3.1. Synthesis and Fundamental Properties of Gold Nanoshells
The XRD analysis confirmed the single-phase character of hydrothermally prepared Mn
0.61Zn
0.42Fe
1.97O
4 nanoparticles and their typical cubic spinel structure with
symmetry (see the XRD pattern in the lower panel of
Figure 1). The lattice parameter at room temperature was refined to a = 8.4542(2) Å, which is practically identical to a = 8.4576(4) Å reported for the given composition in the original study [
16]. The mean size of crystallites was evaluated based on the broadening of the diffraction lines by using the Rietveld method to d
XRD = 12 nm, which is also consistent with the value of 11 nm determined for the prototypical product in [
16].
Interestingly, the XRD pattern of the gold nanoshells (see the upper panel of
Figure 1) is entirely dominated by broadened diffraction lines of the cubic gold with
symmetry, while the diffraction lines of the spinel phase are not discernible, which, however, can be expected taking into account the ratio of gold and ferrite particles (12 mg + 37.5 mg Au via the ultrafine colloid and K-gold, respectively, per 1.2 mg MZF) employed in the synthesis and the magnitudes of scattering factors of Au vs. elements that form the ferrite. The actual content of ferrite in the nanoshells was estimated based on XRF, which provided a weight ratio of Mn-Zn ferrite: Au = 0.017 or 0.013 based on the ratio of Au and Fe or Mn lines, respectively, although significant uncertainties related to the quantification due to the low content of the ferrite have to be considered.
The lattice parameter of gold nanoshells was refined to a = 4.0765(1) Å, which is highly comparable with values reported for gold of high purity in bulk form, e.g, a = 4.07894(5) Å according to [
26]. The significant broadening of its diffraction lines evidenced the nanocrystalline character, and the Rietveld analysis with an isotropic model for gold crystallites provided d
XRD = 7 nm.
Conclusive data on the actual size of particles and their morphology were provided by the TEM study accompanied by a thorough analysis of size distribution. Representative transmission electron micrographs of the silica-coated ferrite nanoparticles, the subsequent intermediate decorated with fine gold seeds, and the final gold nanoshells are shown in
Figure 2a–e, while
Figure 2f presents histograms of sizes for silica-coated particles, final gold nanoshells, and also gold seeds on the silica surface of the intermediate.
A striking feature of the MZF@sil particles is the structure of their magnetic cores that were predominantly formed by small clusters of ferrite nanocrystallites and were encapsulated as a whole by a continuous silica shell. The crystallinity of individual ferrite nanoparticles and their rather random orientation in the observed clusters were evidenced by the lattice fringes visible in the HRTEM mode (
Figure 2b). In contrast, the silica shell was amorphous, and it exhibited a smooth surface and uniform thickness of 20 nm (with a standard deviation of just 2.0 nm). The mean diameter of silica-coated particles was d
mean(MZF@sil) = 72 nm, and the examined set was described by a standard deviation of 17 nm. Considering the mentioned shell thickness, the mean size of the whole magnetic cores formed by the clusters of ferrite crystallites was ≈32 nm.
The gold-decorated intermediate was characterized by highly dense and homogeneous coverage of the silica surface with fine gold seeds, which was enabled by a successful formation of a thick polyelectrolyte multilayer terminated by the cationic PDADMAC. This multilayer altered the negatively charged surface of silica to a positively charged one, thus allowing electrostatic adsorption of the negatively charged gold seeds [
27]. The mean size of the attached gold nanoparticles was determined to be d
mean(Au) = 3.6 nm with a standard deviation of 0.5 nm, which is in agreement with gold nanoparticles reported by Duff [
21].
The final gold nanoshells showed typical morphology with a rather rough surface and a somewhat porous structure clearly reminiscent of the seed-and-growth procedure. The gold nanoshells exhibited the mean diameter of dmean(MZF@sil@Au) = 127 nm, and the analyzed set was described by a standard deviation of 22 nm. The comparison of this value with dmean(MZF@sil) suggests that the mean thickness of gold nanoshells was ≈27 nm in a rough spherical approximation.
The DLS measurement of bare gold nanoshells in a dilute aqueous suspension revealed a Z-average hydrodynamic size of dhydro,Z(MZF@sil@Au) = 208 nm and polydispersity index of pdi = 0.201. The intensity distribution of the hydrodynamic size of bare nanoshells is included in Figure 5a. The difference between the DLS and TEM sizes cannot be attributed just to a hydration layer around gold nanoshells, although the hydration shell definitely increases the hydrodynamic size, and certain aggregation has to be taken into account. Importantly, the DLS of MZF@sil@Au nanoshells did not reveal colloidal instability, and the results were highly repeatable.
Hysteresis loops measured at low and room temperatures on the bare MZF particles and final gold nanoshells are presented in
Figure 3a together with the respective low-temperature virgin curves, among which also the silica-coated particles are included. The bare MZF particles exhibited high magnetization, of 102.6 A m
2 kg
−1 at 5 K and 55.3 A m
2 kg
−1 at 300 K, in the magnetic field of 3 T, which is in excellent agreement with the magnetization data reported in a thorough study on the structure and magnetic properties of hydrothermally prepared Mn-Zn ferrite nanoparticles [
17]. The MZF bare particles were characterized by a coercivity of μ
0H = 25 mT at 5 K and a practically anhysteretic curve at 300 K, where the MZF particles were either in the fully superparamagnetic regime on the timescale of DC magnetometry or exhibited a coercivity lower than the experimental limit of the measurement (given by remnant fields in the SQUID superconducting solenoid).
The gold nanoshells showed a similar response to the external magnetic field given by their ferrite cores, but two distinct features should be commented on. First, the magnitude of magnetization per mass of the material was considerably decreased since the magnetic cores were coated by robust silica and gold layers, both diamagnetic, that strongly diluted the ferrimagnetic phase. Second, the high-field region of the M-H dependence measured on the nanoshells exhibited a different slope compared to a clear linear paraprocess in the bare MZF particles. Actually, the slope of the high-field magnetization curve in the former samples was decreased by the small but already significant diamagnetic susceptibility of the coating materials.
By comparing the magnetization values of the bare MZF particles and the coated samples in a magnetic field above the hysteresis but below a significant contribution of the diamagnetic component, the weight content of the ferrite phase in the products can be roughly estimated. Specifically, at 5 K in the magnetic field of μ
0H = 0.3 T, the MZF, MZF@sil, and MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC samples were characterized by a magnetization of 91.8, 13.1, and ≈2.1 A m
2 kg
−1, respectively (see the inset in
Figure 3a), which leads to the content of Mn-Zn ferrite of 14 wt% in the MZF@sil and of only ~2 wt% in the MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC sample, which provides an unambiguous explanation for the missing diffraction lines of the spinel structure in the XRD pattern. Since the weight fraction of the organic component (a monolayer of low-molecular MBA and MMC on the gold surface) in the MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC particles was negligible, their overall composition can be roughly described as: ~2 wt% of Mn
0.61Zn
0.42Fe
1.97O
4, ~14 wt% silica, and ~84 wt% Au.
Regarding the thermal stability of the ferrimagnetic ordering in Mn-Zn ferrite nanoparticles of the given composition and size, the transition to the paramagnetic state occurs at temperatures much higher than room temperature, even above the experimental limit of the set-up used in the present study, and was estimated to be ≈425 K in the previous report [
28]. Therefore, the ZFC-FC study in
Figure 3b provides primarily an insight into the blocking behavior of ferrite nanocrystallites. The irreversibility temperature, i.e., the bifurcation of the ZFC-FC susceptibility curves, was at ≈330–350 K, indicating the temperature where the superparamagnetic state was achieved within the whole sample. However, the predominant fraction of ferrite nanoparticles was already in the superparamagnetic state at room temperature. The comparison of the ZFC maxima between bare ferrite particles and the gold nanoshells reveals a shift in the distribution of blocking temperatures of ferrite nanoparticles to lower temperatures upon their encapsulation, which can be rationalized based on the suppression of dipolar interparticle interactions by the diamagnetic barriers in the coated sample [
29].
Figure 4 shows UV-Vis absorption spectra of bare gold nanoshells and their counterparts functionalized with a combination of 4-mercaptobenzoic acid and 7-mercapto-4-methylcoumarin. Both the spectra are dominated by a broad absorption band with a maximum at ≈700 nm, which is given by the SPR of gold nanoshells. The considerable width of the SPR band originated in the broad size distribution of nanoshells and was probably further extended by the aggregation. Nevertheless, the significant extension of the band to NIR offers the advantage of a higher penetration depth in biological tissues and promising optical properties for PAI. The UV-Vis spectrum was not significantly affected upon the applied functionalization. Actually, the absorption due to the SPR in gold nanostructures is by orders of magnitude stronger than the absorption of organic chromophores such as MBA or MMC, and thus no additional absorption features emerged in the spectrum of the functionalized product. Importantly, it follows that the functionalization did not interfere with the SPR band, and the applied procedure neither impaired the gold nanostructure nor led to spectrally significant aggregation.
3.2. Gold Nanoshells Functionalized with Model Organic Molecules
The DLS measurements of the hydrodynamic size of gold nanoshells functionalized with the four model molecules, supplemented by the measurement of gold nanoshells prior to functionalization, are depicted in
Figure 5a. The distribution data and Z-average values suggest that the samples modified with DMSA, TG, and MUA were roughly comparable with the initial nanoshells (MZF@sil@DMSA, MZF@sil@Au-TG, and MZF@sil@Au-MUA were characterized by d
hydro,Z = 184, 208, and 182 nm, and pdi = 0.172, 0.249, and 0.161, respectively), whereas the functionalization with the cationic surfactant MTAB led to a considerable increase in the hydrodynamic size (d
hydro,Z ≈ 396 nm and pdi = 0.298), presumably due to aggregation enhanced by the given functionalization.
Figure 5b shows the dependence of the zeta potential on pH for all samples functionalized with the model molecules. The MZF@sil@Au-MTAB nanoshells showed a zeta potential of 20 mV at neutral pH and an isoelectric point pI = 9.6, which confirms the corresponding functionalization. Its anionic counterpart MZF@sil@Au-MUA with long aliphatic carboxylate showed practically inverse behavior with a zeta potential of −23 mV at neutral pH and an isoelectric point pI = 4.4. The samples MZF@sil@Au-TG and MZF@sil@Au-DMSA exhibited a strongly negative zeta potential of −45 and −39 mV at neutral pH, which explains their colloidal stability due to strong coulombic repulsion, and pI ≈ 2.7 and pI = 3.4, respectively. The pH dependence of the zeta potential of the TG-functionalized nanoshells was governed by the native behavior of MZF@sil@Au particles since the thioglycerol moiety in water does not participate significantly in any ionization equilibria, at least not at moderate pH. This explanation is also supported by the measurement of the pH dependence of the zeta potential of native gold nanoshells with silica-coated magnetic cores in [
22].
Figure 5.
Dynamic and electrophoretic light scattering studies on gold nanoshells functionalized with four different model molecules (DMSA, TG, MUA, MTAB): (a) The intensity-weighted hydrodynamic size distribution of gold nanoshells functionalized with the four model compounds, measured on dilute aqueous suspensions by DLS; (b) dependence of zeta potential on pH measured by ELS; the error bars show 95% confidence intervals based on repeated measurements.
Figure 5.
Dynamic and electrophoretic light scattering studies on gold nanoshells functionalized with four different model molecules (DMSA, TG, MUA, MTAB): (a) The intensity-weighted hydrodynamic size distribution of gold nanoshells functionalized with the four model compounds, measured on dilute aqueous suspensions by DLS; (b) dependence of zeta potential on pH measured by ELS; the error bars show 95% confidence intervals based on repeated measurements.
The viability and proliferation of MCF-7 cells incubated with gold nanoshells functionalized with four different model compounds (DMSA, TG, MUA, MTAB) were assessed in real-time by using the label-free xCELLigence system (
Figure 6). The xCELLigence system allows the continuous monitoring of cell adhesion, viability, and proliferation based on measurement of impedance, which is displayed as normalized cell index (CI) values. MCF-7 cells treated with MZF@sil@Au-DMSA, MZF@sil@Au-TG, and MZF@sil@Au-MUA nanoshells at lower concentrations of the ferrite 1.4 and 2.7 µmol(f.u.) L
−1 (i.e., weight concentration of the whole nanoshells ~14 and ~28 µg mL
−1 according to magnetometry) proliferated in parallel with cells in the negative control, as indicated by the increase in CI values. Only a minor decrease in the CI compared to the negative control was observed for cells treated with MZF@sil@Au-MTAB nanoparticles. At the highest concentration of the nanoshells, 5.3 µmol(f.u.) L
−1 (≈55 µg mL
−1 of the whole nanoshells), the proliferation of the cells was slightly impeded, which can be ascribed to the much higher amount of the material used for the incubation, as the ferrite forms only ≈2 wt% of the gold nanoshells (see above).
To further explore the effect of the functionalized gold nanoshells on cell proliferation rate and viability, trypan blue dye exclusion staining was performed after the MCF-7 cells had been treated for 48 h with the nanoshells at concentrations in the range of 1.4–5.3 µmol(f.u.) L
−1. The viable cells that exclude the stain and the dyed dead cells were manually counted. Upon the application of the 5.3 µmol(f.u.) L
−1 dose, the proliferation ability and the number of living MCF-7 cells were likely decreased in the cells treated with MZF@sil@Au-MTAB nanoshells and were significantly (
p ≤ 0.05) decreased in the cells treated with MZF@sil@Au-MUA (
Figure 7a). Despite such rather weak antiproliferative effects observed for the highest concentration of the nanoshells functionalized with MUA and MTAB, the proliferation of other treated cells did not differ significantly from the negative control. Importantly, the percentage of viable cells enumerated as alive in the trypan blue assay remained unaffected for all the treatments (
Figure 7b).
Impaired proliferation frequently occurs as a consequence of cell cycle perturbations. Therefore, the cell cycle distribution of MCF-7 cells was examined upon exposure to gold nanoshells at the highest concentration used in the previous experiments, i.e., 5.3 µmol(f.u.) L
−1 (
Figure 8). The incubation of the cells with the nanoshells functionalized with DMSA and MUA for 48 h resulted in a slightly lower percentage of cells in the S-phase, 6% and 11%, respectively, compared with the untreated control having 14% of S-phase cells. In contrast, regarding the cells treated with doxorubicin as the positive control, the percentage of cells in the S-phase increased and in the G1-phase decreased. The cell cycle distribution in cells incubated with nanoshells functionalized with TG and MTAB did not differ significantly from the negative control.
3.3. Gold Nanoshells for Multimodal Imaging and pH Sensing
The nanosized probe suggested for multimodal imaging and sensing of pH, i.e., the MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC nanoshells were subjected to DLS measurements in pure water and 10 vol% FBS to comparatively probe possible effects of conditions within a biological system, at least based on such a simplified model. Importantly, the measurements in the FBS suspension were repeatable (according to six consecutive measurements after the sample preparation) and did not indicate colloidal instability or time-dependent effects. Representative intensity-weighted distributions of the hydrodynamic size are shown in
Figure 9a for both the suspensions. However, the hydrodynamic size increased from d
hydro,Z = 193 nm (pdi = 0.182) in pure water to d
hydro,Z = 272 nm (pdi = 0.290) in 10 vol% FBS, which can be primarily attributed to the adsorption of serum proteins to the surface of nanoshells, i.e. the formation of a protein corona.
Fluorescence spectra of gold nanoshells functionalized with the combination of MBA and MMC are depicted in
Figure 9b, showing maxima of λ
max,ex = 314 nm and λ
max,em = 375 nm in the excitation and emission scans, respectively. In spite of the relatively low fraction of the fluorophore employed in the functionalization mixture compared to the pH-sensitive SERS reporter (molar ratio of MMC: MBA of 1:5), these measurements demonstrate the clear fluorescence of MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC particles. Moreover, their spectra are consistent with data reported for MMC in the literature, e.g., λ
max,em = 374 nm was determined on MMC solutions both in dichloromethane and toluene [
30].
1H NMR relaxometry showed that the MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC nanoshells represent an extremely efficient T2 contrast agent for MRI. At the temperature of 23 °C and in the magnetic field of 0.47 T, the longitudinal relaxivity was low, r1 = 3.309(3) s−1 mmol−1(f.u.) L, but a very high transverse relaxivity r2 of 903(28) s−1 mmol−1(f.u.) L was observed.
The low value of r1 was expected since the thick silica and gold shells hinder water molecules from direct contact with the magnetic cores, and thus effectively eliminate the inner-sphere relaxation mechanism. At the same time, the distance from the magnetic core lowers the outer-sphere term.
The high value of r
2 relaxivity suggests that the nanoparticles influence
1H relaxation under the terms of the static dephasing regime (SDR) [
31]. In this regime, which is valid for large particles, the
1H spins of water molecules in the suspension, diffusing during the NMR pulse sequence, experience only minor variations of local magnetic fields in the vicinity of the large particles. Therefore, the refocusing of the
1H spins during the CPMG sequence is not efficient and r
2 reaches its higher limit. Importantly, SDR can be reached not only in the case of large crystallite sizes of the magnetic phase [
32] but also clusters of smaller magnetic particles coated with a rather thick diamagnetic shell, as was experimentally demonstrated, e.g., for clusters of ≈11 nm-sized Mn-Zn ferrite nanoparticles encapsulated in TiO
2, achieving the relaxivity of r
2 ≈ 927 s
−1 mmol
−1(f.u.) L in the field of 0.47 T at room temperature [
28].
To unambiguously identify the dominant relaxation regime, the transverse relaxivity was measured depending on temperature and compared with the dependences predicted for the SDR and motional averaging regime (MAR), which both can occur under the given experimental conditions but whose temperature dependences differ. The transverse relaxivity in SDR should follow, under certain assumptions, the temperature dependence of magnetization: r
2,SDR(T) ∝ M(T). In contrast, the relaxivity in MAR is described by r
2,MAR(T) ∝ M(T)
2/D
(H2O)(T) and is usually shaped mainly by the 1/D
H2O(T) dependence, which is more pronounced than M(T) [
28]. Thus, the experimental r
2(T) dependence was normalized by using its value at the lowest experimental temperature of 10.3 °C and was compared with analogically normalized temperature dependences of M(T), 1/D
H2O(T), and M(T)
2/D
H2O(T), where M(T) is the temperature dependence of magnetization of bare MZF cores measured at 0.47 T (data obtained from [
28]) and D
H2O(T) is the temperature dependence of the self-diffusion coefficient of water (calculated using the Speedy-Angel power law with parameters according to [
33]). The results in
Figure 10 confirm that the transverse relaxation in the studied suspension corresponds to SDR while the deviation from SDR at higher temperatures may be attributed to an increasing fraction of particles in MAR due to the growing self-diffusion coefficient and decreasing characteristic diffusion correlation time.
The MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC nanoparticles were further subjected to a proof-of-concept PAI study. In addition to the imaging of thin tubes filled with the suspension with a concentration of 0.64 mmol(f.u.) L
−1 (~5.5 mg L
−1 of gold based on magnetometry) by both ultrasound and PAI modalities of the employed bimodal platform (
Figure 11a), photoacoustic spectrum was recorded in the range of 680–970 nm (
Figure 11b). The spectrum proved a high signal yield in the NIR range, and the photoacoustic signal exhibited a maximum at around 700 nm, where the plasmonic resonance absorption occurs, as shown by the UV-Vis spectrum of MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC in
Figure 4. However, the maximum in the photoacoustic spectrum is narrower compared to the broad band in the UV-Vis spectrum. This difference can be rationalized considering that the UV-Vis spectrum also includes the component of optical scattering, the maximum of which is red-shifted with respect to the absorption, whereas the photoacoustic spectrum primarily reflects the absorption (see, e.g., data on gold nanoshells with a diameter of ~60–70 nm and thickness of the shell 8–12 nm in the study [
34]).
In the context of extensive data on gold nanostructures reported in the literature, gold nanoshells seem to be especially convenient for PAI since their SPR wavelength can be tuned by adjusting their diameter and shell thickness to fit the NIR window, in which the light attenuation by living tissues is relatively low. For an ideal smooth gold nanoshell, a red shift of the SPR is predicted when increasing the ratio of its inner and outer diameters [
35]. A red shift also occurs when increasing the shell thickness at a constant ratio of the two diameters [
36]. In contrast, the SPR of gold nanospheres occurs at smaller wavelengths, typically below 600 nm (for example, λ
SPR = 575 nm for nanospheres with a diameter of ≈100 nm [
37]) and increases only moderately with the particle size [
36]. Gold nanorods offer similar versatility when it comes to adjusting λ
SPR to the NIR window when compared with gold nanoshells. The longitudinal SPR wavelength follows a linear dependence on the aspect ratio of the nanorods [
36,
38], and λ
SPR = 700 nm roughly corresponds to the aspect ratio of 3 in the work by Ni et al. [
38]. Nevertheless, both nanorods and nanospheres lack the magnetic component of the present gold nanoshells with Mn-Zn ferrite cores.
The SERS spectra measured on aqueous suspensions of MZF@sil@Au-MBA+MMC nanoshells with different pH values are shown in
Figure 12a, and the following interpretation of Raman bands is based on several reports [
22,
39,
40,
41,
42]. The most intense band at ≈1592 cm
−1 corresponds primarily to the aromatic ring vibration of MBA [
39], which was present in fivefold molar excess to MMC, but involves also the in-plane C=C stretching of the lactone/benzene rings in MMC. The successful functionalization of gold nanoshells with MMC molecules is unambiguously evidenced by the band at ≈1537 cm
−1, where modes of the benzene ring of MMC are manifested. The second most intense peak at ≈1177 cm
−1 probably results from modes of both MMC and MBA [
22]. Similarly, the peak at ≈1077 cm
−1 can be ascribed to the ring vibrations primarily of MBA and to a lesser extent also of MMC, whereas the peak at 1056 cm
−1 can be attributed just to MMC (probably the bending vibration of C-H and deformation vibration of C-O) [
22].
Previous studies have already shown that the intensities of certain bands in the SERS spectra of MBA are dependent on pH and can be employed for pH sensing [
12]. In the present case, the spectra are more complex due to the manifestation of MMC modes, which, however, can be employed as an internal standard for the normalization of the spectra. Avoiding the spectral region where glass typically contributes to an increased background and trying to analyze intense bands with a high signal-to-noise ratio, we will arrive at the region of 1235–975 cm
−1 containing three intense peaks. Among them, the bands at ≈1077 cm
−1 and 1056 cm
−1 seem to be particularly suitable as revealed upon the normalization of the spectra to the MMC band at 1056 cm
−1 (
Figure 12b). The ratio of their intensities I
R(1077)/I
R(1056) shows a clear dependence on pH and decreases with increasing pH (
Figure 12c). It would be too speculative to explain the observed dependence without DFT studies, but one may draw attention to, for example, the study by Michota and Bukowska [
39], who suggested that MBA molecules are at least tilted with respect to the Ag/Au surface at neutral and higher pH, while they adopt more vertical orientation under more acidic pH.