3.1. Li4NH Synthesis Using a Multimode Microwave Reactor
MW synthesis in a commercial multimode cavity (MMC) reactor offers faster processing (over times of the order of minutes), increased energy efficiency and lower cost [
9] than conventional high temperature approaches. To date, MW heating experiments with solid-state hydrogen storage materials have been limited to the study of the dehydrogenation properties of a small number of alkali, alkaline-earth and transition metal hydrides and of the alkali metal borohydrides, LiBH
4, NaBH
4 and KBH
4 [
10,
11,
12]. Nevertheless, given the difficulties in mapping the microwave field distributions in MMCs, there are some drawbacks related to this synthetic approach such as variable reaction reproducibility and poor material homogeneity.
Table 1 shows representative experiments performed to ascertain the appropriate reaction conditions for the successful synthesis of Li
4NH (samples 1–5). A schematic of the reaction set-up for the synthesis of the samples described in this section is shown in
Figure 1. Several reaction parameters such as microwave power, reaction times, atmosphere and the use of graphite (G) as an external microwave susceptor were considered. It should be noted that the reaction times in
Table 1 were not continuous; each reaction was stopped at regular intervals (
ca. 1 min steps) to allow for cooling in an attempt to avoid overheating of the silica reaction ampoule.
Figure 1.
Reaction set-up using an multimode cavity (MMC) reactor.
Figure 1.
Reaction set-up using an multimode cavity (MMC) reactor.
Table 1.
Summary of Li3N + LiH reactions using an MMC reactor.
Table 1.
Summary of Li3N + LiH reactions using an MMC reactor.
Reaction | Power/W | Time/s | Other reaction conditions | PXD results |
---|
1 | 900 | 960 | Ar(g) atm | LiH, α-Li3N |
2 | 900 | 240 | Vacuum | LiH, α-Li3N, Li4NH, Li2O and SiO2 |
3 | 600 | 70 | Ar(g) atm, G | LiH, α-Li3N and Li4NH |
4 | 600 | 300 | Vacuum, G | LiH, α-Li3N, Li4NH and Li2O |
5 | 600 | 390 | Vacuum, G | Li4NH, Li2O |
From these results it was shown that Li
4NH could be synthesised under the conditions highlighted for sample 5.
Figure 2 shows the PXD data obtained from sample 5; additional PXD of a partially reacted sample 2 was plotted for comparison. Silica peaks from the reaction vessel were also observed (marked with asterisks in the PXD pattern). For sample 5, the indexed cell parameters for Li
4NH of
a = 4.893(2) Å and
c = 9.936(8) Å match well to those previously reported by Marx [Tetragonal space group
I4
1/a,
a = 4.8918(1) Å,
c = 9.9321(3) Å] [
4]. Neither N–H nor O–H bands were observed in Raman spectra collected for sample 5. The use of an external microwave susceptor,
i.e., graphite, in these reactions appears essential in order to drive the reaction to completion. This can be rationalised in terms of the necessity to raise the reaction temperature to a point where the reactants exhibit a loss tangent (tan δ) that is sufficient to couple effectively with microwaves [
13]. In fact, it has been reported that graphite achieves a temperature of 1345 K in
ca. 2 min of microwave irradiation [
13]. Reactions performed under argon gas were not observed to proceed to completion, even in the presence of a graphite susceptor.
Figure 2.
PXD data for the as-formed products obtained from MW irradiation in an MMC reactor (a) at 600 W for 390 s sample 5; and (b) at 900 W for 240 s sample 2. Indexed peaks correspond to the tetragonal Li4NH phase.
Figure 2.
PXD data for the as-formed products obtained from MW irradiation in an MMC reactor (a) at 600 W for 390 s sample 5; and (b) at 900 W for 240 s sample 2. Indexed peaks correspond to the tetragonal Li4NH phase.
Despite successfully preparing high purity Li
4NH using an MMC, concerns over repeatability across experiments from uncertainties in the field distribution led us to consider the use of an single mode cavity (SMC) reactor to improve homogeneity, reproducibility and potentially further reduce reaction times. This cavity offers better control over reactions given the opportunity to accurately position the sample in a well-defined electric field [
14]. Moreover, the use of an external susceptor in these reactions is avoided and therefore any risk of product contamination can be minimised.
3.2. Li4NH Synthesis Using a Single Mode Microwave Reactor
A summary of the reactions conducted in SMC system (
Figure 3) is shown in
Table 2. As for the MMC syntheses described in
Section 3.1, cooling intervals were introduced between irradiation periods to avoid melting of the silica reaction ampoule (
i.e., melting point 2073 K). Indeed, heating at 300 W for
t > 240 s led to the destruction of the SiO
2 reaction vessel. It is evident from PXD data collected for sample 8 that single phase Li
4NH could be successfully synthesized at 300 W in 180 s; no reflections from the starting materials α-Li
3N and LiH were observed (
Figure 4). The final product had the appearance of a yellow/beige pellet. Previously, Li
4NH was synthesised from the reaction between Li
3N and LiH at 763 K for 6 h under Ar [
4] and thus with the synthetic approach described here, reaction times could be reduced by a factor of 100 and performed without the need for an inert cover gas.
Table 2.
Summary of Li3N + LiH reactions using a SMC reactor.
Table 2.
Summary of Li3N + LiH reactions using a SMC reactor.
Reaction | Power/W | Time/s | Other reaction conditions | PXD results |
---|
6 | 150 | 270 | Vacuum | LiH, α-Li3N and Li4NH |
7 | 250 | 270 | Vacuum | LiH, α-Li3N and Li4NH |
8 | 300 | 180 | Vacuum | Li4NH |
Figure 3.
Reaction set-up using a SMC reactor.
Figure 3.
Reaction set-up using a SMC reactor.
The MW synthesis of lithium nitride hydride is possible due to the ability of the starting materials to absorb microwave energy and convert this into heat (as reflected in the loss tangent, tan δ). The ability of Li
3N to produce heat in a microwave field may be attributed to its inherent fast ionic conductivity and semiconducting behavior [
15,
16]. In fact, it is well established that microwaves couple directly to charge carriers leading to extremely rapid reactions in many ionic conductors and semiconductors [
17]. Conversely, LiH does not generate significant heat under a microwave field and, for example, no changes in temperature were observed when LiH was placed within SMC (400 W; 20 min) or MMC (500 W; 30 min) reactors [
7,
9]. In fact, in these previous studies among NaH, MgH
2, CaH
2, TiH
2, VH
0.81, ZrH
2 and LaH
2.48 only the transition metal and lanthanide hydrides showed a rapid increase in temperature, which even then only led to the desorption of a small percentage of hydrogen (< 0.5 wt %).
Figure 4.
PXD data for tetragonal Li4NH obtained in an SMC reactor at 300 W for 180 s under vacuum (sample 8).
Figure 4.
PXD data for tetragonal Li4NH obtained in an SMC reactor at 300 W for 180 s under vacuum (sample 8).
During the reactions described here (samples 1–8), a purple plasma was observed along the length of the silica reaction tube. The purple plasma was followed on most occasions by yellow/orange flashes (Additional
Supplementary Information). The observation of these plasmas/flashes provides evidence for the high local temperatures achieved in the reaction vessel (
i.e., Li evaporation occurs at
ca. 1573 K) [
18].
3.3. Thermal Stability of Li4NH
The thermal stability of the nitride hydride was investigated by TG-DTA under flowing argon. TG-DTA of sample 8 showed no evidence of mass change and hence decomposition or dehydrogenation when the sample was heated to 773 K (
Figure 5a). Moreover, it was also evident from mass spectra collected simultaneously while heating that no hydrogen or other gases were evolved over the entire
m/z range (1 ≤
m/z ≤ 200) (
Figure 5b). These results corroborate previous investigations conducted to 698 K under argon [
4]. Indexing of the PXD pattern from sample 8 following the TG-DTA experiment (
Figure 5c) yielded cell parameters for Li
4NH of
a = 4.891(2) Å and
c = 9.9252(8) Å. These lattice parameters are within 2σ of those obtained for this sample prior to the TG-DTA and therefore no significant changes were noted. An Li
2O impurity was noted in the post-TG-DTA diffractogram and was attributed to the presence of moisture in the Ar
(g) and/or a reaction between a small amount of Li
4NH and the alumina sample holder.
The DTA profile for sample 8 however reveals an interesting feature above 700 K with no corresponding simultaneous weight change. This endothermic peak at 770 K can thus be attributed to a structural phase transition in Li4NH. An equivalent exothermic peak in the DTA was observed at 755.6 K on cooling, demonstrating that the phase transition is reversible (and as corroborated by PXD where the tetragonal Li4NH is observed as discussed above).
Figure 5.
(a) Thermogravimetric and differential thermal analysis (TG-DTA) profiles for sample 8 under Ar(g). The sample was heated to 773 K at 5 K min−1 held for 1 h and cooled at 5 K min−1. TG, DTA and temperature curves are represented in black, blue and red respectively; (b) Mass spectra obtained under the conditions shown in (a). NH3(g), N2(g), H2(g) and H2O were monitored; and (c) PXD pattern showing the experimental data for sample 8 after heating and cooling under Ar. The open squares denote a Li2O minor impurity phase.
Figure 5.
(a) Thermogravimetric and differential thermal analysis (TG-DTA) profiles for sample 8 under Ar(g). The sample was heated to 773 K at 5 K min−1 held for 1 h and cooled at 5 K min−1. TG, DTA and temperature curves are represented in black, blue and red respectively; (b) Mass spectra obtained under the conditions shown in (a). NH3(g), N2(g), H2(g) and H2O were monitored; and (c) PXD pattern showing the experimental data for sample 8 after heating and cooling under Ar. The open squares denote a Li2O minor impurity phase.
In light of the evidence for a high temperature phase transition from the TG-DTA data, attempts were made to isolate the high-temperature (HT) Li
4NH phase by heating as-prepared Li
4NH (sample 8) to 798 K at 5 K min
−1 under flowing argon using a conventional furnace and quenching in liquid nitrogen.
Figure 6 shows the PXD pattern of the reaction products collected after quenching (sample 9). The diffractogram comprises reflections for the tetragonal low temperature (LT) phase and Li
2O but is notable for the appearance of a small number of new peaks corresponding to an HT-phase. The reflections for the HT-Li
4NH phase could be indexed to a cube with
a = 4.915(1) Å. The presence of Li
2O in the reaction products is attributed to a possible reaction between Li
4NH and the SiO
2 reaction tube. Hence, it is quite likely that the unknown peaks observed in the powder pattern for sample 9 might correspond to Li–Si–(N–O) impurities from a side reaction with the reaction ampoule. Raman spectra collected for sample 9 showed the complete absence of either N–H or O–H bands.
Figure 6.
PXD pattern of sample 8 (a) after quenching Li4NH from high temperature (to form sample 9); and (b) prior to heating.
Figure 6.
PXD pattern of sample 8 (a) after quenching Li4NH from high temperature (to form sample 9); and (b) prior to heating.
3.4. Structure Determination
Structure refinements performed against PXD data were conducted for sample 8. Selected Rietveld refinement data collected at room temperature are displayed in
Table 3 and additional results are included in the
Supplementary Information (Tables S1 and S2). Although a satisfactory fit for the data could be obtained using a single phase tetragonal model for LT-Li
4NH, a marked improvement in the residuals was achieved when including the second HT-phase identified by the quenching experiments (see above). Traces of silica (assumed to originate from the reaction ampoule) were also found in the diffraction profile of sample 8. The observed-calculated-difference (OCD) profile plot is shown in
Figure 7.
The presence of the HT-phase in sample 8 can be rationalised by the relatively fast cooling rate from the SMC MW reaction (as compared to conventional heating), which allows some of the kinetically stable HT-Li4NH phase to remain in the sample at room temperature.
Table 3.
Selected Rietveld refinement data from the lab X-ray refinement of sample 8 at 298 K.
Table 3.
Selected Rietveld refinement data from the lab X-ray refinement of sample 8 at 298 K.
Empirical formula | LT-Li4NH | HT-Li4NH |
---|
Collection temperature/K | 298 | 298 |
Crystal system | Tetragonal | Cubic |
Space group | I41/a | Fmm |
Lattice parameters/Å | a = 4.8864(1) | a = 4.9462(3) |
c = 9.9183(2) |
V/Å3 | 236.82(1) | 121.01(2) |
Z | 4 | 4 |
Unit cell formula weight, Mw | 171.116 | 85.558 |
Density/g cm−3 | 1.200 | 1.174 |
Phase fraction/wt% | 98.1(5) | 1.8(5) |
No. of observations, parameters | 12,117, 35 |
Rwp, Rp | 0.0373, 0.0273 |
χ2 | 1.962 |
Figure 7.
Observed-calculated-difference (OCD) profile plot from the room temperature Rietveld refinement for sample 8. Observed data are shown in red, calculated data are shown in green and the difference between the two profiles is shown in pink. Black tickmarks correspond to tetragonal Li4NH, red tickmarks correspond to cubic Li4NH and blue tickmarks correspond to SiO2.
Figure 7.
Observed-calculated-difference (OCD) profile plot from the room temperature Rietveld refinement for sample 8. Observed data are shown in red, calculated data are shown in green and the difference between the two profiles is shown in pink. Black tickmarks correspond to tetragonal Li4NH, red tickmarks correspond to cubic Li4NH and blue tickmarks correspond to SiO2.
The LT-Li
4NH phase was modeled in tetragonal space group
I4
1/a with lattice parameters
a = 4.8864(1) Å and
c = 9.9183(2) Å (
Figure 8a) and corresponds to the structure originally reported by Marx and re-determined by Niewa
et al. [
4,
5].from PXD and PND data and single crystal X-ray diffraction data respectively. Initial attempts were made to fit HT-Li
4NH in tetragonal space groups but following the elucidation of the second phase from the quenching experiments described in
Section 3.3, a better structural model was chosen. The structure of HT-Li
4NH was refined in the cubic space group
Fmm with
a = 4.9462(3) Å (
Figure 8b) using a model based on a modified Li
2NH-type
anti-fluorite structure in which N
3− and H
− equally occupy the 4
a site occupied by the imido N atom in Li
2NH [
19]. The structure thus corresponds to a regular Li
2(N,H) cube derived from the tetragonal LT-Li
4NH structure where
acubic ~
atetragonal and
acubic ~
ctetragonal/2.
Figure 8.
Crystal structures of (a) the LT-Li4NH phase (space group I41/a), where Li atoms are represented in pink; N1/H1 are represented in orange; and N2/H2 atoms are represented in blue; and (b) the HT-Li4NH phase (space group Fmm). Lithium atoms are represented in pink and N/H atoms are represented in blue. Polyhedra showing the coordination environment of the Li and N/H atoms are represented in yellow.
Figure 8.
Crystal structures of (a) the LT-Li4NH phase (space group I41/a), where Li atoms are represented in pink; N1/H1 are represented in orange; and N2/H2 atoms are represented in blue; and (b) the HT-Li4NH phase (space group Fmm). Lithium atoms are represented in pink and N/H atoms are represented in blue. Polyhedra showing the coordination environment of the Li and N/H atoms are represented in yellow.
Atomic positions and isotropic thermal parameters for each Li
4NH phase are presented in
Table 4 and
Table 5. Given that PXD is not able to locate hydride accurately, the occupancies of the N
3− and H
− anions in the LT-Li
4NH phase were fixed at values reported by Marx [
4]. Attempts to fix the site occupancies at alternative values representing different distributions of anions led to poorer quality fits. The LT-phase therefore exhibits anion ordering with the 4
a site predominantly occupied by N
3− (at 95%) and the 4
b site similarly almost fully occupied by H
−. The cubic HT-Li
4NH phase displays a disordered N
3−/H
− anion distribution over the 4
a site. The occupancies for the N
3− and H
− atoms in the HT-Li
4NH phase were both fixed to 50% in order to achieve charge balance. Given the structural relationship between the LT- and HT-Li
4NH phases, it is not surprising that the coordination environments around the cations and anions in each phase are very similar. Whereas in the LT- structure the essentially fully ordered N
3− and H
− anions are in a distorted cubic coordination with Li
+ (with distances ranging between 2.044(2)–2.082(2) Å and 1.949(2)–2.556(3) Å respectively), in the HT-structure fully disordered N
3−/H
− anions are in a regular cubic coordination, with an Li–(N
3−/H
− distance of 2.1418(1) Å (
Supplementary Information; Table S1). Li atoms are tetrahedrally coordinated to N/H atoms in the HT-phase. There are also strong similarities between the
anti-fluorite structures of HT-Li
4NH (Li
2N
0.5H
0.5) and Li
2NH (Li
2(NH)). The Li–N
3−/H
− bond lengths are shorter than the lithium-imido Li–N distances reported by Balogh
et al. [
19] in Li
2NH. (2.205 Å).
Nitride hydrides are relatively rare but N
3−/H
− anion ordering similar to that in the LT-Li
4NH phase has also been observed in alkaline earth metal nitride hydrides such as Ca
2NH(D) (cubic space group
Fdm) [
20,
21], Ba
2NH(D) and Sr
2NH (both hexagonal space group
Rm) [
22,
23]. Although there are no previously reported examples of complete N
3−/H
− disorder in the solid state, the anion disorder in HT-Li
4NH is paralleled by the N
3−/F
− distribution in nitride fluorides such as Ba
2NF [
24,
25]. Further studies on deuterated LT-Li
4NH and HT-Li
4NH using powder neutron diffraction will be performed to elucidate the crystal structures more fully (
i.e., determine accurate hydrogen (deuterium) occupancies and anisotropic thermal parameters).
Table 4.
Atom positions and isotropic thermal parameters generated by Rietveld refinement against lab X-ray data for LT-Li4NH (sample 8) at 298 K.
Table 4.
Atom positions and isotropic thermal parameters generated by Rietveld refinement against lab X-ray data for LT-Li4NH (sample 8) at 298 K.
Atom | N1 | H1 | N2 | H2 | Li1 |
---|
Site | 4a | 4a | 4b | 4b | 16f |
x | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0.1959(5) |
y | 0.25 | 0.25 | 0.25 | 0.25 | 0.4618(4) |
z | 0.125 | 0.125 | 0.625 | 0.625 | 0.2794(2) |
100 × Uiso/Å2 | 3.9(1) | 3.9(1) | 3.1(4) | 3.1(4) | 6.93(9) |
Site occupancy | 0.95 | 0.05 | 0.05 | 0.95 | 1.00 |
Table 5.
Atom positions used for Rietveld refinement against PXD data for HT-Li4NH (in sample 8) at 298 K. (Thermal parameters were fixed for this minority phase).
Table 5.
Atom positions used for Rietveld refinement against PXD data for HT-Li4NH (in sample 8) at 298 K. (Thermal parameters were fixed for this minority phase).
Atom | Li1 | N1 | H1 |
---|
Site | 8c | 4a | 4a |
x | 0.25 | 0 | 0 |
y | 0.25 | 0 | 0 |
z | 0.25 | 0 | 0 |
100 × Uiso/Å2 | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.5 |
Occupancy | 1.00 | 0.50 | 0.50 |