1. Introduction
Nowadays, many consumers are aware of the relation between diet and health. A major interest in modifying milk fatty acids (FAs) composition, aiming to enhance the health status of consumers, was noticed in the last two decades [
1,
2,
3]. Such changes are intended to decrease the proportion of saturated FAs (SFAs) in milk fat composition, and to increase the proportion of healthy FAs, such omega-3 FAs (n-3 FAs), conjugated linoleic acid (CLA,
cis-9,
trans-11 C18:2), oleic acid (OA, C18:1
cis-9), and vaccenic acid (VA, C18:1
trans-11) [
4]. These FAs play an important role in human health by reducing the risk of chronic diseases [
5], combatting cancer, preventing atherosclerosis, reducing body fat, and modulating inflammatory and/or immune responses [
6].
The FAs profile of milk depends on several factors; nutritional management being one of most important [
7,
8]. Supplementing cow diets with different sources and types of fat is an effective way of manipulating the FAs profile of milk fat [
3,
9,
10]. Previous research demonstrated that supplementing cow diets with vegetable oils led to an increase in n-3 FAs and CLA concentration in milk fat [
7,
11]. Oils rich in linoleic acid (LA, C18:2 n-6; e.g., sunflower oil) were more effective in increasing CLA in milk fat than oils rich in α-linolenic acid (ALA, C18:3 n-3; e.g., linseed oil), which was more effective in increasing n-3 FAs in milk fat [
3,
12]. Only a limited number of studies have examined how oils which are OA-rich (oleic acid, C18:1
cis-9) (e.g., rapeseed oil) affect lactation performance, the FAs content of milk [
13,
14,
15], and enteric methane emissions in dairy cows [
16,
17]. The form of rapeseed inclusion in dairy cow diets influences the lactation performance and the FAs profile of milk fat. The research carried out by Givens et al. [
15] demonstrated that milk production was higher when rapeseed was ground, compared to the use of whole rapeseeds. The bioavailability of lipids was found to be higher when rapeseed was ground and resulted in a milk FAs profile similar to that determined by rapeseed oil, reducing milk SFAs and increasing
cis-MUFA concentrations, and a lower increase in
trans-FAs [
15]. However, direct comparisons of the efficacy of diet supplementation with fats rich in OA (rapeseed oil or rapeseed seeds), starting from different FC ratios, on milk production, milk fat FAs profile, and milk TAC, are scarce.
In dairy cow rations, modifying the forage to concentrate (FC) ratio or supplementation with unsaturated fats affects rumen fermentation pathways, resulting in different volatile fatty acids profiles and, thereby, different milk FAs composition [
18]. Increasing the proportion of concentrates in cow diets containing vegetable oils often causes a decrease in milk fat content [
17,
19,
20] and an increase in
trans FAs concentrations, that have an inhibitory effect on the de novo synthesis of some FAs [
18,
21,
22].
Increasing the concentration of nutritionally beneficial FAs in milk also increases the risk of milk fat oxidation, leading to changes in the nutritional and dietary properties of milk [
1]. To maintain high milk quality, the concentration of antioxidants should therefore be increased [
23], for them to ensure an increased antioxidant capacity of milk [
2,
24]. Higher concentrations of milk antioxidants (α-tocopherol, β-carotene, and retinol) have been reported in cows fed diets based on grass silage compared to diets rich in concentrates [
25], but also by supplementing the diet with oilseeds [
26].
Only a limited number of studies, with heterogeneous results, assessed the optimal FC ratio in diets supplemented with vegetable fats with the aim of obtaining milk with a healthier FAs profile (for human consumers), without affecting the productive performances of cows [
18,
19]. Consequently, the aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of two FC ratios and supplementation with ground rapeseed on milk production and composition, FAs profile, and the TAC of milk obtained from Jersey cows.
4. Discussion
The aim of this research was to evaluate the effect of diets with different FC ratios, supplemented or not with MR, on the intake, production and composition of milk, the FAs profile of fat, and the TAC of milk.
In general, DMI in ruminants increases with the decreasing NDF content of the diet [
18,
41]. In this research, decreasing the FC ratio increased the DMI, which is in agreement with a lower NDF content of the concentrate-rich diets. Previous studies demonstrated that DMI was strongly correlated with NE
L intake in dairy cows (r = 0.98), this conclusion being confirmed by the present study [
41].
Fats, especially those rich in UFAs, can reduce feed digestibility, can modify rumen fermentation processes (acetic acid to propionic acid ratio), ultimately leading to a decrease in DMI, especially when fats exceed 6–7% of DM [
27]. In this research, supplementing the feed with MR even if it led to an increase in the fat content to approximately 6% of DM, the intake of DM was not affected. Similar results were obtained by Chichlowski et al. [
42] when the feed of dairy cows was supplemented with ground rapeseed seeds, which increased the fat concentration in the diet to 6.4% (of DM), concluding that this amount of fat is not sufficient to change the rumen pH, acetate-propionate ratios in the rumen, and consequently feed consumption. In addition, Egger et al. [
43] and Kliem et al. [
44] found that DMI did not change when the diet of dairy cows was supplemented with 73–96 g rapeseed/kg DM.
Milk production was influenced both by the FC ratio and by supplementing the diets with MR, via their effect on DMI and NE
L intake (
Table 3). The increase in milk production in cows fed with diets rich in concentrates (HC) is due to the higher intake of easily fermentable proteins and carbohydrates, but also to the lower content of NDF and ADF, which favors the production of propionate and the synthesis of microbial proteins in the rumen [
17,
18,
45].
In a meta-analysis by Plata-Pérez et al. [
1], it was found that supplementing the diet of cows with oilseeds can increase milk production due to the increase in NE
L intake. In our study, the increased milk production in cows fed the HR diet compared to the H diet, was consistent with the higher energy density of the HR diet and, respectively, the higher intake of NE
L (
Table 3). Even if MR supplementation of the diet that had a low proportion of concentrates led to an increase in the energy density of the feed (LR compared to L), still, the daily milk production did not increase, probably due to the change in rumen fermentation and the decrease in NDF digestibility and ADF in the presence of supplemented fats [
6,
46].
The reduction of milk fat concentration in cows fed diets rich in concentrates (HC diets) is probably due to the change in rumen fermentation and the formation of
trans FAs, which inhibits FAs synthesis in the mammary gland, an aspect supported by the significant increase in total
trans C18:1 in milk fat (
Table 4) [
23]. The
trans double bond of
trans type FAs is formed during rumen fermentation and their proportion in milk fat increases in cows fed diets rich in UFAs, without leading to a decrease in milk fat percentage [
42,
47]. On the other hand, diets rich in concentrates increase propionate production in the rumen and reduce the amount of precursors of the de novo synthesis of milk FAs (i.e., acetate and butyrate), thus reducing milk fat concentrations [
7,
48].
This research confirms the findings reported by Nielsen et al. [
49] suggesting that an increased proportion of C18:1
trans-10 in milk fat is determined by a diet high in starch and low in NDF, which are associated with a reduction in milk fat content. Moreover, Lock et al. [
50] associated the high level of C18:1
trans-10 in milk with the decrease in milk fat concentration.
Milk protein content was higher in diets with a low FC ratio, probably due to the relationship between milk protein content and the provision of glucogenic nutrients (the relationship between dietary starch content and protein content from milk: R
2 = 0.40; [
45]).
Some researchers [
51] reported a decrease in milk fat content, while others reported that dietary fat supplementation had no effect [
6,
11]. When the diet is high in fat, the decrease in milk fat percentage occurs only when the
trans-10 C18:1 isomer has a higher concentration compared to the
trans-11 C18:1 isomer [
47]. In this research, supplementing the diet with MR did not lead to a decrease in the milk fat percentage, and the proportion of the
trans-10 C18:1 isomer in the milk fat was much lower compared to the
trans-11 C18:1 isomer (
Table 4), thus confirming the results of previous studies [
42,
47]. In addition, it was found that oilseeds that have a high content of LA (e.g., sunflower seeds, cotton seeds, soybeans) induce a significant decrease in milk fat concentration, because LA has an effect of inhibiting the fermentation processes in the rumen, and it is believed that LA is a substrate in the production of
trans isomers, which are related to the milk fat depression syndrome [
7,
47]. Flax seeds and rapeseed seeds, having a lower content of LA, form a smaller number of isomers that inhibit the de novo synthesis of FAs with short and medium chains in the mammary gland and thus have a smaller influence on the milk fat concentration [
1].
A number of studies have reported a close inverse relationship between the concentration of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk and milk fat content [
19,
22,
52]. In this research, the decrease in the FC ratio reduced the milk fat content but significantly increased the concentration of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA, while supplementing diets with MR had no effect on these parameters (
Table 3 and
Table 4).
The introduction of vegetable oils in the feed of cows affects the synthesis of microbial proteins, resulting in a decrease in the intake of amino acids in the duodenum and, respectively, in the concentration of milk proteins. It has been estimated that for every 100 g of fat consumed, milk protein concentration decreases by 0.03 percentage points [
7,
47]. Therefore, this research is in agreement with those previously reported, but the decrease in milk protein concentration as a result of supplementing the diets with MR was smaller: per 100 g of supplemented fat, the milk protein concentration decreased by 0.02 percentage points. It is possible that in this research the relative decrease of ruminal microorganisms, caused by the intake of PUFAs in the rumen through rapeseed, is lower, and thus the intake and absorption of amino acids in the duodenum is higher than in the case of other oleaginous seeds richer in PUFAs.
The larger amounts of concentrates in the cows’ feed favor the synthesis of propionic acid in the rumen, which in intermediate metabolism leads to a larger amount of glucose, and this causes an increase in the concentration of lactose in milk [
45]. In this research, the decrease in the FC ratio was not accompanied by an increase (
p ˃ 0.05) in the concentration of lactose in milk, although a trend in this direction was observed, probably due to the low threshold for increasing the weight of concentrates in the cows’ feed from 35% to 50%.
The inclusion of rapeseed in the diet of cows reduced the content of SFAs in milk, possibly by decreasing the production of acetic acid in the rumen, which is the main substrate for the de novo synthesis of medium-chain FAs [
1,
15].
In this research, increasing the proportion of concentrates in the cows’ feed, but also supplementing the diets with MR, led to a significant decrease in the concentration of PA in milk, thus confirming the conclusions of previous studies that reported that diets rich in starch and supplemented with vegetable oils inhibit the de novo synthesis of PA in the mammary gland [
44]. The lowest concentration of PA was found in the milk of cows fed the high-concentrate (HC) diet and could be attributed to the lower ruminal pH that occurs after the consumption of concentrates, thus confirming the previous observations of Gómez-Cortés et al. [
53]. The decrease in milk fat C16:1
cis-9 content with the MR treatments is consistent with responses reported earlier [
15], where a control diet was compared with diets containing rapeseed oil or rapeseeds milled with wheat. The lower C16:0 and C16:1
cis-9 concentrations in milk from the MR treatments was probably due, in part, to the reduction in de novo synthesis brought about by long chain UFAs [
15].
This research suggests that supplementing diets with MR favored the biohydrogenation of UFAs from feed, causing a significant increase (
p < 0.001) in the level of SA in milk fat [
54,
55,
56]. The increase in the concentration of OA in milk, in the case of diets supplemented with MR, was due to the fact that the daily intake of OA of cows fed with diets supplemented with MR (LR and HR) was higher (157 and 235 g/d, respectively) compared to the diet without MR (L and H) (41.9 and 86.5 g/d, respectively) (
Table 3). Vogdanou [
56] considers that the increased concentration of OA in milk is due to the fact that this FAs, present in large quantities in rapeseed, was not completely hydrogenated in the rumen to SA, and a small amount was isomerized and transformed into VA. The increase in the concentration of OA in milk fat can be determined by the increased dietary intake of OA from rapeseed but also by the improvement of desaturase activity in the mammary gland [
53]. In this research, desaturase activity decreased (
p ˂ 0.01) by supplementing the diet with MR, thus not confirming the conclusions formulated by Gómez-Cortés et al. [
53].
Larsen et al. [
55] reported a close relationship between the concentration of VA and
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk, as the latter is mainly formed by the desaturation of VA in the mammary gland in the presence of Δ
9-desaturase. In this research, VA increased by supplementing diets with MR (LR and HR diets compared to L and H diets), but the concentration of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk was not affected (
Table 4). The results similar to those obtained by us were previously reported by Egger et al. [
43] and Suli et al. [
3], who concluded that the inclusion of rapeseed or flaxseed in the diet of cows did not influence the content of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk fat. Other studies have shown that vegetable oil supplementation can influence the concentration of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk only when high amounts of oil are used in a diet that has an extreme FC ratio [
22].
Djordjevic et al. [
57] reported that OA may be an important precursor for the biohydrogenation of VA. In this research, this conclusion was not confirmed, because the supplementation of diets with MR, which have a high content of OA, did not increase the concentration of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk, which means that the intake increased OA in the feed did not increase the concentration of VA in the rumen. There is research that showed that supplementing the diet with vegetable oils increased the concentration of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk fat in the first week and then decreased and remained relatively constant [
9,
20,
58]. In this research, the determination of the FAs profile in milk was conducted in the third week after the start of supplementing the diet with MR.
The higher amount of concentrates in the feed led to a higher concentration of VA in the rumen and a higher level of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk (
Table 4). The increase in the concentration of VA in milk is directly related to the increase in the concentration of VA in the rumen, but also with a higher proportion of
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA in milk [
8,
59]. In this research, this theory was confirmed by the intensification of desaturation processes at the level of the mammary gland, where a part of VA in the presence of Δ
9-desaturase was transformed into
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA (
Table 4). In addition, the diets rich in concentrates (HC diets) ensured a higher intake of LA which through rumen biohydrogenation leads to the synthesis of VA from which CLA is later synthesized [
8,
60].
The introduction of rapeseed (6.4% of DM diet) in diets with different FC ratios determined an increase in the concentration of total C18:1 in milk by 12.8–23.24% (
p ˂ 0.001;
Table 4). The results of this research are comparable to those obtained by Chichlowski et al. [
42] when they supplemented the diet of cows with rapeseed seeds (14% of DM diet); but Aldrich et al. [
61] obtained a much more pronounced increase in the concentration of C18:1 in milk (by 67%) by supplementing the diet with ground rapeseed (11.2% of the DM diet). The differences in C18:1 concentration in milk fat in the current study could be attributed to the lower proportion of concentrates in the feed, the lower level of rapeseed seed supplementation, or both, compared to the study by Aldrich et al. [
61].
It is known that increasing the proportion of concentrates in feed favors the formation of
trans-10 C18:1 [
1,
62], and MR contains oleic acid which is an important precursor for
trans-10 C18:1 in the rumen. The concentration of other
trans C18:1 isomers in milk, such as
trans (6+7+8) and
trans-9 C18:1, increased with the increase in the proportion of concentrates, but also by supplementing the diets with MR (
p < 0.01;
Table 4). These increases of some C18:1
trans isomers in milk are in agreement with the studies carried out by Matamoros et al. [
62], who concluded that these FAs come from the biohydrogenation of OA in the rumen, their percentages in milk depend on the proportion of
cis-9 C18:1 in the diet. The results obtained in this study confirm that the interaction between the FC ratio of the diets, and their supplementation with MR has a major importance in determining the total
trans C18:1 concentrations in milk fat.
Supplementing the diet with MR led to an increase in the concentration of ALA (
p ˂ 0.05) in milk fat, and to a decrease in the level of LA (
p ˂ 0.01), while the increase in the proportion of concentrates in the cows’ ration had the opposite effect, namely the concentration of LA increased (
p ˂ 0.01) and the level of ALA decreased (
p ˂ 0.001) (
Table 4); this being in agreement with the concentration of these FAs in the cows’ diet (
Table 1). In fact, diets supplemented with MR provided more than twice the amount of ALA than the diets not supplemented with MR, in terms of intake, regardless of the proportion of concentrates in the feed (297.8 vs. 127.7 g/d for diets LC and 292.3 vs. 137.3 g/d for HC diets, respectively) (
Table 3). These aspects influenced the n-6/n-3 FAs ratio, which decreased (
p ˂ 0.001) by supplementing the diet with MR and increased (
p ˂ 0.001) by increasing the proportion of concentrates in the feed.
The tendency to decrease the proportion of PUFAs in milk when the diets were supplemented with MR suggests that a high proportion of rapeseed fat was saturated by the rumen biohydrogenation of UFAs, this hypothesis being supported by the increase in the concentration of VA and the decrease in the level of LA (
Table 4). Increasing the concentration of VA in milk fat is beneficial for consumers, because in the human body, VA under the action of Δ
9-desaturase is transformed into
cis-9,
trans-11 CLA [
4,
47].
Often, the assessment of the quality of milk fats in terms of the impact on human health is based on the ratio between certain FAs groups (PUFA/SFA, n-6/n-3, h/H), the AI, the TI, and the HPI. In the present study, the PUFA/SFA ratio was considerably lower (0.07–0.094) than the recommended values for human nutrition (over 0.45), in all experimental treatments, due to the high concentration of SFAs in milk [
5,
10,
63]. An n-6/n-3 FAs ratio of less than 4 is recommended in human nutrition as a means of preventing cardiovascular diseases and cancer [
5,
38]. Thus, considering the highest n-3 FAs content and the lowest n-6/n-3 FAs ratio in milk fat, the diet with a high FC ratio (65:35) supplemented with MR seems to increase the nutritional value of milk.
Milk that has a low AI and TI value, and higher h/H FA and HPI values, has a lower risk of contributing to the development of cardiovascular diseases, and thus can be considered a functional food with benefits for human health [
5,
38]. Although no organization has yet established recommended values for these fat quality indices [
4,
64], in this research we found that milk with the best fat quality was obtained from cows fed a diet with low FC and supplemented with MR (HR diet), while the diet with high FC and no MR supplement (L diet) determined the lowest quality of milk fat, in terms of impact on human health.
It is extremely important to determine the antioxidant capacity of milk because oxidation can lead to the deterioration of the nutritional quality of milk and the appearance of unpleasant flavors. The oxidative stability of milk depends mainly on the composition of FAs, as pro-oxidant factors, and on the concentration of tocopherols and carotenoids as antioxidant factors [
2,
24].
The concentration of lipophilic antioxidants in milk is directly influenced by the level of fat-soluble vitamins in animal feed [
65]. In this research, the higher concentrations of lipophilic antioxidants (α-tocopherol, retinol and all-
trans β-carotenes), recorded in the milk of cows fed with LC diets (
Table 7), are due to the significantly higher intake of α-tocopherol and all-
trans β-carotenes through food (
Table 3). On the other hand, grass silage and alfalfa hay containing 5–10 times more carotenoids than concentrates [
66] can justify the higher concentration (
p ˂ 0.05) of retinol and all-
trans β-carotenes in the milk of LC cows compared to HC. The concentration of retinol in milk, observed in this research in cows fed diets not supplemented with MR, is comparable to that reported by Mogensen et al. [
67]; however, the level of α-tocopherol and all-
trans β-carotenes was up to two times higher in this research, probably due to the higher dietary intake of antioxidants.
As expected, supplementing diets with rapeseed increased (
p ˂ 0.05) the concentration of α-tocopherol in milk (
Table 7). The research carried out by Vogdanou [
56] and Larsen et al. [
55] showed a significant increase in the amount of α-tocopherol in milk when the cows’ diet was supplemented with oilseeds (rape, flax) or rapeseed cake, concluding that the concentrations of tocopherols can be increased by increasing their supply from feed.
Noteworthy is the decrease in the retinol content of milk (raw and stored), both as a result of the increase in the amount of concentrates, and as a result of supplementing the feed with MR (
Table 7). Studies by Puppel et al. [
26] demonstrated that the use of flax seeds in cow feed caused an increase in the concentration of retinol and β-carotene in milk, aspects that were not confirmed in this research by using rapeseed.
Lipid oxidation is an inevitable process in which the double bonds of UFAs are attacked by oxidizing compounds, leading to the degradation of milk [
12,
68]. Although several authors have shown that milk becomes more susceptible to oxidation when the UFAs content increases, Salles et al. [
68] concluded that the oxidative stability of milk is more dependent on the antioxidant content than on the UFAs concentration of fat. In this research, even if supplementing diets with MR led to an increase in the concentration of UFAs in milk, the oxidative stability of milk determined by TAC (µmol TE/mL) actually increased both for raw milk and for pasteurized and stored milk. This is due to the increased intake of antioxidants (especially tocopherols) via MR supplementation, which was reflected in a higher concentration of α-tocopherol in milk, thus inhibiting the oxidation of UFAs in milk.
The supplementation of diets with MR led to increased TAC values in milk samples (
p < 0.05), the increase being greater in the case of diets with high FC ratio (
Table 7). This increase in the TAC of milk was due to the increased concentration of tocopherols in rapeseed, but also to the high content of α-tocopherol and all-
trans β-carotenes of grass silage, which provides better protection of UFAs and especially to the polyunsaturated ones that are more susceptible to oxidation. An increase in the TAC of milk was observed when the diet was supplemented with flax seeds in cows [
26], or with camelina seeds in sheep [
69].
The highest antioxidant activity of milk (3.18 µM TE/mL) was associated with the highest concentration of α-tocopherol (1.982 mg/L) measured in raw milk produced by cows fed the LR diet (high FC and supplemented with MR). These results agree with the conclusions of Puppel et al. [
26] who mention that with the increase in the level of tocopherols, the antioxidant activity of milk also increases.
In agreement with this research, the studies carried out by El-Fattah et al. [
70] demonstrated that pasteurization had no effect on the antioxidant capacity of milk. The authors mention that the antioxidant capacity of milk increases if the temperature during the heat treatment is over 100 °C, due to the release of thiol groups from proteins, which act as hydrogen donors. On the other hand, Sanlidere et al. [
71] showed that there are no significant differences between raw, pasteurized, and sterilized milk in terms of antioxidant activity (ABTS), which was 4.02, 4.47, and 4.18 µM TE/mL, respectively.
The storage of milk for 4 days in the refrigerator resulted in a decrease in the concentration of retinol and all-
trans β-carotenes, probably due to the reactive oxygen species formed during storage which were inactivated by the antioxidants in the milk [
72]. As a result of this activity, the antioxidants in milk are oxidized, thus leading to a decrease in their concentration in milk, even α-tocopherol, although this decrease was not statistically significant (
Table 7).
During storage, the TAC of milk decreases significantly in the HC groups and does not change significantly, it tends to decrease in the LC groups, being correlated with the concentration of antioxidants in the milk. Havemose et al. [
25] demonstrated that high levels of α-tocopherol and retinol in milk do not prevent the oxidation of UFAs but delay this process, thus extending the shelf life of milk and dairy products. Therefore, consumers could benefit from the nutritional qualities and bioactive compounds of milk during the 4 days of keeping the milk in the refrigerator.