3.4. Wear Test Results
The changes in the weight of the H111 hot-rolled Al5083 alloy before the heat treatment, after homogenization, in dry environments, and in the NaOH solution as a function of distance are shown in
Figure 7. The wear rates at the end of 10,000 m are comparatively given in
Figure 8, and the friction coefficients measured during wear are presented in
Figure 9. After dry environment wear tests, the Al5083 sample before the heat treatment exhibited greater weight loss, while the homogenized sample showed better wear resistance. The wear test results of the investigated samples in NaOH exhibit similarities. This can be explained by the more homogeneous and stable crystal structure and the increase in hardness value. Comparing the wear results with the hardness results, it is seen that the hardness results support the wear results. When examining the wear results in NaOH, it is determined that the homogenized sample shows better wear resistance, parallel to the results in a dry environment. In the wear test conducted in NaOH, lower wear resistance is expected compared to the dry environment. However, as seen in
Figure 7 and
Figure 8, higher wear resistance and weight loss are detected in the wear results in NaOH.
Since homogenization heat treatment is a critical process that significantly affects the microstructure of alloys [
53,
54], in the H111 hot-rolled Al5083 alloy, the homogenization heat treatment eliminated segregation and refined the microstructure of the alloy ingot. This treatment is aimed at achieving a more uniform distribution of elements throughout the material by reducing segregation. In this case, it can profoundly affect the mechanical properties [
15,
54,
55] and lead to a reduction in corrosion rates [
56]. In summary, the homogenization heat treatment of the H111 hot-rolled Al5083 alloy results in a refined and more uniform microstructure by eliminating segregation and tuning the distribution of elements throughout the material. This treatment leads to improved mechanical properties and corrosion resistance, underscoring the significance of homogenization processes in enhancing the performance of the alloy.
The higher wear resistance of the Al5083 and homogenized Al5083 samples in the NaOH solution compared to the dry environment can be attributed to several factors. It is thought to be due to the lubricating effect of the NaOH solution. The presence of the NaOH solution alters the chemical environment around the aluminum surface, leading to the formation of a protective oxide layer that acts as a barrier against further corrosion. This protective oxide layer is crucial in reducing the corrosion rate of aluminum in alkaline solutions, like NaOH. Additionally, the concentration of OH
− ions in the NaOH solution plays a role in the corrosion behavior of aluminum; higher OH
− ion concentrations can enhance the passivation of the aluminum surface, further reducing the corrosion rate [
57]. Moreover, the interaction between the aluminum surface and the NaOH solution affects the corrosion process. Studies have shown that with increasing NaOH concentration, the corrosion potential shifts to more negative values, indicating a change in the corrosion behavior of aluminum in alkaline solutions [
58]. The presence of Na
+ ions in the solution can also influence the corrosion behavior of aluminum, as they can participate in the formation of corrosion products on the aluminum surface [
59]. It was determined that the alloy exposed to wear in the NaOH solution after homogenization provided the least weight loss and the best wear resistance after 10,000 m. The weight loss and wear rate at 6000 m for this material are 1.09 × 10
−2 g and 5.45 × 10
−8 g/Nm, respectively. The highest weight loss and worst wear resistance were observed for the alloy. The weight loss and wear rates at the end of 10,000 m are 3.23 × 10
−2 g and 16.18 × 10
−8 g/Nm, respectively. According to these results, as shown in
Figure 9, the friction coefficients during wear are parallel, and the homogenized material has the lowest friction coefficient in the NaOH solution after homogenization, with a friction coefficient of 8.06 × 10
−3.
SEM and EDS analyses of the worn surfaces of the H111 hot-rolled Al5083 alloy in a dry environment and NaOH before and after heat treatment and homogenization are shown in
Figure 10. When the SEM image in
Figure 10 is examined, in the gray area at point 1 (
Table 4), faint wear marks and small amounts of broken pieces due to wear are seen clinging to the surface. At point 2, it is seen that there are deep wear marks and pieces broken off from the surface, and these pieces are stuck to the surface. There is a wave appearance due to the broken piece. At point 3, it is seen that the pieces that broke off from the surface during wear stick to the surface again, accumulate, and swell, creating a flake appearance. When the SEM image in
Figure 11 is examined, at point 1 (
Table 5), a slight wear mark is visible in the gray area, but no broken pieces sticking to the surface can be seen. At point 2, it was observed that the broken and broken pieces accumulated on the matrix surface in the gray contrast area, resulting in a wavy image. At the third point, it is seen that a larger piece is stuck to the matrix compared to the broken pieces in the light gray region. In general, fewer wear marks, deformation, and material loss were detected on the surface of the homogenized material compared to the unheat-treated sample. When the SEM image in
Figure 12 is examined, faint wear marks are visible at point 1 (
Table 6). On the other hand, there are no parts breaking off and no parts sticking to the matrix. At point 2, wear marks are seen in the gray-white contrast area. However, an oxide film layer is observed. At point 3, wear marks in the light gray wavy area and a small number of broken pieces after wear are seen adhering to the matrix. When the SEM image is examined in
Figure 13, at point 1 in
Table 7, it was observed that an oxide film layer formed in the area where light gray accumulation was observed. At point 2, it is seen that a small number of broken pieces on the surface are stuck to the matrix. At point 3, slight wear marks can be seen in the gray area. It was determined that homogenized Al5083 had lighter wear, less depth of wear marks, and less amount of breakaway wear compared to untreated Al5083. When the wear in a dry environment and a NaOH solution were compared, it was determined that wear in NaOH increased the wear resistance due to the lubricating effect of NaOH and the formation of an oxide film layer by reacting with Al5083.
3.5. Immersion Tests
In
Figure 14, the change in weight loss of the Al5083 samples before the heat treatment and after homogenization in the NaCl solution after 72 h is given, and
Figure 15 shows corrosion rates after 72 h. In
Figure 16, the change in weight loss of the Al5083 samples before the heat treatment and after homogenization in the NaOH solution after 48 h is given, and corrosion rates after 48 h are shown in
Figure 17. In both environments, the homogenized samples show better corrosion resistance and less weight loss. Homogenization plays a crucial role in influencing the corrosion behavior of various materials. Studies have shown that machining techniques, such as high-pressure torsion (HPT), can increase the corrosion resistance of materials, such as pure Mg, leading to a more homogeneous corrosion surface [
60]. Additionally, a homogeneous distribution of corrosion inhibitors, such as graphene nanoplatelets, can significantly increase the long-term corrosion resistance of materials, such as aluminum [
61]. Conversely, the lack of a corrosion barrier effect due to homogenization can reduce the corrosion performance of some alloys [
62]. Homogenization can also affect stress corrosion cracking resistance; grain refinement and microstructure homogenization increase this resistance in some cases [
63]. It has also been reported that the formation of a more homogeneous passive film due to homogenization increases the corrosion resistance of aluminum alloys [
64]. Similarly, hot working processes that result in finer grains and a more homogeneous microstructure have been shown to reduce corrosion rates of magnesium alloys [
65]. The homogenization process can lead to a reduction in corrosion rates by reducing chemical composition segregation and altering intermetallic formation [
29]. Additionally, improvement and homogenization of microstructures have been found to increase the corrosion resistance of certain alloys by promoting the formation of protective passive films [
66]. Homogenized microstructures can greatly affect the recrystallization behavior, grain size, mechanical properties, and corrosion resistance [
67]. In summary, homogenization plays a vital role in changing the microstructure of materials, affecting the formation of passive films and affecting the distribution of corrosion inhibitors; all of which have been shown to contribute to the overall corrosion resistance of various alloys and composites.
It is seen that the weight loss in the NaOH solution is higher than in NaCl, and it shows lower corrosion resistance. Kharel et al. [
68] found that alloys exhibited higher corrosion rates in NaOH solutions compared to NaCl, supporting the idea that NaOH promotes corrosion to a greater extent. Consequently, the higher corrosiveness of NaOH compared to NaCl can be attributed to accelerated corrosion processes in NaOH solutions, the dissolution of protective films, and specific chemical reactions occurring in the presence of NaOH. While the highest weight loss and corrosion rate were seen in the untreated Al5083 in the NaOH solution, the lowest weight loss was seen in the homogenized Al5083 sample in NaCl.
In the XRD card of the corrosion of the untreated Al5083 sample in the NaCl solution in
Figure 18, the MgO, MgO + Al
2O
3, Al
2O
3, and SiO
2 phases were seen at high rates. XRD peaks of the Al5083 alloy started with the MgO, MgO + Al
2O
3, Al
2O
3, and SiO
2 phases at 37.3°. The highest peak is the second peak and occurred at 43.18° degrees. The MgO, MgO + Al
2O
3, and SiO
2 phases were observed at the highest peak. XRD peaks ended with the MgO phases at 81.42°. In
Figure 19, the MgO and SiO
2 phases were seen at high levels on the XRD card of the corrosion of the Al5083 homogenized sample in the NaCl solution. XRD peaks of the Al5083 alloy started with the MgO, MgO + Al
2O
3, and Al
2O
3 phases at 37.84°. The second peak occurred at 44° with the MgO, MgO + Al
2O
3, and SiO
2 phases and is the highest peak. The XRD peaks of the Al5083 alloy ended with the MgO phase at 81.62°. The XRD measurement of the corroded surface of both the untreated and homogenized Al5083 alloy in the NaCl solution reveals the formation of identical oxides in both samples. The enhanced corrosion resistance of the homogenized Al5083 alloy can be attributed to the formation of a more protective and uniform oxide layer on its surface, which can be achieved by the finer and uniformly distributed intermetallics in the alloy structure.
When the SEM images of the untreated sample after corrosion in the NaCl solution given in
Figure 20 are examined, it is thought that there is fragment attachment after corrosion in the black-gray contrast structure at point 1 (
Table 8). The dark structure at point 2 is thought to be the formation of a residual oxide film. At point 3, the structure seen with gray contrast is seen to have corrosion in the form of flaking, while there are deposits around the flaking. While it is thought that there is material loss due to corrosion, it is also seen that an oxide layer forms on the surface. When the post-corrosion SEM images of the homogenized sample in the NaCl solution given in
Figure 21 are examined, the white shiny structure at point 1 (
Table 9) is thought to be MgO + Al
2O
3. The gray-colored structure at point 2 is thought to be Al
2O
3. The faint gray structure at point 3 is thought to be pitting corrosion and is thought to be a SiO
2 oxide layer. There appears to be pitting corrosion in the matrix, Al
2O
3, and MgO. It has been observed that oxide layers form and accumulate in large structures within the areas pitted by this corrosion. The corrosion rate was enhanced in the non-heat-treated sample due to the existence of fragment detachment, oxide film residue, and flaking corrosion damage. However, the corrosion resistance was improved by the creation of narrow pittings with a homogeneous oxide film.
XRD results of the untreated and homogenized Al5083-H111 alloys after corrosion in the NaOH solution are shown in
Figure 22 and
Figure 23. XRD peaks of the Al5083 alloy started with the MgO, NaOH, and MgO + Al
2O
3 phases at 37.82°. All phases were seen at the highest peak. MgO was observed in high density in all peaks. XRD peaks of the Al5083 alloy ended with the MgO phase at 81. 66°. In the XRD card of the wear test in homogenized Al5083 NaOH, the MgO, SiO
2, and NaOH phases were seen at high levels in
Figure 23. XRD peaks of the Al5083 alloy started with the MgO, NaOH, MgO + Al
2O
3, and SiO
2 phases at 38°. The second peak occurred at 44.04° with the MgO, NaOH, SiO
2, and MgO + Al
2O
3 phases and is the highest peak. The XRD peaks of the Al5083 alloy ended with the MgO phase at 81.7°.
In X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis of the untreated and homogenized Al5083-H111 alloys corroded in NaOH, the presence of a high MgO + Al
2O
3 phase can have important consequences in various materials science applications. The combination of MgO and Al
2O
3 can lead to the formation of spinel phases, such as MgAl
2O
4, which have been detected in different studies. These spinel phases are known to exhibit specific diffraction patterns in XRD analysis, indicating their presence in the material. The formation of spinel phases, such as MgAl
2O
4, is affected by the composition of the materials. The presence of MgO and Al
2O
3 is very important for their development [
69,
70]. Additionally, the ratio of MgO to Al
2O
3 can affect the phase composition of materials. For example, a high MgO content favors the production of certain phases, such as pyroxene, while a high Al
2O
3 content is more conducive to the production of other phases, such as anorthite [
71]. This highlights the importance of understanding the MgO/Al
2O
3 ratio in material synthesis to control phase formation. Moreover, the diffusion of Mg
2+ from MgO to Al
2O
3 can lead to the formation of a spinel network, such as MgAl
2O
4, which is very important in various applications [
72]. The interaction between MgO and Al
2O
3 through diffusion processes plays an important role in the formation of spinel phases and affects material properties. In summary, the presence of a high MgO + Al
2O
3 phase detected by XRD analysis indicates the formation of spinel phases, such as MgAl
2O
4, which is affected by the MgO/Al
2O
3 ratio and diffusion processes between MgO and Al
2O
3. Understanding these aspects is essential for tailoring material properties in various fields of materials science. Prabhakar et al. [
16,
73,
74] found that the grain refinement and the homogeneous and fine dispersion of intermetallics within the structure associated with the friction stir process can increase the corrosion resistance of the Al5083 alloy. A number of studies have demonstrated the effect of various coatings formed during corrosion testing on the corrosion resistance of Al alloys. Ryu and Hong [
75] found that the KF-NaAlO
2 electrolyte resulted in a thick MgAl
2O
4 coating, which exhibited the highest corrosion potential and polarization resistance. Ardelean et al. [
76] observed a shift in the corrosion potential and a decrease in the anodic dissolution current in magnesium and its alloys with cerium, aluminum oxide, and aluminum hydroxide surface films. Kameneva et al. [
77] highlighted the influence of TiN, ZrN, and TixZr1-xN layers on the corrosion resistance of a hard alloy in a sodium hydroxide solution, attributing the differences to surface and internal defects of the coating layers. These studies collectively support the role of Al
2O
3, MgO, and SiO
2, films in slowing down the corrosion process by reducing the charge transfer rate and diffusion flow through the surface layer (such as chloride ion diffusion) [
78]. The presence of phases of elements such as Al, Mg, and Si that form the oxide film increases corrosion resistance through mechanisms, such as the inhibition of oxychlorination [
16,
70,
72,
79]. These studies show that the incorporation of MgO, MgO + Al
2O
3, and SiO
2 oxide films can play a crucial role in reducing corrosion in the Al5083 alloy. In addition, studies by Jha and Bhattarai [
80] on sputter-deposited W-xNb alloys showed that corrosion rates in solutions containing different proportions of NaOH were higher than those in 3.5% NaCl. Hussein [
78] highlighted the positive effect of coatings containing SiO
2 nanoparticles in improving corrosion resistance. Revealing the positive effect of SiO
2 added to composite coatings in the form of nanoparticles [
78] contributes to the understanding of increasing corrosion resistance by the SiO2 film formed on the surface of metal alloys, such as Al5083. In the Al5083 sample that was not treated in the NaOH solution, unlike the homogenized sample, the SiO
2, MgO + Al
2O
3, and Al
2O
3 phases were not seen. The absence of these phases reduces corrosion resistance. The increase in corrosion resistance of the homogenized sample is directly proportional to the increase in oxide films.
As shown in
Figure 8, the lower weight loss in the corrosion tests performed in the NaOH solution compared to dry environments can be attributed to the accumulation of alkali on the surface and the formation of thin oxide films, as observed from the corrosion XRD analysis results (
Figure 22 and
Figure 23). This situation is supported by the lower friction coefficient obtained in the wear tests in the NaOH solution, as shown in
Figure 9.
When the post-corrosion SEM images of the unheat-treated sample in the NaOH solution given in
Figure 24 are examined, the gray structure in the pit at point 1 (
Table 10) is thought to be the NaOH oxide layer. The small structure at point 2 is thought to be a MgO and Al
2O
3 oxide film. It is thought that the structure seen in the form of a white crust at point 3 is the accumulation of the NaOH oxide layer. It is observed that pitting corrosion occurs on the surface with the appearance of a seashell due to the solution effect. When the SEM images of the homogenized sample after corrosion in the NaOH solution given in
Figure 25 are examined, it is thought that MgO and a small number of NaOH oxide layers are formed in the large white structure at points 1 and 2 (
Table 11). It is thought that MgO + Al
2O
3 is formed in the gray structure seen as the dot. At point 3, the structure in the dark region is thought to be MgO and SiO
2. It was observed that the seashell appearance on the surface decreased, and higher levels of oxide layers accumulated on the surface compared to the unheat-treated sample.
The corrosion of aluminum in various solutions, including NaCl and NaOH, has been extensively researched to comprehend its impact on the material’s behavior [
68,
80,
81,
82]. Alameer [
82] has also delved into the corrosion behavior of Al matrix composites in NaCl, HCl, and NaOH solutions at different temperatures, revealing that the type of solution and temperature conditions significantly affect the corrosion behavior of Al alloys. The corrosion behavior of Al matrix composites in a 10% solution of sodium chloride (NaCl), sodium hydroxide (NaOH), and hydrochloric acid (HCl) was examined; the highest corrosion rate was in the HCl solution, which is excessively corrosive for most materials [
82]. The Al alloy has been found to exhibit poor corrosion resistance when exposed to alkalis, such as the NaOH solution, as Al alloys are rapidly attacked by even dilute alkali solutions. Alameer [
82] showed that Al alloy matrix composites exhibited a lower corrosion rate in the NaCl solution compared to other solutions, and also the corrosion rate increased with rising exposure time. This is due to the fact that chloride undergoes decomposition when exposed to water for an extended period of time. When examining the corrosion SEM images of Al5083 alloys in the NaCl solution (
Figure 20 and
Figure 21) and NaOH solution (
Figure 24 and
Figure 25), it was found that the corrosion surface in the NaOH solution had a rougher texture, and a clearly visible oxide film in the form of a layer in the NaCl solution was not observed in the NaOH solution.
3.6. Hydrogen Evolution
Figure 26 shows the hydrogen evolution rate of the unheated and homogenized samples in the NaOH solution, and
Figure 27 presents the corrosion rate graphs of these samples. In
Figure 26, it is observed that the hydrogen output of the homogenized sample, although it starts slower, gradually increases and reaches the 100 mL hydrogen gas output level in a shorter time. The untreated sample’s gas evolution starts rapidly, then decreases, and subsequently shows a stable increase. When the corrosion rates are compared, there is an initial high increase followed by a decrease, and then a continuous increase is observed in the untreated sample. The homogenized sample exhibits a slow corrosion rate followed by a steady state.
When comparing the two graphs, it can be seen that hydrogen output and the corrosion rate are directly proportional. As the release of hydrogen gas increases, the corrosion rate also increases. The homogenization heat treatment has significant effects on the release of hydrogen gas and promotes gas formation. One reason for this is that the phases within the grain become coarser with homogenization and are distributed homogeneously into the matrix (
Figure 24). Hydrogen gas production increases as the phases within the grain react with the NaOH solution. Homogenously dispersed phases increase the surface area and, consequently, the production of hydrogen gas. Research has shown that heat treatment can indeed affect hydrogen formation rates. Studies on the microstructural evolution of Al-5083, particularly the β phase (Al
3Mg
2) at grain boundaries and intragranular particles, indicate that the presence and distribution of phases can affect the hydrogen evolution behavior of the alloy. Goswami et al. demonstrated that the β phase at the grain boundaries of samples subjected to longer aging dissolved more during corrosion [
83]. In the case of Al5083, the homogenization heat treatment may influence the hydrogen evolution behavior. Yao et al. found that the hydrogen evolution rate increased slightly after heat treatment, indicating a potential compromise in the post-treatment protection of the material [
84]. Additionally, Petroyiannis et al. [
85] showed that heat treatment at certain temperatures can release hydrogen trapped in corroded alloys, thereby affecting the properties of the material.
Hydrogen evolution is a significant phenomenon closely linked to corrosion processes in various materials, particularly metals like aluminum, magnesium, and zinc. The evolution of hydrogen during corrosion is a result of cathodic reactions that occur concurrently with anodic dissolution, influencing the overall corrosion rate [
86]. Studies have shown that hydrogen evolution can take different forms, such as large stable bubbles on uncorroded regions, fine bubbles at the corrosion front, and medium-sized bubbles behind the corrosion front [
87].
Furthermore, the connection between hydrogen evolution and corrosion is evident in the context of galvanic coupling, where higher rates of hydrogen evolution are observed on dark corroded surfaces compared to uncorroded surfaces. This increased hydrogen evolution catalyzes self-corrosion processes, leading to accelerated material degradation [
88]. The advancement of the hydrogen front alongside the corrosion front in materials, like aluminum alloy 2024, demonstrates how hydrogen can penetrate materials through intergranular paths generated during the corrosion process [
89].
Hydrogen evolution is intricately linked to corrosion processes in various materials, influencing corrosion rates, morphology, and localized corrosion behavior. Understanding the mechanisms of hydrogen evolution during corrosion is essential for developing effective corrosion mitigation strategies and improving the performance and durability of materials exposed to corrosive environments.