Research on Electrochemical Controllable Machining Technology of Small-Sized Inner Intersecting Hole Rounding

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

Please address the following in the revision

1. Which optimization tool is used and Why?

2. Why built-in fixed cathode machining method is preferred?

3. Why the concentration of the current density at the sharp corners of the workpiece?

4. The regression equation needs to be validated.

5. How uniformity of the current density distribution is achieved?

6. Literature review is poor. Include the optimization for your processing. Pl check this paper for optimization methods available https://doi.org/10.12982/CMJS.2022.034

 

 

Author Response

Please see the attachment.

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf

Reviewer 2 Report

The work entitled "Research on Electrochemical Controllable Machining Technollogy of Small-sized Inner Intersecting Hole Rounding" is very interesting. It considers the problem of the rounding of the inlet channels intersecting them. The theme is reflected in the plumbing industry. Currently, the accuracy of execution plays a very important role in influencing the frictional resistance of the fluid flow.

What I miss in this work is only the roughness of the tested surface, I hope that this problem will be discussed in the next article. The work is scientifically suitable for publication.

 

The work still requires an editorial correction.

Below are the errors:

Line 33 "[3, Error! Reference source not 36found."

line 41 [10, Error! Reference source not 41found.] "

Below I present errors regarding spaces before measurement units. Please standardize and arrange that there is no or no space in the whole work. Same for "%" and "V"

line 48 5mm

line 49 0.9mm is 0.15mm

line 275 "1mm" no space

line 112, point 3, should start on the next page

line 180, dot 4, should start on the next page

line 275 "1mm" no space.

Author Response

Please see the attachment.

Author Response File: Author Response.pdf