1. Introduction
Xenoliths of diamond-bearing peridotites and eclogites as well as inclusions of olivine- and silica-normative minerals in diamonds [
1] are indicative of the ultrabasic–basic evolution of diamond-forming silicate-carbonate-(C-O-H-fluid) systems in the depths of the upper mantle. The combined genesis of diamond-bearing rocks and paragenetic inclusions in diamonds occurs in upper mantle diamond-forming chambers [
2]. Taken together, these rocks and diamonds were transferred by kimberlitic magma from the mantle chambers through the cumulative centers of the Earth’s core to diamond-bearing explosion tubes [
3,
4,
5,
6,
7]. The upper mantle xenoliths of native peridotites and eclogites, enclosing the diamond-forming chambers, were also captured by kimberlitic magmas [
1,
8]. It is evident that these rocks were formed as a result of ultrabasic–basic magmatism evolution in a period of crystallization in the global magma ocean with a pyrolite composition [
9].
In the absence of experimental evidence, the physico-chemical causes and mechanisms of the ultrabasic–basic evolution of the upper mantle magmatic systems remain unknown [
10,
11,
12,
13]. H. J. Yoder relates the key problem in the following principle question: how is the crystallization of products of partial melting of garnet peridotite accompanied by the disappearance of two main phases—olivine and orthopyroxene—while only garnet and clinopyroxene are formed (i.e., eclogite) [
14].
The question requires a closer look at the liquidus structure of the multicomponent olivine-clinopyroxene/omphacite-corundum-coesite (Ol-Cpx/Omp-Crn-Coe) system of the upper mantle (
Figure 1) [
15]. The composition diagram of the multicomponent system (
Figure 1a) is a complex mixture of elementary tetrahedrons and simplexes, two of which are ultrabasic—peridotite/pyroxenite P
1-peritectic (A) and Ol-Crn-eclogitic E
1-eutectic (B)—and three of which are basic—Crn-Ky-eclogitic E
2-eutectic (C), Ky-Coe-eclogitic E
3-eutectic (D) and Coe-Opx-eclogitic P
2-peritectic (E). The complex coordinate framework of the peridotite–eclogite system and a diagram of the liquidus structure are projected onto the divariant section Ol,Cpx-Crn,Cpx/Omp-Coe,Omp, presented in
Figure 1b. Each simplex is a bearer of only one invariant eutectic or peritectic point.
One distinction between the ultrabasic and basic simplexes of the upper mantle substance is the inner plane Opx-Cpx/Omp-Grt-Crn of the complex diagram. In this case, a univariant cotectic Opx, Cpx, Grt, L of the simplex A (2↔15 with maximum), connecting the ultrabasic P1 and basic P2 peritectics (simplex E), has a temperature maximum (i.e., thermal barrier) at a piercing point in the inner boundary plane. Another thermal barrier exists at a univariant cotectic Cpx/Omp, Grt, Crn, L of simplex B (6↔7) between ultrabasic eutectic E1 and basic eutectic E2 of simplex C.
It should be realized that the boundaries between simplexes represent a peculiar kind of physico-chemical barrier, considering that evolution of the multicomponent system is bounded by its liquidus structure in the volume of separate simplex. Eutectic points with minimal temperatures in the neighboring simplexes as well as temperature maxima in the piercing points also present as thermal barriers in equilibrium under fractional conditions.
Under equilibrium conditions, these thermal barriers eliminate the possibility of the melt evolving from an ultrabasic to a basic composition. In this way, the peritectic point of olivine may not exist, and in consequence, a peritectic disappearance of olivine may not be realized.
Originally, the peritectic reaction of orthopyroxene was affected under conditions of ultrabasic–basic evolution of upper mantle magmatic systems. The reaction has been experimentally studied in the multicomponent olivine-orthopyroxene-clinopyroxene-garnet (Ol-Opx-Cpx-Grt) system in its polythermal Opx
51Ol
09Grt
40-Cpx
51Ol
09Grt
40 section at 4.0 GPa and 1450 °C [
7,
16]. As a result, orthopyroxene disappears in the peritectic reaction with the melting and formation of clinopyroxene. A similar simplified reaction of enstatite melting with formation of diopside was studied in experiments at 2.0 GPa and 1650 °C [
17] and at 3.0 GPa and 1750 °C [
18]. In this case, the peritectic reaction of orthopyroxene is favored over evolution of the upper mantle magmatism only in ultrabasic compositions [
15].
As for the olivine problems, a contradiction arises between mineralogical data concerning the probability of its disappearance via the ultrabasic–basic magma evolution on the one hand, and physico-chemical evidence of the impossibility of the olivine peritectic reaction under equilibrium conditions on the other. Nevertheless, an experimental observation of the solid-state reaction of olivine and jadeite with garnet formation [
19] allows for the olivine peritectic reaction with jadeite-bearing melt and garnet formation under fractional crystallization conditions.
After the peritectic point P
1 Ol, Opx, Cpx, Grt, L (
Figure 1b), olivine persists only in compositions of the univariant cotectic Ol, Cpx, Grt, L (3→4 without a maximum) that is directed to the eutectic point E
1 of the adjacent ultrabasic simplex. Under conditions of fractional crystallization, the figurative point of the system composition is liable to move within the ultrabasic composition along the univariant cotectic Ol, Cpx, Grt, L to eutectic point E
1 if the jadeite component in the system is absent or its concentration is restricted.
Meanwhile, after fractional removal of clinopyroxene, a portion of the jadeite component in the residual melts is first accompanied by the growth in clinopyroxene and then in omphacite components in the general composition of the system. As a result, portion 3 of the univariant cotectic Ol, Cpx, Grt, L is gradually displaced in the direction of the boundary plane Opx-Cpx/Omp-Grt-Crn (
Figure 1b). The increase in jadeite concentration also produces the boundary system Jd-Di with completely miscible components. As a result, the new voluminous frontier simplex Ol-Jd-Di-Grt is formed. This simplex forms in the boundary space between the ultrabasic and basic compositions. Thus, the role of the jadeite component in the fractional multicomponent magmatic system changes from an impurity in the ultrabasic peridotites to the system-forming component of basic eclogites.
Thus, under natural conditions, the olivine peritectic reaction represents a key mechanism in the ultrabasic–basic evolution of the upper mantle magmatism. The Earth’s gravitational field is favorable to fractional magma evolution and correspondingly to progressive compositional changes in the general system as the residual melts. In these circumstances, the forming minerals break away from the mother melts, whereas low-melting components (including jadeite) accumulate in the melts. Finally, sequential crystallization of clinopyroxene and omphacite results in formation of the continuous jadeite-diopside solid solutions.
Experimental studies of melting phase relations of the upper mantle ultrabasic–basic Ol-Jd-Di system in the Ol-Omp (=Jd
62Di
38) polythermal section (
Figure 2 and
Figure 3) at 6 GPa reveal a peritectic reaction of olivine and jadeite-bearing melt with formation of garnet [
20]. As a result, a transition to the basic univariant cotectic Omp, Grt, L is observed with formation of bimineral eclogites. It can be seen that the liquidus structure of the Ol–Di–Jd–(reactionary Grt) system (
Figure 3) is of special interest as a peculiar “physico-chemical bridge” between the ultrabasic peridotite-pyroxenite and basic eclogite rocks of the upper mantle garnet-peridotite facies. These results reveal not only genetic relations between ultrabasic and basic rocks but also physico-chemical mechanisms of continuous fractional magmatic evolution and petrogenesis from olivine-bearing peridotites to silica-saturated eclogites. These data provide an explanation for the continual petrochemical trends of rock-forming components in clinopyroxenes/omphacites and garnets of differentiated rocks of garnet-peridotite facies [
21].
The fluid-bearing system Ol-Di-Jd-(C-O-H) in the Ol
95(C-O-H)
05–Omp
95(C-O-H)
05 polythermal section [
22] (
Figure 4 and
Figure 5) was also investigated experimentally at 6 GPa. It was found that a super-critical C-O-H fluid (with content of 5.0 wt.%) influences the composition and temperature of the peritectic reaction of olivine and jadeite-bearing melt with formation of garnet. This reaction controls the closing stage of the fractional ultrabasic–basic evolution of upper mantle magmatic melts. According to experimental evidence, the reaction retains its significance, since the C-O-H fluid components do not induce changes in melting phase relations of the ultrabasic–basic olivine-jadeite-diopside-(reactionary Grt)-(C-O-H-fluid) system at 6 GPa. Along with this, metasomatic CO
2 carbonization of silicates and solvation of H
2O fluid in completely mixed silicate–carbonate melts were found. It also was found that C-O-H fluid favorably influences the temperature decreases of liquidus and solidus boundaries, respectively, from 1660 to 1580 °C and from 1420 to 1290 °C, as well as increases the olivine component in the olivine peritectic reaction by 10 wt.%.
Thus, peritectic reactions of orthopyroxene and olivine with melts lead to conversion of the ultrabasic peridotite mineral system into the basic eclogitic one under conditions of the upper mantle fractional magmatic evolution. It is essential that xenoliths of diamond-bearing peridotites and eclogites in kimberlitic explosion tubes as well as inclusions of the olivine- and silica-normative minerals in diamonds are able to influence the possibility of an ultrabasic–basic evolution of the upper mantle diamond-forming multicomponent silicate-carbonate-(C-O-H-fluid) system. However, the problem has still not been studied with physico-chemical experiments.
Meanwhile, the genesis of diamond and associated mineral phases is realized in the upper mantle diamond-forming chambers according to the mantle-carbonatite theory [
7]. Under these conditions, the parental silicate-carbonate media of diamonds and genetically associated phases are formed by streams of C-O-H-fluids reacting with native silicate rocks of the upper mantle. The C-O-H fluid inclusions in diamonds and xenolithic minerals testify to its presence in the mantle at pressures up to 10 GPa [
23]. In this case, the fluid compositions are variable, from CO
2 enriched with H
2O to H
2O enriched with CO
2 [
24]. Genetic links between the mantle silicate and diamond-forming silicate-carbonate systems originate in metasomatic reactions of CO
2 with upper mantle silicate minerals, resulting in formation of carbonate minerals and melts. Then, the same mantle minerals and graphite were dissolved in carbonate and completely miscible silicate-carbonate melts containing C-O-H fluid. As a result, chambers of diamond-forming silicate-carbonate-(C-O-H-fluid)-carbon melts were formed. In these processes, the peritectic reaction of olivine and jadeite-bearing melt with formation of garnet moved to take place in the silicate components of the diamond-forming system. Carbonate-bearing diamond-forming melts are effective solvents of solid carbon phases, producing carbon-saturated diamond solutions. Oversaturated diamond silicate-carbonate melt solutions of carbon are generated at lower temperatures in the diamond-forming chamber. This leads to the spontaneous crystallization of diamond. As a result, diamonds with paragenetic mineral inclusions as well as diamond-bearing peridotites and eclogites are formed [
2]. Consolidated diamond-bearing upper mantle chambers come into existence over extended geological periods.
The ultrabasic–basic melt conversion of multicomponent diamond-forming melts of the olivine-orthopyroxene-clinopyroxene-garnet-(Mg-Fe-Ca-Na-carbonates)-(C-O-H-fluid) system under upper-mantle PT conditions has not been experimentally investigated.
The main objectives of this work are the following:
- (1)
Experimental studies at 6.0 GPa of liquidus phase relations in the diamond-forming olivine-jadeite-diopside-(Mg-Fe-Ca-Na-carbonates)-(C-O-H-fluid) system with 7.5 wt.% of fluid. Therewith, the possibility of the peritectic reaction of olivine and jadeite-bearing melt with formation of garnet will be established.
- (2)
Evaluation of the influence of carbonate components and increased content of the super-critical (C-O-H) fluid on phase relations and PT conditions of the diamond-forming system.
- (3)
Substantiation of a physico-chemical scenario for fractional ultrabasic–basic evolution of the diamond-forming silicate-carbonate-(C-O-H-fluid) melts and formation of diamond-bearing rocks and diamonds with paragenetic inclusions of ultrabasic and basic minerals.
3. Experimental Studies
The melting phase relations of the diamond-forming olivine (Ol)–jadeite (Jd)–diopsite (Di)-MgCO3-FeCO3-CaCO3-Na2CO3-(C-O-H-fluid) system were experimentally studied at 6.0 GPa in the Ol74Carb18.5(C-O-H)7.5-Omp74Carb18.5(C-O-H)7.5 polythermal section, where Ol = Fo80Fa20, Omp = Jd62Di38 and Carb = (MgCO3)25(FeCO3)25(CaCO3)25(Na2CO3)25. The content of the starting (C-O-H) fluid was 7.5 wt.%. Choosing this section permits to trace the change in system composition from an ultrabasic olivine-bearing to a basic silica-saturated system. Moreover, estimation of the transfer from clinopyroxenes, enriched with the diopside component, to omphacites, enriched with the jadeite component, is made possible.
The diagram of the melting phase relations for the system under experimental study was constructed (
Figure 8) using the electron microscopic (
Figure 9) and analytical (
Table 1) data. This permits to determine the liquidus structure of the diamond-forming system and the composition of the invariant point for the olivine peritectic reaction, which is a key physico-chemical mechanism of the fractional ultrabasic–basic evolution of diamond-forming silicate-carbonate melts.
Intense processes of carbonatization of the silicate components of minerals and melts of the diamond-forming system proceed under the action of the CO
2 components from the supercritical C-O-H fluid. This is evidenced by numerous small-sized quenched grains of Na, Mg, Fe and Ca carbonates amongst clinopyroxenes and omphacites as well as inclusions in garnets. The newly formed carbonates add themselves to the carbonate constituent of the diamond-forming system. The reactions of CO
2 fluid with olivine and other rock-forming minerals of the upper mantle with formation of Mg-carbonate are known [
29,
30]. The supercritical C-O-H-fluid becomes enriched with the H
2O component after binding of CO
2 in the formed carbonates.
The compositions of the experimental phases of olivine are variable, with an average value of (Mg
2SiO
4)
58(Fe
2SiO
4)
42. The content of the jadeite component NaAlSi
2O
6 in the clinopyroxene-omphacite solid solutions is changeable within 10–67 wt.%, and the concentration of the pyrope component in the grossular-pyrope garnets corresponds to 9.7–46.0 wt.%. Garnets are the product of the peritectic reaction of olivine and jadeite-bearing silicate-carbonate melts with dissolved H
2O fluid. Single garnet crystals may be as large as 200 µm after spontaneous crystallization (
Figure 9c,e,f).
The peritectic reaction of olivine (P) at 6.0 GPa and 1020 °C after study the Ol
74Carb
18.5(C-O-H)
7.5-Omp
74Carb
18.5(C-O-H)
7.5 polythermal section of the Ol-Jd–Di–Carb–(C-O-H-fluid) system was revealed (
Figure 8). It is necessary to turn our attention to the peritectic reaction in the phase diagram of the multicomponent system being represented as a quasi-invariant “point”. Actually, it is a short univariant line parallel to the temperature coordinate. Respectively, the combined univariant ultrabasic Ol,Grt,Cpx/Omp,L and basic Grt,Omp,L cotectics appear as narrow divariant fields. The topological peculiarities are in agreement with Rhines’ phase rule for multicomponent systems [
27].
On the basis of the experimental data, a diagram of the liquidus structure of the diamond-forming Ol
74Carb
18.5(C-O-H)
7.5-Jd
74Carb
18.5(C-O-H)
7.5-Di
74Carb
18.5(C-O-H)
7.5 system was constructed (
Figure 10). The auxiliary dotted thin line over the diagram demonstrates the relative position of the polythermal section (see
Table 1).
The peritectic point P of the diamond-forming system is shifted to the boundary of the olivine-bearing composition when compared to the similar upper mantle olivine-jadeite-diopside-(C-O-H-fluid) system with a 5.0 wt.% content of C-O-H fluid (
Figure 6) [
22]. Therewith, the solidus temperature of the diamond-forming system decreased by 270 °C down to 1000–1020 °C relative to the upper mantle silicate system Ol
95(C-O-H)
05–Omp
95(C-O-H)
05.
According to experimental data, supercritical H
2O fluid is liberated upon crystallization of the diamond-forming silicate-carbonate fluid Ol–Jd–Di–Carb-(C-O-H-fluid) and the upper mantle Ol–Jd–Di-(C-O-H-fluid) native systems [
22]. In these cases, H
2O fluid can form self-dependent subsolidus phases.
From a geochemical point of view, merging of both the diamond-forming silicate-carbonate and the upper mantle silicate systems is accompanied by them splitting into magmatic and hydrothermal systems coexisting in the open state.
According to preliminary data, evidence of hydrothermal activity is observed in the subsolidus phase assembly of the diamond-forming system in the form of embryonic geode-like structures filled with silicate and carbonate phases (
Figure 11a). The reaction of the H
2O fluid and carbonates with formation of water-bearing carbonate mineral nesquehonite (MgCO
3·3H
2O) was also established by self-dependent minerals and paragenetic inclusions in diamond (
Figure 11b).
4. Discussion
An investigation into the liquidus structure of the multicomponent diamond-forming silicate-carbonate-(C-O-H-fluid) system via physico-chemical experiments at 6.0 GPa revealed a peritectic reaction of olivine and jadeite-bearing melt with formation of garnet. Therewith, the key role of this reaction in the fractional ultrabasic–basic evolution of the parental melts for diamond and genetically associated minerals was demonstrated. As a result, a rational physico-chemical explanation has been given for the genesis of diamond-bearing peridotites and eclogites, as well as the paragenesis of diamonds with of ultrabasic and basic mineral inclusions.
The importance of the peritectic reaction of olivine and jadeite-bearing melt with formation of garnet in the fractional ultrabasic–basic evolution of the upper mantle magmatic systems and the genesis of native peridotite and eclogite rocks has been demonstrated in previous experimental studies [
20,
22]. It is probable that the physico-chemical mechanisms and processes took place at the time of the crystallization of the global magmatic ocean at upper mantle depths.
An analysis of mineralogical and experimental information, related to the upper mantle silicate rocks and diamond-forming silicate-carbonate materials, has revealed the physico-chemical mechanisms of the ultrabasic–basic evolution. A clearer view of the genetic links between diamond-forming systems and upper mantle native rocks has been obtained. The principal conclusion lies in the fact that after formation of the diamond-forming systems with the use of upper mantle native peridotite rocks, the capability of the native peridotites for the peritectic reaction of olivine was passed on to the silicate components of the diamond parental medium.
Hence, the diamond-forming processes represent the combined crystallization of diamonds and associated phases with the formation of paragenetic mineral inclusions in diamonds. The inclusions are analogous to the upper mantle minerals that were recrystallized in the completely mixed silicate-carbonate diamond-forming melts. Rock-forming minerals of the diamond-bearing rocks originated similarly and are estimated to be recrystallized analogues of the mantle minerals.
The origin of diamond-forming systems in the Earth’s mantle is among the principal questions for the mantle-carbonatite theory of diamond genesis [
7]. Under these conditions, the systems’ compositions must be suited the creation criteria for diamonds and their paragenetic and xenogenetic mineral phases [
30]. These requirements relate to diamond-bearing peridotites and eclogites as well as syngeneic mineral inclusions in diamonds.
The CO
2 component of ascending supercritical C-O-H fluid provides the metasomatic carbonation reactions of the rock-forming mantle minerals of peridotites (olivine, orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene and garnet) and/or eclogites (omphacite and garnet). As a result, diamond parental silicate-carbonate (Mg, Fe, Ca and Na) melts with dissolved elemental carbon are formed. The components of the mantle minerals are dissolved in the carbonate melts, forming the silicate constituent of the diamond-forming medium. The origin of the carbon source has been retraced by isotopic data from the accretion of the carbonaceous chondrites in mantle-native carbon-bearing rocks [
31,
32,
33]. As a result of these reactions, completely miscible silicate-carbonate melts formed. The silicate-carbonate melts, just like the carbonate ones, are the effective solvents of carbon that result in diamond-forming silicate-carbonate-carbon melt solutions. As this takes place, the silicate constituent of the melt solutions retains the ability to induce peritectic reactions of orthopyroxene and olivine. These reactions make the ultrabasic–basic transfer of the diamond-forming melts under conditions of fractional crystallization possible.
The content of the supercritical H2O fluid dissolved in silicate-carbonate melts becomes dominant in relation to the remaining CO2 fluid. Under solidus PT conditions, the completely mixed silicate-carbonate melts with dissolved H2O fluid crystallize, forming subsolidus silicate and carbonate minerals. At the same time, the components of the H2O fluid are separated, with formation of their own supercritical phase. This phase becomes the chemically active agent of hydrothermal processes. In this way, a supercritical hydrothermal system has formed that is open with respect to the enclosing silicate-carbonate subsolidus association of the diamond-forming system and is capable of physico-chemical reactions with the system.
It is probable that supercritical H2O fluid and the carbonate components are responsible for a decrease in the solidus temperature to 1000–1020 °C compared to the diamond-forming system.