Forecasting of Hypoallergenic Wheat Productivity Based on Unmanned Aerial Vehicles Remote Sensing Approach—Case Study
, Jacek Waga 2, Andrzej Oleksy 1, Marcin Rapacz 2, Marek Kołodziejczyk 1, Piotr Wężyk 3, Agnieszka Klimek-Kopyra 1,*, Robert Witkowicz 1, Andrzej Skoczowski 4, Grażyna Podolska 5 and Wiesław Grygierzec 6
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
All the related comments are in the annexed file.
Comments for author File: 
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Response to Reviewer’s comments.
We would like to thank for comments and suggestion, which help us a lot and increased a scientific value of our manuscript. We hope that quality of manuscript has been improved.
Changes are visible in text of manuscript.
The manuscript correction includes each section of manuscript.
We corrected the title.
In introduction section we cut long sentences and we add additional description dedicated to remote sensing techniques.
In methodology section we added information about vegetation periods and agrotechnical details.
Vegetation indices are presented in table.
In result section description of tables was checked, and it fits well.
In result section we added recommended sentences.
In conclusion we added the recommendation.
Kind regards,
Authors
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Please consider reviewing the grammar of the manuscript: lines 13, 14, 76, etc.
Line 53, the Figure does not have caption. It should be Figure 1. Please, quote this figure in the body of the manuscript before the figure.
Line 111, when speaking about a figure, this should be placed before the figure (line 109).
Line 122, Figure 3 is not quoted in the text. When fixed, you should place quotation in the text before the figure.
Line 145, Table 1 is not quoted in the previous text. Same as figures, first you quote the table or figure in the text and then you place it in the manuscript with the correct caption.
Line 232, please don´t start a paragraph with a figure (Fig. 7). You should place some text and quote the figure before placing it. Please, consider using a better quality image for picture 7.
Line 235, same as before with Figure 7. Figure 7 and Figure 8 should be placed after the text and the quote.
Line 255. Figure 9 should be placed after the citation in the text (line 257). Consider improving the resolution of this image.
Line 298, Figure 10 should be quoted in the text before the figure. Why you place a composition just for EVI index and not for the rest of the indices?
Line 307, the text talks about LAI index and makes a reference to Fig 10. But Fig 10 caption is about EVI index. Can you explain this?
Line 385, did you see this behaviour in your experiment? Can you quote the figures you have calculated?
Al Figures and tables should be aligned to the right margin of the document.
Consider placing Tables 2 to 7, Table 9 as aditional material at the end of the text, for a better format and comprehesion of the manuscript.
Discussion, please consider speaking about the correlation (R2) of the indices graphs.
First pages does not contain page number. Is only present from line 325. Correct this.
References font should be the same as the rest of the text. Please review the template provided by the journal.
Author Response
Rev.2
Response to Reviewer’s comments
We would like to thank for comments and suggestion. We hope that quality of manuscript has been improved.
Line 53, the Figure does not have caption. It should be Figure 1. Please, quote this figure in the body of the manuscript before the figure.
Res. We corrected the figures headings.
Line 111, when speaking about a figure, this should be placed before the figure (line 109).
Res. We corrected the order of outcome description
Line 122, Figure 3 is not quoted in the text. When fixed, you should place quotation in the text before the figure.
Res. We improved manuscript. Figures citation is included in text. We also corrected the order of outcome description
Line 145, Table 1 is not quoted in the previous text. Same as figures, first you quote the table or figure in the text and then you place it in the manuscript with the correct caption.
Res. We improved manuscript. Figures and tables citation is included in text. We also corrected the order of outcome description
Line 232, please don´t start a paragraph with a figure (Fig. 7). You should place some text and quote the figure before placing it. Please, consider using a better quality image for picture 7.
Res. We improved manuscript. Figures and tables citation is included in text. We also corrected the order of outcome description
Line 235, same as before with Figure 7. Figure 7 and Figure 8 should be placed after the text and the quote.
Res. We improved manuscript. Figures and tables citation is included in text. We also corrected the order of outcome description
Line 255. Figure 9 should be placed after the citation in the text (line 257). Consider improving the resolution of this image.
Res. We improved manuscript. Figures and tables citation is included in text. We also corrected the order of outcome description
Line 298, Figure 10 should be quoted in the text before the figure. Why you place a composition just for EVI index and not for the rest of the indices?
Res. We improved manuscript. Figures and tables citation is included in text. We also corrected the order of outcome description
Line 307, the text talks about LAI index and makes a reference to Fig 10. But Fig 10 caption is about EVI index. Can you explain this?
Res. We improved manuscript. Figures and tables citation is included in text. We also corrected the order of outcome description
Line 385, did you see this behaviour in your experiment? Can you quote the figures you have calculated?
Res. It was deleted .
Al Figures and tables should be aligned to the right margin of the document.
Res. Figures and tables are out of margine, since it is automatic format setting by MDPI
Consider placing Tables 2 to 7, Table 9 as aditional material at the end of the text, for a better format and comprehesion of the manuscript.
Discussion, please consider speaking about the correlation (R2) of the indices graphs.
Res. Correlations are already mentioned in manuscript
First pages does not contain page number. Is only present from line 325. Correct this.
Res. It was corrected.
References font should be the same as the rest of the text. Please review the template provided by the journal.
Res. The font of references was uniform.
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Line 106 to 111: this paragraph should be placed before the quoted Figure (Fig.1).
Line 152: this should be Figure 3?
Please, consider reviewing the layout of the manuscript to avoid large blank spaces (i.e line 105, line 127, line 208, line 251, line 278, line 319); and review the indentations at line 61, 68, 142. Try to design a smooth layout of the text, figures and tables for a better lecture of the manuscript.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
We would like to thank for comments.
All changes are visible in text.
We replaced mentioned paragraph before Figure 1.
We corrected number of Figure 3. We did reference of Figure 3 to suitable place in text of manuscript
We corrected visualization of presented figures. We also removed blank spaces.
We are not allowed to design a smooth layout of the text since there is a role of processing Editor.
We believe that manuscript is well improved.
Regards,
Authors
