1. Introduction
In the recent years, the connections between string amplitudes and arithmetic geometry,
p-adic analysis, combinatorics, etc. have been studied extensively, see e.g., [
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9] and the references therein.
The string amplitudes were introduced by Veneziano in the 60s, In [
10], further generalizations were obtained by Virasoro [
11], Koba and Nielsen [
12], among others. In the 80s, Freund, Witten and Volovich, among others, studied string amplitudes at the tree level over different number fields, and suggested the existence of connections between these amplitudes, see e.g., [
4,
13,
14]. In this framework the connection with local zeta functions appears naturally. This article is intended as a survey of our recent work on the connections between Koba–Nielsen amplitudes and local zeta functions [
6,
7,
8,
9] in the sense of Gel’fand, Weil, Igusa, Sato, Bernstein, Denef, Loeser, etc.
The
p-adic string theories have been studied over the time with some periodic fluctuations in their interest (for some reviews, see [
3,
4,
5,
15]). Recently aconsiderable amount of work has been performed on this topic in the context of the AdS/CFT correspondence [
16,
17,
18,
19]. String theory with a
p-adic worldsheet was proposed and studied for the first time in [
20]. Later this theory was formally known as
p-adic string theory. The adelic scattering amplitudes which are related to the Archimedean ones were studied in [
21]. The tree-level string amplitudes were explicitly computed in the case of
p-adic string worldsheet in [
14,
22]. One can obtain these amplitude, in a formal way, from a suitable action using general principles [
23]. In [
24], it was established that the tree-level string amplitudes may be obtained starting with a discrete field theory on a Bruhat–Tits tree. Determining the convergence of the amplitudes in momentum space is a difficult task, both in the standard and
p-adic case; however, for the latter, this was precisely done for the
N-point tree amplitudes in [
8]. In this article we show (in a rigorous mathematical way) that the
p-adic open string
N-point tree amplitudes are bona fide integrals that admit meromorphic continuations as rational functions, this is done by associating to them multivariate local zeta functions (also called multivariate Igusa local zeta functions) [
25,
26,
27,
28]. In [
6] we establish in a rigorous mathematical way that Koba–Nielsen amplitudes defined on any local field of characteristic zero (for instance
,
,
) are bona fide integrals that admit meromorphic continuations in the kinematic parameters. In the regularization process we use techniques of local zeta functions and embedded resolution of singularities.
The
p-adic strings are related to ordinary strings at least in two different ways. First, connections through the adelic relations [
21] and second, through the limit when
[
23,
29]. In [
29] was showed that the limit
of the effective action gives rise to a boundary string field theory, this was previously proposed by Witten in the context of background independent string theory [
30,
31]. The limit
in the effective theory can be performed without any problem, since one can consider
p as a real parameter and take formally the limit
. The resulting theory is related to a field theory describing an open string tachyon [
32]. In the limit
also there are exact noncommutative solitons, some of these solutions were found in [
33]. In [
34] a very interesting physical interpretation of this limit was given in terms of a lattice discretization of ordinary string worldsheet. In the worldsheet theory we cannot forget the nature of
p as a prime number, thus the analysis of the limit is more subtle. The correct way of taking the limit
involves the introduction of finite extensions of the
p-adic field
. The totally ramified extensions give rise to a finer discretization of the worldsheet following the rules of the renormalization group [
34].
In [
35] Denef and Loeser showed that the limit
p approaches to one of a local zeta function give rise a new object called a topological zeta function. By using Denef–Loeser’s theory of topological zeta functions, in [
9], we show that the limit
of tree-level
p-adic string amplitudes give rise to new amplitudes, that we have named Denef–Loeser string amplitudes. Gerasimov and Shatashvili showed that in the limit
the well-known non-local effective Lagrangian (reproducing the tree-level
p-adic string amplitudes) gives rise to a simple Lagrangian with a logarithmic potential [
29]. In [
9], we conjecture that the Feynman amplitudes of this last Lagrangian are related to the Denef–Loser amplitudes.
In [
7] we establish rigorously the regularization of the
p-adic open string amplitudes, with Chan–Paton rules and a constant
B-field. These amplitudes were originally introduced by Ghoshal and Kawano. To study these amplitudes, we introduce new multivariate local zeta functions depending on multiplicative characters (Chan–Paton factors) and a phase factor (the
B-field) which involves an antisymmetric bilinear form. We show that these integrals admit meromorphic continuations in the kinematic parameters, this result allows us to regularize the Ghoshal–Kawano amplitudes, the regularized amplitudes do not have ultraviolet divergencies. The theory is only valid for
p congruent to 3 mod 4, this is to preserve a certain symmetry. The limit
is also considered for the noncommutative effective field theory and the Ghoshal–Kawano amplitudes. We show that in the case of four points, the limit
of the regularized Ghoshal–Kawano amplitudes coincides with the Feynman amplitudes attached to the limit
of the noncommutative Gerasimov–Shatashvili Lagrangian.
We denote by
a local field of characteristic zero (for instance
,
,
), and set
and
, where the
are non-constant polynomials in the variables
with coefficients in
. The multivariate local zeta function attached to
, where
is a test function, is defined as
and where
is the normalized Haar measure of
. These integrals admit meromorphic continuations to the whole
, [
25,
26,
36], see also [
37,
38]. The study of Archimedean and non-Archimedean local zeta functions was started by Weil in the 60 s, in connection to the Poisson-Siegel formula. In the 70 s, Igusa developed a uniform theory for local zeta functions in characteristic zero [
25,
26], see also [
36,
39,
40]. In the
p-adic setting, the local zeta functions are connected with the number of solutions of polynomial congruences mod
and with exponential sums mod
[
28]. Recently, Denef and Loeser introduced the motivic zeta functions which constitute a vast generalization of
p-adic local zeta functions [
41,
42].
In the 50 s, Gel’fand and Shilov studied the local zeta functions attached to real polynomials in connection with fundamental solutions, indeed, the meromorphic continuation of Archimedean local zeta functions implies the existence of fundamental solutions (i.e., Green functions) for differential operators with constant coefficients. This fact was established, independently, by Atiyah [
43] and Bernstein [
44]. It is relevant to mention here that in the
p-adic framework, the existence of fundamental solutions for pseudodifferential operators is also a consequence of the fact that the Igusa local zeta functions admit a meromorphic continuation, see ([
45], Chapter 5), ([
46], Chapter 10). This analogy turns out to be very important in the rigorous construction of quantum scalar fields in the
p-adic setting, see [
47] and the references therein.
Take
, and complex variables
and
for
and
for
. Put
, where
denotes the total number of indices
. In [
6] we introduce the multivariate local zeta function
where
is the normalized Haar measure on
. We called these integrals
Koba-Nielsen local zeta functions. In ([
6], Theorems 4.1 and 6.1), we show that these functions are bona fide integrals, which are holomorphic in an open part of
, containing the set given by
Furthermore, they admit meromorphic continuations to the whole
.
The Koba–Nielsen open string amplitudes for
N-points over
are
formally defined as
where
,
, for
(
), is the momentum vector of the
i-th tachyon (with Minkowski product
), obeying
The parameter l is an arbitrary positive integer. Typically, l is taken to be 25 for bosonic strings. However, we do not require using the critical dimension. We choose units such that the tachyon mass is .
In the real case,
is (up to multiplication by a positive constant) the open Koba–Nielsen amplitude of
N-points, see ([
4], Section 8), ([
48], Section 2). If
,
is the Veneziano amplitude [
10]. In the complex case, by using the results of ([
48], Section 2), in [
49], the
N-point, closed string amplitude at the tree level is the product of
times a polynomial function in the momenta
. This fact implies that the techniques and results presented in [
6] are applicable to classical closed string amplitudes at the tree level.
We use the integrals
as regularizations of the amplitudes
. More precisely, we
redefine
where
now denotes the meromorphic continuation of (
1) to the whole
, see ([
6], Theorem 6.1). Furthermore,
extends to a meromorphic function to the whole
, see ([
6], Theorem 7.1).
The articles [
6,
8] deal with the meromorphic continuation of local zeta functions of type
, but their results are complementary. The main result of [
8] is the existence of a meromorphic continuation for
in the case in which
is a non-Archimedean local field of arbitrary characteristic. For instance
or
, the field of formal Laurent series with coefficients in a finite field
. The methods used are based on the stationary phase formula, which allows the explicit calculation of
. On the other hand, the results presented in [
6] depend completely on Hironaka’s resolution of singularities theorem [
50], which is available only for fields of characteristic zero. In this framework, the results of [
6] show that for any field of characteristic zero
, all the zeta functions
converge on a common domain, see (
2), and that the possible poles can be described in a geometric form. We propose the following conjecture:
Conjecture 1. There is a meromorphic function in such that This conjecture and ([
6], Theorem 6.1) imply that
admits a meromorphic continuation to the whole
. By using (
3), this conjecture implies that
is meromorphic function in
. Freund and Witten established (formally) that the ordinary Veneziano and Virasoro–Shapiro four-particle scattering amplitudes can be factored in terms of an infinite product of non-Archimedean string amplitudes [
21]. More precisely, they established that the product of the
p-adic string amplitudes multiplied by the crossing-symmetric Veneziano amplitude is equal to one. Later Aref’eva, Dragovich and Volovich noted that the infinite product used by Freund and Witten is divergent, and established that the product of the
p-adic string amplitudes multiplied by the crossing-symmetric Veneziano amplitude is equal to an expression containing the Riemann zeta function [
51].
We already mentioned that the Denef–Loeser amplitudes
are the limit of the Koba–Nielsen amplitudes
when
p tends to one. This is a consequence of the fact that
, which in turn is a consequence of the motivic integration theory, see e.g., [
41,
52]. Motivic integration is a generalization of the
p-adic integration and the integration with respect to the Euler characteristic. By using this theory one can construct a function
such that
which in turn implies the existence of new type of ‘motivic string amplitude’ at the three level
which is a generalization of the
p-adic Koba–Nielsen and Denef–Loeser amplitudes.
Problem 1. Does the motivic string amplitudes have a physical meaning? Is there an effective action such that the Feynman integrals at the three level are exactly the ?
In [
9], we verified that the four and five-point Feynman amplitudes of the Gerasimov-Shatashvili Lagrangian are related by
. Then we propose the following conjecture:
Conjecture 2. The Feynman amplitudes at the three level of the Gerasimov–Shatashvili Lagrangian are by related .
A precise formulation of this conjecture is given at the end of
Section 6.
This survey is organized as follows. In
Section 2, we review briefly basic aspects of string amplitudes.
Section 3 aims to provide an introduction to
p-adic analysis.
Section 4 is dedicated to the
p-adic Koba–Nielsen amplitudes. We compute explicitly the amplitudes for 4 and 5 points. At the end of the section we provide an outline of the proof that the
p-adic Koba–Nielsen amplitudes admit meromorphic continuations as rational functions in
. The Koba–Nielsen amplitudes can be defined over any local field (i.e.,
,
,
,
, etc.).
Section 5 is dedicated to amplitudes defined on local fields such as
,
. A central idea is that the limit
p tends to one of the
p-adic Koba–Nielsen amplitudes gives a new amplitude, the Denef–Loeser amplitude. We compute the Denef–Loeser amplitudes for 4 and 5 points.
Section 6 deals with the physical interpretation of the limit
of
p-adic string amplitudes. In this section we show, in the case of 4 and 5 particles, that the Feynman integrals at the tree level of the Gerasimov–Shatashvili Lagrangian are related Denef–Loeser amplitudes. We also give a precise formulation of Conjecture 2.
Section 7 deals with the
N-point
p-adic string amplitudes, with Chan–Paton rules and a constant
B-field. We emphasize the explicit calculations of these amplitudes in the cases
, 5. In
Section 8, we briefly review some basic definitions and some central results about analytic manifolds on local fields of characteristic zero, Hironaka’s resolution of singularities theorem and multivariate Igusa zeta functions. In
Section 10, we give an outline of the proof of the fact that Koba–Nielsen amplitudes defined on local fields of characteristic zero admit meromorphic continuations in
. In the cases
, 5, we show explicitly the existence of a meromorphic continuations for amplitudes by outlining the construction of certain embedded resolution of singularities.
2. Generalities of String Amplitudes
String theory is the theory of tiny one-dimensional extended objects propagating in an underlying Riemannian or pseudo-Riemannian spacetime manifold
M. The theory is defined as a theory for a dynamical embedding map
, where
is a compact and oriented Riemann surface with a possible nonempty boundary (
) characterized by the genus
g, their number of boundaries
b and
N marked points.
has local coordinates
(
with
). Under a Wick rotation
and
, the metric written in terms of coordinates
becomes a metric with Euclidean signature. In addition to
X there is a non-dynamical filed
on
, which is the intrinsic metric. The string may oscillate in the target space
M and it has an infinite number of quantum modes of oscillation carrying a representation of the Poincaré group of the target space ( In the present review will be enough to consider
M to be the flat Minkowskian spacetime) and characterized by a mass and a spin. In the bosonic string the spectrum consists of a tachyonic mode with negative square mass. There are a finite number of massless modes described by massless fields on
M. These modes are the target space metric
with Lorentzian signature
, the antisymmetric field
, and the dilaton field
, where
.
M is the target space which is a Riemannian manifold of 26 dimensions in the case of the bosonic string and 10 dimensions for the superstring [
53,
54,
55]. The Euclidean worldsheet action for the bosonic open string is given by
where
where
is the string tension, here
and
stands for the string length. In the above action the physical degrees of freedom are
and
,
is the tangential derivative along
and
is an antisymmetric field. Moreover, the action
is given by
where
is the Euler characteristic of
and
is the Gibbons-Hawking boundary term that we encode in
with the number of boundaries
b. Notice that the vacuum expectation value of the dilaton
can also be incorporated in the action through this topological term. It is also worth noting that this is the most general action that has worldsheet reparametrization invariance, in particular Weyl invariance (
), and is renormalizable by power counting (this implies that there must be two worldsheet derivatives in each term). The second term is analogous to placing an electromagnetic field in the background with which the string interacts; it is a gauge field in that sense. Mathematically it is the integration of the pullback of the
B-field to the string worldsheet. If we define
, the second term of the second line in (
5) may be written as
which is exactly the term considered in [
56] where the partition function of the action was obtained explicitly at tree level. Strings propagating in non-trivial backgrounds have been considered in other works [
57].
We now consider flat space as well as a constant
B-field. The open string action (
5) determines the Neumann boundary conditions
where
is the normal derivative to
. We should note that these conditions are in general complex, because we have taken a Wick rotation to a Euclidean signature. We will be concerned about the case when the string worldsheet
is a disk, which corresponds to the open string in the classical limit. It is known that the disk can be transformed into the upper half plane via a conformal transformation, whose boundary is the real line. In these variables the Neumann boundary conditions are [
58]
where
and
, with Im
.
The perturbative scattering amplitudes of
N particles are defined as the correlation function of
N vertex operators
. Furthermore, these amplitudes admit an expansion over the genus
g of
as follows:
where
is the coupling constant of string and
is the Feynman functional integral
here
stands for the volume of the symmetry groups leaving invariant the action (
4). Here the integration is carried out over
the moduli space of Riemann surfaces of genus
g,
b boundaries and
N marked points inserted on the boundary. The difficulty of integration increases with higher values of
g,
b and
N. Fortunately it can be carried out in an explicit form for a few simple cases with lower values of
g,
b and
N. Thus, for instance, the case for closed strings with genus
and
, or open strings with
,
and
, are explicitly performed. Vertex operators
are functionals of the embedding fields
X and their derivatives. They are given by
where
represents a functional of
X and its derivatives associated with the species of field in the string spectrum,
,
are the position and momentum vectors in target space
M and
is the Minkowskian inner product. For instance for tachyons
. For gauge fields
and
, where
is the polarization vector. The graviton is
, where
is the polarization tensor. For bosonic closed strings, the tachyon is the lowest state and it has a
, where
is the Minkowskian norm. The open string tachyon has
. In units where the Regge slope
or where the string tension
we have that for the closed string tachyon
and for the open string
, which will be used in the following sections of the present survey. The massless open string gauge field and the closed string graviton have
.
For open strings one can see that in the functional integral with action (
5) the expansion in Taylor’s series of exponential of the second term of (
5), leads to a superposition of amplitudes with different powers of the vertex operator of the gauge field (
6) inserted in the boundary
.
From now on, we restrict ourselves to the case of bosonic closed strings with
and bosonic open strings with
and
, i.e., the 2-sphere and the disk. For closed strings, by worldsheet diffeomorphisms and Weyl transformations of
, allow us to fix the worldsheet metric
to the Euclidean flat metric
. This is the called the
conformal gauge. In the absence of a
B-field, there is a remnant
symmetry which cannot be fixed by the local Weyl symmetry. This is called the
conformal Killing symmetry. This symmetry does act on the complex worldsheet coordinates
of the 2-sphere separately. In the holomorphic sector (for the anti-holomorphic sector a similar argument is applied)
where
and
. This symmetry allows the choice of three points on the sphere which could be at 0, 1 and
∞. For open strings the remnant symmetry preserves the boundary is
. In the open string case the vertex operators are inserted on the boundary of the disk and this symmetry can be used to fix three points on the boundary that also may be 0, 1 and
∞. As with the case of closed strings, for open strings the presence of a
B-field spoils the
symmetry avoiding the possibility to fix three points of the positions of the vertex operators on the boundary
.
The two-point function with these boundary conditions is given by
with
and where
are quantities independent on
z. Basically, what we want are the
N-tachyon scattering amplitudes at tree level for the action (
5). This is done by inserting the following
N tachyon vertex operators
at different points of the boundary of the open string worldsheet
and obtaining the correlation functions of these operators.
To obtain it we must realize that the correlators in the path integral formalism can be computed as Gaussian integrals [
54]. Consider the following integral
where
is a differential operator. The symbol ∼ has been used to indicate that there are some proportional factors not relevant to the analysis. Here
is the inverse operator, or Green’s function, that satisfies
We can see that we can use this result to obtain the scattering amplitudes by choosing the appropriate source
.
Since we are interested in the vertex operators inserted at the boundary, we should restrict the propagator to it. By taking
and
for real
in (
7) we get
where
is the sign function. Now we can see that it suffices to choose the current as
in (
9). From this we can obtain the scattering amplitudes by finally integrating the expected values of the vertex operators over the entire boundary of the worldsheet, which now is just integrating over the real variable
. The result is
where
and
. These amplitudes are of the Koba–Nielsen type. The factor involving the sign function in the last line is actually more general, because it only depends on the variables through the sign functions, and any derivatives of it are 0. This allows us to write
The symbol
means that the expectation value taken on the second line is using the propagator (
10) without the second term. This is achieved by writing the polynomial as an exponential and keeping only the corresponding linear terms. For example [
48]:
where
indicates to only keep linear terms in
. So, we can see two direct effects of the
B-field on the action (
5). The first is that the effective metric on spacetime becomes
given in (
8). The second is that at tree level (Remember, this came from the fact that we are in the full upper half plane with the simplest zero genus topology) the scattering amplitudes acquire a phase factor that depends on the cyclic ordering of the momenta
and the matrix
. But the overall form of the amplitudes is the same as without the
B-field.
In the case of open strings for
N points with vanishing
B-field and with flat metric
and units with
and for a fixed ordering of the external momenta
, from (
11) we obtain the Koba–Nielsen amplitude, with the three fixed points in
,
and
,
where we have changed the variables
to
x’s variables in (
11), In [
48,
53,
54,
55].
The four-point amplitude is Veneziano’s amplitude
It is known that this definition of Veneziano’s amplitude describes only one of the three decay channels
s,
t and
u corresponding to the different inequivalent permutations of the momenta. If we consider the sum over the three channels and performing a suitable change of variables [
59] is possible to write the total amplitude as
In terms of the gamma function the above amplitude writes
where
s,
t and
u are the Mandelstam variables and they are defined as
,
and
and they satisfy
, and
is the gamma function. Thus, the 4-point amplitudes whose integration is
it already includes the three channels.
Moreover, this procedure also works for
N point amplitudes [
4,
48] and it yields
For completeness we write the form of closed strings in absence of
B-field the
N-point amplitude is given by
The four-point amplitude is the Virasoro–Shapiro amplitude
It is worth noting that the Veneziano four-point amplitude (
12), describing only one channel, can be written also as an integral over the whole
if we introduce some multiplicative characters as
:
where the function sign
is
of
and is
if
[
14].
The generalization for
N-point amplitudes is given by
In [
14]. The open string amplitude (
11) with a non-vanishing
B-field can be carried out in this form using the multiplicative character sign
. This form is of particular interest in connection to the Ghoshal–Kawano amplitudes [
60] studied later in this survey.
4. -Adic Open String Amplitudes
In [
14], Brekke, Freund, Olson and Witten work out the
N-point amplitudes in explicit form and investigate how these can be obtained from an effective Lagrangian. The
p-adic open string
N-point tree amplitudes are defined as
where
is the normalized Haar measure of
,
,
,
,
, is the momentum vector of the
i-th tachyon (with Minkowski product
) obeying
The parameter
l is an arbitrary positive integer. Typically,
l is taken to be 25. However, we do not require using the critical dimension. In [
8], we show that the
p-adic open string amplitudes (
19) are bona fide integrals and that they have meromorphic continuations as rational functions in the kinematic parameters. We attach to these amplitudes a multivariate Igusa-type zeta function. Fix an integer
and set
,
and
as
We now put
and
satisfying
for
. The
p-adic open string N-point zeta function is defined as
where
,
is the normalized Haar measure of
, and
In the definition of integral (
20) we remove the set
from the domain of integration to use the formula
for
and
. The reason for using the name ‘zeta function’ is that the integral (
20) is a finite sum of multivariate local zeta functions.
Take
a locally constant function with compact support, then
for
for any
, is a multivariate Igusa local zeta function. In characteristic zero, a general theory for this type of local zeta functions was elaborated by Loeser in [
36]. In particular, these local zeta functions admit analytic continuations as rational functions of the variables
.
We want to highlight that the convergence of the multivariate local zeta functions depends on the fact that the locally constant function
has compact support. For example, we consider the following integral:
If the integral
exists for some
, then the integrals
exist. The first integral
for
. For the second integral, we use that
is locally integrable, and thus
if and only if
. Then, integral
does not exist for any complex value
s.
Theorem 1 in [
8] establishes that the
p-adic open string
N-point zeta function is a holomorphic function in a certain domain of
and that it admits an analytic continuation to
(denoted as
) as a rational function in the variables
. Hence, in the theory of local zeta functions, the convergence and the existence of a meromorphic continuation as a rational function in the variables
of integrals of type (
20) is a new and remarkable result.
The
p-adic open string
N-point zeta functions
are regularizations of the amplitudes
. More precisely, we define
where
. By Theorem 1 in [
8],
are well-defined rational functions of the variables
,
i,
, which agree with integrals (
87) when they converge.
In the following two sections, using the methods given in [
8], we compute the
p-adic open string amplitudes in the cases
, 5.
4.1. p-Adic Open String 4-Point Amplitude
The 4-point string amplitude is given by
We attach to this amplitude the local zeta function:
We now divide the integration domain (
) into sectors. Given
, the attached sector is defined as
Then, we have two sectors:
| | |
| | |
| | |
and
where
and
We now compute
. By using the Examples 2 and 3:
for
and
.
We now consider integral
. By using the ultrametric inequality
for
,
To compute this last integral we proceed as follows. For
, we set
and
Notice that
,
are compact sets and that
is an analytic change of variables satisfying
, then using this change of variables, we have
Now, by using that
converges for
and the dominated convergence theorem,
, i.e.
on
. Therefore
this function is holomorphic in
which is a nonempty open subset in
because it contains the open set defined by the conditions:
We denote the meromorphic continuation of integral
also by
. Now, we regularize the
p-adic open string 4-point amplitude using
:
This amplitude can be rewritten as
with
where
means the summation over all pairs of compatible channels
. Then
Indeed, by using that
,
, we obtain
From (
23)–(
26), we obtain
Then
which agrees with (
22).
4.2. p-Adic Open String 5-Point Amplitude
The
p-adic open string 5-point amplitude is given by
and the 5-point local zeta function is given by
where
. We divide the integration domain
in sectors. Given
the attached sector is defined as
Table 1 shows all the sectors for the computation of the 5-point amplitude.
Now, by using the notation
we have
Case 1..
By changing of variables as
and using Lemma 7 of [
8], we have
The integral
is holomorphic in the solution set of the following conditions:
Case 2.
In this case,
and
, now by ultrametric property
and
, then
The calculation of
is similar to the case of integral (
21):
The integral
is holomorphic in the domain
The calculation of
is similar to the calculation of
given in the Subsection of 4-point zeta function. By changing of variables as
, we obtain
The integral
is holomorphic in
Case 3.
In this case,
, by the ultrametric inequality
and
, then
These integrals are similar to the ones obtained in the case of
:
the integral
is holomorphic in
And
the integral
is holomorphic in
Case 4..
Using the partition
, with
, we have
where
Using Lemma 4 of [
8], we have
The integral
is holomorphic in
Using Examples 2 and 3,
and
These integrals are holomorphic in
Finally, by Example 6,
This integral is holomorphic in
In conclusion, the 5-point local zeta functions is holomorphic on the region of
defined by
which is a nonempty subset, since it contains the open set
We regularize the
p-adic open string 5-point amplitude using the meromorphic continuation of
by setting
The amplitude
agrees with the one computed in [
14] using the Feynman rules of the effective Lagrangian:
where
,
, and
and
are summed over all pairs of compatible channels. By a pair of compatible channels
,
we mean that
i,
j,
k and
l are different, and that
,
k <
l.
4.3. p-Adic Open String N-Point Amplitudes
We fix an integer
and consider the general
N-point zeta function:
We divide the domain of integration
into sectors. Given
the attached sector is defined as
Hence, the
N-point zeta function (
40) can be written as
where
with
and
.
In addition
,
are multivariate local zeta functions and
with the convention that
for
, 1.
In [
8] we show that
has an analytic continuation to the whole
as a rational function in the variables
by showing that all functions that appear on the right-hand side of (
41) are holomorphic in a region
in
(Definition 3 and Remarks 9 and 10 in [
8]) defined by
where
,
are families of nonempty subsets of
T, and
is a nonempty subset of
.
with
,
,and
a family of nonempty subsets of
;
where
’s a family of nonempty subsets of
I;
where
is a nonempty subset of
with
,
.
In Lemma 9 of [
8], we show that region
contains and open and connected subset of
defined by the conditions
for
,
,
. For the case
we only consider conditions (
49) and (
50). Like in the cases
and
, the key point is to reduce the integrals
,
to certain simple integrals, for which admit meromorphic continuations to the whole
as rational functions in the variables
.
We now state the meromorphic continuation of the open string N-point zeta function.
Theorem 1 (Theorem 1 in [
8])
. (1) The p-adic open string N-point zeta function, , gives rise to a holomorphic function on , which contains an open and connected subset of . Furthermore, admits an analytic continuation to , denoted also as , as a rational function in the variables . The real parts of the poles of belong to a finite union of hyperplanes, the equations of these hyperplanes have the form (42)–(47) with the symbols ‘<’, ‘>’ replaced by ‘=’. (2) If , with for , then the integral diverges to . 6. A Physical View of the Limit on -Adic String Amplitudes
The problem of finding a relation between the physical string amplitudes and the
p-adic one has been present since the initial proposal. One of the first attempts is that of the Adelic amplitudes which can be written as an infinite product of physical non-Archimedean amplitudes [
14,
21].
There are other possibilities to look for a link between Archimedean and Non-Archimedean amplitudes. One of them is to consider the limit
. This limit is very intriguing and there are different interpretations of it [
23,
29,
34]. For instance, in [
23] it was argued that the analytic continuation of
p to the complex numbers can be reflected in the Lagrangian and equations of motion by turning the non-local equations of motion into a local and linear dynamical description with a logarithmic potential. This is an ordinary theory with real physical amplitudes. In [
29] it was argued that as similarly found in [
23], the expansion of the effective action around
leads to a linear theory with logarithmic potential. Besides that, this theory is deeply related to the boundary string field theory proposed by Witten [
30] in the context of the developing of a background independence string theory. The limit
also can be interpreted in terms of some scaling transformations of the renormalization group for the Bruhat–Tits tree [
34].
As we have seen in this survey, the non-Archimedean nature is encoded in the worldsheet theory. In this context we must recall that
p as a prime number, thus the analysis necessarily needs to be carry out in a rigorous way. The right way of taking the limit
involves the introduction of unramified finite extensions of the
p-adic field
. In [
9] the limit
was discussed for tree-level string amplitudes, by using the topological zeta functions introduced by Denef and Loeser [
35,
66]. We found that the limit
of
p-adic string amplitudes leads to certain string amplitudes (which are rational functions) that we termed the
Denef–Loeser open string amplitudes. These Denef–Loeser amplitudes for
, 5 points were computed in
Section 5.5 and
Section 5.6, for more details see [
9]. On the other hand for
, 5, in [
9], we computed the limit
of the effective field theory of
p-adic amplitudes, i.e., the Gerasimov and Shatashvili Lagrangian (
61) involving a logarithmic potential. By computing the interacting generating functional at the tree level, we verified that the corresponding amplitudes coincide exactly with the Denef–Loeser amplitudes. Based on this fact we have formulated a conjecture, which was already stated in the introduction of this survey.
In what follows we review the evidence of the mentioned conjecture in the cases
, 5 following [
9]. First, we review some basic results from [
29] starting with the effective action which is a field theory whose perturbative analysis leads to the
p-adic scattering amplitudes [
14], it can be written as
where
is the Laplacian on
M and
g is the coupling constant. The corresponding Euler-Lagrange equation is
In the source space (and consequently in the amplitudes)
p is a prime number; however, in the target space (and consequently in the Lagrangian and in the equation of motion)
p is a real parameter. Thus, one can formally proceed to approach
p to one and perform a Taylor expansion at
of the expression
and
. Then the resulting equation of motion is given by
This is the motion equation of the Gerasimov–Shatashvili action
where
and
is the potential
We consider that action (
61) is the limit
p tends to one of the effective action (
58).
The action corresponding to the free theory with a source is written as
Now, the action (
61) can be conveniently rewritten as
where
. Then the potential
can be expanded in Taylor series around the origin in the form
where
and
D are constants and they are real numbers.
Now, we briefly review the form of obtaining the four-point and five-point amplitudes from the Lagrangian (
61) [
29]. In quantum field theory
N-point correlation functions of
N local operators
in
N different points
of
M, can be written as
where
is the generating functional constructed using interacting Lagrangian (
62). The functional can be computed as
where the generating functional of the correlation function for the free theory with sources is given by
Moreover, is the Green-Feynman function of the differential operator .
For the computation of the interacting 4-point amplitudes can be obtained through the generating functional
In terms of
, 4-point amplitudes implies the computation of
Here
is the Green-Feynman propagator. This amplitude corresponds to the Feynman diagram with only one vertex and four external legs. following the notation of [
14], we write for it the symbol
.
The contribution to the 4-point amplitudes of
in (
63) has a contribution at the second order of the expansion. The corresponding Feynman diagrams have two vertices at points
x and
y with two external legs, which are connected by a propagator
. Thus, we have
Moreover, the contribution to the 4-point amplitudes from the term
arises to second order. Thus, it yields
The sum of expressions (
64) and (
66) constitutes the total amplitude which contains the sum of the three channels
s,
t and
u. They are expected to be the
p-adic 4-point amplitudes arising in the limit
. Thus, in the Fourier space it is expected to be written schematically as
where
is the propagator
in momentum space. Then
agrees with
up to the constant
, see (
54).
In the case of amplitudes of 5-points, the contribution of the term
in the Lagrangian is written as
Thus, the corresponding 5-point amplitude is
The contribution will be encoded in the symbol .
Another contribution come from the term
. In the Fourier space the corresponding diagrams have precisely 2-vertices, 5 external legs attached to these vertices and one internal leg between the two vertices (see, Section 3 of [
14]).
This latter contribution to generating functional is written as
The 5-point amplitude yields
Moreover, in the computation of the 5-point amplitudes, the last contribution comes from the term
The diagrams associated with this expansion are diagrams with three vertices. Two of them have two external legs and the other leg is internal. The remaining leg has one external line and two internal lines attached.
Then the total contribution is
where
a is a constant.
Summarizing, the 5-point amplitudes
obtained from Lagrangian (
61) can be written schematically (in notation from [
14]) by
where the three terms in the sum corresponds to the contributions of Equations (
67), (
69) and (
71) respectively. Notice that
agrees with
up to the constants
,
, see (
55).
We now give a precise formulation of Conjecture 2 announced in the Introduction. By using the Feynman rules for the effective Lagrangian given in [
14],
where the constants
K,
are rational functions in
p with rational coefficients. Furthermore, if
, the constant term
K is not zero. Formally, we have
We denote by
the Feynman amplitude of Lagrangian (
61). We conjecture that
where
. Notice that we are not asserting the existence of any relation between the constants
,
and the constants
,
.
10. Meromorphic Continuation of Koba–Nielsen Amplitudes
Defined on Local Fields of Characteristic Zero
The Koba–Nielsen open string amplitudes for
N-points over a local field
of characteristic zero are defined as
where
,
, for
, is the momentum vector of the
i-th tachyon (with Minkowski product
), obeying
The parameter
l is typically taken to be 25. However, we do not require using the critical dimension, thus
l can be any positive number. These amplitudes were introduced by Brekke, Freund, Olson and Witten, among others in their works about string amplitudes, see e.g., Section 8 of [
4]. In the case
and
, the amplitude (
87) is the Veneziano amplitude, see [
10]. In Section 2 of [
48] and [
49], it was established that the
N-point closed string amplitude at the tree level is the product of
times a polynomial function in the momenta
. Hence, the results established in [
6] are still valid for closed string amplitudes at tree level.
If we take the Minkowski products of the kinematic parameters as follows
, the string amplitude (
87) becomes to the following integral which is a type of multivariate local zeta function
where
is the normalized Haar measure on
,
, with
denotes the total number of indices
, and
We have called integrals of type (
89)
Koba–Nielsen local zeta functions. For simplicity of notation, we put
instead of
in (
89).
In [
6], we establish, in a rigorous mathematical way that the Koba–Nielsen string amplitudes defined on any local field of characteristic zero are bona fide integrals and that they can be extended to meromorphic functions in the kinematic parameters. In order to prove the meromorphic continuation of (
89), we express it as linear combinations of local zeta functions. These computations were first made in the case of
, but they can be easily extended to other local fields of characteristic zero. Thus, we only review the real case. We consider
as an
-analytic manifold, with
, and use
as a coordinate system. In order to regularize the integral (
89), we use a partition of
constructed using a smooth function
satisfying
for some fixed positive
sufficiently small. This function is well-known, see e.g., Section 1.4 of [
69], Section 5.2 of [
26]. The number 2 was chosen in an arbitrary form, the key point is that the interval
is included in the locus where
.
Now, we can write
with
where the functions
are defined as
for
, including the empty set, with the convention that
. Notice that
and
, for
, i.e., the functions
form a partition of the unity.
In the case
,
is a classical multivariate Igusa local zeta function (since
has compact support). It is well known that these integrals are holomorphic functions in a region including
for all
, and they admit meromorphic continuations to the whole
, see ([
6], Theorem 3.2).
In the case
, by changing variables in (
91) as
for
, and
for
, we have
, and by setting
for
, i.e.,
we have that supp
and
. Now setting
, and
we have
where
is the divisor defined by the polynomial
The integrals
, with
, are not classical multivariate local zeta functions thus we do not apply the theory of local zeta functions. Thus, in [
6] we show that they define holomorphic functions on some nonempty open in
, and admit meromorphic continuations to the whole
.
Lemma 1. (Lemma 4.1 of [
6])
For any , the function is holomorphic in on the solution set of a system of inequalities of the formwhere , and , are finite sets. More precisely, for each k, either all numbers are equal to 0 or 1 and , or all numbers are equal to 0 or and .In addition, admits an analytic continuation to the whole , as a meromorphic function with poles belonging to To show the existence of the meromorphic continuation of
it is necessary that all the integrals
be holomorphic in a common domain, and then Formula (
90) allows us to construct a meromorphic continuation of
. We show that
contains a nonempty open subset of
by studying the possible poles of integrals
for any
I, and proving that
is a holomorphic function in the region
This fact was proved in Theorem 4.1 in [
6].
Furthermore, the Koba–Nielsen local zeta function
is convergent and holomorphic in the region determined by the following inequalities:
for all
variables
,
for all subsets
with
,
for all subsets
with
,
for all subsets
with
,
for all subsets
with
. This region contains the open subset defined by
for all indices
.
As in the
p-adic case, we use the meromorphic continuation of (
89) to the whole
, which is denoted by
, as regularizations of the amplitudes
by redefining
see Theorem 6.1 of [
6]. It is important to mention here that in the regularization of
, we do not use the kinematic restrictions (
88).
Furthermore, in [
6] we show that
converges on some open subset of
by showing that this open is mapped into the domain of convergency of
by
. In addition, we prove that
extends to a meromorphic function to the whole
, and that its polar set is contained in the inverse image of the polar set of
under that mapping, where the possible poles are described in terms of numerical data of suitable resolutions of singularities:
Theorem 4. (Theorem 7.1 of [
6])
Let be a local field of characteristic zero. The integral converges and is holomorphic in the open set . It extends to a meromorphic function in on the whole .If is an -field, then the possible poles of belong towhere , and , are finite sets, and if , and if . If is a p-adic field, then is a rational function in the variables , and its possible poles belong to More precisely, for each r, either all numbers are equal to 0 or 1 and , or all numbers are equal to 0 or and .
We now show explicitly the existence of a meromorphic continuation for in the cases , 5, by using Hironaka’s resolution of singularities theorem.
10.1. Example: 4-Point Koba–Nielsen String Amplitude
The 4-point Koba–Nielsen open string amplitude is defined as
Using the function
where
is sufficiently small, we construct the following partition of the unity:
Notice that
and
, for
. Hence,
with
and
The integral (
98) is a multivariate local zeta function since
has compact support. By a classical result of local zeta functions
converges when
and
Furthermore, it admits a meromorphic continuation to the whole
, see Theorem 3.2 of [
6].
The second integral (
99) is not a multivariate local zeta function but it can be transformed in one by changing of variables as
, then
, and by setting
, we have that
Notice that the support of
is contained in
and
. Thus, integral (
99) becomes
which is analytic when
and
. We concluded that
is analytic in the region
Which contains the open set and .
10.2. Example: 5-Point Koba–Nielsen String Amplitude
Fix
. By using the function
, see (
97), we define the following partition of the unity:
Then
. We consider the first integral
Since
has compact support, then integral (
100) is a local zeta function. Thus, we use resolution of singularities of the divisor
defined by
. This arrangement is not locally monomial only at the points
and
. Hence, we pick a partition of the unity,
, and we write
where
We assume that and are smooth functions with support in a small neighborhood of and , respectively. So, we only compute the integrals and .
In terms of convergence and holomorphy, around
, the factor
can be neglected, hence we only need an embedded resolution of
, which is obtained by a blow-up at the origin. It means to make the changes of variables
Hence integral
becomes
where
is invertible on the support of
and can thus be neglected from the point of view of convergence and holomorphy. Hence, by ([
6], Lemma 3.1), we obtain the convergence conditions:
We can take other chart of the blow-up, i.e., the change of variables
with this change yields the same first and second condition and
By symmetry we can consider any of these changes of variables. Completely similarly, for the convergence of
, we need also the new conditions
The conditions coming from the locally monomial integral
are already included.
The integral
is not a multivariate local zeta function, so we take the following change of variables
, then we have
, and by setting
, we have that
Since
is locally monomial in the support of
, the only new condition is
Completely analogously,
induces the extra condition
For the last integral, we are setting
and
. Thus,
In this case, we have the same divisor as for
; the differences are the powers of
and
and the function
that does not contain
in its support. Hence, the only new condition will arise from the blow-up at the origin, namely
Hence
is analytic in the region defined by conditions (
101)–(
106), i.e.,
This region of convergence contains the open subset defined by
Then, in particular, is analytic in the interval .