1. Introduction
A regular two-graph is the pair
, where
is a finite set of vertices and
is a set of unordered triples of
such that every four-subset of
contains an even number of triples of
and every pair of vertices lies in the same number of triples of
. G. Higman introduced regular two-graphs, and his work was continued by Taylor in [
1], where he connected regular two-graphs with strongly regular graphs. The first attempt at classifying regular two-graphs on at most 50 vertices was made by Bussemaker, Mathon, and Seidel in [
2], and they produced a classification for all regular two-graphs with less than 30 vertices. Spence and McKay continued their work in [
3,
4]. In [
5] also, the authors increased the number of known regular two-graphs on 38 and 42 vertices. As far as we know, the number of known regular two-graphs on up to 50 vertices is listed in
Table 1. In the table,
n denotes the number of vertices and
is the number of known regular two-graphs, where the number is overlined if the classification is complete for the particular case.
The classification and enumeration of regular two-graphs is closely related to one of the main problems of strongly regular graph theory—the construction and classification of strongly regular graphs with given parameters.
Let be a simple regular graph with v vertices and of valency k. is a strongly regular graph with parameters if any two adjacent vertices have common neighbors, while any two nonadjacent vertices have common neighbors. We denote strongly regular graphs with parameters by SRG .
Regular two-graphs are related to strongly regular graphs in a few ways. First, the descendants of regular two-graph on
v vertices are strongly regular graphs with parameters
. Moreover, a strongly regular graph with parameters
will be associated with a regular two-graph if and only if
. For more information about descendants and graphs associated with a two-graph, see
Section 1.1.
Classification for strongly regular graphs with up to 36 vertices has been performed. The SRGs with up to 50 vertices that still need to be classified are those with parameters
,
,
,
,
, and
. In this work, we are interested in SRGs connected to regular two-graphs on up to 50 vertices, regardless of whether they are descendants or associated with a regular two-graph. Since SRGs
and SRGs
with nontrivial automorphisms were enumerated (see [
5,
6,
7]), our interest has been on strongly regular graphs with parameters
,
, and
. The descendants of a regular two-graph on 46 vertices are SRGs
; the descendants of a regular two-graph on 50 vertices are SRGs
; for SRGs
, the associated two-graph on 50 vertices is regular.
In [
8], we presented a method to construct strongly regular graphs with an automorphism group of composite order from orbit matrices. We used this method in this work to construct strongly regular graphs. Next, we constructed related regular two-graphs, and in a final step, we obtained descendants of these regular two-graphs.
The aim of this work was to enumerate SRGs , SRGs , and SRGs with as the automorphism group and update the results on regular two-graphs on 46 and 50 vertices and their descendants.
Since the SRGs with parameters
,
, and
having
as the automorphism group are classified (see [
9]), we enumerated SRGs
, SRGs
, and SRGs
with an automorphism group of order six and constructed two-graphs related to them. In this way, we enumerated all regular two-graphs on 46 vertices and on 50 vertices that have at least one descendant with an automorphism group of order six or at least one strongly regular graph, associated with it having an automorphism group of order six. Thus, we found 236 new regular two-graphs on 46 vertices and 51 new regular two-graphs on 50 vertices, and we obtained 3172 new SRG
and 398 new SRG
as descendants of the corresponding regular two-graphs.
In
Section 1.1, we give a brief overview of the basic definitions and background results. Then, in
Section 2, we explain the methods we used in this work: construction of strongly regular graphs from their orbit matrices, construction of two-graphs from strongly regular graphs, and construction of descendants of two-graphs. We used the method of constructing strongly regular graphs with an automorphism group of composite order from their orbit matrices in
Section 3 to classify strongly regular graphs with parameters
,
, and
that have an abelian group of order six as the automorphism group. In addition to this classification, in
Section 3.4, we use the classification of SRGs
with a nonabelian group of order six as the automorphism group to construct all regular two-graphs on 46 that have at least one descendant with an automorphism of order six. In
Section 3.5, we use the classification of SRGs
and SRGs
having an automorphism of order six to construct all regular two-graphs on 50 vertices that have at least one descendant with an automorphism of order six or at least one strongly regular graph with an automorphism of order six associated with it. We also construct descendants of the new regular two-graphs and obtain new strongly regular graphs with parameters
and
. Finally, we give a brief overview and the conclusion in
Section 4.
For the construction and study of the orbit matrices, graphs, and two-graphs, we used our programs written for GAP [
10].
1.1. Basic Definitions and Background
Here, we give a brief review of the basic definitions and background results taken from [
5,
11,
12,
13,
14]. For more details on strongly regular graphs and regular two-graphs, we refer the reader to [
11,
12,
13,
14].
A two-graph is the pair , where is a finite set of vertices and is a set of unordered triples of , called coherent triples, with the property that every four-subset of contains an even number of coherent triples. A regular two-graph is a two-graph where each pair of vertices is contained in the same number of coherent triples. The complement of two-graph is two-graph such that is the complement of in the set of all three subsets of . A self-complementary two-graph is a two-graph that is isomorphic to its complement. We say that two-graphs and are isomorphic if there is a bijection on the set of vertices that induces a bijection on the set of coherent triples. The automorphism group of a two-graph is the group of permutations on the set of vertices that preserves the set of triples, and the full automorphism group is the group of all such permutations. For the two-graph , we denote its full automorphism group by .
Let
be a simple regular graph with
v vertices and of valency
k.
is a strongly regular graph with parameters
if any two adjacent vertices have
common neighbours, while any two nonadjacent vertices have
common neighbours. We denote strongly regular graphs with parameters
by SRG
. A conference graph is SRG
. An automorphism of a strongly regular graph is a permutation of the set of vertices preserving adjacency, and the full automorphism group is the group of all such permutations. For the graph
, we denote its full automorphism group by
. For strongly regular graphs
and
, and for
, the
G-isomorphism is an isomorphism
for which there is an automorphism
such that, for every
and every
, it follows:
Two-graphs are related to graphs in several ways. First, there are graphs associated with two-graphs, and second, there are graphs called descendants of two-graphs. From the graph , we can construct two-graph by defining a triple of as coherent if the triple induces a subgraph in with an odd number of edges. In this case, we say that two-graph is associated with two-graph . If is SRG , then the associated two-graph is regular if and only if . From a two-graph , we can construct a graph , called a descendant of , in the following way: we fix and let be the vertex set of , then set for any two other vertices to be adjacent in if is coherent in . The two-graph is regular if and only if each of its descendants is SRG . Conference two-graphs are those that have conference graphs as descendants.
In this paper, we classified SRGs , SRGs , and SRG that have an abelian group of order six as the automorphism group. We also enumerated regular two-graphs on 45 vertices with at least one descendant with automorphisms of order six and regular two-graphs on 50 vertices that have at least one descendant with automorphisms of order six or at least one strongly regular graph with automorphisms of order six associated with it. Since SRGs and SRGs are conference graphs, regular two-graphs on 46 and on 50 vertices are also conference two-graphs.
3. Results and Discussion
In this section, we present the classification of SRGs
, SRGs
, and SRGs
that have
as the automorphism group by using the method described in
Section 2.1. We also enumerated all SRGs
, SRGs
, and SRGs
with an automorphism of order six and constructed regular two-graphs on 46 and 50 vertices from them. In this way, we found 236 new regular two-graphs on 46 vertices and 51 new regular two-graphs on 50 vertices, and we obtained 3172 new SRG
and 398 new SRG
as descendants of the corresponding regular two-graphs.
3.1. SRG (45,22,10,11) with as Automorphism Group
There are 2104 strongly regular graphs with parameters
that are descendants of 97 known regular two-graphs with 46 vertices (see [
2,
20,
21]). Moreover, there are 288 SRGs
with the symmetric group
as the automorphism group (see [
9], Theorem 6), and 208 of them are not descendants of known regular two-graphs. As far as we know, these are the only known SRGs
. The analysis of the known SRGs
is presented in
Table 2. The eigenvalues of SRG
are
.
Here, we present the results of SRGs having as the automorphism group.
We constructed them using the method described above. First, we determined all permissible orbit length distributions
by solving the system of equations:
We obtained 190 possibilities for the distributions and then found the corresponding prototypes for each orbit distribution using Mathematica.
A prototype of a fixed row for the distribution
is a vector
whose components are nonnegative integer solutions of linear equations:
A prototype of a row
r corresponding to an orbit of length
for the distribution
is a vector
satisfying this system of linear equations:
We constructed the orbit matrices row-by-row using the prototypes while eliminating mutually
G-isomorphic orbit matrices. In this case, only one distribution leads to any orbit matrices. The next steps are to refine the obtained orbit matrices, i.e., to construct the corresponding orbit matrices for
and, finally, to construct the SRGs with parameters
. For the construction, we used our programs written in GAP. For each orbit length distribution, we present the number of nonisomorphic orbit matrices for
, the number of orbit matrices for
, and the number of constructed SRGs with parameters
in
Table 3.
Using GAP, we checked isomorphisms of strongly regular graphs and compared them with known SRG , then found that, among the constructed strongly regular graphs, there are 208 mutually nonisomorphic graphs, 204 of which are new. The results of our construction and an analysis of the full automorphism groups of the 208 constructed graphs are summarized in Theorem 1.
Theorem 1. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 208 strongly regular graphs with parameters (45, 22, 10, 11) whose automorphism group is isomorphic to a cyclic group of order six. The full automorphism group of these graphs is presented in Table 4. We analyzed the SRGs having or as the automorphism group and eliminated the isomorphic SRGs using our programs written in GAP. The results are summarized in the following theorem.
Theorem 2. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 496 strongly regular graphs with parameters (45,22,10,11) whose automorphism group has order six.
3.2. SRG (49, 24, 11, 12) with as Automorphism Group
According to [
22], there are 54 regular two-graphs on 50 vertices giving 785 descendants, i.e., SRGs
. In addition, there are 72 SRGs
having the symmetric group of order six as the automorphism group (see [
9], Theorem 8), and 50 of them are not descendants of known regular two-graphs. As far as we know, these are the only known SRGs
. The analysis of the known SRGs
is presented in
Table 5. The eigenvalues of SRG
are
.
Here, we present all SRGs
with
as the automorphism group and show that there are exactly 99 of them. We constructed them using the method described above. First, we checked all permissible orbit length distributions
by solving the system of equations:
We obtained 259 possibilities for distributions and then found the corresponding prototypes for each orbit distribution using Mathematica.
A prototype of a fixed row for the distribution
is a vector
whose components are nonnegative integer solutions of linear equations:
A prototype of a row
r corresponding to an orbit of length
for the distribution
is a vector
satisfying this system of linear equations:
We constructed the orbit matrices row-by-row using the prototypes while eliminating mutually
G-isomorphic orbit matrices. We obtained 259 possibilities for orbit length distributions, but only a few of them led to orbit matrices. The next steps were to refine the obtained orbit matrices, i.e., construct the corresponding orbit matrices for
and, finally, construct the SRGs with parameters
. For the construction, we used our programs written in GAP. For each orbit length distribution, we present the number of nonisomorphic orbit matrices for
, the number of orbit matrices for
, and the number of constructed SRGs with parameters
in
Table 6.
Using GAP, we checked the isomorphisms of strongly regular graphs and compared them with known SRG , then found that, among the constructed strongly regular graphs, there are 99 mutually nonisomorphic graphs, 50 of which are new. The results of our construction and an analysis of the full automorphism groups of the constructed 99 graphs are summarized in the following statement.
Theorem 3. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 99 strongly regular graphs with parameters (49,24,11,12) whose automorphism group is isomorphic to a cyclic group of order six. The full automorphism group of these graphs is presented in Table 7. We analyzed the SRGs having or as the automorphism group and eliminated the isomorphic SRGs using our programs written in GAP. The results are summarized in Theorem 4.
Theorem 4. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 145 strongly regular graphs with parameters (49,24,11,12) having an automorphism group of order six.
3.3. SRG (50,21,8,9) with as Automorphism Group
There are exactly 18 Steiner
systems, and 18 SRGs (
) obtained from them can be found in [
22], while 3 of them have a nonabelian automorphism group of order six. Moreover, there are 42 other SRGs (
) with a nonabelian automorphism group of order six (see [
9], Theorem 9). In
Table 8, we present the analysis of the known SRGs
. The eigenvalues of SRG
are
.
Here, we present the 51 constructed SRGs that have an abelian automorphism group of order six.
We constructed them using the method described above. First, we checked all permissible orbit length distributions
by solving the system of equations:
We obtained 170 possibilities for the distributions and then found the corresponding prototypes for each orbit distribution using Mathematica.
A prototype of a fixed row for the distribution
is a vector
whose components are nonnegative integer solutions of linear equations:
A prototype of a row
r corresponding to an orbit of length
for the distribution
is a vector
satisfying this system of linear equations:
We constructed the orbit matrices row-by-row using the prototypes while eliminating mutually
G-isomorphic orbit matrices. Only a few of the orbit length distributions led to orbit matrices. The next steps were to refine the obtained orbit matrices, i.e., construct the corresponding orbit matrices for
and, finally, construct the SRGs with parameters
. For the construction, we used our programs written in GAP. For each orbit length distribution, we present the number of nonisomorphic orbit matrices for
, the number of orbit matrices for
, and the number of constructed SRGs with parameters
in
Table 9.
Using GAP, we checked the isomorphisms of strongly regular graphs and compared them with known SRG , then found that, among the constructed strongly regular graphs, there are 51 mutually nonisomorphic graphs, 45 of which are new. The results of our construction and an analysis of the full automorphism groups of the 51 constructed graphs are summarized in Theorem 5.
Theorem 5. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 51 strongly regular graphs with parameters (50, 21, 8, 9) whose automorphism group is isomorphic to a cyclic group of order six. The full automorphism group of these graphs is presented in Table 10. By analyzing the SRGs having or as the automorphism group and eliminating the isomorphic SRGs with GAP, we obtained the results summarized in Theorem 6.
Theorem 6. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 90 strongly regular graphs with parameters (50, 21, 8, 9) whose automorphism group is of order six.
3.4. Regular Two-Graphs on 46 Vertices
There are at least 97 regular two-graphs on 46 vertices (see [
2,
20,
21]), yielding 2104 descendants that are strongly regular graphs with parameters
. Representatives of the descendants can be found in [
2,
21,
23]. The analysis of the known regular two-graphs on 46 vertices is shown in
Table 11. The second column of the table contains the order of the corresponding full automorphism group of the regular two-graph
, while in the third column, we give the number of non-isomorphic descendants of
with a given full automorphism group. In the last column, we indicate whether a
is self-complementary or not, and in the first column, we give the number of regular two-graphs
that have the given properties.
In
Section 3.4.1, we analyze SRGs
with
or
as the automorphism group and construct the corresponding two-graphs. In this way, we classified regular two-graphs on 46 vertices that have at least one descendant with an automorphism group of order six, while increasing the number of known regular two-graphs on 46 vertices from 97 to 333 and the number of known SRGs
from 2104 to 5276.
3.4.1. Descendants with an Automorphism of Order Six
From Theorem 2, we know that there are 496 strongly regular graphs with parameters with an automorphism group of order six. We analyzed these strongly regular graphs and obtained the following result.
Theorem 7. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 240 regular two-graphs on 46 vertices that have at least one descendant with an automorphism group of order six, and among them, there are 14 self-complementary regular two-graphs. They give rise to 3200 strongly regular graphs with parameters (45, 22, 10, 11).
Proof of Theorem 7. From 496 SRGs
with an automorphism group of order six, we constructed the corresponding regular two-graphs on 45 vertices and eliminated the isomorphic ones. We obtained 240 regular two-graphs
, and among them, there are 14 self-complementary two-graphs and 113 pairs of complementary two-graphs. We constructed 3200 descendants from these regular two-graphs. The results on the constructed regular two-graphs are summarized in
Table 12, and in the table, each pair of complementary two-graphs is represented by one of them.
Table 12.
Descendants of the regular two-graphs on 46 vertices.
Table 12.
Descendants of the regular two-graphs on 46 vertices.
i | |
Descendants of | “S” |
---|
1–42 | 6 | | NO |
43–102 | 6 | | NO |
103–106 | 12 | | NO |
107–111 | 12 | | NO |
112–113 | 24 | | NO |
114–121 | 6 | | YES |
122–123 | 12 | | YES |
124–127 | 24 | | YES |
Using our programs written in GAP, we compared the constructed two-graph with already known regular two-graphs on 46 vertices and found that the graphs , and were already known, so 236 of the constructed two-graphs are new. The results obtained are summarized in the following theorem.
Theorem 8. Up to isomorphism, there are at least 333 regular two-graphs on 46 vertices. Among them there are 27 self-complementary two-graphs, and they give rise to 5276 nonisomorphic descendants.
3.5. Regular Two-Graphs on 50 Vertices
There are at least 54 regular two-graphs on 50 vertices yielding 785 descendants that are strongly regular graphs with parameters
. Representatives of the descendants can be found in [
23]. The analysis of known regular two-graphs on 50 vertices is shown in
Table 13. The second column of the table contains the order of the corresponding full automorphism group of the regular two-graph
, while in the third column, we give the number of non-isomorphic descendants of
with a given full automorphism group. In the last column, we indicate whether a
is self-complementary or not, and in the first column, we give the number of regular two-graphs
having the given properties.
Since it holds for SRG that , the associated two-graph is a regular two-graph on 50 vertices.
In
Section 3.5.1, we analyze SRGs
and SRGs
with
or
as the automorphism group and construct the corresponding two-graphs. In this way, we classified regular two-graphs on 50 vertices that have at least one descendant with an automorphism group of order six or at least one graph associated with it having an automorphism group of order six and increase the number of known regular two-graphs on 50 vertices from 54 to 105 and the number of known SRGs
from 835 to 1233.
3.5.1. Descendants with an Automorphism of Order Six
We analyzed 145 SRGs and 90 SRGs with an automorphism of order six and obtained the following result.
Theorem 9. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly 72 regular two-graphs on 50 vertices that have at least one descendant with an automorphism group of order six or at least one graph associated with it having an automorphism group of order six. Among them, there are 10 self-complementary regular two-graphs, and they give rise to 587 strongly regular graphs with parameters (49,24,11,12).
Proof of Theorem 9. From SRGs
and SRGs
with an automorphism group of order six, we constructed the corresponding two-graphs and eliminated the isomorphic ones. We obtained 72 regular two-graphs
, and among them, there are 10 self-complementary two-graphs and 31 pairs of complementary two-graphs. We constructed 587 descendants from these regular two-graphs. The results on the constructed regular two-graphs are summarized in
Table 14, and in the table, each pair of complementary two-graphs is represented by one of them.
Table 14.
Descendants of the regular two-graphs on 50 vertices.
Table 14.
Descendants of the regular two-graphs on 50 vertices.
i | |
Descendants of | “S” |
---|
1–2 | 6 | | NO |
3–4 | 6 | | NO |
5 | 6 | | NO |
6–7 | 6 | | NO |
8 | 6 | | NO |
9–18 | 6 | | NO |
19 | 12 | | NO |
20 | 18 | | NO |
21–23 | 18 | | NO |
24 | 24 | | NO |
25 | 24 | | NO |
26 | 24 | | NO |
27 | 36 | | NO |
28 | 72 | | NO |
29 | 126 | | NO |
30 | 144 | | NO |
31 | 1008 | | NO |
32 | 6 | | YES |
33–34 | 6 | | YES |
35–36 | 12 | | YES |
37 | 24 | | YES |
38 | 48 | | YES |
39 | 150 | | YES |
40 | 3528 | | YES |
41 | 117,600 | | YES |
Using our programs written in GAP, we compared the constructed regular two-graphs with known regular two-graphs on 50 vertices and found that 21 graphs:
were already known, so of the constructed two-graphs, 51 are new. The results are summarized in the following theorem.
Theorem 10. Up to isomorphism, there are at least 105 regular two-graphs on 50 vertices. Among them, there are 11 self-complementary two-graphs, leading to 1233 nonisomorphic descendants.