1. Introduction
Agro-industrial waste residuals produced indiscriminately constitute extreme environmental pollution. However, currently, such waste is attracting researchers’ attention since it can be converted into wealth [
1,
2]. For instance, Gu et al. [
3] valorized sewage sludge to be used as a catalyst for wastewater elimination. Ullah et al. [
4] applied sugarcane bagasse to adsorb dye from an aqueous stream. Sugarcane bagasse, or
Saccharum officinarum, is an agro-industrial waste by-product, and its lignocellulosic residuals have attracted scientists’ attention for their use as adsorbent materials [
5]. Several authors have applied chemical enhancement to improve the activity of such materials [
6,
7]. Sun et al. [
8] enhanced
Saccharum officinarum by etherification with extra stearic acid. Ahamad et al. [
9] washed
Saccharum officinarum with NaOH and then sonicated it to improve its catalytic activity. Xiong et al. [
10] used various acids to treat such waste material. However, the use of
Saccharum officinarum as an adsorbent material is not considered an ideal solution since it only transfers the pollutants’ phase, with no respect for their mineralization [
11]. However, due to the chemical nature of modified
Saccharum officinarum, which possesses several elements, as well as its reasonably high surface area [
12], it can be used as a photocatalyst.
The primary goal of academics and scientists is to identify an industrial ecology approach that will lead to harmless end products, the aim being to diminish persistent toxic materials [
13]. In this regard, Fenton’s reagent is proposed as an environmentally sustainable benign reagent [
14,
15]. Fenton’s reaction is one of the most advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) and is categorized as a rapid and efficient process. Fenton’s reaction is based on the oxidization of iron metal with hydrogen peroxide to initiate the additional charge production of highly reactive species called hydroxyl radicals, which are mineralizing pollutants. However, the cost of chemical precursors and the acidic working pH range prevent the use of Fenton’s treatment in real applications [
16]. Thus, it is important to identify an alternative iron source instead of fresh chemicals for use as a photocatalyst. The combination of metals, i.e., aluminum and manganese, with iron from a waste source to serve as a source of the Fenton heterojunction is a good alternative [
17,
18]. Additionally, an augmented copper–carbon composite can be introduced as the source of a heterogeneous Fenton-like system. Such elements, when augmented with hydrogen peroxide, produce non-specific hydroxyl radicals, which are the horsepower of oxidizing reactions since such radicals attack the wide range of pollutants in aqueous streams. Thus, this system has a high chance of avoiding Fenton restrictions because it can solve the associated system problems [
19,
20].
Since the 20th century, there is growing awareness about the large amounts of pollutants produced by industrial activities and their effect on the environment. Water shortages are causing severe damage and must be addressed to meet ecological societal needs [
21,
22]. Enormous amounts of toxic effluents from the textile industry are discharged into canals and drains, causing severe destruction of the environmental ecosystem. The textile industry is among the industrial sectors that require substantial quantities of water in the various processing steps [
23]. Aqueous effluents from the industry contain fibers, metals, suspended solids, and solvents and have high biological oxygen demand (BOD) and chemical oxygen demand (COD). Due to restrictive environmental regulations worldwide and public health safety rules, it is important for such effluents to be remediated prior to their discharge [
24,
25].
To the best of the authors’ knowledge, the research on the modulation of Saccharum officinarum as a photocatalytic material to be an exporter of Fenton’s reagent is deficient. The current study is focused on using bagasse residuals, which are the waste material left behind when Saccharum officinarum is processed, as a source of elements to be used as a photocatalyst for textile dye elimination. The residuals were treated and calcined catalyst analysis and characterization were performed to investigate their activity. The impact of the operational variables, i.e., the Saccharum officinarum catalyst and the dose of the hydrogen peroxide reagents, the impact of the pH level in the aqueous solution, dye loading, and wastewater temperature, on the oxidation reaction were evaluated. Response surface methodology was applied for statistical analysis and optimization of the operational parameters.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Aqueous Dye Effluent
Commercial textile dye named Bismarck Brown dye (supplied by Macsen Lab. Udaipur, Rajasthan, 313024, India), with a molecular formula of C21H24N8.2HCl, 11 g/L water solubility at 25 °C, and thermal stability, was used as the synthetic wastewater source. A 1000 ppm dye solution was prepared as a stock aqueous solution, and the aqueous stream was auxiliary diluted as needed. The Fenton reagent oxidation system for Saccharum officinarum was initiated using H2O2 as the peroxide reagent source (30% w/v, provided by Sigma-Aldrich, Darmstadt, Germany). The pH of the aqueous dye stream was adjusted to the required values using Sigma-Aldrich’s H2SO4 or NaOH as needed. All chemicals were used as received from the supplier, without any additional treatment.
2.2. Saccharum Officinarum Activation and Preparation
Sampling expeditions were conducted to obtain
Saccharum officinarum residuals from a sugarcane refinery located in the southern region of Egypt, where it is extensively grown. The dried and milled
Saccharum officinarum powder was thoroughly washed repeatedly before being dried overnight in an electric oven at 105 °C to eliminate any remaining moisture. Then, the obtained material was subjected to chemical treatment described in the literature [
26,
27], as follows: It was soaked for 2 h in an alkali (1 N NaOH). While being soaked, it was heated and stirred. Then, the soaked material was washed multiple times with distilled water until it reached a neutral pH, when the washing water was disposed of. The resultant blend was then subjected to 1 h of stirring with sulfuric acid under heating. After separation and drying, the material was ball milled for size reduction prior to pyrolysis at 500 °C. The material was thus activated and ready for use.
2.3. Bench Scale Set-up
To investigate the impact of dye loading on photo-catalytic oxidation, a glass vessel was filled with 100 mL of wastewater effluent containing Bismarck Brown dye. A stock solution of 1000 ppm dye was prepared and then diluted to the required concentrations (5, 10, 20, and 40 ppm) as per the experimental conditions. Subsequently, Saccharum officinarum ranging from 20 to 80 mg/L and H2O2 ranging from 100 to 800 mg/L were added to the aqueous stream as a source of Fenton’s reagent. To ensure proper catalyst dispersion, the solution was sonicated for 5 min. An ultraviolet lamp (15 W, 230 V/50 Hz) emitting UV illumination of a specific wavelength (253.7 nm) was employed to initiate the photo-catalytic reaction. The lamp was covered with a silica tube jacket to shield it from the aqueous solution and then submerged in the solution. The solution temperature and pH were adjusted as required before the catalyst was added. To carry out the oxidation experiment, the dye solution containing the reagents was subjected to UV irradiance. The sleeved UV lamp was placed inside the aqueous solution to ensure UV irradiance while the solution was magnetically stirred during the reaction time, which led to the oxidation process. Next, at specific time intervals (each 10 min), samples were withdrawn for analysis. Each sample was first passed through a micro-filter for catalyst separation. Finally, the Saccharum officinarum substance was removed through settling and washed repeatedly and the substrate was filtered for cyclic use.
The Bismarck Brown dye removal performance was computed using the following relation:
where
(%) is the Bismarck Brown dye removal performance and
Co and Ct are the initial dye concentration and the final (postoxidation) dye concentration, respectively.
In addition, the data plotted against time are the values of C
t/C
o [
28].
Figure 1 presents a graphical illustration of the experiment.
2.4. Analytical Determination
To determine the extent of Bismarck Brown dye removal and oxidation, UV–Vis analysis was performed using a Unico UV-2100 spectrophotometer, USA, that investigated at the maximum wavelength of the dye (λ 526 nm), which represents the maximum absorbance peak. The pH of the Bismarck Brown dye aqueous effluent was monitored and adjusted through a digital pH instrument (AD1030, Adwa company, Szeged, Hungary).
2.5. Catalyst Characterization
The X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis of the crystallinity of the chemically and thermally prepared Saccharum officinarum material, as well as native Saccharum officinarum material, was conducted using a Bruker-Nonius Kappa CCD diffractometer with a CuKα radiation source at a wavelength of λ = 1.5406 Å in step-scanned mode for 18.87 s. The diffractometer machine operated at 45 kV. The micro-structure morphology of Saccharum officinarum was explored using scanning electron micrographs (SEMs) obtained from a field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM), Quanta FEG 250, with typical magnifications of ×8000 and ×60,000. The analysis was complemented with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) to analyze the principal oxides.
2.6. Experimental Design
A three-level factorial design (Box–Behnken model) with triplicates of central values was used to understand the effect of independent variables on the dependent parameter of Bismarck Brown dye oxidation (%). The independent parameters selected, on the basis of their influence on the process, were pH value, Saccharum officinarum, and H
2O
2 dose. The level of each Box–Behnken factor was determined on the basis of preliminary experiments and is presented in
Table 1.
The full factorial experimental design matrix was generated using statistical analysis software (SAS, Institute, New York, NY 10019, USA). Statistical and graphical analyses were performed using SAS and Matlab (7.11.0.584), respectively. The adequacy of the proposed statistical model was assessed using the analysis of variance (ANOVA) test. A second-order polynomial model was employed to establish the relationship among Bismarck Brown dye oxidation rate (%), the dependent parameter, and the operating independent variables. The corresponding quadratic equation is presented as Equation (2).
where
is the projected (suggested by the model) dye oxidation removal rate dependent variable response (%); i = 1, 2, 3, and j = 1, 2, 3; βo, βi, βii, and βij are the design regression coefficient variables;
and i is the input controlling coded variable.
To simplify the proposed design calculations, the un-coded parameters of the operating system (Ei) were assigned to coded variables (i) in accordance with Equation (2). In addition, after the model significance, the optimum values were calculated through Mathematica software (V 5.2). Then, three additional experiments were carried out at the optimal predicted values to validate the predicted model.
3. Results and Discussions
3.1. Structural and Morphological Characterization of Saccharum officinarum
3.1.1. XRD Analysis
X-ray diffraction analysis was performed to investigate and evaluate the mineralogical composition of pure and treated
Saccharum officinarum material, and the data are represented in
Figure 2. The pattern displays the characteristics of the mineral. The XRD analysis shows that in terms of mineralogical composition,
Saccharum officinarum consists of a bundle of minerals, and not only one mineral, as indicated by the various peaks for each mineral [
12,
29]. Various oxides identified in the XRD pattern of the treated
Saccharum officinarum are Na
2O, SiO
2, CaO, MgO, Al
2O
3, and Fe
2O
3 (
Figure 2b). The peaks at 2θ of 32.4, 37.1, and 43.1 indicate the occurrence of CaO [
30,
31]. In addition, the existence of quartz (SiO
2) is signified by the peaks of 21.0, 21.4, 27.1, 37.2, 39.5, and 44.9 [
32]. Na
2O is specified by the 2θ value of 37.8.
Further, Fe
2O
3 can be identified from the 2θ value of 24.4. Al
2O
3 is located at the peaks of 33.3, 37.2, and 43.1 [
33]. The pure
Saccharum officinarum displayed in
Figure 2a shows the existence of SiO
2, CaO, and Al
2O
3 in lesser amounts than in the treated
Saccharum officinarum. It is noteworthy to mention that other oxides, such as Na
2O, MgO, and Fe
2O
3, did not appear in the native sample. The disappearance of the amorphous nature is also indicated in the treated material.
The significant increase in the cellulose content in the chemically treated sample is the reason behind the increased cellulose crystallinity. However, such behavior is not observed in the untreated sample, as shown in
Figure 2a, due to the occurrence of high amounts of lignin, which might cover the outer space of the cellulose structure [
34]. Additionally, chemical–thermal treatments lead to decomposition reactions, which produce some oxides, in accordance with Cordeiro et al. [
35].
Table 2 presents the EDX analysis of the arrangement of the elements in
Saccharum officinarum, showing its elemental composition. The major elements present are CaO, SiO
2, Al
2O
3, Fe
2O
3, MgO, Na
2O, and MnO. The occurrence of considerable amounts of Fe
2O
3, Al
2O
3, MnO, and MgO, indicated by the XRD analysis, confirms the source of metals before Fenton’s reaction. The waste-derived catalyst with a high elemental content, which reflects good catalytic activity along with other active factors, can essentially catalyze the oxidation reaction.
Although Fe
2+/3+ promotes Fenton’s reaction, other oxides, such as MnO
2 [
36,
37] and Al
2O
3 [
38], display catalytic activity for active Fenton-like reaction. Hence, the presence of such oxides in the modified
Saccharum officinarum promotes Fenton’s reaction. Furthermore, due to the waste iron sludge produced after Fenton’s treatment and for easier separation and reusability, research has focused on heterogeneous Fenton catalysts. In this regard, a variety of supports, such as SiO
2 and various clay materials, have been introduced to improve the catalytic performance of Fenton’s reaction. Furthermore, MgO has previously exhibited to be an excellent adsorbent [
39]. In addition, Silva et al. [
40] coupled Cu and MgO to promote Fenton’s reaction.
3.1.2. SEM Imaging
The morphology of
Saccharum officinarum was evaluated from FE-SEM images. These images show different morphologies because of the effect of chemical–thermal activation, with particles of different shapes. Scanning electron micrographs of pure
Saccharum officinarum and treated material are displayed in
Figure 3.
Figure 3a,b explores pure
Saccharum officinarum at different magnifications, displaying slightly organized particles of a heterogeneous size and shape. Such pure
Saccharum officinarum material morphology shows a severely compact structure. However, the morphology of treated samples, in
Figure 3c,d, shows noticeable differences. The chemically modified
Saccharum officinarum surface shows a disturbance in the cell wall structure, with reduced adherence between the cells. Such alteration would increase the surface area of the catalyst surface, which will lead to extra availability for catalytic reaction. At a high magnification (
Figure 3d), the thermally and chemically modified sample displays a high degree of disorganization of particles, with lower fiber adhesion in comparison to that in
Figure 2b (prior to treatment). Furthermore, the specific surface area of
Saccharum officinarum is monitored and recorded at 436 g/m
2.
3.2. Dye Oxidation by the Modified Oxidation System
3.2.1. Optimum Reaction Time and Comparative Investigation
Different treatment processes (the adsorption system involving the
Saccharum officinarum substance;
Saccharum officinarum/H
2O
2 under UV illumination, called the photo-Fenton system; and
Saccharum officinarum/H
2O
2, called the dark Fenton system) for the treatment of Bismarck Brown dye in wastewater are compared. Fenton’s reagent concentrations were
Saccharum officinarum = 40 mg/L and H
2O
2 = 800 mg/L at the initial pH of 3.0. For all systems, the essential illumination time to reach the plateau state was explored, as shown in
Figure 4.
The data presented in
Figure 4 indicate that the adsorption system had the lowest removal efficiency. The photo-oxidation system under UV illumination was more effective than the dark oxidation system. The data reveal that using
Saccharum officinarum alone for treatment led to the removal of only 11% of the Bismarck Brown dye after 60 min of contact time. However, when Fenton’s reagent was added in the dark, the removal efficiency increased to 35%. When H
2O
2 was added to the wastewater under UV illumination, the removal efficiency increased significantly, to 82%, demonstrating the effectiveness of the Fenton oxidation reaction. The ˙OH radicals generated during treatment with Fenton’s were sufficient for attacking the dye molecules and converting them into harmless end products (CO
2 and H
2O). UV illumination in combination with Fenton’s reagent demonstrated a pronounced removal effect, possibly due to the additional reaction intermediates, ˙OH radicals, generated by the UV illumination. These findings agree with previous studies mentioned in the literature [
41]. Furthermore, to verify the role of
Saccharum officinarum, treatment using UV/H
2O
2 at a dose of H
2O
2 of 400 mg/L is carried out. According to the experimental data, only 3% of the dye is oxidized by using the solo hydrogen peroxide system. The data confirm the role of
Saccharum officinarum and the effectiveness of Fenton’s reaction. This means that the production of ·OH radicals is limited compared to those generated from Fenton’s reaction. Furthermore, solo UV irradiance is applied, which removes only 1% of the dye. However, no Fenton’s reaction occurred in the case of the unmodified
Saccharum officinarum since the oxidation efficiency is lower than that of UV/H
2O
2 treatment (only 26%). This treatment effect could be due to the hydrogen peroxide and UV, which are the main factors responsible for oxidation. However, the presence of untreated
Saccharum officinarum renders the reaction since it is shadowing the UV light instead of leading to Fenton’s reaction. These results agree with the previous findings of Samet et al. [
42] in treating insecticide-containing wastewater through Fenton’s system.
3.2.2. Effect of Initial Dye Loading
Figure 5 illustrates the influence of various loads of Bismarck Brown dye on oxidation efficiency.
Figure 5 shows that the dye oxidation efficiency (70%) was supreme when the starting dye load was the minimum (5 ppm) after 10 min of illumination time and steadily reduced thereafter, achieving an accumulative oxidation efficacy of 92% in 60 min. As previously mentioned, Bismarck Brown dye molecules are made of aromatic rings. ˙OH species, produced by the reaction between metals of Fenton’s reaction and H
2O
2, attack such rings and open them, resulting in the formation of reaction intermediates and oxidizing them into the harmless CO
2 and H
2O. This could be attributed to the fact that as the reaction proceeds, the concentration of ˙OH radicals produced gradually declines due to the reduction in H
2O
2 concentration. Additionally, radicals other than hydroxyl radicals are generated that hinder the Bismarck Brown dye oxidation rate instead of increasing it. An examination of
Figure 5 reveals the rapid degradation of the dye removal attained in the initial time period and a reduction in the oxidation rate with an increase in the dye load. The oxidation efficacies are 92, 78, 74, and 72% for dye concentrations of 5, 10, 20, and 40 ppm in the wastewater, respectively. This is because the generated ˙OH species are inadequate for treating the whole dye. Increasing the oxidation activity, under UV illumination, by reducing the starting pollutant load has previously been investigated in [
41], where the authors applied Fenton’s oxidation to treat benzimidazole. Although the oxidation varies for various concentrations, the same trend is observed in the high initial drop in concentration followed by a slower oxidation rate in all cases. This phenomenon is associated with the hydrogen peroxide consumption as the reaction proceeds. This reagent plays a vital role in the generation of hydroxyl radicals, which is the main responsibility of the oxidation reaction [
28].
3.2.3. Effect of Modified Fenton Variables
Effect of Saccharum Officinarum Dose
To examine the influence of
Saccharum officinarum particles on the treatment of Bismarck Brown dye by Fenton’s reaction, experiments were conducted to explore the effect of
Saccharum officinarum concentration on reaction kinetics.
Figure 6a displays the influence of
Saccharum officinarum on the oxidation system when the
Saccharum officinarum dose is varied over a range of 10 to 80 mg/L. The oxidation efficacy elevated from 39% to 82% when the
Saccharum officinarum dose increased from 10 to 40 mg/L. However, on further increase in the concentration of
Saccharum officinarum, to 80 mg/L, the oxidation efficacy decreased significantly, to 30%. Elements such as aluminum, iron, and manganese, which act as the source of Fenton’s reaction, are critical for initiating the production of the photoactive metal hydroxo intermediate complexes that absorb the photons in the UV illumination and thus generate the ˙OH species. Such non-selective ˙OH species attack the dye particles, further oxidizing and mineralizing them.
An elevation in
Saccharum officinarum reagent to a dose of 40 mg/L increases oxidation efficiency. However, excessive
Saccharum officinarum particles in the reaction medium hinder the elements that produce ˙OH radicals [
43]. In addition, at higher metal concentrations, a muddy, highly colored, aqueous solution is generated, reducing the diffusion of the ultraviolet light into the aqueous wastewater stream. Therefore, hydrogen peroxide reagent photolysis, producing the hydroxyl radicals, is hindered. Hence, an excess of
Saccharum officinarum in the solution of Fenton’s reaction results in reduced dye removal efficiency. Shende [
44] previously verified this by treating violet dye contained in wastewater.
Effect of Hydrogen Peroxide Reagent Dose
Figure 6b displays the effect of the H
2O
2 dose on the oxidation of Bismarck Brown dye molecules in dye-comprising aqueous media. As estimated, elevating the peroxide dose from 100 to 400 mg/L improved the dye oxidation rate and the removal efficacy was enhanced from 21% to 82%. This increase in the removal rate is associated with the extra ˙OH radicals produced through hydrogen peroxide decomposition. However, an excessive increase in the dose of this reagent (higher than 400 mg/L) does not further improve dye removal. For example, increasing the H
2O
2 dosage to 800 mg/L led to a decline in dye removal, to only 32%. Obviously, excessive H
2O
2 concentration hinders the production of the highly reactive ˙OH radicals, generating the less reactive perhydroxyl radicals (HO
2˙) in the reaction medium instead. Such radicals cause a decline in the reaction rate due to the insignificant oxidation capabilities. Therefore, the optimal operating H
2O
2 dose, corresponding to the maximum dye removal, was recorded at 400 mg/L. Various authors [
45,
46,
47] have previously highlighted that Fenton’s reaction might occur at an optimal hydrogen peroxide dose.
Starting pH Effectiveness
Wastewater pH is a vital factor in Fenton’s system. Taking this into consideration, the starting pH value for the aqueous solution was altered over the range of 3.0 to 8.0 since it shows a role in H
2O
2 decay and the hydrolytic speciation of the metal ions. The data displayed in
Figure 6c reveal that the dye removal efficacy is highly correlated with the starting solution pH value and the optimal pH is recorded at 3.0. Unsurprisingly, the removal efficiency increases to 82% and declines with further pH increase. Moreover, increasing the alkalinity of the solution results in further reduction in the dye removal efficiency, to 39%. This might be because the fraction of soluble metal ions declines considerably with pH elevation. In addition, inactive hydroperoxide (HO
2˙) radicals are formed in the oxidation medium, hindering the oxidation rate [
48].
Contrarily, an acidic pH value leads to extra H
+ ions in the reaction medium that react with the superoxide. This reaction leads to a reduction in the elements present in the
Saccharum officinarum residuals and the dissolved O
2. The result is the formation of hydroperoxide (HO
2˙), an inactive radical. The overall reaction is inhibited due to the presence of hydroperoxide radical (HO
2˙) and the superoxide radical anion (O
2˙), categorized as scavenger radicals, in the reaction medium [
48]. This might lead to a decline in the Bismarck Brown oxidation yield, which further declines at alkaline pH conditions since
Saccharum officinarum significantly reduces at pH of about 8.
Oxidation Mechanism
An arbitrary mixture composed of several metals originating from
Saccharum officinarum leads to additive series reduction in oxidation (Red-OX) reactions. Such reactions lead to the production of oxidizing species. Under UV illumination, several metals on
Saccharum officinarum are irradiated and an electron (e)/hole (h) pair is produced on the surface of
Saccharum officinarum, which is the reaction media (Equation (3)). This photo-induced hole might react with H
2O in the solution to generate ˙OH species, as illustrated in Equations (4) and (5). Furthermore, hydrogen peroxide could react with the metal ions present in
Saccharum officinarum, such as iron, to induce Fenton’s reaction, producing extra hydroxyl radicals, as given in Equations (6) and (7) [
49,
50]. The molecules of Bismarck Brown dye, a type of azo dye, have an aromatic type of structure. The highly reactive hydroxyl radicals produced in the aqueous media attack the aromatic ring in the Bismarck Brown dye molecules in order to hydroxylase them by generating a chain of hydroxycyclohexadienyl radicals to mineralize the dye (Equation (8)). Such hydroxylation reaction is mainly responsible for the steady conversion of aromatic compounds into CO
2. Moreover, hydroxyl radicals and the H
+ in the solution react to produce water, which is the end product (Equation (9)).
Although H
2O
2 promotes the generation of ˙OH radicals, its presence in higher doses reduces the oxidation reaction efficiency. This is due to the extra peroxide competing with the dye to react with the ˙OH, resulting in a scavenging effect on the overall reaction rate. Moreover, the two identical hydroxyl radicals recombine and inhibit the overall reaction rate (Equations (10) and (11)) [
51].
3.3. Regression Model Fitting and ANOVA Testing
The performance of the three independent critical factors, pH value, and
Saccharum officinarum concentrations on the modified Fenton oxidation of Bismarck Brown dye was simulated and assessed after 10 min of illumination irradiance time, using RSM based on Box–Behnken experimental design. The experimental design matrix suggested by the software was carried out, and the quadratic polynomial design equation exhibited the related response role according to the following equation:
ANOVA analysis based on Fisher’s statistical examination for ANOVA analysis (
Table 3) was carried out to assess the statistical consequence and the adequacy of the proposed polynomial quadratic design. The quadratic model was foundto be the best fit when it possesses a small standard deviation with a minimal probability value (<0.005) and a high regression coefficient (R
2). The R
2value for the Bismarck brown dye removal response was 96%, with a small probability (
p) value. This confirms a high relationship between the predicted values based on the quadratic design model and the experimental values.
The Matlab software (version, 7.11.0.584) was used to generate 3D surface and 2D contour plots of the parameters.
Figure 7,
Figure 8 and
Figure 9 illustrate the response of each experimental parameter and the main interactions between the investigated variables. Inspection of the 3D surface graph and 2D contour plots of
Figure 7a,b indicates that the rate of oxidation of the dye increases with increasing
Saccharum officinarum concentration. Meanwhile, the curvature displayed in
Figure 7a illustrates the significant influence of the interaction between catalyst dose and pH value. Such good interaction leads to the high yield of hydroxyl radicals, which enhance the dye oxidation rate, as shown by the contour plot of
Figure 7a. However, a further increase in the reagent dose reduces the oxidation efficiency.
Figure 8a,b demonstrates via 3D response surface and contour plots the influence of
Saccharum officinarum dose and pH. The graphical representation scheme verifies that the oxidation rates were enhanced with increasing the
Saccharum officinarum dose. In addition, the acidic environment is favorable for dye oxidation and thus the optimum pH is in the acidic range. This could be explained by the existence of unfavorable radicals in the reaction aqueous solution media as the pH value increases, hindering the reaction rate.
Though the optimal pH of the aqueous solution is close to the acidic pH, this is still considered an obstacle for real application. It is worth mentioning that conversion of waste to wealth is the main advantage of the suggested modified system.
Figure 9a,b illustrates the relation of the coded values of
Saccharum officinarum and hydrogen peroxide for dye oxidation. The 3D response surface and contour plots indicate that an increase in independent variables increases the removal efficiency. The surface and contour plots of the design display that the highest percentage of Bismarck Brown dye oxidation was attained at the junction near the origin of the two parameters. This investigation confirms the relation between reagent doses and the generation of ˙OH radicals. This oxidation methodology is highly cost efficient since it is based on a waste-originated catalyst.
To check the adequacy of the suggested model, the statistically suggested optimized predicted variables (pH 2.9, Saccharum officinarum at 39 mg/L, and H2O2 at 402 mg/L) were used to conduct three replicates of the experiments. After 10 min of reaction time, the predicted percentage of dye removal reached 54%. After another 10 min, the experimental values reached 55% and with the preceding experiment, the final reduction achieved was 85%, compared to 82% when manually optimized values are used.
This investigation verifies the significance of the RSM in optimizing the operating parameters that influence Bismarck Brown dye oxidation using modified Fenton’s reaction via Saccharum officinarum particles as a waste material.
3.4. Temperature Effect
In this part of the study, the oxidation kinetics and thermodynamics of Bismarck Brown dye oxidation are examined. The investigation is based on the kinetics of the photo-oxidation of Bismarck Brown by a modified photo-Fenton system based on Saccharum officinarum particles under a constant concentration at working temperatures of 32, 40, 50, and 60 °C.
The data in
Figure 10 display the positive impact of elevating the operating temperature on dye removal. Temperature elevation completes the reaction more efficiently. The oxidation efficacy improves from 82% to 90% as the temperature increases from 32 to 60 °C, probably because of the excellent production of hydroxyl radicals at high temperatures [
48] because of collisions between the dye particles in the aqueous medium. Moreover, temperature increase affects the reaction between H
2O
2 and metal ions originating from
Saccharum officinarum, increasing the ˙OH output rate and accelerating Fenton’s reaction, leading to increased dye oxidation in the form of color removal [
52].
3.5. Kinetics and Thermodynamic Investigation
To further understand the modified Fenton’s reaction, the kinetics rates of first- and second-order reactions were investigated in accordance with the oxidation of Bismarck Brown via the photo-Fenton treatment system based on
Saccharum officinarum particles. Such kinetic rate orders have been explained by the linearized form of such orders as displayed in Equations (13) and (14) for the first- and second-order reactions, respectively [
28,
29].
where C
o and C
t are the doses of Bismarck Brown dye initially and at time t, respectively, and k
1 and k
2 represent the kinetic rate constants of first- and second-order reaction kinetics, respectively.
By plotting Equations (13) and (14), the most appropriate reaction kinetics for the experimental data suitable for Bismarck Brown dye removal were investigated (
Figure 11).
Table 4 displays kinetic parameters for each kinetic order and also their corresponding R
2 values of the regression coefficients.
Based on the R
2 values, the appropriate kinetic model is selected representing the data for investigating the kinetic order. To locate the best fit, the data exhibited in
Table 4 from this investigation signifies that the first model is rejected because it has lower R
2 values (ranging from 0.59 to 0.77). The correlation values are quite high for the second-order kinetic model, ranging from 0.70 to 0.95. Thus, the second-order model has the greatest correlation coefficient. In this regard, Fenton’s system in the current form generally follows second-order kinetics. Furthermore, the lowest value of half-life time (
t1/2) corresponds to the lower dye concentration. Such records agree with those listed in the literature [
42]. However, other studies have investigated Fenton’s reaction following the first-order kinetic reaction rate.
The kinetic constants investigated for the second-order model treatment processes of this model range from 0.0008 to 0.0293 mg
−1 L min
−1. This slight difference in the
K2values is related to the concentration load, which affects the oxidation intermediates and the dye removal rate in the aqueous medium. As tabulated in
Table 4, the half-life time (
t1/2) increases as the initial dye concentration increases. This might be attributedto the fact that increasing the dye concentration hinders the catalytic activity of
Saccharum officinarum to adsorb Bismarck Brown dye since the
Saccharum officinarum surface is saturated with Bismarck Brown molecules. In addition, the ˙OH output oxidants are not sufficient for oxidizing Bismarck Brown at too-high concentrations [
53].
To understand the reaction for real applications, thermodynamic parametric values were calculated for a photo-Fenton oxidation system based on
Saccharum officinarum. The activation energy (
Ea) of the Brown dye oxidation can be calculated [
54] by using the Arrhenius equation revelation equation for the kinetic rate constant,
, where Ris the universal gas constant value (8.314 J mol
−1K
−1), T is the reaction temperature in kelvin quantity, and Ais the pre-exponential constant. Then, taking the natural log of the Arrhenius formula and plotting
versus 1000
/T (
Figure 12), a straight-line relationship is achieved where its slope could be used to calculate
(energy of activation). The activation energy of the system was recorded at 64.43 kJ mol
−1.
Table 5 displays the other thermodynamic parameters, such as the enthalpy of activation
), the entropy of activation
, and the free energy of activation (∆G`) that was projected using Eyring’s equation (
, where k
B and h are Boltzmann and Planck’s constant, respectively [
45].
Table 5 exhibits
within the temperature range) values in a positive range, indicating that the reaction is endothermic. In addition,
shows positive values, indicating that the system is non-spontaneous at high temperatures with a negative entropy of activation. This result might be due to the development of a well-solvated structure between the dye molecules and ˙OH species.
3.6. Catalyst Reusability
The reusability of
Saccharum officinarum catalyst, in terms of sustainability, is investigated by identifying its oxidation affinity after cyclic use. Initially,
Saccharum officinarum, which is collected after each cycle, is subjected to three sequential washing with distilled water, filtered, and oven-dried at 105 °C for 1 h [
55,
56]. Then, the catalyst is subjected to successive cycles for dye oxidation and the data are exhibited in
Figure 13.
As shown in
Figure 13, as the catalyst is used multiple times, its activity declines, as indicated by its oxidation efficiency. Compared to the oxidation efficiency of 82% when fresh catalyst is used, by the fifth cyclic use, its oxidation efficiency is reduced to 63%. In addition, the catalytic activity is reduced after each use as indicated by the decline in the removal efficiency, as seen in
Figure 13. This might be attributed to the fact that pollutant intermediates cover the active centers of the catalyst, preventing them from attacking contaminates in wastewater. Hence, the overall reaction rate is reduced. It is worth mentioning the activity of the material is still high.