This study employed the following experimental procedures and analytical methods: the preparation of palm oil samples, fire reproduction experiments, fire risk characterization tests, and thermal analyses, including Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) and Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA).
2.1. Palm Oil Samples and Preparation
The palm oil samples used in this study were provided by Samyang Corporation, a South Korean cooking oil manufacturing company. The physical properties of the palm oil were analyzed as having a melting point of 36.6 °C, a flash point of 314 °C, an ignition point of 315 °C, and a mass purity of 99%. To assess the impact of AV on the oil’s properties, samples were collected after 0, 45, and 90 days of use. For comparative purposes, an additional sample (Sample D) was collected from a high-thermal-stress environment: a frozen food frying batter production process where palm oil was used for 90 days. This process was selected as it subjected the oil to greater thermal stress than snack production processes.
The AVs of the samples were measured using the neutralization titration method in compliance with ISO 660:2009 standards [
25]. This method determines the amount of free fatty acids (FFAs) in the oil, which are neutralized by potassium hydroxide (KOH). AV is defined as the milligrams of KOH required to neutralize the FFAs in 1 g of oil. FFAs present in the oil react with KOH, and the consumed quantity of KOH is used to indirectly calculate the FFA content using Equation (1).
where
is sample weight (g),
is the volume of 0.1 N ethanolic KOH solution used for the sample (mL),
is the volume of 0.1 N ethanolic KOH solution used for the blank test (mL), and
is the factor of the 0.1 N ethanolic KOH solution.
As summarized in
Table 1, the AV increased with longer usage periods, aligning with findings from previous studies [
26]. Notably, Sample D, subjected to thermal stress in the frozen food frying batter process, exhibited a relatively higher AV due to contamination and prolonged exposure to high temperatures. This experimental setup was specifically designed to analyze the fire risk characteristics of palm oil, concerning its AV.
This approach enables a systematic assessment of thermal degradation and fire risk factors in palm oil, offering essential data to support the development of safer practices in food processing environments.
2.2. Fire Reproduction Experiment
The fire reproduction experiment was conducted to simulate fire-prone conditions and measure the smoke point and ignition point of palm oil samples. The smoke point is the temperature at which visible smoke first appears from the oil during heating. The ignition point is the minimum temperature at which the oil spontaneously ignites without an external ignition source. This experiment followed the AOCS (American Oil Chemists’ Society) Cc 9a-48 method, utilizing a GL 240 data logger (Graphtec Corporation, Yokohama, Japan) and K-type thermocouples for accurate temperature recording [
27].
In this experiment, 100 mL of palm oil was placed in a tin container and heated incrementally using a burner. The temperature at which visible smoke was first observed was recorded as the smoke point, while the temperature at which flames were observed without an external ignition source was recorded as the ignition point. It is important to note that the measured ignition point is not an intrinsic material property and may differ from standardized results obtained using the ASTM E659 [
28] method.
To ensure consistency, the experiments were performed under controlled environmental conditions: an ambient temperature of 28 °C, relative humidity of 72.3%, and atmospheric pressure of 1029.7 hPa (1.016 atm). The indoor setting minimized the influence of external factors such as wind.
As the measurements of smoke and ignition points rely on visual observation, there is potential for subjective judgment to influence the results. To address this, a video camera was used to document the moments when smoke and flames appeared, providing objective verification. Additionally, the experiment was repeated three times for each sample, with the lowest recorded value selected to ensure data reliability.
This experimental setup was designed to identify the thermal thresholds at which palm oil transitions from a stable state to a fire-prone condition. The results provide critical insights into the thermal degradation characteristics of palm oil, contributing to a deeper understanding of its fire risk profile under various heating conditions. These findings are essential for enhancing fire safety practices in environments where palm oil is used.
2.3. Fire Risk Characterization Tests
To analyze the fire risk characteristics of palm oil, the flash point and ignition point were measured in relation to the AV. The flash point is defined as the lowest temperature at which oil vapors, when mixed with air, momentarily ignite upon exposure to a small flame near the surface of the sample [
29,
30]. There are two main methods for measuring the flash point. The closed-cup method involves heating the sample in a sealed environment to prevent vapor diffusion. In contrast, the open-cup method heats the sample in an open environment, allowing vapors to mix with external air. For the same sample, the flash point measured using the open-cup method is typically higher than that measured using the closed-cup method.
In this study, the Cleveland Open Cup (COC) method was employed, as specified in KS M ISO 2592 (2017) [
31]. The experimental apparatus used was the Petro Test CLA4 model (Anton Paar). Each test was performed under identical conditions and repeated three times, with the average value of the results adopted as the final measurement. The flash point was calculated using Equation (2), ensuring precision and repeatability. This approach provides critical data for assessing the impact of AV on the thermal and fire risk properties of palm oil.
Table 2 presents the testing methods for determining the flash point according to material properties. Given that the anticipated flash point of the palm oil used in this study exceeds 80 °C, the Cleveland Open Cup method was deemed appropriate and thus utilized.
To calculate the flash point corrected to the standard atmospheric pressure of 101.3 kPa, the following equation is used:
where
is the flash point (°C),
is the measured flash point (°C), and
is the atmospheric pressure during the experiment (kPa).
After obtaining the corrected flash point, the value is rounded to the nearest even number in its final unit. This rounding ensures consistency and adherence to standard reporting formats. Finally, the corrected flash point is expressed in degrees Celsius for practical application and reporting.
This correction process ensures that the reported flash point values are standardized, enabling accurate comparisons across experiments conducted under varying atmospheric conditions.
The mechanism of spontaneous ignition is based on the theory of thermal ignition as described by Daniel A. Crowl and Joseph F. Louvar (2020) [
32]. Depending on the type of heat source that increases the material’s temperature, spontaneous ignition can be classified into three categories: spontaneous ignition, autoignition, and pyrophoric ignition. In fire and explosion studies, spontaneous ignition typically refers to autoignition. This occurs when a material ignites at its minimum ignition temperature due to an external heat source.
The autoignition temperature (AIT) is not an intrinsic material property. It is affected by factors such as the sample’s physical and chemical properties, oxygen concentration, container size in the test apparatus, and heating rate. For this study, AIT measurements were conducted in accordance with ASTM E659-15 [
28] using a Petro Test ZPA-3 apparatus (Petrotest GmbH, Dahlewitz, Germany ).
Each experiment was performed three times under identical conditions, and the lowest value among the measured results was selected to represent the AIT. The measured data were evaluated to ensure compliance with the maximum allowable deviations for repeatability and reproducibility (as outlined in
Table 3). To standardize the results, the final AIT values were rounded down to the nearest 5 °C.
This methodology ensures accurate and reliable measurement of AIT, providing a comprehensive understanding of the thermal behavior and fire risk associated with the tested materials under controlled conditions.
2.4. Differential Scaning Calorimeter and Thermogravimetric Analysis
According to the definition of thermal analysis by the International Confederation for Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry (ICTAC), thermal analysis refers to a set of analytical techniques used to measure the physical and chemical characteristics of materials as a function of temperature [
33]. The thermal analysis was carried out using DSC and TGA to evaluate the materials’ thermal properties. DSC data were analyzed using STARe Software (version 12.0), while TGA data were processed using Universal Analysis 2000 Software (version 4.5A). These techniques are essential for precisely measuring thermal stability, decomposition characteristics, and thermal transitions, providing critical insights into the properties of the materials.
DSC is a thermal analysis technique that measures the difference in heat flow between a sample and an inert reference material as they are subjected to the same temperature program. This technique allows for the quantitative evaluation of endothermic (heat absorption) and exothermic (heat release) processes. In this study, DSC analysis was conducted in accordance with ASTM E537-20 [
34] using a Mettler Toledo DSC 822e instrument (Mettler Toledo Instrument, Greifensee, Switzerland). Samples weighing 10–15 mg were placed in aluminum pans and analyzed over a temperature range of −40 °C to 600 °C, with a heating rate of 10 °C/min. Experiments were conducted under both nitrogen and air atmospheres to compare the thermal decomposition and reactivity of the samples under different conditions. The purge gas flow rate was maintained at 50 mL/min.
The data obtained from DSC analysis were presented in a thermogram, where the x-axis represents temperature and the y-axis represents heat flow. The thermogram can depict heat flow values or be simply labeled with directional arrows, such as ‘Exo’ (exothermic, heat release) or ‘Endo’ (endothermic, heat absorption), along with their corresponding arrows. The thermograms identified three main types of thermal changes: transitions, exothermic reactions, and endothermic processes, which are crucial for understanding the thermal behavior of the materials analyzed in this study.
This comprehensive approach to DSC analysis provides valuable data for assessing the thermal stability and chemical reactivity of the materials under varying environmental conditions [
35].
The onset temperature is defined as the temperature at which an exothermic or endothermic reaction begins, marked by the initial deviation of the thermal analysis curve from the baseline. The extrapolated onset temperature is determined by extrapolating the tangent of the exothermic or endothermic graph to intersect the baseline, providing a precise value for the start of the reaction. The peak temperature represents the point at which the reaction rate within a specific interval (S) reaches its maximum. The reaction enthalpy (ΔH), indicating heat absorption (endothermic) or release (exothermic), is calculated using the peak area and the sample’s weight. The peak area is obtained as the product of the x-axis (time, in seconds) and the y-axis (heat flow, in watts, W = J/s), resulting in energy units of joules (J). Dividing the peak area by the sample weight yields the reaction enthalpy per unit weight, expressed as J/g.
TGA is a thermal analysis technique used to measure changes in the mass of a sample as a function of temperature or time. It is used to assess the thermal stability, decomposition characteristics, and oxidative behavior of materials. TGA incrementally increases the temperature at a constant rate, providing insights into the sample’s mass loss and adsorption behavior. This study followed ASTM E1131-20 [
36] and utilized the TA TGA 5500 instrument (TA Instruments, New Castle, USA). Samples weighing 5–6 mg were placed in aluminum pans and analyzed within a temperature range of 30–1000 °C, with a heating rate of 10 °C/min. The experiments were conducted under identical atmospheric conditions as those used for the DSC analysis.
The data obtained from TGA are represented as a thermal decomposition curve, with the x-axis indicating temperature and the y-axis showing the percentage of sample weight remaining. This curve depicts the mass loss behavior of the sample and provides critical information on its decomposition [
37].
The thermal decomposition curve obtained from TGA can vary significantly depending on the test conditions, particularly the composition of the surrounding atmosphere. The gas environment is one of the most critical factors influencing TGA results. Typically, analyses are conducted in either an inert or an oxidative atmosphere.
In the experiments conducted using Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) and Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA), high-purity nitrogen gas (purity > 99%) was used as the protective and purge gas. This created an inert atmosphere, preventing oxidation and enabling precise observation of thermal decomposition and physical changes. In such conditions, low-molecular-weight compounds volatilize, high-molecular-weight polymers decompose, and elemental carbon remains stable even above 1000 °C due to the absence of oxygen.
Conversely, air containing approximately 21% oxygen was employed to study oxidative stability and thermal behavior. In this atmosphere, oxygen facilitates the combustion of elemental carbon and accelerates the decomposition of polymers and organic compounds at lower temperatures. This dual-atmosphere approach provided comprehensive insights into material behavior under inert and oxidative conditions.