1. Introduction
The southwestern region of Rio Grande do Sul State, Southern Brazil, is part of the Pampa Biome, a natural ecosystem rich in biological and pedological diversity with environmental, economic, and socio-cultural importance for Brazil, Uruguay, and Argentina [
1], but the fragility of the soil, flora, and fauna makes the Pampa Biome vulnerable to agriculture conversion and degradation [
2]. In this region, there are extensive areas in the process of sandyzation [
3]. According to Bellanca and Suertegaray [
4], such conditions have been interpreted in various ways, from natural origin and resulting from water processes acting on the lithology and specific soils, to anthropic causes associated with overgrazing and land use without conservation practices. In addition to these, Caneppele [
5] also refers to the introduction of wheat and soybean crops and eucalyptus monocultures in the region as conditioning factors of erosion processes in these areas, as well as the use of heavy machinery and non-conservationist soil practices since 1970, causing soil compaction, the creation of preferential paths for drainage, and soil exposure through plowing or suppression of vegetation.
Quartzipsamments are predominantly in areas of the sandyzation process, and they have a sandy texture and a fragile structure, and are not very resistant to wind and water erosion [
2], besides having low water availability, low natural fertility, and low cation exchange capacity [
1,
6,
7].
Agricultural expansion in Quartzipsamments has been taking place [
5], and few studies have been carried out on this soil and its use and management. In this sense, a better understanding of these environments is necessary so that the impacts of land use are minimized, since the intensive non-sustainable use of the land has taken negative consequences in this biome [
2], at levels that are difficult to control.
In Brazil, Quartzipsamments together with other sandy and sandy loam soils represent 8% of the territory [
8]. The authors state that in the past, these soils were of little agricultural relevance due to their limitations, even in areas favorable to mechanization, but currently, agriculture is establishing itself in these areas due to advances in production systems and agricultural practices. FAO [
9] considers these soils as part of the group of Arenosols, covering about 900 million hectares or 7% of the earth’s surface. In this sense, the study and understanding of the behavior and processes involved in sandy soils become relevant, either for its representative area in terms of Brazil and the world, or the advance of agricultural exploitation of these soils of low agricultural land suitability and high environmental fragility.
The fragility of the sandy areas, due to the morphogenetic soil characteristics where the ravine and gully processes are present, conditions a high risk of landscape degradation through the occupation of the soil by crops and forestation [
10,
11]. In a review of recent studies of sandy soils (considered by the authors those with sand > 50% and clay < 20%), Huang and Hartemink [
12] consider these soils as more sensitive to climate change and anthropic activities when compared to others, and due to population growth and urbanization, they have been widely used in the supply of food and other products and services for society.
Although Quartzipsamments are environmentally fragile, they have been widely used for agricultural purposes. Despite their low agricultural land suitability, it seems that political and economic issues favor the advance of the agricultural use of Quartzipsamments in southern Brazil, but little information is available about these soils, especially their morphology, fertility, and physical–hydric properties, as well as practices for better agricultural use. Thus, this work aims to characterize the morphological, chemical, and physical–hydric properties of Quartzipsamments; point out some difficulties and challenges in the use and management of these soils; and propose strategies for better soil use. Our hypothesis is that Quartzipsamments are soils of low suitability for agricultural use due to their low fertility and available water to plants, besides being unstructured due to the low content of organic matter and clay, demanding conservation practices to improve their properties.
3. Results
The morphological data (
Table 1) show that all Quartzipsamments profiles have a weak structure in subangular blocks that break down into single grains. They are very deep soils (>100 cm), with colors ranging from reddish (2.5 YR) to yellowish (10YR), always with high values and chromas (≥4). The color indicates the good drainage of the analyzed profiles. The consistency verified was loose and non-plastic and non-sticky for virtually all profiles. The horizon boundary distinctness varied predominantly between clear and gradual.
The particle size distribution is shown in
Table 2 and
Table 3. There is a predominance of medium and fine sand fractions, with mean values in the horizons ranging from, respectively, 218.13 to 756.38 g kg
−1 and 178.66 to 577.04 g kg
−1. In the sand fraction, quartz mineralogical composition predominates. The silt and clay contents were extremely low, the mean values in the horizons ranging from, respectively, 4.53 to 57.35 g kg
−1 and 23.03 to 126.29 g kg
−1. The textural class of horizons, according to Santos et al. [
15], is sandy, and according to the USDA-NRCS [
24], it is sand and loamy sand only for horizons with more than 100 g kg
−1 of clay, such as C1 of NQ1 and NQ6, and C3 of NQ2.
The flocculation degree, which represents the resistance of the soil structure to disintegration, presented a wide range of values (8.78 to 80.79%) (
Table 3).
The Quartzipsamments profiles showed high values of macroporosity and saturated hydraulic conductivity and low values of microporosity and available water (
Table 4). These results are consistent with the characteristics of these sandy soils. The high conductivity was associated with macropores, the main responsible for the flow of air and water, and the low availability of water due to lower microporosity, pores responsible for retention and availability of water.
In general, the surface horizon showed higher total porosity and macroporosity (
Table 4). Generally, the bulk density was higher with increasing depth.
The evaluated Quartzipsamments are acidic and, in general, with low fertility, with predominantly low Ca and Mg contents and very low K [
28] (
Table 5). The cation exchange capacity at pH 7.0 and the organic matter are predominantly low [
28] (
Table 6), reflecting a high risk of leaching and impact on the environment due to smaller adsorption sites and high hydraulic conductivity (
Table 4) and, in terms of agricultural use, requiring an application in installments of fertilizers. These results corroborate the single-grain soil structure (
Table 1 and
Table 4), since electrical charges and organic matter contribute to soil aggregation. The chemical results are consistent with the low clay content of these soils (
Table 3) because, in this particle size, soil reactivity occurs [
29].
According to Pearson’s correlation analysis, the increment in macroporosity increases the total porosity (
r = 0.80) and decreases the microporosity (
r = −0.50), with a consequent increase in the saturated hydraulic conductivity (
r = 0.45) and a decrease in available water (
r = −0.41) (
Table 7). The increase in bulk density decreases its total porosity (
r = −0.19), although with no effect on macroporosity and microporosity, which suggests that there is a decrease in the size of the macropore with increasing bulk density, but no increase in microporosity. Because the vertical flow of water in the soil occurs mainly in macropores, while the water available to plants is in the micropores, increasing microporosity decreases hydraulic conductivity (
r = −0.75) and increases available water (
r = 0.47). Particle density showed an inversely proportional relationship with microporosity (
r = −0.45) and a positive relationship with hydraulic conductivity (
r = 0.40); that is, with an increase in particle density, there is a decrease in microporosity and an increase in hydraulic conductivity.
Soil bulk density showed a positive and significant correlation with clay (
r = 0.45) (
Table 8), indicating that clay, even in small proportion in these soils, can occupy the spaces between larger particles (silt and sand), decreasing the size of the macropore, with a consequent decrease in total porosity and an increase in bulk density, but with no influence on microporosity, as seen in
Table 7. At 10% probability, the degree of flocculation was positively correlated with total porosity (
r = 0.30) and bulk density (
r = 0.33).
Increasing pH water and pH KCl, there is an increase in the availability of Ca (
r = 0.47 and 0.44, respectively), Mg (
r = 0.38 and 0.35), and K (
r = 0.37 and 0.37), and an increase in CECeffective (
r = 0.46 and 0.43), CECpH7.0 (
r = 0.44 and 0.42), and base saturation (
r = 0.45 and 0.43) and a decrease in Al saturation for pH KCL (
r = −0.34) (
Table 9). Increasing organic matter, there is an increase in CECeffective (
r = 0.57) and CECpH7.0 (
r = 0.66), with a consequent increase in the availability of Ca, Mg, and K and base saturation, and a decrease in Al saturation, evidencing the effect of organic matter in the chemical improvement of these soils where the clay content is low, and the adjustment of pH improves soil fertility.
The Na (
r = 0.47) and K (
r = 0.42) showed a positive and significant correlation with very fine sand, while Ca had a negative correlation with coarse sand, as well as CECeffective and CECpH7.0 (
Table 10). The increase in pH water decreases the degree of flocculation of the soil (
r = −0.34).
Increasing organic matter, there is an increase in total porosity (
r = 0.53) and a decrease in bulk density (
r = −0.47) (
Table 11). The effect of some chemical variables on soil physics may be associated with electrical charges and aggregate formation. In these soils, the increase in microporosity has a positive effect on increasing the availability of Ca (
r = 0.74), Mg (
r = 0.67), K (
r = 0.38), and on CECeffective (
r = 0.74), CECpH7.0 (
r = 0.72) and base saturation (
r = 0.58), and decreasing Al saturation (
r = −0.37).
4. Discussion
The low clay contents in these soils are highlighted because practically all the reactivity of the soil, such as the cation exchange capacity, is available in this particle size [
29]. The availability of nutrients to the soil in the medium and long term from weathering is not significant due to the predominantly quartz mineralogical composition. The flocculation degree resulted in a wide range of values (8.78 to 80.79%), and this soil property is especially important in terms of soil water erosion resistance because it represents the resistance of the soil structure to disintegration.
Although the bulk density values showed a wide range of variation (1.32 to 1.64 Mg m
−3), the mean value of the profiles did not show significant variation (1.41 to 1.47 Mg m
−3) (
Table 4). According to FAO [
9], Arenosols have high bulk density values, ranging from 1.5 to 1.7 Mg m
−3, and considering the quartz density of around 2.65 Mg m
−3, the total porosity is around 0.36 to 0.46 m
3 m
−3. Although the total porosity was obtained directly by weighing, the values (0.380 to 0.522 m
3 m
−3) are close to those indicated by FAO [
9].
The range of macroporosity and microporosity values found are, respectively, 0.253 to 0.373 m
3 m
−3 and 0.083 to 0.182 m
3 m
−3. Working with different uses of Quartzipsamment in Rio Grande do Sul State, Reichert et al. [
30] found microporosity values similar to this study (0.073 to 0.169 m
3 m
−3) but higher to macroporosity (0.398 to 0.570 m
3 m
−3). The values found in the present study and by the aforementioned authors are completely opposite to what is usually found for clayey soils. For example, in comparative terms, Suzuki et al. [
31], studying different land use and management systems, verified for an Oxisol (clay between 640 and 664 g kg
−1) macroporosity and microporosity values of, respectively, 0.219 to 0.017 m
3 m
−3 and 0.476 to 0.354 m
3 m
−3, and total porosity of 0.573 to 0.460 m
3 m
−3, which refers to a lower agricultural and environmental suitability of Quartzipsamments when compared to other soils. Variations in bulk density according to its clay content are well documented [
32,
33,
34,
35]. The higher total porosity and macroporosity verified in most of the profiles in the superficial horizon can be associated with the action of the few roots in this superficial soil layer, while the greater values of bulk density with an increase in the depth can probably be related to the smaller action of roots and by the weight of the upper soil layers causing pressure on the subsurface layers.
The saturated hydraulic conductivity is extremely high in the Quartzipsamments evaluated, ranging from 127.85 to 672.26 mm h
−1, associated with the large volume of macropores (water-flow pores), as also observed by Reichert et al. [
30]. According to Mesquita and Moraes [
36], the flow of water in saturated soil occurs preferentially in macropores (pores with diameter >50 μm). FAO [
9] points out Arenosols as water-permeable soils, with the saturated hydraulic conductivity varying between 300 and 30,000 cm day
−1 (125 and 12,500 mm h
−1), and depending on the particle size distribution and the organic matter content, the available water capacity can be less than 3 to 4% or greater than 15 to 17%. FAO [
9] also mentions that because most pores are relatively large, much of the retained water is drained at a tension of only 100 kPa.
Suertegaray [
7] even mentions that the water dynamics in Quartzipsamments from Southwest of Rio Grande do Sul State, with regard to erosion, are associated with concentrated superficial processes, which originate furrows, ravines, and gullies. According to the author, laminar flow is not characteristic of these areas due to the high infiltration capacity of these soils.
A fact that draws attention is the low coefficient of variation of the saturated hydraulic conductivity (8.88 to 19.71%) (
Table 4). Generally, this property presents great spatial variability, generating a high coefficient of variation and requiring a greater number of samples to reduce this variability [
36]. Coefficient of variation values can be greater than 200% for hydraulic conductivity [
37]. According to the same authors, this variability is associated with types and land use, position in the landscape, depth, instruments and measurement methods, and experimental errors. The lower variability in Quartzipsamments allows the minimum number of soil samples in spatial variability studies. The low coefficient of variation of the saturated hydraulic conductivity in our study may be associated with the single-grain structure and high sand content in the soil profiles.
The volume of available water is extremely low (0.006 to 0.038 m
3 m
−3) (
Table 4), associated with the sandy texture and low volume of micropores (pores responsible for water retention and availability). Reichert et al. [
38] found for soils from Rio Grande do Sul State that field capacity and permanent wilting point increased in a similar proportion with increasing clay content of the soils. The authors also verified an average volume of available water to plants of 0.089 m
3 m
−3 for sandy soils and 0.124 m
3 m
−3 for very clayey soils, reaching 0.191 m
3 m
−3 for silty clay soils.
Compaction, so harmful in soils with higher clay content, can increase microporosity in sandy soils and the volume of available water to plants. However, studies are needed to indicate the appropriate level of compaction to improve water retention and availability for plants without preventing their root growth by increasing soil bulk density.
Working with four profiles of sandy soils from the Brazilian semiarid region, Santos et al. [
39] recommend lower irrigation rates and more frequent application, due to the lower water-holding capacity of these soils and greater risk of nutrient leaching.
In sandy soil (89% sand), the incorporation of clay together with organic matter increased aggregate stability, total soil porosity, and available water content and decreased soil bulk density. Moreover, increasing plant height and number of shoots of physic nut (
Jatropha curcas L.) were observed [
40]. While the biochar added to sandy soil (93.2% sand) increased water-holding capacity, decreased drainage, and increased available water for crop use [
41].
The high acidity and low fertility of these soils require an adjustment of pH and mineral reserve, which would demand high costs with fertilizer. Due to high sand and low clay contents, these soils require split fertilization to reduce leaching rates and increase the efficiency of nutrient uptake by plants. According to the “Manual de adubação e de calagem para os Estados do Rio Grande do Sul e Santa Catarina/Manual of fertilization and liming to the Rio Grande do Sul and Santa Catarina States” [
28], for these sandy soils (<20% clay) or with CEC < 7.5 cmolc dm
−3, it is recommended to avoid total corrective fertilization of K or P due to the possibility of leaching these nutrients or salinity problems, as well as the splitting of nitrogen fertilization.
Due to the smaller adsorption sites (low cation exchange capacity at pH 7.0 and organic matter) and the high hydraulic conductivity, there is a high risk of leaching and environmental damage, requiring an installment of fertilizer application in the agricultural use of these soils. In order to improve the chemical efficiency of these soils, it is recommended to increase their levels of organic matter, something that should occur gradually, with consequent improvement of the physical structure and biological activity of these soils. Meanwhile, due to the low levels of clay and organic matter, these soils need, at each crop, to be corrected through high doses of limestone and fertilizers, which can become financially unfeasible in the short and medium term.
Considering the very low K contents, for its total correction, the amount of 120 kg of K
2O per hectare is recommended [
28]. To correct the pH, raising it to a value of 6.0, the equation indicated by the SBCS-NRS/CQFS [
28] was used:
where NC is the limestone requirement in t ha
−1 (with relative power of total neutralization—PRNT 100%), OM is the organic matter content (in %), and Al is the exchangeable aluminum content of the soil (in cmol
c dm
−3).
From the calculations, considering the variation in Al and organic matter contents in the topsoil horizon, the limestone requirement ranged from 1.46 to 3.63 Mg ha−1. This calculus of K2O fertilizer and limestone reflects the high costs for fertility adjustment.
As reported by Donagemma et al. [
8], a common practice adopted by technicians and farmers in sandy soils is the application of limestone doses above 6 Mg ha
−1, and may even exceed 10 Mg ha
−1 because, according to farmers, when applying the dose of 2 Mg ha
−1, as recommended in corrective and fertilizer handbooks, crop yield will be very low. The authors explain this due to the low reactivity of limestone in these soils, associated with the low aluminum content and low buffering power of the soil, and possible losses of cations in depth, by leaching.
Hartemink and Huting [
42], Bezabih et al. [
43], Reichert et al. [
30], and Olorunfemi et al. [
44] also found in sandy soil a correlation between organic matter and CEC, and Bezabih et al. [
43] also observed a correlation between pH and CEC, and porosity and bulk density with organic carbon and CEC. The results of Olorunfemi et al. [
44] agree with the observations of this study on the negative correlation between base and aluminum saturation.
According to Reichert et al. [
30], for most sandy soils, a large part of the CEC comes from organic matter. From the collection of published data from tropical sandy soils in western and eastern Africa, Blanchart et al. [
45] showed that organic matter is the main determinant of soil fertility, nutrient storage, aggregate stability, and microbiological and enzymatic activities. According to the authors, although cultural practices or land use have a lower impact on the increase of organic matter when compared to clayey soils, this is the way to increase them and improve soil biofunction, which determines the agronomic and environmental potential of the sandy soils.
Reichert et al. [
30] verified changes in the physical properties of a Quartzipsamment related to organic carbon, which lead to a resistance of this soil to degradation. According to the authors, the accumulation of organic matter in sandy soils is more important than in clayey soils due to their fragility and difficulty in increasing their organic matter content. In sandy soils, the soil aggregation is mainly controlled by carbon dynamics [
46], and our study corroborates considering the low organic matter content and the single-grain soil structure.
The increase in organic matter can lead to a decrease in the use of mineral fertilizers [
28] and, as a consequence, less leaching and risks of contamination of water resources (surface due to erosion and subsurface due to leaching). In addition, its sandy texture requires split fertilization to decrease nutrient leaching and increase plant uptake [
28].
Alternatives are being studied to improve soil structure and fertility of sandy soils. For example, the use of clay and natural polymers increased the CEC and the number of available cations, and decreased the leached cations of coastal sandy soil (98% sand) [
47]. While long-term application of organic amendments improved physical (bulk density was decreased, available water-holding capacity was increased), biological (enhanced the overall soil microbial activity, such as species number and diversity, especially of the desirable groups such as heterotrophic aerobes, actinomycetes, and pseudomonads), and chemical properties (increasing soil organic matter, carbon, pH, Mehlich 1-extractable P, K, Ca, Mg, Mn, Cu, Fe, and Zn concentrations, CEC) of a sandy soil [
48].
The application of sewage sludge in sandy soil (87.69% sand) increased the organic matter content of soil; improved the infiltration rate, decreasing the water erosion under simulated high-intensity rainfall; decreased bulk density and increased the tendential air permeability of soil; and the soil compaction level was reduced in the first year after compost re-treatment. However, all the beneficial effects of sewage sludge last only for two years [
49]. While the use of liming and catch crops alone did not influence cereal yield and straw and plant height, in the fourth year of study, all yield trait components significantly increased with the use of farmyard manure, liming, and catch crops together in a Podzol sandy soil (62.9% sand) [
50].
It is known that current production techniques and technologies have evolved and improved and are accessible; however, it is worth highlighting the high cost of agricultural production of these soils, requiring a careful analysis in terms of production costs and sales value of the products.
Table 12 presents the difficulties and challenges specific to or associated with Quartzipsamments.
Due to the sandy texture (
Table 2) and low organic matter content of these soils (
Table 6), reflected in poorly structured soils (
Table 1 and
Table 4), they are very susceptible to erosion and the sandyzation process, requiring complex and permanent techniques and practices for the conservation of the soil, such as terracing and maintenance of permanent vegetation cover on the soil surface. Associated with this, there is still little vegetation cover, usually native pasture, although soybean cultivation is expanding in these soils and the use of the land with agriculture and livestock without grazing control and no adoption of conservation practices. Suertegaray et al. [
10] highlight that the dynamics of land use, without prior recognition of its agricultural land suitability, is capable of intensifying the morphogenetic processes, weakening the landscape in a relatively shorter time than the dynamics of nature itself. Therefore, sustainable land use in Biome Pampa is just possible if the economical activities consider the soil suitability and the adaptations of its plant and animal communities [
2].
In this sense, studying a toposequence with three sandy soils (sand between 89 and 95% and clay between 9 and 3%), Thomaz and Fidalski [
51] observed that the soil position in the toposequence and the total sand content were the variables that best explained the erodibility interrill, in an experiment under simulated rainfall, and emphasized the need for differentiated management systems along the toposequence.
Furthermore, the low volume of available water (
Table 4), considering these soils of low agricultural land suitability, and the high hydraulic conductivity and low water-holding capacity (
Table 4), associated with the minimum contents of clay, silt (
Table 3), and organic matter (
Table 6), characterize these soils as very fragile environmentally [
2], and should be used very carefully, especially due to the risks of leaching; transport of metals, pesticides, and other agrochemicals; and contamination of surface and subsurface water resources, besides the high susceptibility to erosion and sandyzation.
Suertegaray [
7] reported that, due to the fragility of the soils where the sands occur, they are highly susceptible to erosion when their agricultural management occurs through heavy machinery, which forms rills that can evolve into the formation of ravines and gullies. According to the author, intensive pastoral activity, with animal overcrowding is indicated as a cause of erosion, linked to the formation of rills by the trampling of cattle through trails.
Figure 4 shows water and wind erosion and the extensive areas of bare and exposed Quartzipsamments to sandyzation.
The use of cover plants is efficient in reducing the transport of sand by the wind in these soils, being an effective alternative to contain the expansion of the sandyzation process [
52].
In recent years, the return of soybean cultivation in Quartzipsamments has been observed; however, for their agricultural use, planning is essential to improve the structure of these soil, with the use of cover plants with a significant contribution of biomass to increase organic matter, soil physical structuring, and increase biological activity, and the use of soil and water conservation techniques. Moreover, cover crops can reduce evapotranspiration, a factor that can be limiting in these soils with low water-holding capacity. For example, Eltz and Rovedder [
53] observed temperatures above 40 °C at 3 cm depth in exposed soil in a sandyzation area, but when this area was replanted with cover crops, the soil temperature was reduced by around 18.6%.
Among alternatives for cover crops, Rovedder [
54] cites
Lupinus albescens (lupine) as a potential specie for the recovery of sandy soils, while Reichert et al. (2016) found that eucalyptus was more efficient in increasing soil organic carbon after conversion from native field to conventional planting, eucalyptus and unvegetated area.
Silva [
55] cites the dwarf butia tree (
Butia lalemanti), a common palm in the sandy top relief and deep soil, mainly in the cities of São Francisco de Assis and Manoel Viana, as a contributor to the minimization of laminar erosion caused by floods, besides being a specie adapted to water stress.
Gass et al. [
56] cite that the advance of monocrops on the sands of Rio Grande do Sul State have occurred without the knowledge of the potential use of native plant species endemic to the region, most of which are unknown in their food, medicinal, ornamental, aromatic properties, condiments, and for use in projects for the recovery of degraded areas.
From our study, we verify the low agricultural suitability and the high environmental fragility of Quartzipsamments in Rio Grande do Sul State. The agricultural use of these soils will be intensified, especially due to political and economic issues; therefore, studies are needed to guide farmers, extensionists, and stakeholders on the best way to use and manage them. Any incentive to use these sandy soils and the availability of technologies (e.g., irrigation, fertilizers, and machinery, among others) requires technical monitoring, specific recommendations for these soils, and monitoring of the soil and the environment. Specific recommendations include lower irrigation rates and more frequent application, due to the lower water-holding capacity of these soils and greater risk of nutrient leaching; split fertilization to reduce leaching and increase the efficiency of nutrient uptake by plants; include plant species adapted to this soil and climatic conditions in a rotation crop system, to produce enough volume of biomass to increase organic matter content, with consequent improvement of the soil physical structure and biological activity; maintenance of permanent vegetation cover on the soil surface to reduce water evaporation and erosion; and use of techniques and practices for soil and water conservation, such as terracing and keyline arrangement.