2. Results and Discussion
As shown in the transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images (
Figure 2a–f), all of the Nd
3+–Yb
3+–Er
3+-doped UCNPs have a uniform morphology with an average diameter between 20 nm and 35 nm. The calculated average particle size for different amounts of Nd
3+ ions are shown in
Figure 2n. As the concentration of Nd
3+ ions increases, the average particle size decreases from ~34 nm to ~21 nm.
Figure 2.
TEM (transmission electron microscopy) image and the size distribution of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles: (a,g) X = 0; (b,h) X = 0.25; (c,i) X = 0.5; (d,j) X = 1.0; (e,k) X = 2.0; (f,m) X = 3.0; (n) average nanoparticle diameter of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%).
Figure 2.
TEM (transmission electron microscopy) image and the size distribution of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles: (a,g) X = 0; (b,h) X = 0.25; (c,i) X = 0.5; (d,j) X = 1.0; (e,k) X = 2.0; (f,m) X = 3.0; (n) average nanoparticle diameter of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%).
With the same concentration of Yb
3+ ions and Er
3+ ions, parts of the Y
3+ ions (
r = 1.159 Å) [
17] were replaced by Nd
3+ ions (
r = 1.249 Å) [
17]. This confirms that doping of the lanthanide ion with a size larger than the Y
3+ ion in NaYF
4 host lattices should result in the formation of smaller nanoparticles. The X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of samples in
Figure 3 indicate that all of the samples crystallize into the hexagonal NaYF
4, which accords basically with the standard X-ray diffraction JCPDS (joint committee on powder diffraction standards) 16-0334.
Figure 4 shows the upconversion luminescence spectra of NaYF
4 nanoparticles with different dopants. All four samples produce upconversion photoluminescence (PL) under excitation at 808 nm using a power density of 3 W/cm
2. As shown in
Figure 4, four major sensitized UC emission bands centered at 410 nm, 520 nm, 540 nm and 655 nm, which correspond to the transitions of Er
3+ ions:
2H
9/2 →
4I
15/2,
2H
11/2 →
4I
15/2,
4S
3/2 →
4I
15/2 and
4F
9/2 →
4I
15/2, respectively, are observed. There are emissions of Er
3+ ions even on the premise that NaYF
4 host lattices are doped only with Er
3+ ions. This means that the UC emission of Er
3+ ions mostly results from the limited excited state absorption of Er
3+ ions. The Yb
3+ ions can hardly absorb the photons at 808 nm. Therefore, doping with Yb
3+/Er
3+ can only weaken the emission of Er
3+ ions by an energy back transfer process from Er
3+ ions to Yb
3+ ions. Moreover, it can be seen that the emission of Er
3+ ions is also weakened after doping with Nd
3+/Er
3+, although Nd
3+ ions can absorb the photons at 808 nm effectively. This shows that Nd
3+ ions cannot transfer their energy to Er
3+ ions efficiently. The excited Nd
3+ ions lose their energy to the other states radiatively or relax to their ground state non-radiatively. The intensity of upconversion luminescence of NaYF
4: Nd
3+/Er
3+ is lower than that of NaYF
4: Yb
3+/Er
3+, which shows that the energy back transfer Er
3+ → Nd
3+ is much more efficient than Er
3+ → Yb
3+, even when the Nd
3+ concentration (0.5 mol%) is much lower than the Yb
3+ concentration (20 mol%). Furthermore, due to codoping with Yb
3+ ions, the luminescence intensity of sample NaYF
4: Nd
3+/Yb
3+/Er
3+ is much stronger than that of NaYF
4: Nd
3+Er
3+. This shows that Yb
3+ ions can act as the bridging center to prompt energy transfer from Nd
3+ ions to Er
3+ ions under 808-nm excitation.
Figure 3.
XRD pattern of the as-synthesized NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles.
Figure 3.
XRD pattern of the as-synthesized NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles.
Figure 4.
Upconversion emission spectra using a log scale for the emission intensity of NaYF4: Er (2 mol%), NaYF4: Yb/Er (20/2 mol%), NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/0.5 mol%) and NaYF4: Er/Nd (2/0.5 mol%) nanoparticles under 808-nm excitation.
Figure 4.
Upconversion emission spectra using a log scale for the emission intensity of NaYF4: Er (2 mol%), NaYF4: Yb/Er (20/2 mol%), NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/0.5 mol%) and NaYF4: Er/Nd (2/0.5 mol%) nanoparticles under 808-nm excitation.
As shown in
Figure 5a,b, four sensitized UC emission bands centered at 410, 520, 540 and 655 nm, which correspond to the transitions of Er
3+ ions:
2H
9/2 →
4I
15/2,
2H
11/2 →
4I
15/2,
4S
3/2 →
4I
15/2 and
4F
9/2 →
4I
15/2, respectively, are observed both under 808- and 980-nm excitation using a power density of 2.5 and 250 mW/cm
2, respectively. In this paper, we discuss only the green and red emission bands.
Figure 5c,d shows that the intensity ratio of green to red emission (
Rg/r) is higher under 808-nm excitation than the ratio under 980-nm excitation. As the Nd
3+ concentration increases, both the intensity ratios of green to red emission under 980- and 808-nm excitation increase to a maximum and then decrease gradually. Introducing Nd
3+ ions with different amounts into NaYF
4: Yb
3+/Er
3+ has an effect on the non-radiative energy back transfer from Er
3+ ions to Nd
3+ ions and then influences the cross-relaxation process of Er
3+ ions, which dominate the green-to-red emission ratio [
18]. Therefore, it is concluded that the Nd
3+ ions with a certain concentration are effective at originating the green emission of Er
3+ ions. In addition, the high intensity ratio of green to red emission under 808-nm excitation shows that 808-nm excitation is favored over the green emission of Er
3+ ions for biomarkers.
Figure 5.
Upconversion emission spectra of the NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles under (a) 808-nm excitation and (b) 980-nm excitation. The inserted image in (a) is the magnified green emissions; (c,d) the dependence of green and red emission intensity on Nd3+ concentration and the dependence of Rg/r on Nd3+ concentration of the NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles under 808-nm and 980-nm excitation.
Figure 5.
Upconversion emission spectra of the NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles under (a) 808-nm excitation and (b) 980-nm excitation. The inserted image in (a) is the magnified green emissions; (c,d) the dependence of green and red emission intensity on Nd3+ concentration and the dependence of Rg/r on Nd3+ concentration of the NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles under 808-nm and 980-nm excitation.
The UC luminescence spectra presented in
Figure 5a reveal the effect of Nd
3+ concentration on the emission intensity of Er
3+ under 808-nm excitation. The intensity of Er
3+ emissions is enhanced when the concentration of Nd
3+ ions ranges from 0.0 to 0.5 mol%, then decreases when the Nd
3+ concentration exceeds 0.5 mol%. It can be concluded that co-doping with a low content of Nd
3+ ions will promote the upconversion emission of Er
3+ ions, and the upconversion intensity of Er
3+ ions depends greatly on the concentration of Nd
3+ ions. Therefore, the energy transfer from Nd
3+ ions to Er
3+ ions is the main mechanism to produce the upconversion emission of Er
3+ ions. When the concentration of Nd
3+ is more than 0.5 mol%, the upconversion intensity of the Er
3+ ions decreases greatly. The more Nd
3+ ions there are in the UCNPs, the shorter the distance is between the adjacent ions. The energy back transfer from Er
3+ ions to Nd
3+ ions and the non-radiative cross-relaxation (CR) between Nd
3+ ions become particularly active once the concentration of Nd
3+ ions is higher than 0.5 mol%. As a result, some Er
3+ ions are de-excited by a resonant cross-relaxation energy transfer to Nd
3+ ions [
19], which leads to a decrease in the upconversion intensity of the 520-, 540- and 645-nm emissions of Er
3+ ions. Furthermore, the distortion of the local symmetry around the Er
3+ ions is another significant reason for enhancing emission. When the concentration of Nd
3+ ions increases to over 0.5 mol%, more and more Nd
3+ ions occupy interstitial sites, which will cause the increasing defect centers. On the other hand, an Er
3+ ion may be surrounded by more than one Nd
3+ ion with the increase of Nd
3+ concentration. This renders the crystal field around Er
3+ more symmetric again. The UC emission is thus reduced. Therefore, for the sake of using the 808-nm excitation for biological applications of UCNPs, Nd
3+ ions with a concentration of about 0.5 mol% are necessary to be doped in NaYF
4: 20% Yb
3+, 2% Er
3+ UCNPs.
In order to study the energy back transfer from Er
3+ ions to Nd
3+ ions, the upconversion spectra of prepared UCNPs under 980-nm excitation were detected. There are only the emissions of Er
3+ ions in the visible light region. The energy transfer from Yb
3+ ions to Er
3+ ions is the main upconversion mechanism under 980-nm excitation. The Nd
3+ ion makes almost no positive contribution to the upconversion emission of Er
3+ ions under 980-nm excitation. However, the intensity of the 520-, 540- and 655-nm emissions of Er
3+ ions decreases with increasing Nd
3+ concentration, which indicates that the Nd
3+ ion has a quenching effect on the upconversion emissions of Er
3+ under 980-nm excitation. There may be an energy transfer from Er
3+ ions to Nd
3+ ions. With increasing Nd
3+ concentration, the energy transfer from Er
3+ to Nd
3+ ions becomes more efficient. Some Er
3+ ions transfer energy to Nd
3+ ions by three resonant cross-relaxation (CR) transitions:
These three processes depopulate the
4F
9/2,
4I
11/2 and
4I
13/2 states of Er
3+, respectively. As a result, the luminescence of Er
3+ is quenched and gradually becomes weak with an increase in the Nd
3+ ion concentration. To avoid the energy back transfer from emitting ions to the primary sensitizer, the Yb
3+/Er
3+-doped core and Nd
3+/Yb
3+ co-doped shell should help, since the Nd
3+ ion is separated from the Er
3+ ion in such a case. This idea has already been presented in the literature [
20,
21].
In order to study the luminescence kinetics and the mechanism of the upconversion emission, the decay curves of
4S
3/2 →
4I
15/2 (540 nm) for the samples were measured. The normalized decay curves of the
4S
3/2 →
4I
15/2 transition at 540 nm for the NaYF
4: Yb
3+/Er
3+ without and with Nd
3+ ions under 980-nm excitation are presented in
Figure 6. Each of the decay curves of the samples could be fitted to a single exponential function
I(
t) =
I0exp(−
t/τ), where
I and
I0 are the emission intensities at time
t and zero, and τ is the lifetime [
22]. As shown in
Figure 6, the lifetime decreases from 207 to 187 μs after doping with 0.5 mol% Nd
3+ ions. It can be proven that there occurs an energy back transfer from Er
3+ ions to Nd
3+ ions.
Figure 6.
Luminescence decay curves of Er3+: 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition in NaYF4: Yb/Er (20/2 mol%) nanoparticles with and without Nd (0.5 mol%) co-doping. The inserted image is the emission spectrum of the 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition under 980-nm excitation.
Figure 6.
Luminescence decay curves of Er3+: 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition in NaYF4: Yb/Er (20/2 mol%) nanoparticles with and without Nd (0.5 mol%) co-doping. The inserted image is the emission spectrum of the 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition under 980-nm excitation.
The measured rise times are shown in
Table 1 with respect to Nd
3+ concentration. The rise time and fall time of the 808-nm pulse is very short compared with that of the upconversion emissions and is neglected. This shows in
Table 1 that the rise time of samples NaYF
4: Nd
3+/Yb
3+/Er
3+ is longer than that of the sample NaYF
4: Nd
3+/Er
3+ when the concentration of Nd
3+ is lower than 1 mol%. The longer rise times of such samples indicates that the energy transfer is the dominant mechanism for the upconversion process of the Nd
3+–Yb
3+–Er
3+ system with a small amount of Nd
3+ ions under 808-nm excitation. However, the rise time decreases from 1 to 0.4 ms as the concentration of Nd
3+ is increased from 0.25 to 3 mol%. As the concentration of the Nd
3+ ions is increased, the interionic distance is decreased, and hence, the transition probability increases. As a consequence, the rise time decreases with the increase of concentration, since the transfer rate is the inverse of time [
23].
Table 1.
Rise times and lifetimes for individual 540-nm upconversion emission of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles.
Table 1.
Rise times and lifetimes for individual 540-nm upconversion emission of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles.
%Nd3+ | X = 0 | X = 0.25 | X = 0.5 | X = 1 | X = 2 | X = 3 |
---|
rise time (μs) | 724 | 1028 | 903 | 892 | 540 | 412 |
lifetime (μs) | 203.6 | 185.6 | 171.6 | 161.8 | 151.1 | 150.6 |
The normalized decay curves of the
4S
3/2 →
4I
15/2 transition at 540 nm for different amounts of Nd
3+ ions under 808-nm excitation are presented in
Figure 7b. The calculated lifetimes are summarized in
Table 1. The lifetime of sample NaYF
4: Yb
3+/Er
3+ agrees well with the lifetime of 230 μs, which has been reported [
24]. As the Nd
3+ concentration increases, the lifetime of the
4S
3/2 state decreases from 203.6 to 150.6 μs. We will discuss this trend according to the formula τ = 1/(Γ +
knr), where Γ and
knr are the radiative and non-radiative decay rates, and τ is the lifetime [
25]. The Nd
3+ ions, having a larger ionic radius than Y
3+ ions, are beneficial for reducing the interionic distance. Both the radiative and non-radiative decay rates of Er
3+ ions will speed up with the decrease of the separation distance [
26]. Thus, the lifetime will decrease correspondingly. However, compared to the non-radiative decay rate, the radiative decay rate increases more rapidly as the ionic separation distance decreases [
27]. The radiative transition is the dominant process, which can be attributed to luminescence enhancement. The observed emission enhancement is mainly due to the competition between the changes in radiative and non-radiative decay rates. After reaching a certain distance, the higher the Nd
3+ concentration is, the faster the energy back transfer (Er
3+ → Nd
3+) will be, which causes the decrease of the lifetime, and the less the luminescence enhancement or even quenching. Furthermore, the increased Nd
3+ concentration leads to a reduced average distance between the adjacent ions, which tend to non-radiatively cross-relax (CR). The process is described as:
The non-radiative CR depopulates partially the excited
4F
3/2 level, resulting in a simultaneous luminescence intensity and lifetime decrease with the increase of Nd
3+ concentration [
28].
Figure 7.
(a) Luminescence rise and decay curves of the Er3+: 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition in NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles under a pulse 808-nm excitation (pulse width = 11.05 ms); (b) luminescence decay curves of the Er3+: 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition in NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles. The inserted image is the emission spectrum of the 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition under 808-nm excitation.
Figure 7.
(a) Luminescence rise and decay curves of the Er3+: 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition in NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles under a pulse 808-nm excitation (pulse width = 11.05 ms); (b) luminescence decay curves of the Er3+: 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition in NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/X mol%) nanoparticles. The inserted image is the emission spectrum of the 4S3/2 → 4I15/2 transition under 808-nm excitation.
In order to investigate the energy transfer mechanisms involved in the population of states of Er
3+ ions, the dependence of upconversion luminescence intensity on the 808-nm and 980-nm NIR excitation power of UCNPs with
X = 0.5 mol% as a sample is shown in
Figure 8. The UC emission intensity
Iup is proportional to the incident pumping power
P as
Iup ∝
Pn, where
n is the number of infrared multi-photons involved in a single visible photon generation [
29]. The exponent power
n could be determined from the slope of linear regression in a double logarithmic plot of the emitting intensity as the function of excitation intensity. The trend of the slope excited by 808-nm exactly follows that excited by 980-nm under low-power and intermediate-power pumping conditions, respectively. However, the measured slopes of the upconversion luminescence change from 1.72 to 1.30 for green fluorescence emission and from 1.60 to 1.27 for red emission in
Figure 8a with increasing pump power, due to the saturation effects. The number of the luminescence center (Er
3+) is a constant and does not change with the pump power. Therefore, the saturation effect is obviously under high power excitation. In addition, it was reported that higher pump power can increase the competition between linear decay and the upconversion process of the intermediate excited states, which results in a significantly reduced slope, too [
29]. The slopes of the green fluorescence are 1.24 and 1.74, and that of the red emission are 0.60 and 1.98 under low-power and intermediate-power pumping conditions, respectively. Based on the slopes, the green and the red fluorescence emission intensity are approximately proportional to the square of the pumping power under the intermediate-power pumping condition, indicating that these emissions are performed by a two-photon process, as well as the energy loss during the upconversion process, because
n is smaller than 2. For lower excitation powers, which are below or around an excitation power threshold, the upconverted fluorescence intensity is weak, and the crystal is nearly transparent to the pump, thus resulting in it ineffective at absorbing photons. As a result, the
n values for the emissions are close to one under the low-power condition [
30]. These values of
n in
Figure 8a are smaller than those in
Figure 8b, because a photon’s energy at 808 nm is higher than that at 980 nm. It can be seen that the power threshold for 808-nm excitation is larger than that for 980 nm; because the concentration of the sensitizer Nd
3+ ions for 808-nm excitation is much less than Yb
3+ ions for 980-nm excitation and the Nd
3+–Yb
3+–Er
3+ energy transfer may lead to more energy consumption. Furthermore, the
n value for the green emission is larger than that for the red one excited by 808 nm, indicating a faster growth of the green fluorescence than the red one as the pump power increases. Because the
n value for the green emission is smaller than that for the red one excited by 980 nm, which is opposite of 808 nm, it can also be proven that 808-nm excitation is favored to the green emission of Er
3+ ions.
Figure 8.
Log-log plot of the upconversion emission intensity of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/0.5 mol%) nanoparticles as a function of the pump power under (a) 808-nm excitation and (b) 980-nm excitation.
Figure 8.
Log-log plot of the upconversion emission intensity of NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd (20/2/0.5 mol%) nanoparticles as a function of the pump power under (a) 808-nm excitation and (b) 980-nm excitation.
Having analyzed the results obtained from the upconversion emission spectra, the measurements of decay time and the dependence of luminescence intensity on excitation power, the upconversion mechanism of the Nd
3+–Yb
3+–Er
3+ system under 808-nm excitation has been proposed and is shown in
Figure 9. Nd
3+ ions in the ground state are excited by an 808-nm laser and reach their excited state
4F
5/2 or
2H
9/2 corresponding to the transition
4I
9/2 → (
4F
5/2,
2H
9/2). The (
4F
5/2,
2H
9/2) excited states are unstable; thus, some Nd
3+ ions relax quickly to the
4F
3/2 state through a multi-phonon non-radiative relaxation. The energy transfer (ET) between Nd
3+ ions and Yb
3+ ions,
2F
7/2 (Yb
3+) +
4F
3/2 (Nd
3+) →
2F
5/2 (Yb
3+) +
4I
11/2 (Nd
3+), occurs with considerably high efficiencies [
31,
32]. As a result, the
2F
5/2 state of Yb
3+ ions is populated. Two subsequent successive energy transfers from excited Yb
3+ ions to Er
3+ ions bring the Er
3+ ions directly to their
4F
7/2 state. Some Er
3+ ions in the
4F
7/2 state relax to the lower
2H
11/2,
4S
3/2 and
4F
9/2 states through the multi-phonon relaxation, respectively; then,
2H
11/2,
4S
3/2 and
4F
9/2 are populated. The electrons in the
2H
11/2,
4S
3/2 and
4F
9/2 states jump to the ground state
4I
15/2 and give the green (520 nm, 540 nm) and red (655 nm) emissions.
Figure 9.
Proposed energy transfer mechanism under 808-nm excitation in NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd nanoparticles. The dashed-dotted, dashed, dotted and full arrows represent photon excitation, energy transfer, multi-phonon relaxation and the emission process, respectively. For clarity, only dominant energy transfer processes are shown in the proposed mechanisms.
Figure 9.
Proposed energy transfer mechanism under 808-nm excitation in NaYF4: Yb/Er/Nd nanoparticles. The dashed-dotted, dashed, dotted and full arrows represent photon excitation, energy transfer, multi-phonon relaxation and the emission process, respectively. For clarity, only dominant energy transfer processes are shown in the proposed mechanisms.