefly, bovine hemoglobin (10 mg/mL) was entrapped by co-precipitation of 0.25 mol L
−1 manganese chloride (MnCl
2) and 0.25 mol L
−1 sodium carbonate (Na
2CO
3) and the resulting particles are covered with human serum albumin (HSA). Hemoglobin and albumin molecules were cross-linked by glutaraldehyde with a final concentration of 0.04%. and the salt templates were dissolved by 0.18 mol L
−1 EDTA resulting in the final HbMPs.
2.2. Morphology of Hemoglobin Microparticles
To obtain access to the shape of the particles and to estimate the size, we applied scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM). As is evident from
Figure 1b–e the particles exhibit a non-spherical, peanut like shape with a ratio between the short and long axes of approximately 1:1.5. Inspection of SEM and AFM images yields a range between 600 nm and 1100 nm for the long axis of the particles. Our observations show that the size of the particles derived from SEM is smaller compared to AFM, which is explained by the different preparation procedures. For SEM, the samples must be dried and the particles are covered by a thin platinum layer. Hence, due to dehumidification shrinking of the HbMPs might be induced [
17]. On the other hand, AFM images are taken in solution approximately matching the biological environment for the intended application. The particles in
Figure 1d,e, imaged by AFM, were oriented differently, one with its long axis parallel (
Figure 1d) and the other with the particle’s long axis upright (
Figure 1e) with respect to the surface. Due to their different orientation, the maximum heights (encoded in false colors) of the particles relative to the surface, are approximately 600 nm and 900 nm, respectively. In SEM and AFM images, the waist of the particles is visible. Furthermore, both methods reveal the fine structure of the surface, which is associated with the MnCO
3 scaffold used to incorporate the proteins and which is finally removed when producing the HbMPs.
2.3. Optical Determination of metHb in Hemoglobin Microparticles
To measure collimated transmittance spectra of diluted HbMP suspensions, we used a dedicated optical setup [
11] (
Figure S1), described in more detail in the Materials and Methods section. Regular spectrophotometers are intended for purely absorbing samples but unsuitable for the quantitative analysis of light-scattering samples. In contrast, our setup allows the quantitative determination of the spectral extinction cross section of the HbMPs in suspension, since unwanted contributions from light scattered in non-forward directions are negligible due to the small divergence of the incident light beam and a low angle of detection for the transmitted light.
We derived from the measured spectral transmittance
of the particle ensemble the average spectral extinction cross section
according to:
where
denotes the concentration of HbMPs in the stock suspension,
the volume fraction of the stock suspension in the measurement suspension and
the absorption length of the cuvette.
In order to avoid the influence of large uncertainties associated with the direct flow cytometric measurement of the concentration
and the values derived from particle size and the packed particle volume (PPV) (see
Section 2.5. Physical Properties of HbMPs), for quantitative comparison we consider the quantity:
being the volume-specific extinction cross section (VSECS). The symbol
is the mean volume of the HbMPs and PPV, i.e. packed particle volume denotes the solid fraction of particles in the stock solution. The advantage of our approach is that the PPV is known to higher accuracy than the particle concentration in the stock suspension. Furthermore, compared to
,
changes only moderately with the mean particle size (
Figures S2 and S3), while being equally sensitive to the relative Hb composition.
Experimental results and calculated extinction spectra are compared for three differently treated samples: (a) exposed to air and hence saturated with oxygen, (b) treated with sodium nitrite (NaNO
2) to convert all Hb components to metHb and (c) purged with argon to obtain deoxygenated Hb. These preparations are referred to in
Figure 2 and in the following as (a) oxyHbMP and (b) metHbMP. The case (c) is shown in
Figure 3 as “measurement (argon)”. Calculations are based on the Lorenz-Mie theory [
12,
15] taking into account the known optical properties of the individual proteins in the HbMPs (see
Section 3.6. Model for optical properties). Lorenz-Mie theory refers to the exact mathematical solution for the scattering and absorption of light by a homogeneous spherical particle. Its use is justified here because the influence of the HbMPs’ non-spherical shape on the extinction spectra was proven to be negligible [
18].
In
Figure 2a, the measured extinction cross section of oxyHbMP reveals the decrease of the cross section with increasing wavelength, caused by light scattering as well as the absorption bands of hemoglobin centered at about 413 nm (Soret band), 543 nm and 578 nm (Q-band). The corresponding calculated cross section was varied with respect to the ratio of oxyHb and metHb and compared to measured spectra. The resulting simulated curve in
Figure 2a, obtained for 35% metHb abundance relative to the total Hb, does reflect the same behavior as the measured one, except the shift to higher values of the volume-specific cross section
. We attribute this deviation in the smaller measured cross sections, which were observed in all measurements, to systematic uncertainties caused: (i) by particle loss due to adhesion when pipetting, (ii) by agglomeration, (iii) or by trapped volume leading to a systematic increase in the PPV value. However, the observed spectral characteristic is well reproduced by our simulations. In addition, based on our simulations we estimated an accuracy for the determination of the metHb fraction to be 5 percentage points, i.e. the uncertainty is given by
, where
is the mass fraction of metHb relative to the total Hb. The spectrum measured for 100% metHb and the related calculated spectral cross section are shown in
Figure 2b. For calibration purposes, the Hb in the HbMP suspension was completely converted to metHb by NaNO
2. Compared to the oxygenated sample, the Soret band is slightly shifted from 413 nm to about 409 nm and its width is somewhat reduced. In addition, the Q bands characteristic for oxyHb are missing and a small metHb specific peak appears at approximately 640 nm. Again, the observed spectral features are reproduced by the cross section simulated for 100% metHb portion. In
Figure 2c,d an enlarged view for the wavelength region of the Soret bands is shown. We include in
Figure 2c results for calculated cross sections assuming different metHb fraction, i.e. 0%, 30% and 50%. The simulated curve for 100% metHb is shown in
Figure 2d for comparison with the experiment. It is obvious from our simulations and measurements that the increase of the metHb portion results in a shift of the Soret band towards smaller wavelengths. The best agreement between measured oxygen saturated HbMP suspensions was obtained for a metHb fraction of 35% and 65% oxyHb.
Besides the samples of HbMPs saturated with oxygen and converted to metHbMP, we studied the transition between oxygenated HbMPs and partially deoxygenated HbMPs. Starting with the fully oxygenated sample as shown in
Figure 2a,c, i.e. the fractions correspond to 65% oxyHb, 35% metHb and 0% deoxyHb, the cuvette was flushed with argon for about 60 min. As can be seen from
Figure 3 the experimental cross section changes when the sample is exposed to argon. Besides the Soret band characteristic for oxyHb, we observe a superposition with the absorbance of deoxyHb, the maximum of which is located at about 430 nm. Deoxygenation using argon is difficult and complete release of oxygen requires an unrealistically long treatment of the sample. Hence, only partial deoxygenation was reached in our experiment and the agreement with the simulation result is best for 32.5% deoxyHb, 32.5% oxyHb and 35% metHb. To illustrate the change of the line shape, we include also calculations for 0% deoxyHb and 65% deoxyHb in
Figure 2e. In particular, for 0% deoxyHb the combination of the metHb and oxyHb bands leads to a slight shift and a broadening of the measured absorption band. On the other hand, for 65% deoxyHb both Soret bands for the respective Hb variants, i.e. metHb and deoxyHb, are clearly discernable.
2.4. MetHb Detection by X-ray Fluorescence
Near edge X-ray absorption fine structure (NEXAFS) is sensitive for the chemical state of the targeted element. Hence, due to the different oxidation states of iron Fe(II) and Fe(III) in oxyHb/deoxyHb and metHb, both variants are distinguishable in the HbMP suspension by scanning the photon energy of the exciting radiation across the L2 and L3 absorption edges of iron. The scanning range between 698 to 736 eV corresponds to a range of vacuum wavelengths between 1.776 to 1.685 nm.
In
Figure 4a NEXAFS fluorescence spectra of two HbMP suspensions are shown, exposed to air (dot-dashed red curve, oxyHbMP) or treated with sodium nitrite (NaNO
2) to convert all Hb variants to metHb (dashed brown trace). For metHbMP, apart from a small shoulder at the low energy edge, the spectrum is dominated by the peak caused by the Fe(III) absorbance. Hence, approximately all Hb variants are converted to metHb. We used this measurement for normalization at 100% metHb content. The spectrum of the oxyHbMP shows a broad absorbance feature between 705 eV and 715 eV with the indication of two superposed maxima. It is evident that these maxima in the oxyHbMP spectrum coincide with the peaks of the Fe(II) and Fe(III) absorbance in the reference spectra [
19]. To guide the eye, we include vertical lines at the corresponding energies. These two contributions to the measured oxyHbMP fluorescence spectrum are illustrated in
Figure 4b. To prove the consistency with results of optical extinction measurements, the measured metHbMP spectrum was scaled according to the 35% metHb content in the oxyHbMP sample (the result is included as brown trace). The resulting difference spectrum (red line) between the measured oxyHbMP fluorescence and the scaled metHbMP exhibits a single Fe(II) peak only, thus being in agreement with the Fe(II) and confirming that the X-ray fluorescence spectra are in accordance with results derived by optical transmission measurements.
2.5. Physical Properties of Hemoglobin Microparticles
To set the size distribution for the analysis of the spectral extinction measurements, we characterized the HbMP sample with respect to the (sphere-equivalent) particle volume, the particle size distribution and the packed particle volume (PPV). In addition, the particle concentration in the stock suspension was determined directly by flow cytometry and derived from the measurements of the particle size and the PPV. Densities of the HbMP stock suspension and the supernatant were measured and used to calculate the density of the HbMP. Densities of reagents used for sample dilution and preparation, i.e. acetated Ringer’s solution and Pronase solution were determined. All values and estimated uncertainties are listed in
Table 1 together with density increments of heme-free globins/HSA and bovine Hb, needed to calculate the density of the HbMP. Details of the different methods applied for the characterization of the HbMP are given in the corresponding paragraphs in Section Materials and Methods, i.e. dynamic light scattering (DLS), analytical centrifugation (AC), determination of the PPV, flow cytometry and density measurements.
The results for the median particle diameter and the relative distribution width differ for the DLS and AC methods. As previously discussed [
20], the determination of particle size in the 10 to 1000 nm range is complex and the results strongly depend on the specific method used. In particular, polydisperse samples like the HbMPs are sensitive to such method specific differences. In addition, elastic properties, porosity and orientation of the HbMPs will influence the determination of size and size distribution. Taking into account that these effects are more pronounced in AC measurements due to the high centrifugation forces, for our analysis of spectral extinction measurements, we rely on the DLS results.
In order to calculate the concentration of the particles in the HbMP stock suspension, the total Hb concentration in the HbMPs and their density, we measured the packed particle volume. The details of the calculations and the PPV measurement are given in the section Materials and Methods. In principle, the PPV is determined similar to hematocrit measurements in blood samples. However, due to the smaller size and lower density of the HbMPs compared to erythrocytes [
21], we increased the relative centrifugal force and the centrifugation time to assure complete sedimentation. To account for the elastic deformability of the HbMPs, the boundary between the solid fraction and the supernatant was read out several times to obtain the final value after about 100 h when relaxation of the particles was complete (
Figure S4). We observed a change of the PPV value of 4%, the end point is given in
Table 1. In our analyses, volume of fluid trapped between the solid phase particle is neglected, hence the value given corresponds to an upper limit.
The particle concentration is calculated using the PPV and the sphere-equivalent volumes determined by DLS and AC. Since the different–method specific–sizes result in correspondingly different concentrations, we used flow cytometry to directly measure the concentration of HbMPs in the stock suspension. However, flow cytometry yields the lowest concentration associated with particle loss due to adhesion on tube and container walls during preparation and measurement and agglomeration of the HbMPs. Taking into account the respective uncertainties, it follows from our observations that at present only a concentration range of 260 pL−1 1125 pL−1 can be reliably given. As consequence, we introduce the volume-specific extinction cross section , defined in Equation (2), which does not explicitly depend on the concentration and only slightly changes with particle size.
In our analysis of the optical extinction spectra, we noted that the experimental data are not well reproduced by the simulations, if the HbMPs are modeled using only the three Hb components for the complex RI. The simulated cross sections are too low under this assumption. Instead, a significant content of heme-free proteins had to be included in the model. Such proteins do not exhibit significant absorption features in the spectral range under consideration, but increase the real part of the RI and hence influence the light-scattering properties, including extinction cross sections. While a certain content of HSA in the HbMPs (≤10% of the total protein content) is expected from the production, the apparent concentration of heme-free proteins is much higher. We attribute this to Hb molecules that lose their heme group during production or storage of the particles, i.e., globin molecules. Throughout the text, the heme-free proteins in the HbMP are referred to as a globin/human serum albumin mixture (Gl/HSA). Their content was assessed by means of high accuracy density measurements.
The densities of the stock suspension of HbMPs and the supernatant were measured by means of an instrument based on a mechanical oscillator method [
22]. In addition, the densities of acetated Ringer’s solution used for diluting the stock suspension for AC measurements and Pronase solution for the enzymatic digestions in context with the spectrophotometric total Hb determination are listed in
Table 1. The value for ultrapure water that served for validation is also included. The uncertainties of typically 10
−4 g mL
−1 represent standard deviations for ≥10 repeat measurements. In analogy with the determination of the density of erythrocytes [
20], we obtain the ensemble averaged density of the HbMPs from the measured densities of the HbMP stock suspension
and the supernatant
in combination with the PPV value (see
Section 3.12. Density of HbMPs) according to:
As described in the Hb Concentration in HbMPs subsection, the density difference
derived from these measurements is compared to calculated values based on the linear superposition of the mass concentrations
of Hb and
of heme-free globin/HSA (
Table 2), weighted by the corresponding density increments DI (see
Table 1):
This comparison reveals that the density difference
cannot be explained by a particle consisting of predominantly hemoglobin and small HSA contributions. A significant mass of heme-free globin must be present. It follows from the absolute mass concentrations given in
Table 2 that the suspension–and most likely also the HbMPs − contains 48% hemoglobin and 52% heme-free globin/HSA. These results derived from the high accuracy density measurement explain the low Hb concentrations in the particle suspension and in the HbMPs.
2.6. MetHb and Functional Hb in Hemoglobin Microparticles
Results for the metHb fraction in HbMPs obtained by spectral extinction measurements and NEXAFS are compared to measurements based on oxygen release [
23,
24,
25], details of which are given in Materials and Methods section. The absolute mass concentrations for the functional Hb components determined by the oxygen release procedure are related to the total Hb concentrations of the stock suspension, listed in
Table 2a. The total Hb concentration was obtained by spectrophotometric absorbance measurements. Briefly, HbMPs were enzymatically digested followed by the alkaline haematin and detergent (AHD) conversion procedure [
26,
27]. In addition, in
Table 2a the values for the Hb mass concentrations in the supernatant of the HbMP stock solution and in the HbMP are given as well as the concentration of heme-free proteins and HSA. As described in Materials and Methods, these values are derived from the measured total Hb mass concentration, high accuracy density measurements and the packed particle volume (PPV), i.e. the solid fraction in the HbMP stock suspension (see
Table 1). The total mass concentrations summarized in
Table 1a elucidate that about 8% of the hemoglobin is not incorporated in the particles or is released during production or storage into the supernatant. The amount of heme-free globins/HSA slightly exceeds 50%.
The part of functional Hb is listed in
Table 2b for the three different preparations of the sample referred to as oxyHbMP for the suspension exposed to air and thus saturated with oxygen, as metHbMP when treated with sodium nitrite (NaNO
2) and deoxyHbMP when using sodium dithionite (Na
2S
2O
4). The oxygen release method allows the determination of absolute values for the functional hemoglobin, for the air-equilibrated suspension the mass concentration is 11.8 g L
−1. As can be seen from the first column in
Table 2b, for the deoxygenated sample as well as for the metHbMP suspension, we still observe a significant oxygen release, indicating that the conversions were not complete. The absolute values were related to the total hemoglobin concentration in the sample (
Table 2a) and we obtain the relative concentrations of non-functional hemoglobin and metHb. In this work, we focus on the comparison of the relative concentrations of the non-functional component for oxygenated samples (
Table 2b, yellow row). The metHbMP suspensions were used for the validation of the spectral extinction and X-ray fluorescence methods, as indicated by the value set to 100%.
It is apparent that the concentration of metHb determined by the oxygen release procedure as difference between the total Hb concentration and the oxyHb concentration is significantly larger compared to the results obtained using spectral extinction and X-ray fluorescence measurements. This discrepancy is attributed to the hindered confirmation change of hemoglobin when embedded in the salt matrix and cross-linked, which results in increased time constants for oxygen intake and release and change in the reaction equilibrium. On the other hand, the optical method distinguishes metHb and oxyHb on the basis of different refractive indices and X-ray spectroscopy is sensitive against Fe(II) and Fe(III), independent on the localization of the two Hb components. The value of 35% determined for the relative metHb concentration corresponds to an absolute value of 0.65 x (120.1) g L−1 ≈ 78 g L−1 of functional hemoglobin in the particles. Taking into account the ratio of Hb and heme-free globin/HSA in the stock suspension of 1.086, we obtain a total protein concentration of (120.1 + 130.5) g L−1 for the particles, which results in a fraction of about 31% of functional Hb in the particles. This value obtained for the specific batch investigated indicates that it is absolutely necessary to control the production process in order to improve the oxygen transport capacity and to allow reproducible fabrication of the HbMPs.