1. Introduction
A large part of overhead transmission lines (OHTL) outages is caused by their extended length and vulnerability to various factors, including constant ones like manufacturing and operation, as well as variable factors such as climatic conditions and human activity. Seasonal variations also play a role, with more outages occurring in spring and summer due to thunderstorms and high temperatures, while winter poses increased risks from stronger winds and solid precipitation. The growing influence of global climate change and the increased occurrence of extreme weather events have led to a rise in emergencies and outages within electrical grid companies. As climate change intensifies, the aging power grid, combined with increasing energy demands due to population growth, is expected to result in a higher likelihood of power outages [
1,
2,
3] and raises concerns about the resilience of the electric grid to future climate and weather hazards. The impacts of power outages are heterogenous among different countries and larger impacts occur in countries of lower-income, larger land area, and lower electrification rates [
4]. Additionally, increased social impacts are expected as the likelihood of outages increases [
5].
In 2022, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released its sixth report, highlighting that human-induced climate change is already having a more extensive and profound impact on both nature and human populations than previously expected [
6]. This report underscores that certain consequences of climate change are now inevitable, manifesting with greater intensity and frequency across broader geographic regions. As climate change progresses, there is a significant increase in the likelihood and severity of extreme meteorological conditions. Heatwaves are becoming more prolonged and intense [
7], heavy rainfall events are occurring more frequently, leading to increased flooding [
8], and both the frequency of storms and associated wind speed are rising simultaneously [
9,
10]. It is also known that thunderstorm activities are shifting towards the north, making summertime lightning density much higher in the northern regions, including Lithuania [
11]. Additionally, increased intraseasonal variability in winter temperatures [
12] contributes to an elevated risk of icing or wet snow load events in some parts of the European continent [
13]. The increasing frequency of these phenomena collectively leads to higher losses and costs for the society, business, and the electricity sector.
Extratropical storms, with their strong winds, are among the foremost natural hazards in Europe, causing extensive damage to forests and society [
14,
15] and acting as a primary cause of OHTL outages worldwide [
16]. Between 1980 and 2020, climate-related disasters accounted for approximately 80% of the total economic damage caused by natural hazards in the EU [
17]. According to the EMDAT database, storms and floods each comprised about 35% of the total reported disasters, collectively making up nearly 70%. Notably, storms have been the most significant disaster type, impacting almost 60% of the entire EU [
18]. In highly forested countries, power distribution companies face substantial challenges due to such storms, with falling trees leading to power outages affecting hundreds of thousands of customers annually [
19]. Analysis shows that a 20% increase in the average values of extreme wind speed and ice thickness can decrease the reliability of the power line by 30% and 17%, respectively [
20].
Lightning poses another significant risk to OHTLs. Lightning discharges can cause various forms of damage, including temporary disconnections or shutdowns following direct strikes. Additionally, nearby lightning strikes can lead to temporary disturbances in the operation of these lines. Historical outage data provided by the UK’s NaFIRS indicate that lightning strikes were the primary direct cause of over 20,000 supply interruptions between 2010 and 2019 [
21]. Studies have shown that these outages can result in substantial economic losses due to the need for repairs and maintenance and reduced service reliability, as well as the economic impact of power outages on consumers and businesses [
22,
23]. Lightning strikes also cause significant economic losses in the electricity sector by damaging infrastructure and reducing the reliability of power systems. For example, in China, lightning-related damages increased from
$7.4 million in 1997 to
$66 million in 2007 [
24].
Icing on transmission lines can lead to increased mechanical load on the structures, causing line sagging, conductor galloping, and even tower collapses. This results in power outages and costly repairs. The phenomenon is particularly prevalent in regions with frequent snowfalls [
25,
26]. The accumulation of wet snow on power lines and ice storms poses significant challenges, leading to power supply failures during the cold season. In recent years, numerous widespread power outage incidents have been attributed to extreme atmospheric icing on electricity transmission and distribution networks caused by ice storms and wet snowstorms. These phenomena generate wet snow and ice, leading to extensive financial losses and prolonged power outages [
27].
Ensuring the reliability and resilience of electricity infrastructure is a critical global concern, as modern society relies heavily on a consistent and adequate electricity supply. The significant interconnectedness between the electricity sector and other crucial infrastructure systems means that disruptions in this sector can have severe consequences for national security, societal and economic stability, and public health. Climate change, along with its associated extreme weather events, presents increasingly complex challenges that we must prepare for and overcome in the future.
Lithuania’s power supply infrastructure, consisting of over 85,000 km of 0.4–35 kV overhead transmission lines and running through forested regions (forests cover one-third of the country’s territory), is significantly vulnerable to disruption from windstorms, lightning, heavy snowfall events, and icing. The aim of this research is to determine the impact of meteorological conditions on the number of outages in the 0.4–35 kV power grid and to identify the threshold values of hazardous meteorological conditions or their combinations that lead to a significant increase in outages in Lithuania.
2. Materials and Methods
Unplanned OHTL outage data in the 0.4–35 kV power grid were obtained from the Lithuanian electricity distribution network operator “Energijos skirstymo operatorius AB” (ESO), covering the period from January 2013 to March 2023.
The data include information on the date, time, and duration of each outage event, as well as the line where the event was recorded. These data were integrated with the grid OHTL network data, including coordinates, to determine outage locations.
Meteorological and lightning data, provided by the Lithuanian Hydrometeorological Service, were used in this research. Hourly data from 25 meteorological stations were employed, covering air temperature (°C), precipitation amount (mm), and average and maximum wind speeds (m/s) (
Figure 1).
Each OHTL outage was assigned to the nearest meteorological station. To determine the nearest station, 25 spatial polygons were created, one for each station. By intersecting the spatial information of the OHTL network with these polygons, the nearest meteorological station was assigned to each OHTL. The corresponding hourly meteorological information from the designated station was then linked to each outage event.
Using the state-georeferenced dataset, GDR50LT, we determined the percentage of each OHTL passing through forested areas. If any part of the line crossed a forest, it was considered as a line in a forested area. A total of 276,334 unplanned OHTL outages occurred in Lithuania from January 2013 to March 2023. Of these, 49.4% occurred in forests and 50.6% in non-forest areas. The average length of an overhead line is 0.41 km (1.28 km in forests and 0.21 km in non-forest areas), though in some cases, it exceeds several kilometers.
To determine the impact of lightning on the number of outages, 95,650 cloud-to-ground lightning strikes recorded in the territory of Lithuania from April 2018 to December 2022 were analyzed. This period was chosen due to data availability, as lightning in Lithuania has only been measured by their type (i.e., cloud-to-cloud, cloud-to-ground) since 2018. The territory of Lithuania was divided into a 0.25 × 0.25° grid, where the hourly sums of lightning strikes and the number of outages were calculated. These results were then recalculated for a 1000 km2 area. Throughout the study period, 6037 OHTL outages were recorded during cloud-to-ground lightning events in certain areas.
Even in the absence of hazardous meteorological conditions, OHTL outages occur due to infrastructure faults, deliberate or accidental human impacts, and damage caused by wildlife and vegetation. On average, there were 3.1 overhead-line disconnections per hour in Lithuania or 0.036 disconnections per thousand kilometers of line. To assess the impact of meteorological conditions on the rate of OHTL outages, we calculated the relative number of outages (RNO) by dividing the number of outages associated with specific meteorological indicator values by the average number of outages observed over the entire study period. According to national regulations, an emergency situation arises in Lithuania when the number of disconnections exceeds 50 per hour, as this overwhelms repair teams availability and leads to an accumulation of outages. This scenario can be attributed to a more than 15-fold increase in disconnections compared to the average rate. This 15-fold increase criterion serves as a threshold in this research.
Not all meteorological variables are equally effective at describing the hazardous conditions leading to outages. To identify the most important variables, we evaluated how well each one correlates with the increase in the relative number of outages (
Figure 2). OHTL outages are influenced not only by the meteorological conditions at the time of the outage but also by the conditions leading up to it. To evaluate these influences, we analyzed various variables, such as average wind and gust speed, snow and rain amounts, and mean air temperature over different time periods: 1, 3, 12, and 24 h. Minimum and maximum air temperatures were calculated for a 24 h period only. We divided each variable range into 20 bins and calculated the RNO for each bin. The last 20th bin represents maximum values and the most extreme conditions. Consequently, it has the smallest number of occurrences and thus the highest uncertainty. To minimize this uncertainty while comparing OHTL sensitivity, we used the RNO calculated with each variable values from the second largest bin (19th).
The most significant indicator of wind impact was the gust speed, either measured during the outage or over the 3 h preceding it. The mean wind speed had a much lower impact on OHTL outages compared to gusts.
Snow accumulation over the 12 h before an outage was a slightly better predictor of outages than 24 h accumulation and significantly better than shorter-term snow accumulation. The pattern for rain was different. Outages increased most significantly with rain accumulated over 1 and 3 h before the outage, while rain accumulated over longer periods had a weaker effect. Therefore, this study focused on analyzing the impact of 3 h and 12 h totals for rain and snow, respectively. Rain was distinguished from snow based on air temperature and relative humidity indicators, using a methodology developed by Finnish and Swedish scientists [
28].
Unfavorable air temperature conditions led to a smaller increase in OHL outages. It is likely that the direct effect of air temperature is small and is more manifested in the fact that it characterizes the conditions for the formation of complex hazardous meteorological phenomena. For example, when the air temperature is close to 0 °C, icing or wet snow cover is likely, but the air temperature itself does not have a direct impact on the OHL outage increase. Among all air temperature indicators, the maximum temperature over the 24 h before the outage had the greatest impact on the relative number of outages (RNO) (
Figure 2).
To identify sudden shifts in time series, indicating significant changes in mean or variance, various change point detection methods are employed. Change point detection methods are useful tools for identifying sudden shifts or structural breaks in time series data. They operate by identifying alterations in the underlying properties of a time series, like mean, variance, or trend, to indicate points where the series deviates from its prior behavior. These shifts are typically detected by comparing segments of the time series across different intervals and measuring statistical discrepancies between them. Such methods are especially valuable for identifying transitions in natural phenomena or system behaviors, enabling the detection of anomalies or adapting predictive models accordingly. One advanced method is Bayesian inference, which effectively identifies change points in complex and high-dimensional time series data. This approach aids in understanding system dynamics, detecting anomalies, and making future projections [
29]. Bayesian analysis uses a probabilistic model to measure confidence in inferences based on specific assumptions. It treats unknown parameters or hypotheses as random variables rather than constants, making it particularly suitable for climate research [
30]. In our study, we used the R version 4.4.1 bcp.package for Bayesian change point analysis, which returns the posterior probability of a change point occurring at each time index in the series. This package is designed to detect changes in the mean of independent Gaussian observations [
31]. Interpreting a shift involves assessing the posterior probability at each point: a high posterior probability indicates a likely structural break. Structural breaks suggest that the process generating the data has undergone a change, making the patterns before the break potentially different from those after it. Structural breaks can highlight particular weather thresholds (e.g., wind speeds, precipitation levels) where transmission line reliability begins to decline. This can be useful for modeling the risk of outages under specific severe weather conditions and planning preventive maintenance or design reinforcements for resilience.
4. Discussion and Conclusions
This study investigates the impact of various meteorological conditions on the frequency of unplanned outages of overhead transmission lines (OHTLs) in Lithuania’s 0.4–35 kV power grid from January 2013 to March 2023. The investigation revealed that wind gust speeds, heavy precipitation, and lightning are the primary drivers of these outages, with compounded meteorological conditions significantly exacerbating the risk. Meanwhile, the direct impact of temperature is negligible.
A key factor is the significant rise in outage rates as wind gust speeds increase. When wind speeds reach 21 m/s, the number of outages increases 15-fold, and at 25 m/s, the outages rise 25-fold. This increase is more pronounced in forested areas where a 15-fold increase is observed at 20 m/s compared to 21 m/s in non-forested areas. This significant influence of wind gusts on outage rates aligns with findings from studies in other countries [
19,
32]. These findings are essential for power grid management, emphasizing the need for focused interventions in heavily forested areas frequently exposed to strong winds.
Precipitation, particularly heavy rainfall and snowfall, also plays a critical role. The analysis shows a significant increase in outages with accumulated rainfall and snowfall. A 15-fold increase in outages is observed when 3 h accumulated rainfall exceeds 32 mm. Similarly, when 12 h snowfall exceeds 16 mm, the relative number of outages increases 15-fold, highlighting the severe impact of heavy snowfall on the power grid. The substantial increase in outages during heavy precipitation events corresponds with the other research [
13,
33]. However, our study offers a more precise quantification of the impact thresholds specific to the Lithuanian conditions.
Lightning discharges are another significant factor contributing to substantial outages, especially in forested regions. The data indicate that during periods of high lightning activity, the number of outages can spike dramatically. For example, when the frequency of cloud-to-ground lightning strikes exceeds 50 per hour (per 1000 km2), the number of outages increases by approximately 10-fold compared to periods with no lightning. In forested areas, the impact is even more pronounced, with the number of outages increasing up to 12-fold under similar lightning conditions. However, lightning often affects areas where wind or precipitation during storms likely played a role, making it challenging to pinpoint the exact cause of each outage.
This study’s most critical insight lies in its analysis of the compound effect of meteorological factors. The combined impact of strong winds and heavy precipitation (rainfall or snowfall) significantly amplifies the outage risk. For example, even with a small amount of rainfall (8 mm in 3 h), the outage rate increases sharply when combined with wind gusts exceeding 20 m/s. Similarly, in forested areas, the relative number of outages reaches 15 when wind gusts are 18 m/s or more, coupled with 3 mm of rainfall over 3 h. For snowfall, the relative number of outages increases 15-fold with only 1–2 mm of snowfall when wind speeds in gusts are higher than 15 m/s. Such gusting wind speeds, along with rainfall and snowfall accumulation over 3 and 12 h periods, occur relatively frequently. Consequently, the hazard posed by these compound events is significant and represents a substantial risk to the power grid. Other studies have demonstrated that compound events, such as the combination of strong winds and precipitation, have a greater impact on overhead power line damage than wind alone [
2]. This further underscores the importance of incorporating compound events into risk assessment and management strategies.
Such studies help to understand how different meteorological factors, both individually and in combination, determine the reliability of power grids. By identifying specific thresholds, such as wind speeds or precipitation values that lead to increases in power outages in Lithuania, targeted mitigation strategies can be developed. Emphasizing the compounded effects of multiple weather phenomena highlights the need for a holistic approach to infrastructure resilience. Such studies are essential for policy making, optimizing resource allocation and ultimately strengthening the resilience of power systems in the face of climate change and the increasing frequency of extreme weather events [
16].